Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
Rebochan
Feb 2, 2006

Take my evolution

Worst Middle East Cartoon: C
Really, it was just a matter of picking which Dry Bones was the worst, and it was not easy.
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: E
All of the police brutality cartoons were stomach churning, but this one is a position real people are taking and seeing it in cartoon form is even more vomit inducing than usual. AND HE STILL SHARPTON FAT!
Worst Torture Report Cartoon: J
"Oh boo hoo, how DARE the Democrats ruin our CHRISTMAS by making us read about TORTURE!" I sometimes forget dad-joker JRROSE is in fact a lovely human being as well as a dad-joker.
Worst The Interview Cartoon: D.
Pushing it over was the fact that dragon is in multiple Catalinos.
Worst cartoon about a tragedy: B
It was a tough pick between A and B for trying to slam loving golf jokes into serious tragedies. That actually made it descend to a lower level of hell to me.
Worst caricature: G
There's a special level of pettiness when you realize that everyone ELSE in this category was a politician, and this is a racist caricature of a woman that makes mild criticism of *video games*. And that was Gamergate in a nutshell! All of the godawfulness of our usual crowd, except directed at something with almost zero impact on the world and targeting people who have no real power.
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: O
Because gently caress YOU MCCOY
Worst Label: J
You are wrong about everything.
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: A
That took some special effort. It was a race between A and C though McCoy's pettiness towards a dead black kid really pushed him over.
Laziest cartoon: A

Most easily reinterpreted: A
So easy you almost wonder if Bruce had a moment of sobriety when he drew it.
Overall worst political cartoon of the year: I
This one filled me with the most RAGE out of any excrement I saw this year.
Best edit/parody: Q.
Gonna keep that one around for years to come...

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Kumaton
Mar 6, 2013

OWLBEARS, SON
Worst Middle East Cartoon: K
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: B
Worst Torture Report Cartoon: H
Worst The Interview Cartoon: B
Worst cartoon about a tragedy: I
Worst caricature: B
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: A
Worst Label: N
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: H
Laziest cartoon: L
Most easily reinterpreted: K
Overall worst political cartoon of the year: F
Best edit/parody: A

Defenestration
Aug 10, 2006

"It wasn't my fault that my first unconscious thought turned out to be-"
"Jesus, kid, what?"
"That something smelled delicious!"


Grimey Drawer
Worst Middle East Cartoon L
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon A
Worst Torture Report Cartoon D
Worst The Interview Cartoon A
Worst cartoon about a tragedy B
Worst caricature A
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon I
Worst Label K
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon H
Laziest cartoon A
Most easily reinterpreted A
Overall worst political cartoon of the year I

Best edit/parody Q (It's not the right genre, but dammit, it scans, and I like rewarding effort)

DarklyDreaming
Apr 4, 2009

Fun scary
Worst Middle East Cartoon:
C

Worst Police Brutality Cartoon:
D

Worst Torture Report Cartoon:
H

Worst The Interview Cartoon:
B

Worst Cartoon About a Tragedy:
H

Worst Caricature:
G

Worst "A Thing Happened" Cartoon:
C

Worst Label:
J

Least Concealed Bigotry in a Cartoon:
H

Laziest Cartoon:
K

Most Easily Reinterpreted:
B

Overall Worst Political Cartoon of the Year:
C

Best Edit/Parody:
I

Funosaurus
May 28, 2009



Worst Middle East Cartoon: B
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: A
Worst Torture Report Cartoon: D
Worst The Interview Cartoon: A
Worst cartoon about a tragedy: I
Worst caricature: C
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: A
Worst Label: G
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: O
Laziest cartoon: A
Most easily reinterpreted: B
Overall worst political cartoon of the year: D
Best edit/parody: O

R. Mute
Jul 27, 2011

let's do this

Worst Middle East Cartoon - G
Hard start. They're all pretty repulsive and I was very much tempted to vote A or C (for approving of murdering children and calling for genocide), but G wins out because of how insufferably smug, childish and callous it is.

Worst Police Brutality Cartoon - F
Difficult again, but the cold calculation involved in trying to spin this to serve the small government agenda is just sickening. It wins out over the Allie because it manages to shoehorn 'police as victims' in there.

