Search Amazon.com:
Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us $3,400 per month for bandwidth bills alone, and since we don't believe in shoving popup ads to our registered users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
«74 »
  • Post
  • Reply
Zaran
Mar 26, 2010


Alternate title: If Goons did Spaceflight it would end up like SeaLaunch - The Spaceflight Megathread 3.0


The writing says: Do not point this bit down or you will not go to space today.

Welcome to the third revision of the spaceflight megathread launcher thread. This thread is for all things related to the space industry, but not so much astronomy as we have a thread for that in DIY & Hobbies. Manned, unmanned, probe, satellite, DIY space projects, explosions, new technologies and private industry are all welcome here. Sometimes we like Meteors too it seems!

The one subject that we are not welcoming here is the "Buran vs Shuttle shitfest":

Luceo posted:

What I said was that there's a ridiculous amount of Buran-specific love in this thread for a spacecraft that only flew once. I'm a huge fan of the Russian space program; hell, it's actually the reason I studied the Russian language in college.

Buran may have been a superior machine to the shuttle, in theory, but it never got a chance to prove it. By virtue of being a spaceship that could make a completely unmanned flight and land automatically on a runway, was it pretty cool? Yes, yes it was. It still only flew once, regardless of the reasons, and compared to the shuttle's 133 successful missions spanning 30 years, all that can be said is that we'll never know what it could have been.

They were both spaceplanes, colossal wastes of money, and flawed designs. But I'm going to have to give the nod to the shuttle on this one by virtue of its accomplishments.

Next Launch:
Delta IV-M+ to take USAF WGS-5 into Orbit, so USAF can tell each other just how much they see you fap.

Rocket: Delta IV-M+ (5,4)
Payload: WGS-5
Launch Location: Cape Canaveral SLC-37B
Launch Window: 24 May 0027 UTC / 01:27am BST / 23rd May 8:27pm EDT
Webcast: http://www.ulalaunch.com/site/pages/Webcast.shtml

Upcoming Launch Manifest

Last Updated: May 7th

You can also Sync to the Google Calendar!

Be warned, this is still a work in progress!

Zaran fucked around with this message at May 21, 2013 around 11:09

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Zaran
Mar 26, 2010


Links to useful websites! - Stolen from last thread that was stolen from the thread before that.

News sites
http://www.astronomyaggregator.com/ - SA Goon Zero Gravitas' news site. Please help out by telling your friends!
http://www.space.com
http://www.spaceflightnow.com
http://www.nasaspaceflight.com - including the obligatory plug for L2 on the forums http://www.nasaspaceflight.com/l2

Space Agency Sites
http://www.nasa.gov
http://www.federalspace.ru/?lang=en
http://www.esa.int
http://www.asc-csa.gc.ca/eng/default.asp
http://www.cnsa.gov.cn/n615709/cindex.html
http://www.isro.org/
http://www.jaxa.jp/index_e.html

Private spaceflight companies
The wikipedia article below has a list of companies, spacecraft, and links to each ocmpany's page.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_o...light_companies

Blogs
http://waynehale.wordpress.com/ - Required reading for all
http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/beyondapollo/ - Came across this recently, plans for post-Apollo missions that never happened.

Useful Encyclopedia-style websites
http://www.astronautix.com/ - There is absolutely everything here. Seriously.
http://www.russianspaceweb.com/
http://www.buran-energia.com/

If I missed a site or a link is dead let me know and I will fix it!

If you are someone who hangs out on IRC, a lot of the posters in this thread can be found in #spaceflight @ irc.synirc.net

Remember, if you too want to feel like this guy below:

Check out the Kerbal Space Program thread: http://forums.somethingawful.com/sh...hreadid=3485342

Past OP Images:
Buran vs Shuttle Shitfest: http://i.imgur.com/Wt5iran.png (Never used this one in the OP, but sometimes refrence it in the thread)
Kerbals of the Mun: http://i.imgur.com/nlo6vyM.png
Iron Man Fixes Dragon: http://i.imgur.com/wfvHHiJ.png
All of humanity, except Michael Collins: http://i.imgur.com/cNH3Qs0.jpg

I just want to take this last line to thank thehustler who ran the last two threads and helped proof read the OP for me!

Zaran fucked around with this message at May 9, 2013 around 13:02

Toughy
Nov 29, 2004

"A grudge over food is deeper than the ocean."

