Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
Plastic_Gargoyle
Aug 3, 2007

http://www.airliners.net/aviation-forums/general_aviation/read.main/6066721/

Venezuela still has yet to pay what it owes to a number of foreign airlines, unsurprisingly. I thought this comment was interesting, though:

quote:

During [American Airlines] last Q1 earnings' call, it was mentioned that they have $750 million in cash trapped in Venezuela and that revenues from Venezuelan ops are 90% in Bolivares. This basically means that 10% of the revenue comes from customers paying in USD. That 10% is the only hard currency that's partly funding the ops into CCS [Caracas Airport] and MAR [Maracaibo Airport].

Some predictably stupid responses later on, unfortunately.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

BabyChoom
Jan 7, 2014

by XyloJW
The opposition can't do what Maduro can't do unless they are willing to gently caress the poor. They need to start nationalized farming or some poo poo so that produce doesn't just get exported into the back market. They also need to raise those gas prices because it's just throwing money away. Raising it a penny a week for a year would buffer a lot of outrage and people would get used to the higher prices gradually.

They really need to invest in tractors or tractor production and other farming stuff. It isn't enough to redistribute land when the people given land don't have the tools or knowledge to farm.

OwlBot 2000
Jun 1, 2009
Heavy industry plus food imports is probably a better path than :belarus:

BabyChoom
Jan 7, 2014

by XyloJW
I woulda thought that land redistribution would be a good thing but everyone wants to live in the big cities instead of developing the land.

Maybe they could start a prison farm program or something. Or perhaps spend money on co-op farming. Hell they could give illegal immigrants from Colombuia work visas or something and hire them to farm nationalized or privatized mega farms. Because, obviously, there doesn't seem to be a lot of natives who want to become farmers.

meat sweats
May 19, 2011

BabyChoom posted:

The opposition can't do what Maduro can't do unless they are willing to gently caress the poor.

The opposition's current policy proposal is for a substantial minimum wage increase to outpace inflation, but I guess we won't be hearing anything about this from people who insist that this is some battle between Heroic Socialist Leader and the Laissez-Faire Gang because that's their preconceived notion of how the world works.

quote:

They need to start nationalized farming or some poo poo so that produce doesn't just get exported into the back market.

oh my god

Chuck Boone
Feb 12, 2009

El Turpial
One Tuesday, CNN en Español reporter Ismael Cala interviewed Luisa Ortega Diaz, the Venezuelan Attorney General. The interview can be found here.

The interview was fairly cordial up until the very end, when Luisa Ortega suggested - perhaps with no ill intention - that the Cala "was not following events in Venezuela closely" because he had asked her a question she argued had already been answered through a press conference earlier. Ismael snapped on her, told her that saying those things were an attempt to discredit journalists, and asked her to not do it again.

Here is the transcript:

quote:

Ismael Cala: With all due respect, I have to make use of the voice of social media, which has changed and pluralized communications and even the way in which we conduct journalism through traditional channels. There are some comments that say, for example – Judith Romero says, “The Venezuelan Attorney General lives in a another country. My god…” There are many comments like this. And really, I’m surprised, because all of the suspected and alleged violations or accusations of [violations] of human rights, and you’ve told me that none of what I’ve told you is true. When it’s been reported, and CNN has reported, that there are dozens of accusations of torture, women who had – apparently – electricity applied to their breasts, others were threatened with rape, a young man was stripped naked in the middle of the street, the incident of the young man and the rifle. And you’re telling me that none of this is true? Or, I want to understand, if there is the possibility that some of this might be true once it is investigated?

