Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
KYOON GRIFFEY JR
Apr 12, 2010



Runner-up, TRP Sack Race 2021/22
It's heavy and expensive (new) but it's a good engine otherwise. DSG only on the VR6 though.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

nm
Jan 28, 2008

"I saw Minos the Space Judge holding a golden sceptre and passing sentence upon the Martians. There he presided, and around him the noble Space Prosecutors sought the firm justice of space law."

Throatwarbler posted:

Have they fixed all this poo poo yet? If so then I only have to worry about the defective piston rings/oil consumption and the intake carbon build up then? :rolleye: I read the manual transmissions on these are poo poo too, defective throwout bearing/clutch fork or something. If I want a good looking 2.0T FWD with a manual I'll take a Buick Regal.

Surely the VR6 is better, I mean it doesn't have a turbo so that should eliminate half of the problems right there. I can't find any systemic issues with it so I'd like to think that it's a nice used buy, but they probably never sold that many of them in the first place.
Didn't the 3.6 VR6 in the passat have a bunch of problems? I know the early ones had a spectacular failure rate.
I know they had oil pump issues.

Oxford Comma
Jun 26, 2011
Oxford Comma: Hey guys I want a cool big dog to show off! I want it to be ~special~ like Thor but more couch potato-like because I got babbies in the house!
Everybody: GET A LAB.
Oxford Comma: OK! (gets a a pit/catahoula mix)
This thread can be the embodiment of the parable of the goon in a hole who insists on digging his way out, despite the pleas of other goons.

goodfuldead
Feb 14, 2009

what a long strange thread its been
Next year I will be in the market for roughly a 25k used or 30k new sports car. I don't 'need' anything, as in luxury. If I could get a quality super 7 for that I'd be all over it. I was thinking an elise or BRZ (new), but honastly I'm up for anything. Comfort is of no concern. I already have a family CUV and a muscle car. Handling, RWD and light. What would you do with 25k?

nm
Jan 28, 2008

"I saw Minos the Space Judge holding a golden sceptre and passing sentence upon the Martians. There he presided, and around him the noble Space Prosecutors sought the firm justice of space law."

goodfuldead posted:

Next year I will be in the market for roughly a 25k used or 30k new sports car. I don't 'need' anything, as in luxury. If I could get a quality super 7 for that I'd be all over it. I was thinking an elise or BRZ (new), but honastly I'm up for anything. Comfort is of no concern. I already have a family CUV and a muscle car. Handling, RWD and light. What would you do with 25k?

Do you need to park it on the street at all? If so, the Elise does not have real bumpers. Anyone bumping the car can cause serious chassis damage. Otherwise, a pretty awesome choice.

I've driven the FR-S in anger, and it really just felt like an RX-8 with a less fun engine. The RX-8 has some engine issues, but honestly a newer one that you actually check the oil (they consume oil by design, it is not a flaw) on will be fine.

Other decent choices would be an S2000 or a boxster/cayman.

Will you be tracking or autocrossing the car?

kimbo305
Jun 9, 2007

actually, yeah, I am a little mad
Is there a best (for the loanee) way to go from one car with a payment to another car that will need a payment? I'm 6k away from the end of the loan on my current car, and I'm considering it as trade-in. If I'm aggressive, I can pay it off in 3 or 4 months. But if there's financial advantages to trading it in with money left on the loan, I would consider that.

destructo mentioned seriously good rates through PenFed, and that got me thinking about whether it'd be possible to soften the blow of the trade.

goodfuldead
Feb 14, 2009

what a long strange thread its been

nm posted:

Do you need to park it on the street at all? If so, the Elise does not have real bumpers. Anyone bumping the car can cause serious chassis damage. Otherwise, a pretty awesome choice.

I've driven the FR-S in anger, and it really just felt like an RX-8 with a less fun engine. The RX-8 has some engine issues, but honestly a newer one that you actually check the oil (they consume oil by design, it is not a flaw) on will be fine.

Other decent choices would be an S2000 or a boxster/cayman.

Will you be tracking or autocrossing the car?

Nah, I have a dedicated garage space for my fun cars. I own a bodyshop, so kits/whatever doesn't scare me. I want an absurd car. I want to drive something that feels/is a race car. And, yes, I will autox/track. I've owned wrx's, mustang gt's (new edge, fox, s197's, sn95's and a couple first gens. I rock a 65 merc comet cyclone 289hipo in the summer/fall/spring. I am tired of body roll/understeering.