Worst Torture Report Cartoon - G
Easier this, because of the reckless disregard of reality.

Worst The Interview Cartoon - A
This is just a bad cartoon in the technical sense. It's just so bad.

Worst cartoon about a tragedy - F
B's a close second. Both use the tragedy to score cheap and unrelated points, but F wins because the victims were Muslims as well, you idiot.

Worst caricature - C

Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon - C
lmao

Worst Label - B
Has to be a Ramirez, obviously. But which one? Decisions. J's the best label, btw.

Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon - All of them, but mostly C I guess

Laziest cartoon - J

Most easily reinterpreted - B
Ramirez once again faces his mortal enemies - the metaphor and painful irony.

Overall worst political cartoon of the year - E
J with a dishonourable second place.

Best edit/parody - E
Hmm. E, F or J, for me. E just edges it, imo.

ToxicFrog
Apr 26, 2008


I had a lot of trouble deciding whether "worst" means "worst opinions" or "worst expression of those opinions".

Worst Middle East Cartoon: C

Ramirez put in a good effort, but Kirschen's combination of really lovely artwork and an open call for genocide takes the crown. We can only hope that the crown is made of angry bees.

Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: B

This was a tough one but Ramirez edges out Rall and Braco.

Worst Torture Report Cartoon: G

I almost voted for D, but G's literally-the-opposite-of-reality approach offends me more.

Worst The Interview Cartoon: A

They're all poo poo but A manages to be both poo poo and incomprehensible label salad.

Worst Cartoon About a Tragedy: H

There's a lot of vile opinions in this category, and also a lot of "what the gently caress is this even trying to say". But in the end I have to go with Gorrell for lazily making GBS threads out a maple leaf and calling it a day.

Worst Caricature: C

Do I go with Ramirez's Captain Flatfish, or Kirschen's actual Nazi propaganda? A difficult choice, but in the end A inspired at least some chuckles for its sheer ineptitude while C inspires only loathing and horror. Dishonourable mention to D, which should win the "most easily mistaken for a bag of popcorn" category.

Worst "A Thing Happened": D

Ramirez makes a good effort with Ebola Gay, but [unreadable squiggle] races past him by turning "a thing happened" into "microsoft employees are literal parasites".

Worst Label: G

There are worse cartoons overall in this category but DEBT DEBT DEBT DEBT DEBT DEBT DEBT. The only other real contender is K, but that is somehow less visually offensive.

Least Concealed Bigotry: C

Holy poo poo in the end I just threw a dart :suicide:

Laziest Cartoon: F

Many of these cartoons are the result of basically zero effort on the part of what we laughably call the artist, but this one has the additional bonus of claiming that Turkey is bent on world domination.

Most Easily Reinterpreted: B

If it weren't signed "Ramirez" I would think this is genuinely and without sarcasm A Good Cartoon.

Overall Worst: G

It looks like someone threw up on my monitor.

Best Edit: D

Ye Fowle Herald, of course.

zakharov
Nov 30, 2002

:kimchi: Tater Love :kimchi:
Worst Middle East Cartoon - C
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon - E
Worst Torture Report Cartoon - D
Worst The Interview Cartoon - A
Worst cartoon about a tragedy - J
Worst caricature - F
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon - O
Worst Label - E
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon - H
Laziest cartoon - A
Most easily reinterpreted - B
Overall worst political cartoon of the year - F
Best edit/parody - K

Biffmotron
Jan 12, 2007

Worst Middle East Cartoon: C
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: E
Worst Torture Report Cartoon: D
Worst The Interview Cartoon: B
Worst cartoon about a tragedy: E
Worst caricature: G
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: I
Worst Label: K
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: A
Laziest cartoon: E
Most easily reinterpreted: B
Overall worst political cartoon of the year: G
Best Edit/Parody: I

World Famous W
May 25, 2007

BAAAAAAAAAAAA
Worst Middle East Cartoon: C

Worst Police Brutality Cartoon :B

Worst Torture Report Cartoon: G

Worst The Interview Cartoon: B
Why was this a category?