Luisa Ortega: I’ve told you that there are 145 investigations of alleged violations of human rights. In other words, we in the Public Ministry, in regards to these events that have occurred since February 12 until now, have some [open] investigations. We are going to determine if those events did occur. If it’s shown that they did in fact occur, we are going to ask for sanctions against those who are found to be responsible, and we will apply those sanctions. So, I'm not saying that what you’re saying isn’t true. I’m saying that, with respect to the young man who talked about the rifle, at least until now what the investigation has found is that it isn’t true that this event happened as you described it.
When it comes to other cases, of course, we are investigating, and the investigations – following the law and following the constitution, and following due process – will be the ones to give us a result. Undoubtedly, a current of opinion unfavourable to the Venezuelan state has been developing through social networks. And not only through social networks. Right now, we’re facing a “4th Generation War”, in other words, not a war with rifles or cannons, but a war through social networks and the media. Well, we have always been a people who have faced all obstacles that have appeared and all of the attacks against the Venezuelan state with chivalry and bravery, and we will do the same in this case, and we will be victorious.
The Venezuelan government is committed --- I invited you to read the Constitution of the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela. More than 286 articles that talk about human rights. And not only the constitution – last year, the Venezuelan state approved a law against torture. Do you think that a state that wants to violate human rights would make a law of that nature? Not only that, but the lab which I mentioned is unique in the world. We don’t have knowledge of the existence of another lab like that in the world. Would we create a lab to investigate police officers if we didn’t want to sanction human rights violations? And that lab only investigates cases of human rights violations.
I also invite you to visit the Public Ministry website – https://www.mp.gov.ve – so that you can see the work we’re doing in the Public Ministry, including the work the Public Ministry lab is doing. When you visit Venezuela, I invite you to visit this lab so that you yourself can be witness how we our scientists and experts do their work.

Ismael Cala: Yes. I’ve been following over the last few days, especially before this interview, everything that you write on your Twitter account. I’ve seen your meetings, your work on commissions, I’ve read the article you wrote for Ultimas Noticias today, so I’m trying to keep up with what you’re doing. I imagine that it’s not easy being Attorney General in Venezuela right now.
Geraldine Moreno, a case of a woman who was killed by rubber bullets fired into her face. This is what we know. What’s the status of that case? Has the investigation made progress?

Luisa Ortega: Yes. We requested three arrest warrants. We are waiting for the warrants to be executed, and if not, we will take other measures. But in that case we are also committed to the truth and the clarification of that event.

Ismael Cala: There’s a lot of talk about political prisoners in Venezuela. The most emblematic case is that of the opposition politician Leopoldo Lopez. What is Lopez being charged with, and are there any political prisoners in Venezuela?

Luisa Ortega: No, there are no political prisoners, because political prisoners are in jail for their ideas and their ideologies. In the case of Venezuela, those are in jail are there for common crimes. For example, in the case of Leopoldo Lopez, one of the crimes of which he is being accused is arson [incendio en grado de determinador], association for the purposes of committing crimes, damages to public property [en grado de determinador], and public instigation. For example, the violent acts that started taking place on February 12 started here in the Public Ministry. The Public Ministry was almost burned. The façade of the Public Ministry [building] was practically destroyed. The library of the Public Ministry was burned. Historical documents, data going back 200 to 300 years, disappeared because they were burned. Seven buildings that house 800 people would have been burned because the only exit [to them] is the one that was here, blocked by demonstrators and where this man was. Unfortunately, all of us here would have died. Fortunately, things – a team was able to put out the fire and the damages weren’t great. But, do you think that an action like planning things like establishments, public offices, universities, burning the Ministry of Homes – the ministry that guarantees home for the poorest Venezuelans – the CDI that are medical centres for the poorest, a university –

Ismael Cala: -- Yes, but what is the concrete evidence, what is the concrete evidence against Leopoldo? The evidence?

Luisa Ortega: Those are elements that were conveniently handed over to the Tribunal de Control [a court that oversees proper procedure is followed during investigations/trials], so, more than 20 or 30 – I don’t have the number right now – but if you want I can invite you that when they hold the public audience, if it goes to trial, that you can witness the audience and see for yourself if the evidence presented by the officials, or those presented by the defense, are strong or not. But, on a program, asking me to –

Ismael Cala: Is there already a confirmed date for the audience?

Luisa Ortega: The preliminary audience – but that’s a private audience because that audience isn’t for getting to the bottom of the issue, that’s where if the law was followed is debated. Because the control judges are “guarantee judges”, to guarantee that due process was followed. If a trial is ordered, well, that will be public. And since you follow me on Twitter - @OrtegaDiaz – I will let you know through there.

Ismael Cala: Great, well, I will be reading because we have to stay informed. And believe me, for us it’s a right to be able to have – and I thank you greatly for having accepted our invitation to answer our questions. Today, by the way, the Institute for Human Rights of the International Lawyer’s Association demanded that the government withdraw all charges and compensate judge Maria Lourdes Afiuni for physical and emotional damages. What do you think about this?

Luisa Ortega: Well, they have a right to demand what they want. In fact, Venezuela is so democratic that here people even ask for the President of the Republic to resign. Even though – legally and constitutionally – recall referendums and elections are provided. Still, you see that everyone through Twitter and through television programs disrespected the president and the authorities of different institutions.