Also the 'delicateness' of a car doesn't matter I'll have full coverage on anything i get.

Phone
Jul 30, 2005

親子丼をほしい。
Elise, Spec Miata, Cayman S, or an NSX.

kimbo305
Jun 9, 2007

actually, yeah, I am a little mad
I don't think any 30k new car will be aggressive enough for you. There'll be too many compromises.

nm
Jan 28, 2008

"I saw Minos the Space Judge holding a golden sceptre and passing sentence upon the Martians. There he presided, and around him the noble Space Prosecutors sought the firm justice of space law."

goodfuldead posted:

Nah, I have a dedicated garage space for my fun cars. I own a bodyshop, so kits/whatever doesn't scare me. I want an absurd car. I want to drive something that feels/is a race car. And, yes, I will autox/track. I've owned wrx's, mustang gt's (new edge, fox, s197's, sn95's and a couple first gens. I rock a 65 merc comet cyclone 289hipo in the summer/fall/spring. I am tired of body roll/understeering.

Also the 'delicateness' of a car doesn't matter I'll have full coverage on anything i get.

You're getting a Lotus.

powderific
May 13, 2004

Grimey Drawer

goodfuldead posted:

Nah, I have a dedicated garage space for my fun cars. I own a bodyshop, so kits/whatever doesn't scare me. I want an absurd car. I want to drive something that feels/is a race car. And, yes, I will autox/track. I've owned wrx's, mustang gt's (new edge, fox, s197's, sn95's and a couple first gens. I rock a 65 merc comet cyclone 289hipo in the summer/fall/spring. I am tired of body roll/understeering.

Also the 'delicateness' of a car doesn't matter I'll have full coverage on anything i get.

Can you get a lotus 7/caterham kit over here? Cause those are crazy and seem like the definition of what you're looking for. No idea on prices, but I'd think a kit would fall in there. Flyin miata had some wacky body reduction kit for the miata that looks sort of like one. Or you could drop an ls3 in a miata.

edit: the caterham kits look like they'd be outside the price range, but Flyin Miata's Westfield kit looks like it could be pretty cool. The kit makes them weigh something like 1300 lbs, so even a very mild turbo would turn it into a rocket.

powderific fucked around with this message at 06:46 on Dec 26, 2012

Sole Survivor
Aug 21, 2009

goodfuldead posted:

Nah, I have a dedicated garage space for my fun cars. I own a bodyshop, so kits/whatever doesn't scare me. I want an absurd car. I want to drive something that feels/is a race car. And, yes, I will autox/track. I've owned wrx's, mustang gt's (new edge, fox, s197's, sn95's and a couple first gens. I rock a 65 merc comet cyclone 289hipo in the summer/fall/spring. I am tired of body roll/understeering.

Also the 'delicateness' of a car doesn't matter I'll have full coverage on anything i get.

Spend an extra 25k and get an Ariel Atom or Caterham if you want a true race car. Otherwise, a used Lotus or Porsche Cayman S is as good as it'll get.

Pester
Apr 22, 2008

Avatar Fairy? or Fairy Avatar?
Proposed Budget: Up to $1300.
Used
Body Style: 4 Door

Style: It would be nice to have a car with a hatchback and four doors for moving and buying big things without needing to have it hauled- I'm even kind of tempted by trucks that I see for cheap, willfully ignoring how much the low mpg would cost me. My current car has been crapping out for a while though, and only getting around 15 mpg even though it's a compact, however, so maybe I wouldn't notice a huge difference.

Car usage: I drive 13 miles on the highway to work every day. and now that it won't accelerate beyond 50 mpg or switch into higher gears, I need to get a different car asap. Like, within a few days. It would be nice to have a car reliable enough to take the nearest big city, about 100 miles, every so often. It's either me or one other person most of the time.

What aspects are most imortant to you? Reliability, and cost of repair and maintenance.

Other: I don't think that it would be financially responsible of me to commit to car payments considering how much money I have free from other obligations per month.

I was looking at a 1996 Saturn SL2 on Craigslist, and I'll be calling a couple of junk yards too. The tone of the saturn guy seems to be that of someone who's meticulous about repair and maintenance. Is there anything specific type of repair that is likely to be needed on a high-mile Saturn that I should ask if he's had done already? Same question for a 2002 Ford Focus for suspiciously cheap that does not have any pictures or information at all, really.

