Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
TheOmegaWalrus
Feb 3, 2007

by Hand Knit
The speech has been labeled "major", but it's doubtful that it will contain anything meaningful or new.

I read somewhere that new Egyptian protests had begun recently but were shut down quickly by the military. What exactly is the state of Egypt currently?

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

The X-man cometh
Nov 1, 2009

Lascivious Sloth posted:

Great article, I can completely get behind what he's saying. It shows how ideologically hypocritical Al-Qaeda is in essence. I agree with his comments on how things play out will help shape Jihadism in the future, but I think we're past the point of losing western interest or it becoming a civil war. NATO has really stepped up in the past 2 weeks, and more time only equals less resistance from Govt forces and more training for the rebels when the rebels are allowed to attack.

It really shows how important it is for the West to stop supporting unpopular tyrants like Mubarak, the al-Sauds and the al-Khalifas of Bahrain, because it's easy to demonize tyrants, but not ordinary people fighting for their homes like the Libyan rebels.

Gaddafi's also pretty westernized, that might have helped. I wonder what those jihadis think about the Bahraini crackdown. I assume the jihadis are Sunni, as well.

Space Monster
Mar 13, 2009

eSports Chaebol posted:

Well, in many cases, some (though of course not all) of them are. And while those sorts of people might not be terribly popular in their own countries, they are the sorts of people whom we in America are most likely to hear about and are most likely to see held up as examples of legitimate alternatives to oppressive regimes. Nobody denies for example that Robert Mugabe is terrible dictator, but at least he doesn't support international sanctions on an already beleaguered Zimbabwe unlike the Democracy-Certified opposition leader, Morgan Tsvangirai.

Yes. Anti-totalitarian government protesters in Iran, Belarus, and China are in favor of U.S. colonialism. Why else would they protest their clearly legitimate governments? It's obvious to them that they can't run their own countries and that they should depend upon our wise, tempered rule from afar.

eSports Chaebol
Feb 22, 2005

Yeah, actually, gamers in the house forever,

Space Monster posted:

Yes. Anti-totalitarian government protesters in Iran, Belarus, and China are in favor of U.S. colonialism. Why else would they protest their clearly legitimate governments? It's obvious to them that they can't run their own countries and that they should depend upon our wise, tempered rule from afar.

Anti-totalitarian protestors hold a variety of different opinions, and even have different reasons to oppose their governments, because being against totalitarianism isn't much of a defining opinion in and of itself. What I'm saying is that those who have opinions most amenable to U.S. foreign policy interests are those portrayed the most favorably in the U.S. And given how U.S. foreign policy operates (i.e. not very nicely), those people generally don't have the best interest of their countrymen in mind as much as other protestors.

Brown Moses
Feb 22, 2002

Lots of reports of shooting in Tripoli through out the night, and into the morning. Gaddafi and co are claiming it's celebratory gunfire, although journalists in the Rixos are saying it doesn't sound like it, especially as it's been going on all night.
There were lots of Tweets about it throughout the night, obviously it's hard to verify any of this information, but here's a list of Tweets in order of time:

quote:

Stone_SkyNews: I can hear lots of gunfire outside the Rixos in Tripoli tonight. Not v close but certainly audible. Doesn't sound like celebratory. 8 hours ago

quote:

Stone_SkyNews: Very confusing messages at Rixos. We are told that groups from Benghazi have called state tv to say they support #Gaddafi .... 8 hours ago

quote:

ilibico In tripoli gunfire and clashes in fashloum and tajura. Not sure if journalists at Rixos can here atleast fashloum clashes 8 hours ago

quote:

Thanku4theAnger: LPC Tripoli: Epic Clashes taking place in Tripoli from around 20 mins. Very intense. It's everywhere


quote:

Stone_SkyNews @Guma_el_gamaty can hear lots of gunfire from Rixos. Can't tell direction or distance. 7 hours ago

quote:

libyanproud: BREAKING/EMERGENCY : phone call to syahya in #tripoli , loud screaming of men and women , lots of gunshots, started 01:00 and ongoing :( 7 hours ago

quote:

LibyansVoice: Libyan Youth Movement Gun fire being heard in Tripoli, quite a few reports say they hear it from Bab al Azizia (gaddafi's compound) 7 hours ago

quote:

Tripolitanian: BREAKING: Source says intense gunfire in various locations in #Tripoli, anti-#Gaddafi protests near city center. 7 hours ago

quote:

EEE_Libya: Friends in Tripoli just called and told us to celebrate... sounds a bit overzealous but still exciting nonetheless 7 hours ago

quote:

Tripolitanian: Very intense gun-fire being heard in Soug aljum3a (phonetic) district of #Tripoli 7 hours ago

quote:

Tripolitanian: Source in #Tripoli says there are stray bullets hitting apartment buildings near city center!! omg, omg....... :( 7 hours ago

quote:

LbrlOkie77: Just come down from roof top.... LOTS of gun fire around tripoli!! Source in Tripoli 7 hours ago

quote:

Sorin129 @mushuthalohari @rima_misurata and even @libyanswb saying there is lots of gunfire in Tripoli. They normally always saying is pretty quiet 7 hours ago

quote:

AlmanaraMedia: Reports that FF of #Tripoli have shot gun fire at the Television building window glass while Shakeer was broadcasting live 7 hours ago

quote:

anguswalkeritv: #Tripoli all seems to be celebratory gunfire - not battles - state TV claiming to be showing pro Gaddafi celebrations in Benghazi

quote:

AlmanaraMedia: 15 minutes ago: Reports of heavy gun fire heard in AlMajaheri area in Tajoura 6 hours ago

quote:

Tripolitanian: There is still gun-fire even now.. I kinda wish I was in #Tripoli.. 6 hours ago

quote:

LibyaOfPeace: #Tripoli:the reason behind all these heavy Pro-G demos are to hide an on-going attack on Gaddafi's compound tonight that is ongoing 6 hours ago

quote:

Stone_SkyNews @anguswalkeritv @sorin129 agree. A few hours ago it sounded different. What we are hearing now around Rixos is celebratory. 6 hours ago

quote:

Stone_SkyNews Lots of UNCONFIRMED reports of clashes in areas away from Rixos. Is what we at seeing and hearing a diversion? I dont know. 6 hours ago

quote:

Inphinite_: Pretty intense gunfire in #Janzour tonight - concentrated near bigshot #Gaddafi right hand man 6 hours ago

quote:

LibyansWB: #Tripoli : gunfires are still going on in Janzur, Gergaresh, Gorji, Sriim, Dahra, Ben Ashour, Soug al joma'a, hadba and hai dimashiq 6 hours ago

quote:

Libya_United: Over the phone it wasn't constant gunfire but I was able to hear audible gunfire at least twice. 6 hours ago

quote:

RRowleyTucson #Tripoli: There are shouts of 'Down with the Regime!' on Matar (Airport) street. Shots fired in #Gaddafi's Aziziyah compound. -
48 minutes ago

There's no reports of who was doing the shooting and what their aims were, so hopefully there will be some news from Tripoli about what actually happened last night.

[edit]ChangeInLibya is posting some stuff in the last 5 minutes about what happened last night:

quote:

There were plenty of clashes in Tripoli last night and one (trustworthy) source says that some 200+ FF prisoners were freed. Tripoli: Some of the injured people (rghly 200) that were kidnapped from hospitals by Gaddafi were freed yesterday in Tripoli

[edit]A little more from ChangeInLibya:

quote:

Tripoli: Some homes belonging to officers and soldiers responsible for kidnappings in the city were set on fire yesterday

Brown Moses fucked around with this message at 10:55 on May 19, 2011

Brown Moses
Feb 22, 2002

ChangeInLibya is posting a translation of the Misrata update from May 18th:

quote:

In the early morning, freedom fighters started to attack the western and eastern fronts of Misrata simultaneously.

There were fierce clashes and freedom fighters managed to advance all the way to the middle of Tawergha in the East. They found items that were stolen from Misrata and these items were returned. Gaddafi forces bombarded FF with mortars&GRAD. The heavy bombarded forced freedom fighters to retreat from Tawergha and go back to Misrata's outskirts.

As for the western front, freedom fighters managed to control a very large part of Naim district of Zliten.

In the southern part of Misrata, freedom fighters found Gaddafi forces in "Sikit" area trying to bombard the city.

1 freedom fighter died and 3 were injured in yesterday's fighting, but we caught a large group of Gaddafi soldiers.