Ismael Cala: An emblematic case is that of the ex-security secretary Ivan Simonovis, who has been detained since 2002, and according to his lawyers there was no evidence on which to convince him, and the opposition has asked that the executive to grant him amnesty due to his health. What do you think about this situation, who is as I say delicate health, and who is the subject of this petition?

Luisa Ortega: Yes, I’ve already spoken on that issue, on the case of Ivan Simonovis. It’s not in the Public Ministry’s power to grant amnesty, because that’s part of the legislation, and of the president. I’m always in favour of amnesty when it doesn’t imply impunity, because civil society always expects that the punitive power of the state be executed in cases where crimes have been committed. If this doesn’t happen, then a loss in confidence in the institutions of the state and in the penal justice occurs. If amnesty does not imply impunity, I agree with it.

Ismael Cala: Let’s go on to another case. Many people, including myself, wonder why there haven’t been any details regarding the Nairobi Pinto case – kidnapped, then released. Everyone says, “Why haven’t we heard any details about this?” Do you know what happened to her? Why haven’t we heard details?

Luisa Ortega: Yes, I think that you’re not following Venezuelan news closely, because the day that she appeared, she gave a press conference with the Minister of the Interior and Justice. She had the opportunity to explain some things. The Minister too. And after that, she gave a press conference. So, it’s not true that there hasn’t been any information about –

Ismael Cala: -- But in the press conference she said, “I can’t give out any details for security reasons”. I’m asking you to give me details that no one has heard from the journalist or from the other person [the Minister of the Interior and Justice]. If I get kidnapped and give a press conference, and say, “I can’t give out any details for security reasons”, then the press conference didn’t contain any details.

Luisa Ortega: You’re asking me to put the security of a journalist at risk? I can’t do that. On the contrary, I –

Ismael Cala: -- No, I’m asking you to stop saying I’m not informed. I’m asking that you stop saying I’m not informed. I’m asking you to respect me as I respect you, and that we don’t use the tactic of invalidating the journalist by saying that he’s not informed. We heard Nairobi say that she couldn’t give out details due to her security. If you answer me that question, I’ll be happy with your response. But don’t tell me again that I should be better informed on the situation in Venezuela. Do we agree?

Luisa Ortega: Goodnight.

Ismael Cala: Goodnight. Thank you very much for being with us tonight. Evidently, we have to have the ability to listen, and the ability to have a conversation. I’m tired of the fact that many people use the tactic of invalidating journalists in order to not answer – or evade – questions.

For those not familiar with the case, Nairobi Pinto is a Globovision journalist who was kidnapped earlier this month from the steps outside her house. She was held somewhere for a week, and then released in the middle of the night with no conditions. No one ever contacted her family asking for a ransom. Nairobi gave a press conference where she essentially said "I can't say anything. They didn't mistreat me and I didn't see their faces. Thank you for your time". At the time of her kidnapping, some people questioned whether or not it had something to do with the fact that she was a journalist. The lack of details regarding the case still causes lingering questions.

I found the attorney general's comments regarding human rights violations to be really shallow. Her argument that "We don't violate human rights because that's illegal" is laughable. It's great that there are investigations taking place into the alleged violations, but her attitude towards human rights violations allegations seems willfully blind.

On the issue of political prisoners, her answer was equally sneaky: "There are no political prisoners here because no one here in jail is a political prisoner". But when pressed for what evidence they had on Leopoldo Lopez, she went off on how the building was burned, how 800+ people almost died, how the library burned to the ground, etc. "We have witnesses and recording of Leopoldo Lopez planning and ordering an arson attack on the Public Ministry building" is evidence. What she provided was just a retelling of events they are blaming on Leopoldo Lopez.

BabyChoom
Jan 7, 2014

by XyloJW
The current Venezuelan government is some tame poo poo. Taking such abuse from shills and hatchet men. If this was any other country and the same poo poo was happening, a lot of the upper middle class/high class and their lackies would be in jail or dead. One guy got stripped naked in the middle of the street in Venezuela? Is that the types of scandals over there? Because, believe it or not, tons of people get beatings in the USA and get their clothes stolen.