Edit: I don't drive stick at the moment, but my father or my boyfriend can teach me. Hopefully it won't take more than a few days to learn.

Pester fucked around with this message at 20:18 on Dec 26, 2012

Vasudus
May 30, 2003
Proposed Budget: Not to exceed $25,000. Ideally 20,000.
Used or New
Body Style: 4 door Crossover or Sedan
Use: Daily driver
Most important aspects: AWD, reliability, good MPG

I've got a 2003 Mazda 6 w. 80k miles that has been non-stop problems this year. I need to ditch it and get something else before I have to dump more money into it. I've been looking at getting either a used Murano or Rogue, or possibly a new Rogue. I don't really have that much attachment to those Nissans, I just think they look pretty.

Basically if it has AWD, doesn't look like rear end, gets good MPG and won't break all the loving time, I'm interested in suggestions.

Throatwarbler
Nov 17, 2008

by vyelkin

nm posted:

You're getting a Lotus.

Eh, I dunno, I think Lotuses are kind of played out these days. Every comparison on the C&D lightning lap has the Elise/Exige posting track times that are basically around that of a base model C6 Corvette. A C6 Z06 is significantly faster while also having "comfort " features like carpets and adjustable seats and a cabin that normal people can fit in. The Elise isn't really a real "fast" fast car, so much as "pretty fast for a car with a Corolla engine". It might make more sense in European countries where you have to pay significantly more money to get a 7.0l engine and foot-wide tires, but in the US it's just a shoddily built (There was an AI poster that had his Elise's rear suspension come apart on the highway because some parts weren't installed with the right torque at the factory and almost did him in. He made a thread about it a while back) Lucas parts bin that isn't very fast for the price.

Throatwarbler
Nov 17, 2008

by vyelkin

Pester posted:

Proposed Budget: Up to $1300.
Used
Body Style: 4 Door

Style: It would be nice to have a car with a hatchback and four doors for moving and buying big things without needing to have it hauled- I'm even kind of tempted by trucks that I see for cheap, willfully ignoring how much the low mpg would cost me. My current car has been crapping out for a while though, and only getting around 15 mpg even though it's a compact, however, so maybe I wouldn't notice a huge difference.

Car usage: I drive 13 miles on the highway to work every day. and now that it won't accelerate beyond 50 mpg or switch into higher gears, I need to get a different car asap. Like, within a few days. It would be nice to have a car reliable enough to take the nearest big city, about 100 miles, every so often. It's either me or one other person most of the time.

What aspects are most imortant to you? Reliability, and cost of repair and maintenance.

Other: I don't think that it would be financially responsible of me to commit to car payments considering how much money I have free from other obligations per month.

I was looking at a 1996 Saturn SL2 on Craigslist, and I'll be calling a couple of junk yards too. The tone of the saturn guy seems to be that of someone who's meticulous about repair and maintenance. Is there anything specific type of repair that is likely to be needed on a high-mile Saturn that I should ask if he's had done already? Same question for a 2002 Ford Focus for suspiciously cheap that does not have any pictures or information at all, really.

Edit: I don't drive stick at the moment, but my father or my boyfriend can teach me. Hopefully it won't take more than a few days to learn.

No one is going to reply to this because there is nothing anyone can help you with on a $1300 car. The make and model won't matter because for that amount of money you're looking at a very questionable proposition no matter what kind of car it is.

There are people in AI who successfully buy and own very cheap cars because they know what they are doing and can at least do some minor repair work themselves. Either you can become one of these people (pick a model, find some forums and other internet resources and learn it inside out, assuming you already have a basic knowledge of how cars/internal combustion engines work), or car ownership isn't for you right now. How do you even get insurance when you only have $1300 to spend on a car?

Vasudus posted:

Proposed Budget: Not to exceed $25,000. Ideally 20,000.
Used or New
Body Style: 4 door Crossover or Sedan
Use: Daily driver
Most important aspects: AWD, reliability, good MPG

I've got a 2003 Mazda 6 w. 80k miles that has been non-stop problems this year. I need to ditch it and get something else before I have to dump more money into it. I've been looking at getting either a used Murano or Rogue, or possibly a new Rogue. I don't really have that much attachment to those Nissans, I just think they look pretty.

