Search Amazon.com:
Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us $3,400 per month for bandwidth bills alone, and since we don't believe in shoving popup ads to our registered users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
«8 »
  • Post
  • Reply
Red_October_7000
Jun 22, 2009


Sixgun Strumpet posted:

Found one of the repros at a gunshow once. I considered it, but it's essentially just a really expensive wall hanger.

Are the reproductions unsuitable for shooting, as I've heard the originals are? Or is it just that such an arm is so complex to load that only the most dedicated would shoot it with any frequency?

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Sixgun Strumpet
Feb 16, 2009

I suspect I am still
terribly pleased.

Red_October_7000 posted:

Are the reproductions unsuitable for shooting, as I've heard the originals are? Or is it just that such an arm is so complex to load that only the most dedicated would shoot it with any frequency?

You can shoot it, but it a black powder monstrosity. It's neat, but more pleasurable to look at and fiddle with then fire because of all the cleanup involved. They also are pretty expensive. Which is to be expected, a lot of work goes into making one.

Butch Cassidy
Jul 28, 2010

Hey there partner!

Sixgun Strumpet posted:

...black powder monstrosity. It's neat, but more pleasurable to look at and fiddle with then fire because of all the cleanup involved....

Sixgun Strumpet
Feb 16, 2009

I suspect I am still
terribly pleased.

Butch Cassidy posted:



What? I'm not allowed to think that a revolver is more trouble then it is worth?

Butch Cassidy
Jul 28, 2010

Hey there partner!

I thought you were sullying the good name of black powder.

Sixgun Strumpet
Feb 16, 2009

I suspect I am still
terribly pleased.

Butch Cassidy posted:

I thought you were sullying the good name of black powder.

No, it's just that specific gun. I manhandled one at a gunshow and all I could think of was "This thing would be an everloving bitch to clean". Also, it was a lot of money.

I decided that if I was ever to have a LeMat I would just buy a real one, since I would never want to shoot it anyway.

Ygolonac
Nov 26, 2007

FURRED STREET,
BITCHES!




Butch Cassidy posted:

I thought you were sullying the good name of black powderHoly Black.

Corrected for infidel.

Myoclonic Jerk
Nov 10, 2008

Cool it a minute, babe, let me finish playing with my fake gun.


Sixgun Strumpet posted:

You can shoot it, but it a black powder monstrosity. It's neat, but more pleasurable to look at and fiddle with then fire because of all the cleanup involved.

Misread this the first time as "Black Power monstrosity."

Mad Dragon
Feb 29, 2004



Grand Prize Winner posted:

Would any of you guys happen to have a LeMat revolver? The thing seriously weirds me out.

http://forums.somethingawful.com/sh...1#post339849133

DeathSandwich
Apr 24, 2008

I fucking hate puzzles.


Chill_Bebop posted:



Do C96s count?

No it doesn't. Give it to me.

I totally wish there was a company that made functioning C96 replicas.

atomicthumbs
Dec 26, 2010



DeathSandwich posted:

No it doesn't. Give it to me.

I totally wish there was a company that made functioning C96 replicas.

TFR should start a company that makes awesome functioning gun replicas. Goon project!

Gtab
Dec 9, 2003

cop killer
cop killer
cop killer


atomicthumbs posted:

TFR should start a company that makes awesome functioning gun replicas. Goon project!

sigh

Safety Dance
Sep 10, 2007

Five degrees to starboard!

atomicthumbs posted:

TFR should start a company that makes awesome functioning gun replicas. Goon project!

I've considered doing this (not as a TFR project, though). I'd need to have lots of CNC and 3D scanning capabilities lined up before I even filed for the FFL.

Sixgun Strumpet
Feb 16, 2009

I suspect I am still
terribly pleased.

atomicthumbs posted:

TFR should start a company that makes awesome functioning gun replicas. Goon project!

Functioning gun replicas? That's a waste of time.

See, if you have a company capable of doing that you have a company capable of upgrading designs.

.22lr Volcanics, 1/2 scale FALs in .223, 9mm lever actions, 4.6x30mm chambered Hi Powers, 12 shot .22lr Webley Autorevolvers.