Misrata is mostly quiet and peaceful nowadays, especially the centre of the city. Bombardment on civ. homes stopped. This is due to the fact that battles are now in the outskirts and the city can't be reached using GRAD rockets anymore.

NATO jets were heard above the city and they hovered for a very long time.
Women and children went out on anti-gaddafi demonstrations and the youth tried to clean the streets.
Most importantly, water is now back to Misrata and so is electricity. Telephone lines are being fixed as well.
The city still lacks gas canisters for cooking, a working sewage/waste disposal system and medicines

Brown Moses
Feb 22, 2002

Live blogs May 19th
Guardian
AJE
LibyaFeb17.com

quote:

Mark Stone says that lots of gunfire could be heard in Tripoli, it didn’t sound celebratory. He adds that there are many unconfirmed reports of clashes in various areas. State TV reported that groups in Benghazi pledged their allegiance to Gaddafi, which was followed by celebratory gunfire in Tripoli. “Is what we at seeing and hearing a diversion? I dont know,” he wrote.

quote:

According to a Tunisian security source, Gaddafi’s wife and daughter crossed into Tunisia. The Tunisian Interior Ministry denied that any members of the Gaddafi family were in the country in remarks to Al Jazeera and Al Arabiya TV. Al Jazeera quoted a ministry spokesman as saying Tunisia would arrest any members of the Gaddafi family should they enter the country under a U.N.-imposed travel ban. A Libyan opposition source said the women were in Djerba to accompany Aisha’s husband, who he said had been injured in the Libyan conflict, and was seeking treatment in Tunisia

quote:

A tape recorded by Osama bin Laden before his death, in which he praises the Arab spring protest movement, has been released posthumously onto Islamist militant websites, writes Jason Burke.

Here's what Bin Laden said about the Middle East uprisings:

quote:

I think that the winds of change will blow over the entire Muslim world, God willing... The sun of the revolution has risen from the Maghreb... The light of the revolution came from Tunisia. It has given the nation tranquillity and made the faces of the people happy,"

Tunisia was the first but swiftly the knights of Egypt have taken a spark from the free people of Tunisia to Tahrir Square. This wasn't a revolution of starving and pain, but a revolution of giving and peace," the Saudi-born fugitive said.

Bin Laden and friends think these sort of uprisings will inevitably lead to radical Islamic governments in those countries.

quote:

Egypt has suspended the prison sentences of 120 people who participated in protests following the revolution that toppled President Hosni Mubarak.

The Supreme Council of the Armed Forces has also denied using gunfire to break up sit-ins that have continued following Mubarak's ousting from power.

In a major new report Amnesty International documents how both the army and the Egyptian security service tortured detained protesters.

Its UK director, Kate Allen, who was part of the research team, said:

quote:

There's still a mountain to climb in terms of achieving justice for the brave protesters of Egypt's uprising.

In the first of a three-part series on Egypt 100 days after the revolution, the Guardian's Middle East editor Ian Black reports on the mounting alarm about continuing disorder.

quote:

Obama's speech is due to start at 11.40am (EDT) 4.40pm (BST). After the speech the White House is organising a Twitter chat with national security adviser Ben Rhodes.

NPR's Twitter guru Andy Carvin, who is facilitating the chat warns that not every question will be answered, but we've been told the White House will accept a question from the Guardian. Our Middle East editor Ian Black is working on something.

What would you ask the White House about the Obama's policy towards the Middle East?

One of the aims of Obama's speech is to answer criticism that the administration is "leading from behind" on foreign policy. An article in New Yorker earlier month portrayed White House foreign policy as torn between idealism and realism.

Ballz
Dec 16, 2003

it's mario time

Brown Moses posted:


Bin Laden and friends think these sort of uprisings will inevitably lead to radical Islamic governments in those countries.

No mention of the NATO kuffar-backed Libyan freedom fighters? How convenient.

Joementum
May 23, 2004

jesus christ

Lascivious Sloth posted:

quote:

Other international institutions, like the IMF and the World Bank, are expected to offer several billion dollars in additional financing.

This is how you win hearts and minds, promote democracy, and reduce world terrorism.

IMF and World Bank loan guarantees have historically worked against democratic interests in countries, rather than helping them. Also rather bizarre that the US is cancelling $1b in debt and then opening up a new line of $1b in credit to Egypt while continuing to provide aid money. I'll be interesting to see what Egypt's pound of flesh will be a decade from now.