Great job Zaran!!

uXs
May 3, 2005

Mark it zero!

edit: goddammit, read right over it. ignore!

roymorrison
Jul 26, 2005


What was the big deal that people were unwilling to talk about from the last thread. It sort of turned into this circle jerk over who was paying for access to another forum that had some kind of inside information on some big spaceflight announcement. Has whatever that was been publicly announced yet?

Zaran
Mar 26, 2010


Oh that was the announcement of the Golden Spike moon holiday company. We mostly laughed at it when it was made public and then forgot they exist.

roymorrison
Jul 26, 2005


That's it? Wow...underwhelming. Remind me to never get excited about space again. People were making it sound like we were going to land on Mars in the next 20 minutes.

Zero One
Dec 30, 2004

Z is the new C

Reposting because this was at the end of the last thread.

Check out my pictures from my tour of KSC and the VAB yesterday: http://imgur.com/a/5lYiU

Zero One fucked around with this message at Feb 18, 2013 around 21:14

JohnSherman
Feb 29, 2012

You're gonna bob and weave out of the path of a bullet? That I'd like to see.


roymorrison posted:

That's it? Wow...underwhelming. Remind me to never get excited about space again. People were making it sound like we were going to land on Mars in the next 20 minutes.

Well, yeah. People got excited because some relatively big names were attached to the company, but once the details came out it became pretty clear that it is likely just another pie in the sky.

e: The whole secrecy bullshit surrounding it got me to sign up for 2 months on L2. That is I'm never getting back.

JohnSherman fucked around with this message at Feb 18, 2013 around 21:21

roymorrison
Jul 26, 2005


Speaking of pie in the sky, what are the chances of this whole space asteroid mining industry actually taking off.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dVzR0kzklRE

I watch these guys and my eyes cant help but roll into the back of my skull. Are they really going to be able to pull raw materials back to Earth in the next couple years? I hope so but I cant help but feel like I'm just listening to a slick sales pitch loaded with industry buzzwords while watching that video.

Zaran
Mar 26, 2010


If they turn out to be unable to deliver on the mining front for the time being, as I am sure that at some point it will be viable perhaps just not yet, they will make a killing selling the Arkyd 100. $4Mill for a space telescope? I can think of a load of universities that will jump on that as soon as they can even here in the UK. Due to their small size you can probably get a good going rate to have yours sent up cheap on the Arianespace Vega or the Indian PSLV, perhaps even secondary cargo on the Falcon 9 or Falcon Heavy.

DeusExMachinima
Sep 2, 2012


So on a scale from 1 to "Ahahaha you're still insane but maybe if we've very lucky," what effect will the Russia impact/explosion have on space funding?

Deteriorata
Feb 6, 2005

TEAM LIBERAL
Defending and rationalizing Democratic policy since 2008
Please note: I represent the farthest left of allowed D&D discussion. Going beyond this point may result in probation

roymorrison posted:

Speaking of pie in the sky, what are the chances of this whole space asteroid mining industry actually taking off.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dVzR0kzklRE

I watch these guys and my eyes cant help but roll into the back of my skull. Are they really going to be able to pull raw materials back to Earth in the next couple years? I hope so but I cant help but feel like I'm just listening to a slick sales pitch loaded with industry buzzwords while watching that video.

It will work if they can get a vast array of theoretically possible, but untested, technologies all to work on the first try without the incremental development normally associated with spaceflight.

In other words, no. There's not a chance in the world this is going to work or prove to be economically feasible if it ever does. I'm unsure if it's just braggadocio from monied egos or a flat-out scam.

redshirt
Aug 11, 2007
At my post

Does anyone know if Bigelow will have a chance to test one of their inflatable habitats anytime soon? I vaguely recall hearing something about it.

Zaran
Mar 26, 2010


redshirt posted:

Does anyone know if Bigelow will have a chance to test one of their inflatable habitats anytime soon? I vaguely recall hearing something about it.

Yes! They are sending one to the ISS in 2015, using the SpaceX Dragon's external trunk space to ship it.

thehustler
Apr 17, 2004

I am very curious about this little crescendo


JohnSherman posted:

Well, yeah. People got excited because some relatively big names were attached to the company, but once the details came out it became pretty clear that it is likely just another pie in the sky.

e: The whole secrecy bullshit surrounding it got me to sign up for 2 months on L2. That is I'm never getting back.