Come on man! Dream big!

Gtab
Dec 9, 2003

cop killer
cop killer
cop killer


Sixgun Strumpet posted:

Functioning gun replicas? That's a waste of time.

See, if you have a company capable of doing that you have a company capable of upgrading designs.

.22lr Volcanics, 1/2 scale FALs in .223, 9mm lever actions, 4.6x30mm chambered Hi Powers, 12 shot .22lr Webley Autorevolvers.

Come on man! Dream big!

Downscaled 5.56 FALs already exist.


Not FNCs, either. Not FN CALs either. It's the FALMP 5.56mm III rifles, Type 1 and Type 2 (STANAG and Steyr AUG mag, respectively).

Sixgun Strumpet
Feb 16, 2009

I suspect I am still
terribly pleased.

Gtab posted:

Downscaled 5.56 FALs already exist.


Not FNCs, either. Not FN CALs either. It's the FALMP 5.56mm III rifles, Type 1 and Type 2 (STANAG and Steyr AUG mag, respectively).

As far as I can tell none of them were imported.

So fine. A 1/4th scale FAL in .22lr. Ruger Bearcat style.

thermobollocks
Jul 5, 2009

GET A DILLON

Sixgun Strumpet posted:

As far as I can tell none of them were imported.

So fine. A 1/4th scale FAL in .22lr. Ruger Bearcat style.

How about just normal sized .22LR FALs?

Gtab
Dec 9, 2003

cop killer
cop killer
cop killer


Sixgun Strumpet posted:

As far as I can tell none of them were imported.

So fine. A 1/4th scale FAL in .22lr. Ruger Bearcat style.

Former goon Muldune had one. In Ohio.

Roadtard
May 24, 2008

The Sonnensault


Gtab posted:

Downscaled 5.56 FALs already exist.


Not FNCs, either. Not FN CALs either. It's the FALMP 5.56mm III rifles, Type 1 and Type 2 (STANAG and Steyr AUG mag, respectively).

Doesn't Miso have/had a .223 FAL?

Grand Prize Winner
Feb 19, 2007



The image in that post is broken! You're just taunting me now, aren't you?

snotball007
Dec 5, 2011

Disturbing in the least.

Safety Dance posted:

I've considered doing this (not as a TFR project, though). I'd need to have lots of CNC and 3D scanning capabilities lined up before I even filed for the FFL.

Also, from a legal standpoint, you would probably have to have a sizable wad of capital for licensing patents. Or just go the Glock and S&W route and pay the price after a lengthy lawsuit.

I like turtles
Aug 6, 2009

"Wouldn't want to see an angry turtle with a gun, would ya? "

Well...


Gtab posted:

Former goon Muldune had one. In Ohio.

There are also the Springfield .223 FALs. IIRC Miso/Miso's dad have a couple.

Carbohydrates
Nov 22, 2006

Listen, Mr. Kansas Law Dog.
Law don't go around here.
Savvy?


I was told this rifle might belong here.




A (probably) Belgian Warnant action rifle in 6mm Flobert (modern analogue: .22CB), built (probably) between 1888 and 1898. This is a gallery gun designed primarily so that people can get drunk and shoot stuff in a pub or shooting hall. The Warnant action involves a flip-up breech block, designed to be stronger than the Flobert action that preceded it.

commissargribb
Aug 12, 2003

The most dangerous thing on the battlefield is a junior officer with a compass and a map.


Sixgun Strumpet posted:

Functioning gun replicas? That's a waste of time.

See, if you have a company capable of doing that you have a company capable of upgrading designs.

.22lr Volcanics, 1/2 scale FALs in .223, 9mm lever actions, 4.6x30mm chambered Hi Powers, 12 shot .22lr Webley Autorevolvers.

Come on man! Dream big!

I would shoot the gently caress out of a .22 webley topbreak revolver.

Gray Stormy
Dec 19, 2006



commissargribb posted:

I would shoot the gently caress out of a .22 webley topbreak revolver.