Instead of these boarderline traitors trying to tear down the government, they could participate in it and fix problems. But the right wing monied elite and their brainwashed compatriots don't want to fix problems. They want to pass off twitter as some authority on the reality on the ground in Venezuela. Usually by passing off pictures of real crack downs in real totalitarian countries such as Egypt as evidence of brutality in Venezuela. These clowns which compromise the opposition give the racist teaparty in the USA a run for their money and use the same tactics. One of them being the racist birth certificate tactic.

meat sweats posted:

The opposition's current policy proposal is for a substantial minimum wage increase to outpace inflation, but I guess we won't be hearing anything about this from people who insist that this is some battle between Heroic Socialist Leader and the Laissez-Faire Gang because that's their preconceived notion of how the world works.
The opposition policy proposal is bullshit. It would only make the currency even more worthless. It is an act to get some populist votes.

You say I have a preconceived notion of how the world works. That isn't true. Whats true is that in the multifaceted society of Venezuela, you can only see through one.

meat sweats
May 19, 2011

Keep chubbing yourself over your fantasies of killing fields -- you're almost there!

Adventure Pigeon
Nov 8, 2005

I am a master storyteller.
Sometimes I wish it was possible to embed music in people's avatars so Babychoom's could play "Holiday in Cambodia".

There's been a lot of protests, but very little violence from the opposition, yet your reaction is that they should be grateful that they're not being shot in the streets? As for participating in the process, that's sort of hard when the government is more interested in using them as a scapegoat.

Ginny
Sep 29, 2007
3,2,1 Let's Jam!

BabyChoom posted:

The current Venezuelan government is some tame poo poo. Taking such abuse from shills and hatchet men. If this was any other country and the same poo poo was happening, a lot of the upper middle class/high class and their lackies would be in jail or dead. One guy got stripped naked in the middle of the street in Venezuela? Is that the types of scandals over there? Because, believe it or not, tons of people get beatings in the USA and get their clothes stolen.

Instead of these boarderline traitors (??? -hahahaha-) trying to tear down the government, they could participate in it and fix problems.


The amount of videos showing abuse of power and violence by the GNB and colectivos, is overwhelming!!!

The worst blind is the one who doesn't want to see...

meat sweats
May 19, 2011

It's OK that the Venezuelan police torture people for saying they don't like the government because "sometimes people get their clothes stolen" in the U.S., whatever that means. The cutting edge of leftist intellectual thought, right there.

BabyChoom
Jan 7, 2014

by XyloJW

meat sweats posted:

It's OK that the Venezuelan police torture people for saying they don't like the government because "sometimes people get their clothes stolen" in the U.S., whatever that means. The cutting edge of leftist intellectual thought, right there.

You never provided evidence that Maduro has ordered murders. When I called you out on it all you did was whine and cry. You are the cutting edge of right wing "intellectualism". What's your position again? Overthrow the government and reinstate the good old times?

down with slavery
Dec 23, 2013
STOP QUOTING MY POSTS SO PEOPLE THAT AREN'T IDIOTS DON'T HAVE TO READ MY FUCKING TERRIBLE OPINIONS THANKS

meat sweats posted:

It's OK that the Venezuelan police torture people for saying they don't like the government

It's ok for the rest of the first world so /shrug

woke wedding drone
Jun 1, 2003

by exmarx
Fun Shoe

It's kind of interesting to see how the most idiotic ideas get started, like Juche and whatever the Khmer Rouge called their thing. Idiots like BabyChoom get into power and are like "just have everybody farm guys!" *millions perish*

Nintendo Kid
Aug 4, 2011

by Smythe
Hey now, Juche was an effort by Kim Il-Sung and his pals to prove they too were capable of "refining" local variants of marxism, because all the other socialist countries were doing it. It's got several layers of reason more than BabyChoomin'.

I mean, it's ultimately kinda empty and little more than sloganeering for "just listen to your dear leader", but still.

woke wedding drone
Jun 1, 2003

by exmarx
Fun Shoe
Yeah I guess I should say that the blind obedience comes first and the moronic sweeping changes unchecked by cowed underlings come later. Fortunately I don't think BabyChoom has a lot going on in the charisma department.