Worst cartoon about a tragedy: G

Worst caricature: B

Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: Q

Worst Label: E

Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: E
All of them

Laziest cartoon: A
Ha, as if Gorrell wasn't winning this

Most easily reinterpreted: C

Overall worst political cartoon of the year: I


Best edit/parody: O
Need to spread the well deserved love around.

Arsonist Daria
Feb 27, 2011

Requiescat in pace.
Worst Middle East Cartoon:
C This man is literally talking about genocide.

Worst Police Brutality Cartoon:
A Lot of strong contenders here, but this one stands out as the worst. Maybe it's because Ramirez is using Mel Brooks for evil.

Worst Torture Report Cartoon:
G It's actually very arguable, Lester. That's what the document loving says.

Worst The Interview Cartoon:
B Most of these cartoons are merely inept. This one is pointlessly racist and it isn't even accurate on what race.

Worst Cartoon About a Tragedy:
J Putin-senpai, how mighty you are! :swoon:

Worst Caricature:
A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qvAeWR-aE6U

Worst "A Thing Happened" Cartoon:
Q If only millennials knew the joys of transportation.

Worst Label:
K I didn't think anyone could outdo another lazy Ramirez DEBT cartoon but just look at this loving trainwreck.

Least Concealed Bigotry in a Cartoon:
C Yeah the old hick from Duck Dynasty is basically Jesus, Branco, I can see how this is a reasonable conclusion to reach since Jesus was killed for thinking gay people are gross and evil.

Laziest Cartoon:
A Hope picking up the pen to write the caption didn't strain you, Gorrell.

Most Easily Reinterpreted:
A Tinsley teetering on the edge of self-awareness.

Overall Worst Political Cartoon of the Year:
I Looking over all the other Ramirez entries, I kept thinking "No, this can't be the worst this year." Then I saw this comic again and yeah, this is it. This is the loving worst.

Best Edit/Parody:
J Can't help but love the manic labeling.

GorfZaplen
Jan 20, 2012

Worst Middle East Cartoon: C

Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: E

Worst Torture Report Cartoon: D

Worst The Interview Cartoon: B

Worst cartoon about a tragedy: C

Worst caricature: C

Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: O

Worst Label: I

Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: A

Laziest cartoon: A

Most easily reinterpreted: B

Overall worst political cartoon of the year: D

Best edit/parody: D

Crameltonian
Mar 27, 2010
Worst Middle East Cartoon: C
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: J
Worst Torture Report Cartoon: D
Worst The Interview Cartoon: B
Worst cartoon about a tragedy: F
Worst caricature: C
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: E
Worst Label: J
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: C
Laziest cartoon: M
Most easily reinterpreted: D
Overall worst political cartoon of the year: D
Best Edit/Parody: I

dbzfandiego
Sep 17, 2011
Worst Middle East Cartoon: G
gently caress YOU Kirschen
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: A
gently caress YOU Ramirez.
Worst Torture Report Cartoon: G
gently caress YOU Lester.
Worst The Interview Cartoon:D
Catalino is one of the worst "artist" I've ever seen.
Worst cartoon about a tragedy: C
gently caress YOU Branco
Worst caricature: B
See Worst The Interview Cartoon category for my response.
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: O
gently caress YOU McCoy
Worst Label: K
That's true incompetence.
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: A
A LOT of "good" choices in that category Also a Double gently caress YOU to the McCoys
Laziest cartoon: A
No Question about it.
Most easily reinterpreted: B
Crowded field there too.
Overall worst political cartoon of the year: I
Ramirez is an insult to humanity.
Best edit/parody: N
But they are all winners in my heart

The Wiggly Wizard
Aug 21, 2008


Worst Middle East Cartoon
F
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon
F
Worst Torture Report Cartoon
H
Worst The Interview Cartoon
B
Worst cartoon about a tragedy
H
Worst caricature
F
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon
J
Worst Label
J
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon
D
Laziest cartoon
A
Most easily reinterpreted
K
Overall worst political cartoon of the year
D
Best edit/parody
D

fool of sound
Oct 10, 2012
C
D
D
D
A
E
J
N
D
A :ironicat:
B
C
E

Bandanna
Nov 3, 2005

Bulletproof
Worst Middle-East Cartoon: C
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: C
Worst Torture Report Cartoon: D
Worst The Interview Cartoon: A
Worst Cartoon About a Tragedy: F
Worst Caricature: A
Worst "A Thing Happened" Cartoon: I
Worst Label: G
Least Concealed Bigotry in a Cartoon: H
Laziest Cartoon: A
Most Easily Reinterpreted: B
Overall Worst Cartoon of the Year: J
Best Edit: A

Holy crap was choosing the best edit hard, so many good ones.