I was just thinking this to myself today.

kwantam
Mar 25, 2008

-=kwantam


commissargribb posted:

I would shoot the gently caress out of a .22 webley topbreak revolver.

more or less AKA H&R 999. They rule.

Not an Anthem
Apr 27, 2003

I'm a fucking pain machine and if you even touch my fucking car I WILL FUCKING DESTROY YOU.


Carbohydrates posted:

This is .. designed .. so that people can get drunk and shoot stuff in a pub

This is therefore the coolest gun, clearly.

Alarbus
Mar 31, 2010


Following Carbohydrates' post

About two years ago, I posted these photos.

As a background, my grandfather brought it back from WWII, a sniper took a shot at him and mostly missed (grazed his eyebrow), and his men "got the sniper and retrieved the rifle". Unfortunately, while we've had this for a number of years, my grandfather's memory is faded, and fading further.







After he finished having an apopolexy, Cyrano posted this

Cyrano4747 posted:

Those marks are commercial inter-war German manufacturing proofs. They don't quite indicate what you've turned up though. The B-U-G sequence is found on just about every commercially produced gun that was made.

Crown over U = final inspection mark, I'm pretty sure this is when they proof fired it. I always forget what the B and G stood for, but they were the same in every factory, more or less. I want to say one was when they heat treated the steel and the other was when they blued it. I do know that it doesn't have anything to do with black powder or Suhl. I own a bunch of smokeless powder rifles with the exact same B-U-G sequence made at different factories.

You're right about the bore size though. Note that this does not imply any kind of cartridge - it's just the groove-groove measurement of the bore. You would need to get a chamber cast done to figure out what it shoots. I'm guessing one of the larger 8mm rimmed hunting rounds that were popular back then - maybe 8.15x46R.

1472 is the serial number.

I'm guessing the crown over G.K. is a manufacturer's mark, perhaps for the barrel. A lot of makers of fine firearms would buy barrels and actions separately back then, and there were a few companies in Germany and Britain that did a ton of business only making high quality barrels.

There IS a bit of a Suhl connection though, although it's not as direct as you thought - the writing on the barrel reads "P. Oberhammer König. Bayr. Hofbüchenmacher." This is a shortened form of "Peter Oberhammer, Königliche Bayerische Hofbüchenmacher," which translates to "Peter Oberhammer, Royal Bavarian house gun maker." Royalty back in the day would basically put artisan tradesmen on retainer for if they needed a jacket, rifle, chair, whatever - everything they owned was a bespoke item so they needed to have measurements, etc. on file with people they bought stuff from. Peter Oberhammer was a fairly famous gunsmith out of Munich in the late 19th century, so it's really not surprising that he had an ongoing relationship with the Bavarian royal family. The guy had a ton of patents on various target sights, so I'm almost certain that the sights on that rifle were of his design. He was also the local sales rep in Munich for JP Sauer, which was a German gun company based out of Suhl. The barrel could be a Suhl commercial barrel for all I know, but those proofs don't indicate anything one way or the other with that.

München - that's just the German spelling for Munich, where Peter Oberhammer was based out of.

A lot of guns like that were used by random Volkssturm units at the end of the war, basically confiscated by the state to arm last minute, last ditch militias. It's not all that surprising that a really nice target gun like that would get caught up in that mess.

Just in case you're not clear on this, I want to spell it out really clearly - what you have there is a very nice, VERY expensive late 19th or early 20th century bespoke rifle from one of the premier firearms houses in Imperial Bavaria. Don't try to "clean," refinish, or otherwise "improve" the wood. DOn't try to clean up the finish on the gun to make it prettier. Make sure it's stored properly. That is a DAMNED valuable gun and you need to have it appraised by someone who's certified for dealing with that level of firearm.

Do NOT try to disassemble it without the proper tools. It would be a crime to bugger up those screws with a cheap home depot screwdriver.

Seriously, that's a really valuable piece there.

eine dose socken followed up with this

eine dose socken posted:

The rifle you posted isn't a hunting rifle as far as i know, but an indoor target shooting rifle, called a Zimmerstutzen (short indoor rifle) or Scheibenstutzen (short target rifle).
Both the special stock and the tang diopter sights are typical of these traditional southern German sporting arms.