On a different topic, Saturday is the 61st day of US military involvement in Libya.

Brown Moses
Feb 22, 2002

Martin Chulov of the Guardian sent in an interesting audio report, the following part of that report reflects the change in momentum in Libya:

quote:

There has been significant damage done both in terms of the front lines and in terms of the command and control centres here in Tripoli. This has put a sense of trepidation into regime officials here. It could have contributed to the string of recent defections. There does seem to have been a toll taken on the capacity of bureaucrats to get things done. We seem to be in a new phase of this conflict. It is not heading towards an immediate end, however it does seem to have stepped up in recent days.

Another Twitter report from Tripoli:

quote:

1- Clashes between armed anti-regime activists and katiba forces in Shara3 Jamhuriya (Jamhuriya Street)

2- Similar clashes in Gergarish

3- Similar, again, in Mansoora District

4- Man wearing military uniform killed outside the petrol station at Al Hani District. Reportedly killed by security forces. Apparent clash between security.

5- Gun fire was heard all over Tripoli. Some, admittedly, sounded celebratory. Some appeared to be exchanges of fire, with shouting and screaming.

If there's more violence tonight in Tripoli then it might suggest it's the start of something big there.

A Stranger
Sep 14, 2010
It seems that the wave of revolution is reaching southern Europe now as well:
http://english.aljazeera.net/news/europe/2011/05/201151903517791235.html
This could be great news :).

Mr. Sunshine
May 15, 2008

This is a scrunt that has been in space too long and become a Lunt (Long Scrunt)

Fun Shoe

A Stranger posted:

It seems that the wave of revolution is reaching southern Europe now as well:
http://english.aljazeera.net/news/europe/2011/05/201151903517791235.html
This could be great news :).

So, inspired by their arab fellows, the spaniards are rising up to topple their tyrannical, elected government. Yes, this event will truly herald in the long-awaited democratic revolution in Europe.

Wiz
May 16, 2004

Nap Ghost

Mr. Sunshine posted:

So, inspired by their arab fellows, the spaniards are rising up to topple their tyrannical, elected government. Yes, this event will truly herald in the long-awaited democratic revolution in Europe.

Psst, the arab spring revolutions are as much about economic conditions as lack of democracy. Spain's economic conditions are poo poo right now.

Brown Moses
Feb 22, 2002

AJA is reporting a very large build up of rebels soldiers and supplies outside of Brega, sounds like they are preparing for a push, probably so they can reach Sirte at the same time as the rebels in the west.

CeeJee
Dec 4, 2001
Oven Wrangler

Wiz posted:

Psst, the arab spring revolutions are as much about economic conditions as lack of democracy. Spain's economic conditions are poo poo right now.

But it's not because of Zapatero stealing billions to build palaces while keeping the populace poor.

King Dopplepopolos
Aug 3, 2007

Give us a raise, loser!

eSports Chaebol posted:

And given how U.S. foreign policy operates (i.e. not very nicely), those people generally don't have the best interest of their countrymen in mind as much as other protestors.

Just because America's foreign policy is complete poo poo (and it is) doesn't mean that protesters in Iran and China don't have the best interests of their countrymen at heart. That what we do around the globe is criminal doesn't excuse the misdeeds of more oppressive regimes, no matter what they say about us. Torture, for example, is wrong no matter who does it. It doesn't become right if it's at the behest of "anti-colonial" regimes.

Mr. Sunshine
May 15, 2008

This is a scrunt that has been in space too long and become a Lunt (Long Scrunt)

Fun Shoe

Wiz posted:

Psst, the arab spring revolutions are as much about economic conditions as lack of democracy. Spain's economic conditions are poo poo right now.

The word "revolution" tends to mean the overthrow of the current regime and the restructuring of society. In your opinion, are the goals of the current spanish protests to:

A) Usher in the creation of the Glorious People's Anarcho-Syndicalist Republic of Greater Iberia

or

B) Get the current government to be less assholish about the economy?

Comparing the economic woes of Europe with the conditions that the arabs are rising up against is quite frankly insulting to all parties involved.

E: If you think that somehow the protests in Spain are related to the Arab Spring you might as well go all out and claim that the entire Arab Spring started with the riots in Athens.