Spooky Hyena
May 2, 2014

Choosing to benefit from an empire of murder and genocide makes you complicit.
:scotland:
lol, nice meltdown
Worst Middle East Cartoon: C
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: B
Worst Torture Report Cartoon: D
Worst The Interview Cartoon: B
Worst cartoon about a tragedy: F
Worst caricature: A
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: P
Worst Label: I
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: O
Laziest cartoon: A
Most easily reinterpreted: B
Overall worst political cartoon of the year: I
Best Edit/Parody: I

Technogeek
Sep 9, 2002

by FactsAreUseless
Worst Middle East Cartoon: E
There were a lot of terrible ones, but that one just barely edged out thanks to the twofer of "what the gently caress is wrong with you".

Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: G
The whole thing with de Blasio and the NYPD has pushing all my "gently caress the police" buttons since it started, so that one was kind of a no-brainer.

Worst Torture Report Cartoon: I
Barely edged out B by virtue of a Feinstein caricature that makes even less sense than Wormbama.

Worst The Interview Cartoon: B
The lazy racism is what pushes this past the others.

Worst cartoon about a tragedy: C
There were a lot of valiant efforts, but the decision to literally portray black people as dogs gave C that extra little bit of Stormfront spice.

Worst caricature: A
And this is the only caricature that makes less sense than the Feinstein one in my vote for Worst Torture Report Cartoon. (Although G was very nearly a tie.)

Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: P
Probably the hardest category to make a decision on, but the decision to split the Thing between two different (yet very nearly redundant) bits of text, and then shove one of them into a tiny box at the corner, was inspired in its shittiness.

Worst Label: G
There were a number of cartoons with too-long labels and a number of cartoons with too many labels, but only Ramirez could find a way to shoehorn the word "debt" into that many places.

Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: C
I was originally going to vote for D. But as I was writing this, the cartoon somehow managed to pull off an integer overflow of bigotry by leaving me confused as to precisely what stereotype it was attempting to reinforce. C both made it obvious and had a terrible caricature, so it won out in the end.

Laziest cartoon: K
Again, several valiant efforts, but K got the nod by simply not caring enough to find a photograph that lacked JPG artifacts.

Most easily reinterpreted: D
I assume the cartoon was supposed to be something about amnesty, but instead it managed to straddle the line between "Nonsense, this is an election year" and Asay-esque "how is this a bad thing". The result was something that's impossible not to reinterpret.

Overall worst political cartoon of the year: I
Rather than explain why this one got my vote (because seriously), I'm just going to say that the fact that it got my vote is the reason I didn't vote for it in any other category. May as well give the second-stringers a chance.

Best edit/parody: E
What can I say? I'm a sucker for Who Framed Roger Rabbit? jokes.

Ramrod Hotshot
May 30, 2003

Worst Middle East Cartoon C
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon A
Worst Torture Report Cartoon H
Worst The Interview Cartoon A
Worst cartoon about a tragedy I
Worst caricature D
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon G
Worst Label K
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon H
Laziest cartoon K
Most easily reinterpreted A
Overall worst political cartoon of the year B
Best edit/parody I

I Love Annie May
Oct 10, 2012
Worst Middle East Cartoon C
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon E
Worst Torture Report Cartoon B
Worst The Interview Cartoon B
Worst cartoon about a tragedy C
Worst caricature E
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon O
Worst Label G
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon J
Laziest cartoon A
Most easily reinterpreted A
Overall worst political cartoon of the year I
Best edit/parody G

Huge Liability
Mar 2, 2010
Worst Middle East A
Worst police brutality cartoon B
Worst torture report cartoon D
Worst interview cartoon B
Worst cartoon about a tragedy H
Worst caricature F
Worst "a thing happened" cartoon J
Worst label C
Least concealed bigotry A
Laziest cartoon A
Most easily reinterpreted C
Overall worst E
Best edit/parody D

I'll admit that my vote for the worst tragedy cartoon is personal, because it gave me a taste of how citizens every other country in the world must feel when they see American commentary about their country.