Basically if it has AWD, doesn't look like rear end, gets good MPG and won't break all the loving time, I'm interested in suggestions.

The Mazda6 isn't AWD, why do you suddenly need AWD now when you didn't before? In any case you can click my post history in this thread and see a bunch of posts I made about roguhly the same kind of car. For sedans under $30k with AWD you're basically just looking at Subarus. I mean you could look at Suzuki Kizashis or Mitsubishi Lancers but those are really not good cars for people posting in this thread.

Throatwarbler fucked around with this message at 03:30 on Dec 27, 2012

nm
Jan 28, 2008

"I saw Minos the Space Judge holding a golden sceptre and passing sentence upon the Martians. There he presided, and around him the noble Space Prosecutors sought the firm justice of space law."

Throatwarbler posted:

Eh, I dunno, I think Lotuses are kind of played out these days. Every comparison on the C&D lightning lap has the Elise/Exige posting track times that are basically around that of a base model C6 Corvette. A C6 Z06 is significantly faster while also having "comfort " features like carpets and adjustable seats and a cabin that normal people can fit in. The Elise isn't really a real "fast" fast car, so much as "pretty fast for a car with a Corolla engine". It might make more sense in European countries where you have to pay significantly more money to get a 7.0l engine and foot-wide tires, but in the US it's just a shoddily built (There was an AI poster that had his Elise's rear suspension come apart on the highway because some parts weren't installed with the right torque at the factory and almost did him in. He made a thread about it a while back) Lucas parts bin that isn't very fast for the price.
He wants a no comfort 3rd or 4th car with an emphasis on handling and already has a big power car and doesn't want another one. I can't think of anything better than a lotus, if he can fit.

The problem with corvettes and the like is that when you track them, the consumables on a heavier car (3300lbs is heavy for a track car) get expensive. I track a heavy car myself.

Throatwarbler
Nov 17, 2008

by vyelkin
I just think that Lotus has been way oversold by Top Gear and the like. Cars like the Elise are (for the US market at least) clearly taking the "add lightness" mantra far past the point of diminishing returns, and it's just all self-flagellation at that point because for even with all the lightness added they really aren't that fast and certainly not very well built.

Not that self flagellation isn't a perfectly legitimate reason to buy a car of course.

goodfuldead
Feb 14, 2009

what a long strange thread its been
Yeah, dream car would be a used s7 or a used factory five cobra. I'm sorry I forgot to mention no vettes or camaros. Not a chevy fan. My old car isn't what you'd call 'big power' by todays standards, but I'm cool with less power for lower weight.

So is the elise not well built? I mean I'd like to put about 6-7k a year on a car I can drive balls to the wall constantly. I live in ky. I'd hate to have something that my dad would bitch about. He's old and believes we should all drive first gen mustangs (or sn95's for some god awful reason) for all our performance needs. Can an Elise handle 100k miles or do they wear out quickly? I can service the car my self, on a constant basis, if thats what it needs.

goodfuldead fucked around with this message at 04:41 on Dec 27, 2012

Sarcophallus
Jun 12, 2011

by Lowtax
I am looking to buy a car!

Proposed Budget: 15,000 max, preferably.
New or Used: Either - prefer an OK new to a Great-but-worn used.
Body Style: I quite like Hatchbacks.
How will you be using the car?: Daily use, doesn't need to go on long treks often.
Do you prefer a luxury vehicle with all the gizmos? Don't care, manual is fine with me.
What aspects are most important to you? Reliability, handling, and aesthetics. It doesn't need to be super sporty, but less-boring cars are preferred.

Thanks!

edit: Just some additional info:
The cars I've had my eye on specifically are the Ford Fiesta, Honda Fit, Volkswagen Golf/Rabbit, and Mazda2/3. That's roughly in order of preference, but I don't really know enough about them specifically to choose a car from those, and I'm very open to suggestions of other cars I may have missed. It should probably be noted that this is for a first car.

Sarcophallus fucked around with this message at 07:42 on Dec 27, 2012

kimbo305
Jun 9, 2007

actually, yeah, I am a little mad

nm posted:

The problem with corvettes and the like is that when you track them, the consumables on a heavier car (3300lbs is heavy for a track car) get expensive. I track a heavy car myself.

A Z06 is probably midpack in terms of cars that show up on the average track day. It's 3150lbs or so. But yes, the rotors are prone to cracking if you brake hard frequently, and tires are no joke.