Mr. Sunshine fucked around with this message at 15:43 on May 19, 2011

Pedrophile
Feb 25, 2011

by angerbot
If that's true the best thing that came out of this was the video of that cop getting nailed in the face with a molotov.

evilweasel
Aug 24, 2002

t3ch3 posted:

IMF and World Bank loan guarantees have historically worked against democratic interests in countries, rather than helping them. Also rather bizarre that the US is cancelling $1b in debt and then opening up a new line of $1b in credit to Egypt while continuing to provide aid money. I'll be interesting to see what Egypt's pound of flesh will be a decade from now.

No more than it would be if we did nothing. There's also considerably greater appreciation for how these loans should be used than there has been in the past (and when they shouldn't be used). It's also generally in the US's interest for these to work: we don't really want client states over there anymore (or if we do, that ship has sailed), we want the region to settle down. That's best done by giving people what they want: a better standard of living and more freedoms.

Office Thug
Jan 17, 2008

Luke Cage just shut you down!

Mr. Sunshine posted:

The word "revolution" tends to mean the overthrow of the current regime and the restructuring of society.

Revolutions never reconstruct the entirety of society, often times just facets of it which are in danger and pose a serious threat to its stability, such as freedom, the political system, the economy, etc.. Although Spain's current uprising seems like a drop in the bucket compared to Libya's bloody civil war or Egypt's mess, it's still an uprising and a call for revolution. Only, what its demanding is a better economy, something that the government can and should be keeping under control. Spain's immediate condition is a throwback to a long process of increasing disparity of wealth between the rich and the middle-low class http://uk.reuters.com/article/2009/04/08/uk-spain-soupkitchen-idUKTRE53702920090408, much like what's been going on in the US and many other heavily corporate countries for quite a while.

In addition, you can't have a society without some form of economy, since after all the economy is the part of society that literally "delivers the goods" people need. Spain is the 12th largest economy in the world so it really doesn't have any excuse for its lovely broken system in terms of wealth. It's just that the economy's been geared into delivering "the goods" directly towards the rich and upper class, and you can guess which people have the power and the motive to pull that off.

Brown Moses
Feb 22, 2002

Obama's speech on the Arab Spring and the Middle East is starting soon, there's rumours he's making some big announcement about Israel and Palestine, gonna hazard a guess and say it's probably not going to be anything to piss off the Israeli's.

shotgunbadger
Nov 18, 2008

WEEK 4 - RETIRED

Brown Moses posted:

Obama's speech on the Arab Spring and the Middle East is starting soon, there's rumours he's making some big announcement about Israel and Palestine, gonna hazard a guess and say it's probably not going to be anything to piss off the Israeli's.

At worst it will be 'uuuh, maybe stop murdering your citizens too guys, maybe also stop building homes in the ruins of Palestinian houses?' and in ten minutes Obama will be called a nazi anti-Semite monster who wants to personally bomb Israel into dust.

Cable Guy
Jul 18, 2005

I don't expect any trouble, but we'll be handing these out later...




Slippery Tilde
edit: nevermind

Cable Guy fucked around with this message at 17:22 on May 19, 2011

Brown Moses
Feb 22, 2002

There's claims that Tawergha has been captured by the rebels, bar one or two buildings with Gaddafi soldiers trapped inside. That's the last built up area south of Misrata, next I expect the rebels will try to capture the nearby airport, then they can block two major roads to Sirte.

evilweasel
Aug 24, 2002

Brown Moses posted:

Obama's speech on the Arab Spring and the Middle East is starting soon, there's rumours he's making some big announcement about Israel and Palestine, gonna hazard a guess and say it's probably not going to be anything to piss off the Israeli's.

The announcement that the borders should be based on the 1967 borders is going to piss off Israel.

Space Monster
Mar 13, 2009

eSports Chaebol posted:

Anti-totalitarian protestors hold a variety of different opinions, and even have different reasons to oppose their governments, because being against totalitarianism isn't much of a defining opinion in and of itself. What I'm saying is that those who have opinions most amenable to U.S. foreign policy interests are those portrayed the most favorably in the U.S. And given how U.S. foreign policy operates (i.e. not very nicely), those people generally don't have the best interest of their countrymen in mind as much as other protestors.

So anyone that we here in the Evil West like are actually ogres who will destroy their countries.

Excellent.


It sounds to me like we should enforce regime change in the entire middle east, in order to put Muslim extremists and Stalin-style communists in charge!