Mine all the docs you can out of it. It was a lot more fun having L2 when the Shuttle was around.

thehustler
Apr 17, 2004

I am very curious about this little crescendo


Also I really am sorry about the L2 stuff

Bistromatic
Oct 3, 2004

And turn the inner eye
To see its path...


It's OK, lets talk about Buran instead.

Paradoxish
Dec 19, 2003

Will you stop going crazy in there?

Deteriorata posted:

In other words, no. There's not a chance in the world this is going to work or prove to be economically feasible if it ever does. I'm unsure if it's just braggadocio from monied egos or a flat-out scam.

A big part of the problem is that there's not a lot of money in the incremental steps, so you can't really have start-ups coming out to say "well, someday we want to mine asteroids, but only after a decade of trial and error with very little likely return." The fact that somebody has to go first and do all the unexciting, unprofitable stuff is a huge road block for private spaceflight ventures that aren't just trying to iterate on stuff we already do.

Icon Of Sin
Dec 26, 2008



Some pics I meant to post in the last thread, but forgot to because I'm a scrub:





MrYenko
Jun 17, 2012

#2 isn't ALWAYS bad...


Icon Of Sin posted:

Some pics I meant to post in the last thread, but forgot to because I'm a scrub:







I think the shuttle was one of the bigger mistakes our government has ever made, but damned if I don't get a weird feeling seeing the flight articles relegated to a museum...

MattD1zzl3
Oct 26, 2007


MrYenko posted:

I think the shuttle was one of the bigger mistakes our government has ever made, but damned if I don't get a weird feeling seeing the flight articles relegated to a museum...

A Winner is Jew posted:

The intent was sound (mostly re-usable orbiter and launch vehicle), but the execution was mostly all hosed up due to the Air Force adding on a bunch of poo poo to the program so they could take it in case of communists or something like that.



I dont say the "b-u-r" word, but i reject the opinion that the worlds only operational manned spaceplane in history can be considered a mistake. If compromises had to be made to get it funded, that can only be considered a failure if you share how else exactly they should have paid to get the thing built and beyond the prototype/testing phase.

A Winner is Jew
Feb 14, 2008

Shabbat shalom motherfucker!

MrYenko posted:

I think the shuttle was one of the bigger mistakes our government has ever made, but damned if I don't get a weird feeling seeing the flight articles relegated to a museum...

The intent was sound (mostly re-usable orbiter and launch vehicle), but the execution was almost all hosed up due to the Air Force adding on a bunch of poo poo to the program so they could take it over in case of communists or something like that.

Icon Of Sin
Dec 26, 2008



MrYenko posted:

I think the shuttle was one of the bigger mistakes our government has ever made, but damned if I don't get a weird feeling seeing the flight articles relegated to a museum...

It was a beautiful piece of tech, if nothing else. It could get into LEO (which is an accomplishment all it's own), dock with the space station, survive re-entry (with one exception) at ~Mach 25, and glide to landing. A piece of machinery that can do that (repeatedly) is still pretty amazing, all things considered. And seeing it up close was amazing in it's own right

Volmarias
Dec 31, 2002

This could be too paranoid to be effective, but it's a thought.

...

See, stuff like that make me confident in my decision to convert a Jovian moon mine shaft into a survival bunker!

MattD1zzl3 posted:

I dont say the "b-u

Stop it. Stop it right there. I swear this thread had better not turn into another dick waving poo poo fest about whose spaceships are the best or whether spaceplanes are cool or whatever. I just can't take it.

\/\/\/ Edit: Buran inevitably turns into a long, drawn out circular discussion about whether Buran was better than the Shuttle, which leads to a discussion about how terrible the shuttle was, which is ground that we've trodden roughly ten zillion times give or take a launch failure, and it's just boring at this point.

Volmarias fucked around with this message at Feb 19, 2013 around 00:26

reagan
Apr 29, 2008

jawohl mein fuhrer

Bistromatic posted:

It's OK, lets talk about Buran instead.

The amount of goons who loving complain about this in these threads is amazing.

Edit: Close the thread already, because apparently a few people can't talk about space without getting extremely upset when the Buran gets mentioned.

Grand Fromage
Jan 30, 2006

You wildly underestimated my liver's ability to metabolize toxins.

DeusExMachinima posted:

So on a scale from 1 to "Ahahaha you're still insane but maybe if we've very lucky," what effect will the Russia impact/explosion have on space funding?