That said, the Z06 doesn't feel like a race car. Its seat is ridiculously bad. It has no steering feedback. It's fast and handles well, but I would call it a muscle car, not a race car.
A race car is one that is sorta painful to drive (your knees banging into bare metal on every turn) and live with but has extremely direct and meaningful operation in all of its controls. I don't think lap time is a factor.


goodfuldead posted:

So is the elise not well built? I mean I'd like to put about 6-7k a year on a car I can drive balls to the wall constantly. I live in ky.

Based on what you've said, you would probably do ok with an RX8 or S2000. Still a ton more refined than an Elise, but raw enough. I wonder if an RX8 or Elise is cheaper for each year of ownership.

nm
Jan 28, 2008

"I saw Minos the Space Judge holding a golden sceptre and passing sentence upon the Martians. There he presided, and around him the noble Space Prosecutors sought the firm justice of space law."

goodfuldead posted:

So is the elise not well built? I mean I'd like to put about 6-7k a year on a car I can drive balls to the wall constantly. I live in ky. I'd hate to have something that my dad would bitch about. He's old and believes we should all drive first gen mustangs (or sn95's for some god awful reason) for all our performance needs. Can an Elise handle 100k miles or do they wear out quickly? I can service the car my self, on a constant basis, if thats what it needs.

There is some issue with the suspension coming apart but apparently someone with a few hours and handy with a torque wrench can solve it.

oRenj9
Aug 3, 2004

Who loves oRenj soda?!?
College Slice

Sarcophallus posted:

What aspects are most important to you? Reliability, handling, and aesthetics. It doesn't need to be super sporty, but less-boring cars are preferred.


The only vehicle I would nix from your list is the VW. It is just inferior to the Mazda3 in every aspect. Personally, I would get the Mazda3, but the Fit is a solid choice too. The 3 is the fun-to-drive one of the two, while the Fit is the more economical option. I personally hate driving cars with so little horsepower.

Sarcophallus
Jun 12, 2011

by Lowtax

oRenj9 posted:

The only vehicle I would nix from your list is the VW. It is just inferior to the Mazda3 in every aspect. Personally, I would get the Mazda3, but the Fit is a solid choice too. The 3 is the fun-to-drive one of the two, while the Fit is the more economical option. I personally hate driving cars with so little horsepower.

The Mazda3 is probably going to be a bit on the expensive side for me - there just aren't many used nearby [that I've found], and most are sedans. I'll certainly keep an eye out for them, though.

There is a used 2009 Honda Fit Sport nearby with 53000 miles for $12,900. That particular model had a recall out in 2011 ['A FAILURE OF THE SPRING ASSEMBLIES MAY CAUSE THE VEHICLE TO STALL DURING OPERATION INCREASING THE RISK OF A CRASH.'], but I'm not sure if this car has had the issue fixed. Kelley Blue Book puts that model around $12,750, and I figure I could've haggled at least that low to begin with.

The Fiesta is beefier, fancier and better looking though, and that would be for a new 2013 model. It'd be more on the expensive side at around $15,000, but I'm not sure if the difference between it and the Fit is worth 3000 or not. The warranties for purchasing new [and likely APR savings I could get] do appeal to me, though.

Will heed your recommendation with regard to the Golf, especially given the price point.

KYOON GRIFFEY JR
Apr 12, 2010



Runner-up, TRP Sack Race 2021/22
If the car still has an open campaign, you can take it to the dealer and get it fixed for free.

Deviant
Sep 26, 2003

i've forgotten all of your names.


So my $500 car needs a $500 repair, thus, I'm on the market.

Proposed Budget: Still working out what I can afford here. Thinking 60 month, trying to keep my payment manageable. I currently have 300-400 blocked out for a payment. Estimate my credit score between 740-800, so that should put me at a pretty good interest rate, and let me afford something between 15k-20k.
New or Used: Either - been driving beaters so long that i don't know the difference
Body Style: Something sporty, 4d slightly preferred
How will you be using the car?: Daily use, occasional long trip.
Do you prefer a luxury vehicle with all the gizmos? Doesn't hurt. Bluetooth audio would be rad but not a deal breaker in the least.
What aspects are most important to you? Reliability, handling, and aesthetics. It doesn't need to be super sporty, but less-boring cars are preferred.