Berke Negri
Feb 15, 2012

Les Ricains tuent et moi je mue
Mao Mao
Les fous sont rois et moi je bois
Mao Mao
Les bombes tonnent et moi je sonne
Mao Mao
Les bebes fuient et moi je fuis
Mao Mao


SedanChair posted:

It's kind of interesting to see how the most idiotic ideas get started, like Juche and whatever the Khmer Rouge called their thing. Idiots like BabyChoom get into power and are like "just have everybody farm guys!" *millions perish*

I was thinking the same earlier. That post was the perfect primer in how you go from "lets just help the poor!" communism to "gulags for all, suffering for obsolete". Like, "Man, Venezuela needs to nationalize agriculture to make up for imports. Not enough farmers? Lets have prisoners farm. Not enough prisoners? Well, if these "protestors" hate food prices so much let's arrest them and put them to work in the fields. What, now we have gulags? ...but you hang negroes. :smug:"

Rent-A-Cop
Oct 15, 2004

I posted my food for USPOL Thanksgiving!

I especially like the part about foreign migrant workers on privatized mega-farms. Because consolidating farmland, handing it over to corporate interests, and then exploiting migrants to work it has never gone wrong.

Chuck Boone
Feb 12, 2009

El Turpial
There have been a couple of developments regarding Eliecer Otaiza's murder. Today, El Nacional reported that the man arrested in connection to Otaiza's death is a member of a gang called Los Menores that operates in Baruta and El Hatillo in Caracas. Apparently, according to the man, they saw Otaiza driving in their barrio in an SUV and thought that he was a cop, so they killed Otaiza and stole his SUV. It's believed that Otaiza took a wrong turn somewhere and ended up in a bad part of town.

Anyway, Maduro collected all the tin foil he had lying around in Miraflores and fashioned it into a shiny hat and said this today:

quote:

Otaiza’s murder was planned. Otaiza’s murder was executed so that it would appear as a false positive before public opinion as just another act of violence, just like false positives are planned in Colombia. Otaiza’s murder was encouraged from Miami by sectors that had media and economic control before in Venezuela.
(…)
Today, a journalistic campaign [financed] by the right and by written media [started] to complete Otaiza’s murder (…) In newspapers today, a group of journalists started to spread a version of Otaiza’s murder that fits perfectly with that which his murderers put forward.
(…)
I cannot silence truth before a people who deserve justice (…) For months they encouraged Otaiza’s murder and that of some leaders of the revolution, and they prepared it to hide the intentions of its intellectual authors.

Maduro did not offer any evidence for these claims. My favourite part of is when he says that "a group of journalists started to spread a version of Otaiza's murder that fits perfectly with that which his murderers put forward". Yeah, there's a name for when journalists repeat what someone has said: it's called "reporting the news".


SedanChair posted:

It's kind of interesting to see how the most idiotic ideas get started, like Juche and whatever the Khmer Rouge called their thing. Idiots like BabyChoom get into power and are like "just have everybody farm guys!" *millions perish*

Berke Negri posted:

I was thinking the same earlier. That post was the perfect primer in how you go from "lets just help the poor!" communism to "gulags for all, suffering for obsolete". Like, "Man, Venezuela needs to nationalize agriculture to make up for imports. Not enough farmers? Lets have prisoners farm. Not enough prisoners? Well, if these "protestors" hate food prices so much let's arrest them and put them to work in the fields. What, now we have gulags? ...but you hang negroes. :smug:"

That's what happens when you put ideology above all else. The more I dig into Venezuelan politics and news, the more I feel like the PSUV is some kind of weird cargo cult. They know what socialism is kind of supposed to sound and look like, and they're trying really hard to emulate the optics of it, but it just isn't working for some reason. Like, how many more red flags and Venezuelan flag tracksuits do we need to order before domestic production makes up for import disruptions?

karthun
Nov 16, 2006

I forgot to post my food for USPOL Thanksgiving but that's okay too!

Rent-A-Cop posted:

I especially like the part about foreign migrant workers on privatized mega-farms. Because consolidating farmland, handing it over to corporate interests, and then exploiting migrants to work it has never gone wrong.

You left out the prison farms. Angola is the model of BabyChoom's Venezuela.

Vincent Van Goatse
Nov 8, 2006

Enjoy every sandwich.

Smellrose
I want to say that BabyChoom is really funny, but I can't since he's advocating things that literally led to the deaths of millions of people when they were actually tried out.

Rent-A-Cop posted:

I especially like the part about foreign migrant workers on privatized mega-farms. Because consolidating farmland, handing it over to corporate interests, and then exploiting migrants to work it has never gone wrong.

And just imagine what his reaction would be if someone from America suggested this :allears:

Vincent Van Goatse fucked around with this message at 13:26 on May 2, 2014

Ardennes
May 12, 2002
Venezuela does have a domestic food production problem, most likely because prices are far under market value so there is little incentive for the private producers to continue production. Also, I do believe Venezuela has experiment with co-ops but it isn't clear how their production will hold up.