These often elaborate rifles were made for target shooters who used them at indoors competition at Schützen houses, village celebrations and in the back rooms of the local saloon. They normally fire either primer-only rounds or extremely light rounds like 6mm Flobert.
The light rounds were required by the fact that these competitions usually happened indoors and were a staple of everyday Bavarian shooting culture, shooting at painted wood targets (Schützenscheiben) with hunting motifs such as deer or boars.

Look at this rifle for example, it's very similar to yours:



http://www.feuerbixler.de/history11.html

These rifles are the precursors of modern target shooting rifles btw, and many German Schützen associations use similar modernized rifles.


Did anyone start the bar with the primer only gun back room?

mikerock
Oct 29, 2005

I know what you want. I know what you need.

6pm flobert is the same as .22cb? poo poo we had a nice old anschuetz in 6mm flobert for $150 that I passed on because I thought I couldn't get the ammo. We have a case of cci .22 cb gathering dust at the shop.

Carbohydrates
Nov 22, 2006

Listen, Mr. Kansas Law Dog.
Law don't go around here.
Savvy?


mikerock posted:

6pm flobert is the same as .22cb? poo poo we had a nice old anschuetz in 6mm flobert for $150 that I passed on because I thought I couldn't get the ammo. We have a case of cci .22 cb gathering dust at the shop.
Not quite identical, but you can certainly fire .22CB through a 6mm Flobert rifle. Just expect the cases to bulge a bit.

Cyrano4747
Sep 25, 2006

American planes, full of holes and wounded men, took off backwards from an airfield in England. Over France, a few German fighter planes flew at them backwards, sucked bullets and shell fragments from some of the planes and crewmen. They did the same for wrecked American bombers on the ground.

atomicthumbs posted:

TFR should start a company that makes awesome functioning gun replicas. Goon project!



Gtab posted:

sigh

To expand on this:

The long and the short of it is that making repros of things like C96s, Lugers, etc ends up being so expensive, both in terms of parts production and man-hours for the fitting, that you end up with a gun that costs more than a shooter-grade original. gently caress, half the time you end up with a gun that costs as much as a really great condition collector-grade original.

What's worse, you are selling such a niche product that you can't really cut costs through economies of scale.

It's a pipe dream. If you want to own a C96 just save up $750-900 or so for a semi-beater. They're not uncommon guns. My guess is that if I hit gunbroker right now there are at least 10 on there, and at least 2 that are shooter-grade guns at semi-reasonable prices.

edit: huh, fewer than I thought there would be. Only 7 up, and only 1 that's a fairly cheap beater/shooter. Still, not exactly too hard to find if you've got a $750-1000 bankroll.

If you're desperate to own a shooter-grade c96 keep an eye on this

Gtab
Dec 9, 2003

cop killer
cop killer
cop killer


i was actually sighing because goon projects are more guaranteed to failure than any other venture known to man including lead-to-gold dark ages alchemy and in the past goon gun manufacturing (Khalan, for example) has been nightmarishly bad to the point of being a joke, not because of how difficult it would be to make cost-effective replicas in general.

Cyrano4747
Sep 25, 2006

American planes, full of holes and wounded men, took off backwards from an airfield in England. Over France, a few German fighter planes flew at them backwards, sucked bullets and shell fragments from some of the planes and crewmen. They did the same for wrecked American bombers on the ground.

Gtab posted:

i was actually sighing because goon projects are more guaranteed to failure than any other venture known to man including lead-to-gold dark ages alchemy and in the past goon gun manufacturing (Khalan, for example) has been nightmarishly bad to the point of being a joke, not because of how difficult it would be to make cost-effective replicas in general.

Jesus christ. I just imagined a company with the organization and QC of Khalan making something where proper fitting and high quality, small parts are of the utmost importance, like early German autoloaders.

And yes, goon projects are 9 times in 10 doomed to end in tears and recrimination.

Sixgun Strumpet
Feb 16, 2009

I suspect I am still
terribly pleased.