One would hope this will make a lot more people take the asteroid threat seriously, but I'm guessing it won't. My cynical self says either we need to spot a large one well in advance that's guaranteed to hit or a city needs to get wiped out by an asteroid before we do anything about it.

But who knows. This is the first meteor strike that did any kind of serious damage to a populated area, so maybe it'll get things rolling.

Volmarias
Dec 31, 2002

This could be too paranoid to be effective, but it's a thought.

...

See, stuff like that make me confident in my decision to convert a Jovian moon mine shaft into a survival bunker!

Grand Fromage posted:

But who knows. This is the first meteor strike that did any kind of serious damage to a populated area, so maybe it'll get things rolling.

CNN was doing a piece on how the children were all scared because of the meteor. I think we need to have a meteor smack into a city in Western Europe or the US before we see any funding.

McDowell
Aug 1, 2008

Surely, Caligula was my greatest role

Grand Fromage posted:

But who knows. This is the first meteor strike that did any kind of serious damage to a populated area, so maybe it'll get things rolling.

Space power nations might get more involved with asteroid interception/ mining because of the dual use implications.

Russians don't want America to independently develop technology for directed meteorites and vice versa. Hence the existence of Buran.

Klyith
Aug 3, 2007
...and finally, harnessing several dead horses together for increased speed.

So that Indian satellite launch is interesting. I'd never thought about it, but India is a pretty good country for a launch site. Equatorial, good tech base and supply of educated workers, english is widely spoken... I think I'd rather work there than French Guiana.

However, their launch base is on the east coast, against the Bay of Bengal. For a launch to polar orbit, doesn't the rocket have to go west? Are they going to be firing back over land? If there's one thing India doesn't have a lot of, it's unoccupied space where a failed rocket could fall safely.


Volmarias posted:

another dick waving poo poo fest about whose spaceships are the best
I think one of the reasons that the USA vs CCCP stuff can get so heated is that a lot of the same things that make the Soviet space program so good* were the same things that made the country as a whole suck. I'd rather idolize Korolev than Von Braun, but I wouldn't want to live in Russia either in 1970 or today.

*at least in terms of accomplishing a lot with limited resources

Wooten
Oct 4, 2004



roymorrison posted:

Speaking of pie in the sky, what are the chances of this whole space asteroid mining industry actually taking off.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dVzR0kzklRE

In all the concept images it shows these probes happily melting material off of what appears to be a perfectly still asteroid. I imagine a 100m asteroid could do a lot of damage to a tiny space probe if it rotated into it. How will they handle the fact that most asteroids have quite a bit of rotation to them? How do you stop an asteroid from spinning? I imagine it would take quite a bit of force to stop something with the density of platinum.

Beer4TheBeerGod
Aug 23, 2004

Ere we go, ere we go, ere we go, ere we go through the cosmos
Ere we go, ere we go, ere we go, don't know where till we get there. Da red wunz go fasta

Best GM on the forums next to Tias, even if he is a brony :v

I just want to say the cyanotype prints this guy sells are fantastic. I got two of the Orion ones for Christmas, and I was so impressed I ordered two more.

Breaky
Jul 21, 2006

STRIKE FIRST
STRIKE HARD
NO MERCY SIR


Beer4TheBeerGod posted:

I just want to say the cyanotype prints this guy sells are fantastic. I got two of the Orion ones for Christmas, and I was so impressed I ordered two more.

Well. Thanks. There goes the rest of my spending money for this month.

Nth Doctor
Sep 7, 2010

Anybody remotely interesting is mad in some way.


Icon Of Sin posted:

Some pics I meant to post in the last thread, but forgot to because I'm a scrub:







I think I have my own version of each one of these.

I bring this up literally every time I see someone post pics of Discovery at Udvar-Hazy, but did you get a picture of the Gemini VII capsule just to Discovery's starboard side? The mind boggles at two guys spending nearly 14 days in that thing.

Here's a quick phone shot I took the second time I visited discovery. The woman and toddler just walking into the hangar are Mrs. and N+1th Doctor.