TheOmegaWalrus
Feb 3, 2007

by Hand Knit
A good way to bring Israel to the table is threaten to cut off funding.

I have to wonder how much of Obama's "Israel needs to defend itself" was to that effect.

eSports Chaebol
Feb 22, 2005

Yeah, actually, gamers in the house forever,

Space Monster posted:

So anyone that we here in the Evil West like are actually ogres who will destroy their countries.

No, not really. Things aren't black and white like that.

shotgunbadger
Nov 18, 2008

WEEK 4 - RETIRED

TheOmegaWalrus posted:

A good way to bring Israel to the table is threaten to cut off funding.

I have to wonder how much of Obama's "Israel needs to defend itself" was to that effect.

Ahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

Oh my god, he got eviscerated for saying 'woah dudes, pause settlements for a bit in lands you don't really own', can you imagine what would happen if he tried to cut their funding by even a dollar? He's never going to do that, no president will, it's that, or say 'maybe we shouldn't have an economy based around blowing up and torturing our enemies' as the two sure fire ways to kill your political career in America.

King Dopplepopolos
Aug 3, 2007

Give us a raise, loser!

eSports Chaebol posted:

No, not really. Things aren't black and white like that.

That's his point. You're judging opposition movements solely on how the Evil West perceives them. It's something the political version of a hipster would do.

eSports Chaebol
Feb 22, 2005

Yeah, actually, gamers in the house forever,

King Dopplepopolos posted:

That's his point. You're judging opposition movements solely on how the Evil West perceives them. It's something the political version of a hipster would do.

I was trying to explain why it is that people judge movements based on their relation to the West. Judging things on what the West supports alone is hardly sound reasoning, but it isn't random and there are reasons people use Western interests as a clue even when it should only be one thing to consider among many. Being at least provisionally wary of Western influence is far from the least accurate starting point for assumptions, even in cases where both sides are bad, like the Mujahadeen and the Soviet Union.

The X-man cometh
Nov 1, 2009

Mr. Sunshine posted:

E: If you think that somehow the protests in Spain are related to the Arab Spring you might as well go all out and claim that the entire Arab Spring started with the riots in Athens.

According to Tom Friedman, it was caused by Barack Obama, Google Earth and the Beijing Olymics and no joke, what a great place Israel is.

And this version can't even get that ridiculous.

eSports Chaebol posted:

Being at least provisionally wary of Western influence is far from the least accurate starting point for assumptions

Based on your username and avatar, does that mean you think North Korea's on the right track, and the South Korean government needs to be overthrown for its close ties to the US?

The X-man cometh fucked around with this message at 19:18 on May 19, 2011

eSports Chaebol
Feb 22, 2005

Yeah, actually, gamers in the house forever,

el samayo grande posted:

Based on your username and avatar, does that mean you think North Korea's on the right track, and the South Korean government needs to be overthrown for its close ties to the US?

No. Based on your post, do you oppose the South Korean government because it has abandoned the dictatorial ways of Syngman Rhee? I'm sure you don't. What's the point of these silly insinuations?

edit: To clarify, the Korean peninsula is an enlightening example because while South Korea is obviously far freer today than North Korea, the strongman the U.S. supported in South Korea to oppose Communism was hardly a huge fan of human rights! It's not as simple as "U.S. good, other guys bad" or "U.S. bad, other guys good".

eSports Chaebol fucked around with this message at 19:29 on May 19, 2011

The X-man cometh
Nov 1, 2009

eSports Chaebol posted:

No. Based on your post, do you oppose the South Korean government because it has abandoned the dictatorial ways of Syngman Rhee? I'm sure you don't. What's the point of these silly insinuations?

Then why is it imperialistic for the US military to support the rebels in Libya but not when they're defending South Korea? I support both missions, but you seem to have a double standard there.

Nonsense
Jan 26, 2007

el samayo grande posted:

Then why is it imperialistic for the US military to support the rebels in Libya but not when they're defending South Korea? I support both missions, but you seem to have a double standard there.

He hasn't demonstrated any double standard, you just don't want to see the U.S. as possibly supporting bad policy at all!

eSports Chaebol
Feb 22, 2005

Yeah, actually, gamers in the house forever,

el samayo grande posted:

Then why is it imperialistic for the US military to support the rebels in Libya but not when they're defending South Korea? I support both missions, but you seem to have a double standard there.