Update: Here is a list of things I have been eyeing, that I think are cool. Years are flexible.

2010 Mazda 3 (Cheaper than I anticipated, and people seem to rave about them)
2010 Mazda RX-8 (The styling on these makes me rock hard, but I don't know much about them)
2010 Subaru Impreza WRX (Pricy, but awesome)
Nissan Sentra (Currently have a 94. Test drove a newer one, 09 i think. Liked it, but it's boring.)

Deviant fucked around with this message at 17:19 on Dec 27, 2012

Sophia
Apr 16, 2003

The heart wants what the heart wants.
Proposed Budget: $25,000 or less (no financing)
New or Used: Likely new
Body Style: Small / Crossover SUV
How will you be using the car?: Mostly daily driver (60 mile round trip commute to work), rarely may be called upon to tow smallish things.
What aspects are most important to you? MPG, reliability

I currently drive a 2000 Chevrolet Tracker which my family has owned from new (my mom bought it, then I bought it from them about 5 years ago). It's just rolling over to 100K miles, and I've been pretty happy with it (it's been very reliable for me), but I think I'm ready and have the savings for a new car. My biggest issues with my current are that it's not really designed as a highway / interstate car which is 95% of all of my driving - it has a hard time getting up to speed and maintaining speed, especially if it's windy - and that it has just a single CD player which works but is not my ideal.

However, I like that it's high off the ground (I live in the Midwest so it keeps the underside from getting so rusty with the snow plus I have a steep driveway that would scrape the hell out of a car) and that it has a lot of carrying capacity for its small size so I've been looking for something similar. Basically anything I find built in the last few years is going to have some kind of mp3 or Bluetooth capability, I believe, so even though that's important to me I'm not as worried about that. So far I've been looking mostly at a Ford Escape or a Mazda CX-5, with some thought to a Honda CRV, but given how little I know about cars I thought it might be good to get some goon recommendations. My dad is a great mechanic and can help me understand and deal with a lot of things, but he's not incredibly familiar with specific car models.

I'm not opposed to a used car if I found one I was comfortable with, but given my lack of car acumen (even with my dad's help in shopping) and the fact that I plan to drive it for 8-10 years, the depreciation hit isn't as important to me as the warranty / knowing the history aspect.

Thanks for any input / advice / help! I've already seen in the last couple of pages that Escapes might not be the most reliable. A couple of my family members have Edges that they really like, but that's slightly out of my price range and maybe Escapes are a lot crappier.

powderific
May 13, 2004

Grimey Drawer
If you don't need financing, you might still think really hard about a used car—especially since your dad is a mechanic. While the depreciation might not matter that much to you, wouldn't you rather have that cash still in your savings instead of in a car? You can still get a very nice used car that'll last a long time used. You could even just start by looking for Mazda CX-5's or the Edge that your other family members have used to see what they're going for. Nothing wrong with getting a new car if that's the way you want to go, but if you're happy with the old tracker you'll probably be able to find something you'll be even happier with and save a lot of money going used. Especially with your dad's help. Just check around at Edmunds or wherever when you see something you like to make sure it has a decent reliability report.


Deviant posted:

Update: Here is a list of things I have been eyeing, that I think are cool. Years are flexible.

2010 Mazda 3 (Cheaper than I anticipated, and people seem to rave about them)
2010 Mazda RX-8 (The styling on these makes me rock hard, but I don't know much about them)
2010 Subaru Impreza WRX (Pricy, but awesome)
Nissan Sentra (Currently have a 94. Test drove a newer one, 09 i think. Liked it, but it's boring.)

You could look for the sportier Sentra SE-R Vspec or whatever if you like those, it should at least drive more interesting. Nothing wrong with any of your options, really, but the 3 is going to be the most economical of them. If you were willing to go a bit older you could get a G35 coupe in your price range and I think they're great. RX-8's are great cars too, just read up on them a bit as the rotary is a little different to take care of. Nothing at all crazy, you just need to be a little more proactive.

Bank
Feb 20, 2004
Well, poo poo, I guess we're talking about financing.

Bank fucked around with this message at 17:18 on Dec 28, 2012

IOwnCalculus
Apr 2, 2003





Deviant posted:

So my $500 car needs a $500 repair, thus, I'm on the market.

Update: Here is a list of things I have been eyeing, that I think are cool. Years are flexible.

