Max posted:

Woo.

Your Personal Muse posted:

It'll fill up when the loser brigade (people who got lynched because they are bad)(Me) starts trickling in from Soldiers

merk posted:

##vote gulag will literally never try to find scum regardless of alignment.

Tobbs Gnawed posted:

I'm only really into designer genes.

Your Personal Muse posted:

Nice gambit, friend

Max posted:

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

##unvote

flerp posted:

ok ##vote hal

Max posted:

Hal are you secretly / not secretly RPing?

Tobbs Gnawed posted:

I looked it up.

This thread is now about trying to convince me to pick up the game for the switch.

Go!

Dick Bastardly posted:

who agrees that YPM is inherently scummy (regardless of actual alignment)?

(for the record I am not claiming to agree with that sentiment, but I want to know who does)

Tobbs Gnawed posted:

Hmmm, tempting but I'm not great at unique/interesting games.

For example, I started playing Undertale and killed the person who let's you stay in their house or whatever, and occasionally I'd take out the phone and be like, "Hmmm there's nobody to call because you killed them." So I got depressed and stopped playing it even though I made friends with some of the other monsters.

Dick Bastardly posted:

What do you make of Max so far?

Max posted:

TBH I read Gulag's as serious when I saw it.

CCKeane posted:

Hello everybody, your friendly neighborhood Comic Con Badge is here.




I strongly dislike these posts, especially since I think Max's posting has been good overall so far, and I don't really like the elaboration provided, especially since it had to be drawn out. It seems like Cat wanted to make a call, and then later appended the justification to it after Cat was pressed. Cat is my top pick right now.

I have no idea what merk is doing with DB, but I absolutely do not see anything there.

##vote CuriousCat

CCKeane posted:

To be clear, I directly take statements like that as saying that I am personally not welcome to play mafia games because my career frequently precludes me from posting during that time.

merk posted:

Scum Day Vigs do exist.

Stop saying Mr. F is likely town. We know nothing about his alignment based on him having a day vig. We can comment about his alignment based on how he used it.

CCKeane posted:

Thought about this more, I don't like it, and the use of the word "rusty" seems to imply that YPM thinks merk is wrong when he says DB is scum.

CCKeane posted:

What scum did we catch?

merk posted:

I just checked the thread. This never happened:


The first mention of 'pin' in the game is from a joke Gulag post:


No one else mentions a 'pin' before that curiousCat post.

##vote curiousCat

CCKeane posted:

Here you go, merk.

YPM had his vote on DB as he said this. He said he isn't voting you because of your rustiness, but he is voting the person you cased.

So if you are rusty, you're wrong, if you're wrong, YPM is voting town.

Max posted:

Max posted:

I know I’m an unfun stick in the mud but I’m actually serious about cats deadpost. Not much to be done about it though.

Max posted:

Only for another half an hour.

Atomic Soda posted:

and pmush immediately drops the vote because she feels bad, she thinks cat could be frustrated town but she'll vote to avoid a lunch. this could be true but again, hedging.

merk posted:

I’m driving or I’d look myself.

LupusAter posted:

Xad's last couple posts aren't the best look, but again, can't fault someone for trying to stay alive.

Your Personal Muse posted:

Friend, he keeps running away everytime I ask him a question,and tried to summarily dismiss my case by acting like there wasn't substance. He tried to create a town narrative that was clearly alive. He's try to defend himself, just poorly.

Max posted:

Also I'm once again going to bring up a new case for people to look at, re: Hal

Hal hasn't really stuck to many hard opinions thus far in the game. At best I would describe him as posting just enough to appear like he's here without ever doing much, aside from responding to cases and sort of flagrantly changing his opinion as posts come in.



This was an interesting interaction, because it looks on the surface like he's saying that he agrees with Keane. What's wrong here is Keane is making a case on cat with enough conviction to vote her, while Hal apparently agrees but doesn't really follow through. In fact, his next post is a vote on merk.


So I wonder what happened to his feelings on Cat between these two posts.

Especially when this comes up later:


Note: he never actually unvoted merk day 1.

We get this near hammer:


I don't really get the incongruity here about cat. He specifically made a +1 post earlier about her in relation to what Keane said, and that was well before she starting vaguing it up with her claim and backtracking a lot of her reasoning. I know she flipped survivor, but I honestly think her play was messy.

Hal's post here is just wishy washy enough to forgive him no matter which way she flips. It seems deliberately constructed that way.

In fact, I encourage you to just hit the "?" on his profile and take a gander. Almost the entirety of his post history this game could be described as fence sitting, only really responding to whomever the most popular topic of conversation is at the time.

It feels scummy. ##vote Hal