"Why indeed" gets two votes from me not just because of the subject matter and the tastelessness, but the utter smugness that emanates. I can just picture Mr. Ramirez leaning back in his chair, admiring his work and thinking, "Guess you should have thought of this before you chose to be born Palestinian, parent of brutally slaughtered child."

ClothHat
Mar 2, 2005

ASK ME ABOUT MY LOVE OF THE LUMPEN-GOBLITARIAT
protip: trust no links I post
Worst Middle East Cartoon: C
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: A
Worst Torture Report Cartoon: D
Worst The Interview Cartoon: B
Worst cartoon about a tragedy: J
Worst caricature: G
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: C
Worst Label: B
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: A
Laziest cartoon:C
Most easily reinterpreted: B
Overall worst political cartoon of the year: H
Best edit/parody: I

De Nomolos
Jan 17, 2007

TV rots your brain like it's crack cocaine
Worst Middle East Cartoon: K
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: A
Worst Torture Report Cartoon: D
Worst The Interview Cartoon: A
Worst cartoon about a tragedy: J
Worst caricature: A
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: I
Worst Label: G
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: D
Laziest cartoon: A
Most easily reinterpreted: D
Overall worst political cartoon of the year: C
Best edit/parody: D

Reo
Apr 11, 2003

That'll do, Carlos.
That'll do.


Worst Middle East Cartoon: K
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: I
Worst Torture Report Cartoon: D
Worst The Interview Cartoon: A
Worst cartoon about a tragedy: E
Worst caricature: B
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: I
Worst Label: G
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: A
Laziest cartoon: A
Most easily reinterpreted: K
Overall worst political cartoon of the year: A though I hate to even dignify Hope N Change with the title "politcal cartoon."
Best edit/parody: F

Genpei Turtle
Jul 20, 2007

Worst Middle East Cartoon: C
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: I
Worst Torture Report Cartoon: D
Worst The Interview Cartoon: B
Worst cartoon about a tragedy: F
Worst caricature: A
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: I
Worst Label: G
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: O
Laziest cartoon: A
Most easily reinterpreted: B
Overall worst political cartoon of the year: D
Best edit/parody: D

Captain_Maclaine
Sep 30, 2001

Every moment I'm alive, I pray for death!
Worst Middle East Cartoon: C
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: L
Worst Torture Report Cartoon: G
Worst The Interview Cartoon: B
Worst cartoon about a tragedy: H
Worst caricature: A
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: O
Worst Label: G
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: A (this was the toughest category this year, man that's a load of hateful poo poo).
Laziest cartoon: A (I add my vote to those who've said we should give Gorrell a Lifetime UnderAchievement Award in Cartooning and disqualify him from this category in future).
Most easily reinterpreted: H
Overall worst political cartoon of the year: I
Best edit/parody: D (in tribute to Ye Fowl Herald's full canon)

CampingCarl
Apr 28, 2008




Worst Middle East Cartoon C
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon L
Worst Torture Report Cartoon H
Worst The Interview Cartoon E
Worst cartoon about a tragedy D
Worst caricature A
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon J
Worst Label K
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon C
Laziest cartoon A
Most easily reinterpreted B
Overall worst political cartoon of the year A
Best edit/parody F

Every time I do this I feel like there was something worse that didn't get in but can never think of it.

fade5
May 31, 2012

by exmarx
Worst Middle East Cartoon: C Nothing can really match Kirschen literally calling for genocide.

Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: A gently caress you Ramirez.

Worst Torture Report Cartoon: D gently caress you Ramirez.

Worst The Interview Cartoon: B Team America: World Police did this better 10 years ago.

Worst cartoon about a tragedy: E gently caress everyone who used James Foley's beheading as political fodder.

Worst caricature: C Kirschen's caricatures would make a Nazi propagandist proud. I'll admit, I'm a little biased since I put this one together.:v:

Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: E gently caress you Tinsley.