2010 Mazda 3 (Cheaper than I anticipated, and people seem to rave about them)
2010 Mazda RX-8 (The styling on these makes me rock hard, but I don't know much about them)

On the finance aspect, focusing on payment is only viable if you are walking in with a pre-approved interest rate in hand and know the exact term you want to sign up for. Negotiating with dealers on payments is roughly equivalent to begging them to fist you with no lube. Even if you have your rate pre-approved, negotiate on purchase price only (I always go with 'out the door' numbers so that any variances in dealer doc fees are mitigated when comparing dealer A with dealer B).

On the two cars above: I have an '07 Mazdaspeed3 and love it, despite the fact that it hasn't exactly been the world's most reliable car. Most of the reliability issues I've had are directly related to the turbocharged MS3-specific engine, anyway; the regular Mazda3 seems to be decently reliable.

However, I would stay away from the RX-8 solely from the aspect of "you don't know much about them". It's a good car but it's a rotary engine. That comes with many benefits (like a funny exhaust note, very good power for the weight / size of the engine, and a ridiculously high redline) but some considerable downsides since rotaries have some unusual care and feeding compared to piston engines. They consume oil by design - anyone who ever says their RXwhatever doesn't burn any oil is lying, stupid, or both. They actually do better with regular oil instead of synthetic because of this. They need to be flogged regularly. Avoid automatic RX-8s at all costs. An RX-8 that has only ever been driven like a grandma, especially if it's an automatic, will likely need a rebuild (if it hasn't had one already).

On top of this, the fuel economy is pretty poor for a car of that size with that power level; it gets 3MPG worse than my larger, heavier, and more powerful Mazdaspeed3.

They are good cars, but the rotary engine is something best suited to those who know and love the rotary engine. If you decide to jump into it with both feet, you may in fact love it in spite of / because of its foibles.

If you want something like the RX-8 but without the rotary, there's always the Miata :v:

Deviant
Sep 26, 2003

i've forgotten all of your names.


IOwnCalculus posted:

On the finance aspect, focusing on payment is only viable if you are walking in with a pre-approved interest rate in hand and know the exact term you want to sign up for. Negotiating with dealers on payments is roughly equivalent to begging them to fist you with no lube. Even if you have your rate pre-approved, negotiate on purchase price only (I always go with 'out the door' numbers so that any variances in dealer doc fees are mitigated when comparing dealer A with dealer B).

On the two cars above: I have an '07 Mazdaspeed3 and love it, despite the fact that it hasn't exactly been the world's most reliable car. Most of the reliability issues I've had are directly related to the turbocharged MS3-specific engine, anyway; the regular Mazda3 seems to be decently reliable.

However, I would stay away from the RX-8 solely from the aspect of "you don't know much about them". It's a good car but it's a rotary engine. That comes with many benefits (like a funny exhaust note, very good power for the weight / size of the engine, and a ridiculously high redline) but some considerable downsides since rotaries have some unusual care and feeding compared to piston engines. They consume oil by design - anyone who ever says their RXwhatever doesn't burn any oil is lying, stupid, or both. They actually do better with regular oil instead of synthetic because of this. They need to be flogged regularly. Avoid automatic RX-8s at all costs. An RX-8 that has only ever been driven like a grandma, especially if it's an automatic, will likely need a rebuild (if it hasn't had one already).

On top of this, the fuel economy is pretty poor for a car of that size with that power level; it gets 3MPG worse than my larger, heavier, and more powerful Mazdaspeed3.

They are good cars, but the rotary engine is something best suited to those who know and love the rotary engine. If you decide to jump into it with both feet, you may in fact love it in spite of / because of its foibles.

If you want something like the RX-8 but without the rotary, there's always the Miata :v:

Yeah, I'm definitely not going to approach them with the payment number first, that's simply a conversation for this discussion arena.

The list was more of a guideline of things I like, I'm not averse to suggestions outside it. Given that I've always driven beaters, I'm not up on new features like 'airbags' and 'anti-lock brakes' that the kids are going on about.

The RX8 I was eh on, I do like the look, but I wasn't married to it by any means. I've had Miata's suggested to me, but my understanding was that they were pretty bad in crashes.