Elukka
Feb 17, 2011



Deteriorata posted:

It will work if they can get a vast array of theoretically possible, but untested, technologies all to work on the first try without the incremental development normally associated with spaceflight.
Their plan is to build small space telescopes to look for asteroids, then small space telescopes with engines to take a closer look, then explore several asteroids and then perhaps look into mining water. If they ever get that far they'll start looking into metals. On their website they even say that their near-term goal is to "dramatically reduce the cost of asteroid exploration". I don't know likely it is they're successful but it's not at all true they just intend to send some spaceship to mine some platinum in the next few years and hope it works.

MattD1zzl3 posted:

I dont say the "b-u-r" word, but i reject the opinion that the worlds only operational manned spaceplane in history can be considered a mistake. If compromises had to be made to get it funded, that can only be considered a failure if you share how else exactly they should have paid to get the thing built and beyond the prototype/testing phase.
Being the only operational spaceplane is hardly a merit in on itself. I mean, it's sorta cool, but it means nothing in a practical sense. It's much worse than conventional rockets. When NASA was stuck with what may be the most extravagantly expensive launch vehicle in history for three decades it's understandable why one might call it a mistake.

Elukka fucked around with this message at Feb 19, 2013 around 03:29

Jewcoon
Oct 12, 2012


Klyith posted:

So that Indian satellite launch is interesting. I'd never thought about it, but India is a pretty good country for a launch site. Equatorial, good tech base and supply of educated workers, english is widely spoken... I think I'd rather work there than French Guiana.

However, their launch base is on the east coast, against the Bay of Bengal. For a launch to polar orbit, doesn't the rocket have to go west? Are they going to be firing back over land? If there's one thing India doesn't have a lot of, it's unoccupied space where a failed rocket could fall safely.



Polar orbits go either (mostly) North or South. From India, I'd assume they'd be launching south, out over the ocean.

StephanKetz
Feb 21, 2005



And another asteroid mining company appears:

"Today's impact in Russia and the near miss by asteroid 2012 DA14 should shock the world enough to finally act with determination to create an appropriate defense system. Since we didn't even see the comet coming that exploded yesterday over Russia injuring over 1200 people and damaging buildings, a detection system in orbit would be a first step. The newly founded asteroid mining company Deep Space Industries is proposing to install a sentry line of spacecraft circling the Earth to intercept and evaluate incoming threats - a project on which they are already working."

http://www.scienceworldreport.com/a...ense-system.htm

http://deepspaceindustries.com

Icon Of Sin
Dec 26, 2008



Nth Doctor posted:

I think I have my own version of each one of these.

I bring this up literally every time I see someone post pics of Discovery at Udvar-Hazy, but did you get a picture of the Gemini VII capsule just to Discovery's starboard side? The mind boggles at two guys spending nearly 14 days in that thing.

Here's a quick phone shot I took the second time I visited discovery. The woman and toddler just walking into the hangar are Mrs. and N+1th Doctor.



I have that exact same picture too I took a lot of photos while there, those were just the 3 that I had floating around my imgur account. That entire hangar (where the shuttle itself is) is amazing, with the Apollo, Gemini and Mercury capsules, space suits, heat shields, and all the other aircraft there as well. The Enola Gay has a home there, along with a few surviving Nazi warplanes (like the rocket-powered plane that I forget the name of), a Concord, an SR-71 Blackbird (which on it's final flight went from LA to DC in like 2 hours ) and among a lot of other things I'm just not remembering right now. Admission to it is free (though you have to pay for parking ) and I highly recommend going.

Is this the capsule you're thinking of? It barely looks like it would fit one person, but I can see NASA cramming 2 people into it.



e: Imgur is finally spitting out some other pics too. A Saturn V Instrumentation Unit:

Icon Of Sin fucked around with this message at Feb 19, 2013 around 04:45

Nth Doctor
Sep 7, 2010

Anybody remotely interesting is mad in some way.


Icon Of Sin posted:

Is this the capsule you're thinking of? It barely looks like it would fit one person, but I can see NASA cramming 2 people into it.



e: Imgur is finally spitting out some other pics too. A Saturn V Instrumentation Unit:


That's the one!

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

uapyro
Jan 13, 2005


Icon Of Sin posted:


Is this the capsule you're thinking of? It barely looks like it would fit one person, but I can see NASA cramming 2 people into it.




I tried to find some of the pictures from my Gemini capsule, but they didn't turn out so well in a very cramped room.

Little trivia for everyone: Did any pre-shuttle craft ever get reused for 2 missions?

uapyro fucked around with this message at Feb 19, 2013 around 05:14

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply
«74 »