Cyrano4747 posted:

Jesus christ. I just imagined a company with the organization and QC of Khalan making something where proper fitting and high quality, small parts are of the utmost importance, like early German autoloaders.

And yes, goon projects are 9 times in 10 doomed to end in tears and recrimination.

You mean you end up with something like this? http://www.gunbroker.com/Auction/Vi...?Item=276363230

Pitch
Jun 16, 2005

It is a truth universally
acknowledged that an
oniichan in possession
of good fortune must be
in want of an imouto.


Cyrano4747 posted:

Jesus christ. I just imagined a company with the organization and QC of Khalan making something where proper fitting and high quality, small parts are of the utmost importance, like early German autoloaders.
Probably not the worst case scenario. They'd never make it into battery and the hammer pins would fall out. A slightly more competent manufacturer might turn out a downright dangerous gun.

Beardless
Aug 12, 2011

I am Centurion Titus Polonius. And the only trouble I've had is that nobody seem to realize that I'm their superior officer.

What exactly is/was Khalan? A goon-run gun company apparently, but I've never heard of them before.

rossmum
Dec 2, 2008

Cummander ross, reporting for duty!



The goon who started it made terribly out-of-spec AR lowers, one of which forms the basis for the AR of Very Poor Decisions. Then he scammed people.

Destro85
Sep 24, 2002




Alarbus posted:

Following Carbohydrates' post

About two years ago, I posted these photos.

As a background, my grandfather brought it back from WWII, a sniper took a shot at him and mostly missed (grazed his eyebrow), and his men "got the sniper and retrieved the rifle". Unfortunately, while we've had this for a number of years, my grandfather's memory is faded, and fading further.







This a one hell of an amazing rifle with a great story. It looks like it has been well cared for too. My biggest question though, is how valuable is "DAMNED valuable"?

My thought process is that if it illicited that kind of response from Cyrano, then it's gotta be in the tens of thousands. I honestly have no idea though, thats just me pulling a number out my rear end.

Sixgun Strumpet
Feb 16, 2009

I suspect I am still
terribly pleased.

Destro85 posted:

This a one hell of an amazing rifle with a great story. It looks like it has been well cared for too. My biggest question though, is how valuable is "DAMNED valuable"?

My thought process is that if it illicited that kind of response from Cyrano, then it's gotta be in the tens of thousands. I honestly have no idea though, thats just me pulling a number out my rear end.

I'll trade you two hi points and a double barreled shotgun with a rail on it, the rail makes it way better then any old gun, you can put a laser on it! It's not really worth anything, the krauts made terrible guns, the only reason I want it is that I need the stock for wood carving, they did use good wood and I can use it to carve a really good duck.

Seriously, probably not tens of thousands, but likely multiple thousands. Just look up Schutzen rifles. You will come up with stuff like this:

http://www.cottoneauctions.com/disp...layItem_id=1033

Take care of it, and never sell it to anyone other them meeeeee

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Cyrano4747
Sep 25, 2006

American planes, full of holes and wounded men, took off backwards from an airfield in England. Over France, a few German fighter planes flew at them backwards, sucked bullets and shell fragments from some of the planes and crewmen. They did the same for wrecked American bombers on the ground.

Destro85 posted:

This a one hell of an amazing rifle with a great story. It looks like it has been well cared for too. My biggest question though, is how valuable is "DAMNED valuable"?

My thought process is that if it illicited that kind of response from Cyrano, then it's gotta be in the tens of thousands. I honestly have no idea though, thats just me pulling a number out my rear end.

Not tens of thousands, but also not chump change. I'm not familiar with the exact market on those guns, so I can't really give a good estimation.

That said, I fully admit that I tend to exaggerate things just a bit here when it comes to people I've never seen pulling odd, interesting, or valuable stuff out of their closets. Basically I've seen one too many cases of someone producing a cool rifle with some value and then doing something utterly retarded which destroys said value, usually in the pursuit of "cleaning it up" or "making it a bit prettier/restoring it."

Is that condescending? Yeah, a bit, and it makes me a prick, but it also makes people slow their roll a bit on breaking out the metal polishing compound.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply
«8 »