Worst Label: K Gosse wins (again) for sheer loving :words:.

Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: D Obama impregnating Mexican women with Anchor Babies. Yep.

Laziest cartoon: A Gorrell wins like always.

Most easily reinterpreted: D Welcome to America kid, we're happy to have you!:911:

Overall worst political cartoon of the year: I Go die in a fire Ramirez.

Best edit/parody: Q Rorus Raz remains amazing.:allears:

All hail the new king of vileness, Michael Ramriez.

TetsuoTW posted:

Ramirez is a sniper where Lester runs around with a sawn-off shotgun firing toward every snapping twig. Ramirez doesn't always unload with truly offensive poo poo, but when he does he goes for a headshot.
TetsuoTW explains it perfectly. Seriously gently caress you Ramirez.

cheetah7071
Oct 20, 2010

honk honk
College Slice
Worst Middle East cartoon C
Worst police brutality cartoon E
Worst torture report cartoon H
Worst The Interview cartoon D
Worst cartoon about a tragedy D
Worst caricature C
Worst "a thing happened" cartoon B
Worst label J
Least concealed bigotry O
Laziest cartoon H
Most easily reinterpreted B
Overall worst G
Best edit K

alnilam
Nov 10, 2009

The voting was really tough this year. My hat off to all the cartoonists for consistently putting out the vilest, most hateful poo poo that makes it so hard to pick what's worse. God bless us everyone.

Middle east
K

Police Brutality
L

Torture
F

Interview
B

Tragedy
E

Caricature
C

Thing
L
(honorable mention: F, such a thing of beauty)

Label
B

Bigotry
H
(so many close contenders, gently caress)

Lazy
A

Reinterpreted
B

Worst
G
loving lol

Edit
E
(so many good edits, i earnestly thank all the edit-makers)


e: really F should be the BEST "a thing happened" cartoon, there's nothing bad about it

alnilam fucked around with this message at 02:11 on Dec 29, 2014

Shugojin
Sep 6, 2007

THE TAIL THAT BURNS TWICE AS BRIGHT...


Worst Middle East Cartoon: C

Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: D

Worst Torture Report Cartoon: G

Worst The Interview Cartoon: A

Worst cartoon about a tragedy: D

Worst caricature: A

Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: O

Worst Label: G

Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: O

Laziest cartoon: A

Most easily reinterpreted: B

Overall worst political cartoon of the year: I

Best edit/parody: L

seiferguy
Jun 9, 2005

FLAWED
INTUITION



Toilet Rascal
Worst Middle East Cartoon: C
Yaakov wins by default

Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: E
If people actually listened to Sharpton they'd know he calls for nonviolent protest. This is pure racism.

Worst Torture Report Cartoon: D
gently caress off Ramirez.

Worst The Interview Cartoon: D
Catalino is a lazy hack.

Worst cartoon about a tragedy: E
"Political Corectness" is such a lovely label.

Worst caricature: A
Jesus christ this caricature of Holder is awful.

Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: F
If by Best "A thing happened" then this one yes!

Worst Label: B
Yes a private company removing their CEO for being homophobic is "political correctness"

Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: E
I nominate this not for this single cartoon but the series of cartoons Tinsley did on transphobia. gently caress that guy.

Laziest cartoon: J
Always vote Payne's goddamn bumpers.

Most easily reinterpreted: H
I love how Obtuse Branco is on this one.

Overall worst political cartoon of the year: D
I'll always go with one that tries to use 9/11 to score cheap points.

Best edit/parody: I
Gilganixon created a masterpiece with this and probably took the longest of all the edits.

Pants Donkey
Nov 13, 2011

seiferguy posted:

Gilganixon created a masterpiece with this and probably took the longest of all the edits.
I'll have you know that I spend nine hours on every edit :colbert:

This is a real thing that Muir said about his terrible comic full of stuff from GIS with photoshop filters

majormonotone
Jan 25, 2013

Worst Middle East Cartoon - L
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon - H
Worst Torture Report Cartoon - G
Worst The Interview Cartoon - B
Worst cartoon about a tragedy - A
Worst caricature - A
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon - O
Worst Label - K
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon - K
Laziest cartoon - A
Most easily reinterpreted - B
Overall worst political cartoon of the year - I
Best edit/parody - L

it's poo poo!