As for prison farms, no that is a terrible idea and abusive.

I do think large parts of PSUV's program don't make any sense, or have been half-assed even if they are well meaning. Heavily subsidized food is a good thing... as long as you can pay for it, but when you can't you need to figure out a way to keep prices low for those that are the most vulnerable. In addition, Venezuela doesn't have wage controls, so while food and other consumer items are subsidized, wages are all over the place which makes the utility of price controls more moot. In addition, there is the issue of fuel subsidies which are a complete drag on the system and the fact that while CADIVI is very restrictive about currency exchange, when the exchange happens, people are able to obtain hard currency far under black market rates....which means the government has to keep most of that cost.

In addition, while taking a greater portion of oil revenues probably is defensible, much of the nationalization the PSUV has done seems to have been haphazard such as random shopping malls.

Of course, the PSUV had done good as well, government stores and cafes, the co-ops and the Missions are probably all things that should be retained or expanded.

Anyway proposed higher minimum wages are fine, but the details are important, is that with a floating currency and the reduce of price controls or not? Those details are pretty important.

Ultimately, there very likely will be a further crisis though when the government simply runs out of money, and I guess we will see what happens. A better idea would be to radically reconfigure their price control/currency system while minimizing its impact on the poor and still try to retain what positive improvements they have made.

Ardennes fucked around with this message at 13:59 on May 2, 2014

kapparomeo
Apr 19, 2011

Some say his extreme-right links are clearly known, even in the fascist capitalist imperialist Murdochist press...
I feel that BabyChoom is experiencing some of the more religious aspects of socialism. Any level of mortal anguish is to not only to be stoically endured, like Job, it's to be rapturously welcomed as a trial of the Faithful and Saved - the Correct, even - and proof that Social Revolution is underway. Suffering can be dismissed because it will only be a pinprick in comparison to the bliss of Heaven - er, I mean Full Communism.

Adventure Pigeon
Nov 8, 2005

I am a master storyteller.
I don't think he ever had the realization that most sensible leftists had which is that any government that declares a large portion of its populace to be enemies in order to sustain itself is probably a really bad one, regardless of what it calls itself on the political spectrum.

Math Debater
May 6, 2007

by zen death robot

Adventure Pigeon posted:

I don't think he ever had the realization that most sensible leftists had which is that any government that declares a large portion of its populace to be enemies in order to sustain itself is probably a really bad one, regardless of what it calls itself on the political spectrum.

This is interesting to me because I don't think I've ever had such a realization either. To me, it seems like it may be sort of inevitable that any government that really wants to transform society in a revolutionary manner (whether that revolution be Bolivarian or something else) is going to have significant numbers of opponents among the general population. And doesn't it make sense that a revolutionary government would declare those opponents to be enemies of the revolution?

How those enemies are to be dealt with and to what extent they are to be tolerated are other matters, but it seems to me that it would be out of touch with reality for the Venezuelan government not to acknowledge that it has enemies among the Venezuelan people.

computer parts
Nov 18, 2010

PLEASE CLAP

Math Debater posted:

This is interesting to me because I don't think I've ever had such a realization either. To me, it seems like it may be sort of inevitable that any government that really wants to transform society in a revolutionary manner (whether that revolution be Bolivarian or something else) is going to have significant numbers of opponents among the general population. And doesn't it make sense that a revolutionary government would declare those opponents to be enemies of the revolution?

How those enemies are to be dealt with and to what extent they are to be tolerated are other matters, but it seems to me that it would be out of touch with reality for the Venezuelan government not to acknowledge that it has enemies among the Venezuelan people.

I would think that claiming to speak for the people and then declaring a non-insignificant part of the population as enemies of the people is sort of...hypocritical?

Math Debater
May 6, 2007

by zen death robot

computer parts posted:

I would think that claiming to speak for the people and then declaring a non-insignificant part of the population as enemies of the people is sort of...hypocritical?

Yeah, I suppose a revolutionary movement shouldn't go around claiming that it intends to serve the interests of all of the people and should instead be clear as to exactly which segments of the population the revolution is meant to empower and improve the lives of.

In any case, it seems pretty plausible to me that there may be some powerful actors in the Venezuelan business community who have perhaps been trying to undermine the Venezuelan government by sabotaging the Venezuelan economy. But I'm just speculating here. Thanks for reading my post!

Adventure Pigeon
Nov 8, 2005

I am a master storyteller.
Remember that people can have all sorts of reasons for opposing a government, and not all resistance is to government is unhealthy to the government or a country. More so, peoples' stances towards a government can change back and forth depending on the actions.

Declaring segments of the population to be enemies of the state kills any chance for healthy change to be instigated by opposition. Second, the enemies of a government or political party are not necessarily the enemies of a country; often the goal when political parties declare enemies is to falsely equivocate the two. Third, time and time again we've seen that institutions which deal with "enemies" tend to be self-sustaining. When they might otherwise become unnecessary, they find new enemies to sustain themselves. Finally, a proper government should be for everyone in a country, not just those that agree with its ideology.

Also, the vast majority of the time, when a government goes on a witch hunt they're trying to distract from their own fuckups.

Math Debater
May 6, 2007

by zen death robot
Yeah, I think I'm very much not inclined to be a liberal democratic kinda guy, so perhaps I should stay out of politics if liberal democracy is really as good of a thing as so many people seem to think it is.

But I'm totally rooting for the PSUV in Venezuela and the lefty governments throughout Latin America! I wish we had a leftier sociopolitical atmosphere here in the Yankee empire!

Adventure Pigeon
Nov 8, 2005

I am a master storyteller.
I consider myself left wing, but I've never had fantasies about dragging reactionaries off to Kublinka's basement to be shot in the back of the head, so maybe I'm a bad one.

OwlBot 2000
Jun 1, 2009
The problem is that Maduro isn't really doing anything to change the fundamental nature of the economy and build socialism, he's just selling oil and implementing (very poorly) reforms like price controls. I'd held on to the hope that the protests might make Maduro come to his senses but his response has been anything but encouraging. MUD will very likely be as bad or worse but Maduro just isn't worth defending now, no matter your ideological orientation. Even Heinz Dietrich, one of Chavez's mentors, is convinced that Maduro is simply incompetent.

meat sweats
May 19, 2011

There was discussion during the last election in Venezuela (and elsewhere) about the ridiculousness of Maduro the bus driver being elevated to the presidency, which was written off as "elitism" rather than concern over how PSUV completely values loyalty & ideological purity over anything else including competence and human decency. I would like to see what the people who were most concerned about the "elitism" of asking if the person running a command economy had the slightest idea how wages and prices work think now.

woke wedding drone
Jun 1, 2003

by exmarx
Fun Shoe

meat sweats posted:

There was discussion during the last election in Venezuela (and elsewhere) about the ridiculousness of Maduro the bus driver being elevated to the presidency, which was written off as "elitism" rather than concern over how PSUV completely values loyalty & ideological purity over anything else including competence and human decency. I would like to see what the people who were most concerned about the "elitism" of asking if the person running a command economy had the slightest idea how wages and prices work think now.

Isn't the issue not his class or former occupation, but his competence? It's the classism that's gross.

OwlBot 2000
Jun 1, 2009
Many normal working class people have gone on to become great leaders, and many rich men with executive experience who spent their entire lives being groomed to rule have been Miserable Failures. Maduro's actions, not his past as a bus driver, make him incompetent.

OwlBot 2000 fucked around with this message at 03:56 on May 3, 2014

burnishedfume
Mar 8, 2011

You really are a louse...
Of all the things to criticize Maduro for, the fact that he was a bus driver 30 years ago seems really petty and bizarre. Plus he became an unofficial union rep for the bus drivers of the Caracas Metro, which I'd argue is a pretty good place to get experience being a political leader. He is clearly not good at it, so I would say that either he did not learn much from it or what he learned is not applicable to the problems facing Venezuela today, but I don't see any reason why his job history would indicate he would have been any worse of a leader than Henrique Capriles.

E: Mistakenly refereed to Henrique Capriles as Henrique Radonski

burnishedfume fucked around with this message at 05:39 on May 3, 2014

meat sweats
May 19, 2011

DrProsek posted:

I don't see any reason why his job history would indicate he would have been any worse of a leader than Henrique Radonski.

As I am saying, the events since his election have made it clear that the criticisms of his competence were correct.

Also, are you unfamiliar with how Spanish-language names work or how Henrique Capriles is always referred to in Venezuela, or are you intentionally using his matronymic to try to highlight his Jewish heritage as a negative, like Maduro did during the campaign?

burnishedfume
Mar 8, 2011

You really are a louse...

meat sweats posted:

As I am saying, the events since his election have made it clear that the criticisms of his competence were correct.

Your post was about the accusations of incompetence based on his past career, and counter accusations of elitism. It is definitely elitism to say that his career as a bus driver was a warning sign of his incompetence, however it is clear that regardless of his past career Maduro today is incompetent at his position.

As for the name, googled the name to make sure I spelled it right, copied his full name from the Wikipedia link, brain went on autopilot and deleted the middle word assuming it was a middle name (and if you really want to dig deep into the psychology of my typo, I've been spending more time than usual reading Eastern European news and seeing a Slavic-looking name made me forget what thread I'm posting in).

Chuck Boone
Feb 12, 2009

El Turpial
All week, Maduro had been hinting about releasing evidence on Friday that the events of the past months were part of a coup against the government. Yesterday, the Minister of the Interior and Justice, Miguel Rodriguez Torres, went on T.V. to talk about the conspiracy against Venezuela.

This is a partial list of the people the government is implicating in the coup against the country:
  • Humerto Prado, director of the Observatorio Venezolano de Prisiones, an NGO.
  • Eligio Cedeño, a businessman.
  • David Smolansky, mayor of El Hatillo.
  • Maria Corina Machado, ex-member of the National Assembly.
  • Alberto Federico Revell, a journalist.
  • Henrique Salas Romer, ex-governor of Carabobo.
  • Antonio Ledezma, mayor of the Metropolitan District of Caracas.
  • Alvaro Uribe, former President of Colombia.
  • A law firm in Miami.
  • U.S. Congresswoman Ileana Ros-Lehtinen.
  • The U.S. Department of State.
  • Alberto Ravell, director of the news website La Patilla.
  • Lilian Tintori, Leopoldo Lopez's wife.

Torres presented this information during a press release yesterday, a video of which can be found here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fFXTBOZnJq8. I will translate the video probably today or tomorrow.

DrProsek posted:

As for the name, googled the name to make sure I spelled it right, copied his full name from the Wikipedia link, brain went on autopilot and deleted the middle word assuming it was a middle name (and if you really want to dig deep into the psychology of my typo, I've been spending more time than usual reading Eastern European news and seeing a Slavic-looking name made me forget what thread I'm posting in).

Ha! Don't worry about this, I get mixed up with the naming customs too and I'm Venezuelan!

When I first moved to Canada, I went around signing my name "First Name - Father's Last Name - Mother's Last Name". It was a little while before I realized that this wasn't the naming custom people were used to up here. Some of the earliest government documents I got when I came up here still show my full name as I used to write it, while the rest just show my "First Name - Last Name". I gotta get around to fixing that :tinfoil:

Chuck Boone
Feb 12, 2009

El Turpial
Yesterday was World Press Freedom Day. The National College of Journalists released a lengthy statement on the situation of the press in Venezuela. The short version of it is that they believe the conditions the press is suffering from are the worst in Venezuela's history. An interesting point they bring up is that while state-owned print media - or independent media that is aligned with PSUV ideology - has not complained about a lack of paper to print on, virtually all papers critical of the government have. They argue that this can mean two things: 1) They are not suffering from a lack of paper, which means the government is favouring them, or 2) They are not voicing their grievances for fear of government reprisal.

It also came out yesterday that in all of April, Maduro spoke in cadena nacional (when every television and radio station is mandated to broadcast his speech for as long as he talks) for a total of 22 hours and 23 minutes. According to the Regional Alliance for the Freedom of Expression, Maduro's cadenas are the longest in Latin America. Maduro spoke during 192 cadenas in all of 2013.

And some murder statistics, which I always find absolutely mind blowing. According to the CICPC (Venezuelan CSI), so far this year, there have been 4,680 murders in Venezuela. This is pretty good news though, because that number is actually 30% lower than it was last year. That's good, right? :unsmith:

In Caracas alone, there were 36 murders during the first 3 days of May. Over the course of a single night - this past Friday - 9 people were murdered.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

punk rebel ecks
Dec 11, 2010

A shitty post? This calls for a dance of deduction.
IIRC didn't you and other Venezuelans state that all types of print media (proPSUV and proMUD) were suffering from shortages?

Also expect the homicide and crime rate to continue to decline. As I said before lead is likely a huge reason for the massive crime uptick?

  • Locked thread