I think U.S. support for rebels really is partially based on a misguided sense of humanitarianism, similar to intervention in Kosovo; that doesn't mean such intervention is going to have a good outcome or is entirely sincere and divorced from our opposition to Qadaffi as an anti-American leader and self-styled leader of African socialism. Of course even this is further complicated by Qadaffi's compliance in the War on Terror, and that in his fervor to support rebels in Africa of any stripe that he has even helped train imperialist darlings like Blaise Compaore. And then on top of this there is the issue of access to Libyan resources.

And hell, even the Korean War wasn't so clear-cut. After all, things are pretty terrible in half the Korean peninsula today, and while it's mostly Kim Jong Il's fault, that doesn't mean the state of affairs today is the best possible outcome.

Space Monster
Mar 13, 2009

eSports Chaebol posted:

And hell, even the Korean War wasn't so clear-cut. After all, things are pretty terrible in half the Korean peninsula today, and while it's mostly Kim Jong Il's fault, that doesn't mean the state of affairs today is the best possible outcome.

I'm sorry we aren't good enough at war for you.

You seem to be making an attempt at being reasonable, but your opinion of 'anyone who the U.S. views as good must be bad!' is just not. Our government doesn't have pure as the driven snow motives, but whose does? In the case of Libya, Obama was forced to move because public opinion was so in favor of, if not helping the rebels, then at least stopping Gaddafi from massacring half of the country in retribution for revolting. The rebels seem to be pro-democracy, which is kind of the best we can hope for. There's not really a way to be sure. If seeming to be pro-democracy is also pro-US, then I guess the rest of the world should revert back to absolute monarchies?

(your avatar is hilarious btw, I'm assuming that's a reaction shot of him losing an army to spider mines?)

eSports Chaebol
Feb 22, 2005

Yeah, actually, gamers in the house forever,

Space Monster posted:

I'm sorry we aren't good enough at war for you.

You seem to be making an attempt at being reasonable, but your opinion of 'anyone who the U.S. views as good must be bad!' is just not.

I don't agree with that opinion. I agree with you that it is an unreasonable opinion. But people who welcome U.S. intervention in their countries should be eyed suspiciously even though they may turn out to have the best intentions, and the Libyan rebels are no exception.

quote:

Our government doesn't have pure as the driven snow motives, but whose does? In the case of Libya, Obama was forced to move because public opinion was so in favor of, if not helping the rebels, then at least stopping Gaddafi from massacring half of the country in retribution for revolting. The rebels seem to be pro-democracy, which is kind of the best we can hope for. There's not really a way to be sure. If seeming to be pro-democracy is also pro-US, then I guess the rest of the world should revert back to absolute monarchies?

When there isn't a way to be sure, I think that "First, do no harm" is a better policy than "First, drop bombs." It probably would have been wise to realize that we were picking sides in a civil war instead of backing a broad revolution before diving it. Hell, we won't even admit that that's what we're doing. And what will the outcome be if the rebels win? Will NATO stand by and let reprisals happen like they did in Kosovo? It seems pretty likely to be honest.

quote:

(your avatar is hilarious btw, I'm assuming that's a reaction shot of him losing an army to spider mines?)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y39Lv142-B0#t=21m38s

automatic
Nov 3, 2010

by Y Kant Ozma Post

eSports Chaebol posted:


And hell, even the Korean War wasn't so clear-cut. After all, things are pretty terrible in half the Korean peninsula today, and while it's mostly Kim Jong Il's fault, that doesn't mean the state of affairs today is the best possible outcome.

True, but how is this the fault of the UN/US forces? Plenty of blood and capital was spent trying to build South Korea into the country it is today. Obviously the US had less than altruistic motives, but so did the Soviets/Chinese.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

eSports Chaebol
Feb 22, 2005

Yeah, actually, gamers in the house forever,

automatic posted:

True, but how is this the fault of the UN/US forces? Plenty of blood and capital was spent trying to build South Korea into the country it is today. Obviously the US had less than altruistic motives, but so did the Soviets/Chinese.

They might have failed, but I bet diplomatic and even military attempts to settle the division of Korea other than staging a proxy war between the world's greatest powers on a tiny peninsula would have had a better outcome, even if it only meant for example that North Korea would still be a totalitarian state but at least one with much better living conditions for its people.

  • Locked thread