Dopefish Lives!
Nov 27, 2004

Swim swim hungry
Worst Middle East Cartoon - C, because it's all but directly calling for genocide

Worst Police Brutality Cartoon - L, for blatantly trying to redirect and co-opt the issue in a really disingenuous way

Worst Torture Report Cartoon - H, for comparing torture to environmental regulations, which flabbergasted me

Worst The Interview Cartoon - B, for being racist as gently caress without actually making a coherent point

Worst Cartoon About A Tragedy - B, for being completely dismissive of a horrific murder just to make a goddamn golf joke

Worst Caricature - A, because I plan to show this to someone who doesn't read the thread and ask them to identify who it's supposed to be (This one was really hard to narrow down)

Worst "A Thing Happened" Cartoon - C, for Ramirez's shameless praising of his own goddamn newspaper

Worst Label - D, for labeling references to things in Clinton's past that happened so long ago I wasn't even born yet (J was a close second)

Least Concealed Bigotry In A Cartoon - H, for making a "lol black people are dumb and talk funny" comic

Laziest Cartoon - A, the reigning champion of the Gorrell Award For Achievement In Underachieving

Most Easily Reinterpreted - H, because I can't quite warp my mind enough to interpret this to mean that this anti-IRS group shouldn't be investigated

Overall Worst Political Cartoon of the Year - I, which I would declare as the worst, most offensive, most horrific cartoon Ramirez has ever done, but I know there is always more and it is always worse

Best Edit/Parody - E, for cracking me up every time I see it

A HUNGRY MOUTH
Nov 3, 2006

date of birth: 02/05/88
manufacturer: mazda
model/year: 2008 mazda6
sexuality: straight, bi-curious
peircings: pusspuss



Nap Ghost
Worst Middle East Cartoon C (Good lord Kirschen)
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon A
Worst Torture Report Cartoon D
Worst The Interview Cartoon abstain (boo this category)
Worst cartoon about a tragedy D (though G, Chip Bok's sad attempt at a Chicken Little burn is never not funny)
Worst caricature A (Bok-Obama sucks big time but what even is that Holder)
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon L (Ebola Gay. Ebola Gay)
Worst Label K
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon B (how lucky we are to be able to choose between "haha blacks are animals, am i right" and J's "haha Obama's an ape, am i right")
Laziest cartoon L (amazing, a non-Gorrell)
Most easily reinterpreted B
Overall worst political cartoon of the year I (G could have been in the previous category, though. haha DEBT is the one thing he didn't break!! Uh I mean it doesn't need fixing!! Wait poo poo)
Best edit/parody D (AHM ♥ YFH)

Sir Rolo
Oct 16, 2012
Worst Middle East Cartoon F
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon E
Worst Torture Report Cartoon F
Worst The Interview Cartoon A
Worst cartoon about a tragedy G
Worst caricature B (
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon O
Worst Label J
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon K
Laziest cartoon A
Most easily reinterpreted B
Overall worst political cartoon of the year I
Best edit/parody G

Portals
Apr 18, 2012

Worst Middle East Cartoon C

Worst Police Brutality Cartoon E

Worst Torture Report Cartoon H

Worst The Interview Cartoon D

Worst cartoon about a tragedy H

Worst caricature E

Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon A

Worst Label G

Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon E (this one was loving difficult but Tinsley's bigotry somehow really got to me)

Laziest cartoon K

Most easily reinterpreted B

Overall worst political cartoon of the year C

Best edit/parody D

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Maera Sior
Jan 5, 2012

I generally voted for the one that made me want to punch the "artist" the most. Or caused the most swearing.

Worst Middle East Cartoon: D
Worst Police Brutality Cartoon: G
Worst Torture Report Cartoon: D
Worst The Interview Cartoon: B
Worst cartoon about a tragedy: E
Worst caricature: B
Worst "A Thing Happened" cartoon: H
Worst Label: G
Least concealed bigotry in a cartoon: A
Laziest cartoon: A
Most easily reinterpreted: B
Overall worst political cartoon of the year: I
Best edit/parody: B

  • Locked thread