I am heavily leaning towards a 2010 Mazda 3, local dealer has a few in the 15k range, with some haggling, I could probably do quite well. Here's an example:

http://www.classicmazda.com/used/Mazda/2010-Mazda-Mazda3-Orlando-FL-492d72c30a0a00de009f8ac15c5792ed.htm

Sophia
Apr 16, 2003

The heart wants what the heart wants.

powderific posted:

If you don't need financing, you might still think really hard about a used car—especially since your dad is a mechanic. While the depreciation might not matter that much to you, wouldn't you rather have that cash still in your savings instead of in a car? You can still get a very nice used car that'll last a long time used. You could even just start by looking for Mazda CX-5's or the Edge that your other family members have used to see what they're going for. Nothing wrong with getting a new car if that's the way you want to go, but if you're happy with the old tracker you'll probably be able to find something you'll be even happier with and save a lot of money going used. Especially with your dad's help. Just check around at Edmunds or wherever when you see something you like to make sure it has a decent reliability report.

Thank you for taking the time to reply and for the advice! I'm not looking to actually buy until March or so, just starting to think about the process, so I'll definitely spend some time looking around for used versions of what I ultimately decide I'm looking for. In the end I'm sure it's going to depend on what is out there and what the price is vs. a new one.

KYOON GRIFFEY JR
Apr 12, 2010



Runner-up, TRP Sack Race 2021/22
I wouldn't go 60 months on a used car UNLESS there were no early repayment penalties and I was getting a significantly better rate than a 36/48mo loan.

Deviant
Sep 26, 2003

i've forgotten all of your names.


KYOON GRIFFEY JR posted:

I wouldn't go 60 months on a used car UNLESS there were no early repayment penalties and I was getting a significantly better rate than a 36/48mo loan.

I'm going to look into doing a 36/48. What sort of interest rates should I be asking for, nay, demanding, with a 740-800 credit score?

powderific
May 13, 2004

Grimey Drawer
Credit unions usually publish their rates. If you pick a couple near you it's pretty easy to get everything approved through them before going to a dealership. Mine is around 2-3% with a similar score.

IOwnCalculus
Apr 2, 2003





Penfed is advertising 1.49% on used cars and anyone can join for a $15 donation, it looks like.

Deviant
Sep 26, 2003

i've forgotten all of your names.


powderific posted:

Credit unions usually publish their rates. If you pick a couple near you it's pretty easy to get everything approved through them before going to a dealership. Mine is around 2-3% with a similar score.

Now how exactly does this work, because don't they typically want to know what you're buying before they agree to finance you? Seems kind of chicken-and-egg at first glance.

Guinness
Sep 15, 2004

I only had to tell my credit union in general terms what I was planning on buying and how much I wanted to be pre-approved for. I ended up buying what I generally told them so their estimated APR was the exact same as what the final APR was when I went back to get the loan finalized after finding the specific car I was going to buy.

For a new car it shouldn't really vary much in the first place, and for used cars they usually have different buckets of estimated rates based on age, miles, and brand/segment. They're usually pretty broad categories.

Really not a lot to worry about unless you get an estimate APR based on telling them that you're going to buy a 3 year old Lexus with less than 40k miles but then go buy a 10 year old Chevy with 150k miles.

Guinness fucked around with this message at 22:48 on Dec 27, 2012

Deviant
Sep 26, 2003

i've forgotten all of your names.


Guinness posted:

I only had to tell my credit union in general terms what I was planning on buying and how much I wanted to be pre-approved for. I ended up buying what I generally told them so their estimated APR was the exact same as what the final APR was when I went back to get the loan finalized after finding the specific car I was going to buy.

For a new car it shouldn't really vary much in the first place, and for used cars they usually have different buckets of estimated rates based on age, miles, and brand/segment. They're usually pretty broad categories.

Really not a lot to worry about unless you get an estimate APR based on telling them that you're going to buy a 3 year old Lexus with less than 40k miles but then go buy a 10 year old Chevy with 150k miles.

Ok, that works, I have an idea what I'm going to get. I really do like the look of the Mazda 3.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

KYOON GRIFFEY JR
Apr 12, 2010



Runner-up, TRP Sack Race 2021/22

Deviant posted:

Now how exactly does this work, because don't they typically want to know what you're buying before they agree to finance you? Seems kind of chicken-and-egg at first glance.

"I'm looking for a used-car note, X term, about 17-20k principal. What kind of rate would you give me?"

If they can't tell you what rate they'll offer, approximately, how do they entice you to use their financing not another lending institution's?

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply