Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
DrDork
Dec 29, 2003
commanding officer of the Army of Dorkness

Turtlicious posted:

What this means is she wants to play games on it for probably the next 5 or 6 years. Her budgets is upwards of $900.
Yeah....not gonna happen, buddy, sorry. Other than a refurbed ThinkPad or similar, you're gonna be hard pressed to find a laptop that'll still work in 6 years for under $1k, let alone a "gaming" one.

That said, you can quite handily play Minecraft and a lot of similar indy games on the HD4x00 iGPUs these days, and you don't need more than maybe a GF 840/850 to play Civ V, so if that's the level of game she's looking at, there's no real reason to think that she'll need a real "gaming" laptop to begin with--though of course she'll fall further behind the power curve as time goes on.

The best bang-for-your-buck is probably the y510p. It still won't play games 6 years from now, but it'll be the best balance between power and being not-a-poo poo-box laptop that you can find for under a grand.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

dissss
Nov 10, 2007

I'm a terrible forums poster with terrible opinions.

Here's a cat fucking a squid.
Civ 5 isn't exactly demanding - works fine at 1600x900 on my machine with an NVS5200 (which is slower than even a 710m)

butt dickus
Jul 7, 2007

top ten juiced up coaches
and the top ten juiced up players
I can play it at 1920x1080 on my HD 4400.

Sudden Loud Noise
Feb 18, 2007

My Lenovo L440 is coming in the next couple of days. I'll be upgrading the RAM myself. It comes with a DDR3L DIMM. Is there any issue mixing it with a regular DDR3 stick?

TasogareNoKagi
Jul 11, 2013

So the T440p does indeed come with a half-height M.2 slot (it's for the optional WWAN card). Trying to find a decent, appropriately sized SSD to go there is proving impossible, however.

spidoman posted:

My Lenovo L440 is coming in the next couple of days. I'll be upgrading the RAM myself. It comes with a DDR3L DIMM. Is there any issue mixing it with a regular DDR3 stick?

The L is for low voltage, which all the Haswells use. You'll need another DDR3L stick.

Hadlock
Nov 9, 2004

Turtlicious posted:

a "gaming" laptop out for her. What this means is she wants to play games on it for probably the next 5 or 6 years. Her budgets is upwards of $900.

As mentioned, set her sights to "realistic", she might get three good years out of a y510. A giant floppy gaming laptop is not going to survive four years of college and then the two after that.

Is she planning on using this to take notes in class as well?... (:ohdear:)

Srebrenica Surprise
Aug 23, 2008

"L-O-V-E's just another word I never learned to pronounce."
I would absolutely lug around and take notes on my V7, even though it's slightly heavier than I'd prefer for a "college laptop" at almost 4.5lb, but it will play all those games fine. I would not take notes on a Y510p or want to carry it anywhere. Portability and weight/size should definitely take precedence over games and longevity.

Die Sexmonster!
Nov 30, 2005

Srebrenica Surprise posted:

Portability and weight/size should definitely take precedence over games and longevity.

This. Get a chromebook or refurbished windows 7 laptop for notes and use something else for heavy lifting. You really don't want to be carrying a higher end machine around... anywhere.

DrDork
Dec 29, 2003
commanding officer of the Army of Dorkness

Srebrenica Surprise posted:

I would absolutely lug around and take notes on my V7, even though it's slightly heavier than I'd prefer for a "college laptop" at almost 4.5lb, but it will play all those games fine.
The V7 is also a 15.6" 1366x768 screen, which is terrible. It has basically nothing to recommend itself over many other laptops, especially at its price ($900). It's about a half-pound lighter than a bunch of other 15" laptops, but it pays for that with underwhelming specs and being an Acer, which is a huge downside to begin with.

If you want portable + reasonably powerful, look at 14" models and there's a bunch of good options. Chromebooks, as noted, are also a great option for note-taking (though you probably shouldn't be taking notes on a computer to begin with, as new research is showing what basically any graduate could already tell you: you learn better by actually writing poo poo down rather than typing), and you will likely be able to pick up used ones for <$200.

Turtlicious
Sep 17, 2012

by Jeffrey of YOSPOS
I'll definitely try to go more realistic, but I just know no matter how much I try to sell it she's not going to go for something that doesn't seem "powerful" it looks like the y510 is the best choice.

E:
This laptop will also be for home use so she can bring it down stairs where the air conditioner works.

Turtlicious fucked around with this message at 02:40 on May 15, 2014

Mental Hospitality
Jan 5, 2011

Turtlicious posted:

I'll definitely try to go more realistic, but I just know no matter how much I try to sell it she's not going to go for something that doesn't seem "powerful" it looks like the y510 is the best choice.

E:
This laptop will also be for home use so she can bring it down stairs where the air conditioner works.

Would she be willing to stretch her budget a bit for something like This? I imagine the more modern GTX850 will be viable longer than the GT755.

Ideally she should just buy a Chromebook and let your build her a PC for 700 dollars.

Srebrenica Surprise
Aug 23, 2008

"L-O-V-E's just another word I never learned to pronounce."

DrDork posted:

The V7 is also a 15.6" 1366x768 screen, which is terrible. It has basically nothing to recommend itself over many other laptops, especially at its price ($900). It's about a half-pound lighter than a bunch of other 15" laptops, but it pays for that with underwhelming specs and being an Acer, which is a huge downside to begin with.
I am talking about the V7-482PG. It is the only reasonably portable 14" system with decent discrete graphics and a screen that isn't 1366x768 TN you will get for ~$900, although the 750M is a little dated now. The 15" version is indeed a piece of poo poo, even the upgraded version. With a stretched budget there may be more options to choose from, but not many. The V7's MSRP was originally something like $1200 and the P34GV2 etc etc are all above that.

e: the G550JK looks pretty good too, but I'm still suspicious of 15.6" systems' practicality. 14" is, at least to me, already loving enormous. there may be other refresh systems around $900-$1k with something like a lower-end 8xx part matching the 750m, IPS screen, and that's reasonably portable, but I'm not the one shopping for a new laptop

e2: oh the W230ST refresh came out. this is kind of a ridiculous deal

Srebrenica Surprise fucked around with this message at 02:58 on May 15, 2014

A Good Dog
Jan 19, 2007
bee
So I'm looking for an OK laptop that is reasonably sturdy and is able to do some light gaming. Is this HP Envy any good?
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16834257847

The specs look great for that price and I'm not too scared of the refurb (although I may hawk up the extra $$ to get ths year warranty). Anyone have advice? The lack of discussion about HPs in glancing at this thread is troubling.

The Iron Rose
May 12, 2012

:minnie: Cat Army :minnie:

A Good Dog posted:

So I'm looking for an OK laptop that is reasonably sturdy and is able to do some light gaming. Is this HP Envy any good?
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16834257847

The specs look great for that price and I'm not too scared of the refurb (although I may hawk up the extra $$ to get ths year warranty). Anyone have advice? The lack of discussion about HPs in glancing at this thread is troubling.

Depends on what you define 'light' gaming as but for a sub-700$ laptop that looks half decent. Resolution is acceptable. Fifteen inches is going to be a pain in the rear end though.

A Good Dog
Jan 19, 2007
bee
Light as in I am OK with cranking down the settings to minimum if I reaally need to play that title. I think I have a grasp on the limitations of those specs, I suppose I am looking for any red flags about that line or particular machine... a cursory glance at reviews makes me more inclined to pull the trigger.

dissss
Nov 10, 2007

I'm a terrible forums poster with terrible opinions.

Here's a cat fucking a squid.
I wouldn't buy any system that doesn't have an SSD (or have an easy way of switching the system drive to one) - it really is that dramatic of a difference, far more so than a quad core processor, or adding large amounts of RAM.

A Good Dog
Jan 19, 2007
bee
Can't I swap the this HDD for an SSD if I wanted? I don't see myself doing it immediately (cost-prohibited) but maybe down the road. I guess I don't have any experience modifying laptops so I don't know.

Die Sexmonster!
Nov 30, 2005

A Good Dog posted:

So I'm looking for an OK laptop that is reasonably sturdy

That machine will likely handle all your computing needs quite well, but it's HP. That model especially is plasticky garbage, find a computer store and give the keyboard a little push. If you need sturdy, there's a reason this thread is full of ASUS and Lenovo, among other brands mentioned I have less experience with.

A Good Dog
Jan 19, 2007
bee
Hrm that's what I was afraid of. Maybe I'll hold off until a good deal comes along on something more reliable.

I'm pretty good with treating electronics gently but I'd rather something that will last... ugh I might still get it just because I'd rather have one sooner rather than later.

A Good Dog
Jan 19, 2007
bee
I WAS just looking at a similarly priced Thinkpad with worse specs... I guess that's the tradeoff, innit?

-Blackadder-
Jan 2, 2007

Game....Blouses.

-Blackadder- posted:

So what's good these days for the following:
    Things I want
  • High Portability (thin/lightweight)
  • Good Battery Life
  • Decent sized Screen
  • Bargain (as much as possible)

    Things I Don't Need
  • High performance
  • Gaming & media

Basically this is a going to be a highly portable laptop that I carry around for school and work. The little gaming I do is being handled just fine by my desktop, so I have no interest in buying a laptop to play games on or watch movies. I just want it for school and work. That means that being easy to carry around and having good battery life is the most important thing.

sports posted:

I don't think you need the performance standard met by the current MacBook Air, so I'd recommend the HP 15" Chromebook, or if you sacrifice the screen for better all around quality go with the Acer C720.

Sorry, I should've specified that I'm looking for a windows machine.

Are there any laptops with windows that fit what I'm looking for?

Hadlock
Nov 9, 2004

A Good Dog posted:

I WAS just looking at a similarly priced Thinkpad with worse specs... I guess that's the tradeoff, innit?

Modern laptops are so fast that the average consumer can't tell them apart. Especially if they have an SSD.

Tom Guycot
Oct 15, 2008

Chief of Governors


-Blackadder- posted:

Sorry, I should've specified that I'm looking for a windows machine.

Are there any laptops with windows that fit what I'm looking for?

How about a yoga 2 pro/yoga 2 13"/11"?

Drunk Badger
Aug 27, 2012

Trained Drinking Badger
A Faithful Companion

Grimey Drawer
I notice some Lenovo outlet laptops have switchable HD4xxx and a 730m gpus, what controls which one is used? Is that an option if I want a cheaper laptop with some form of non-intel gpu? The benchmarks put it higher than the 260m I use now

A Good Dog
Jan 19, 2007
bee
So this Thinkpad Edge http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16834317106 would be more durable? No SSD unfortunately, and it's i5 instead of i7 and 4gb RAM instead of 12 (although that's upgradable of course).

Honestly I kind of like the larger screen on the HP and (although I know it's probably a bit of a gimmick) the Beats Audio speakers/woofer, since I don't have a TV and use my laptop as my media player. Again though I would probably just invest in some decent speakers if the Thinkpad's are garbage.

Another plus is that it comes with a year warranty (which I would have had to pay for on the HP) and an option for a 3yr one. I'm starting to lean towards that Lenovo...

Hadlock
Nov 9, 2004

A Good Dog posted:

So this Thinkpad Edge it's i5 instead of i7 and 4gb RAM instead of 12

Unless you're in grad school for engineering or science I don't think you'll need the quad core i7. You're venturing in to supercomputer territory at that point. Over in the spaceflight megathread one guy is using his laptop's i7 to model rocket engine exhaust at supersonic speeds overnight. Modern physics sandbox games can't really take advantage of that kind of horsepower.

A Good Dog
Jan 19, 2007
bee
Oh wait, the HP doesn't have a larger screen.

Yeah I just read up about it over in the PC building thread. I actually AM going to grad school for physics in a year or two haha but I don't think I will be doing that kind of research.

Reading up on the Thinkpad Edge though makes me dubious; it sounds like a lot of people bought it thinking it was going to be a Thinkpad and were disappointed at the lower quality. If it's not really more durable than the HP Envy I might just go with that. I'm still shopping around to see if I can't get a good deal on a somewhat comparable proper Thinkpad, though.

Flipperwaldt
Nov 11, 2011

Won't somebody think of the starving hamsters in China?



A Good Dog posted:

So this Thinkpad Edge http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16834317106 would be more durable? No SSD unfortunately, and it's i5 instead of i7 and 4gb RAM instead of 12 (although that's upgradable of course).

Honestly I kind of like the larger screen on the HP and (although I know it's probably a bit of a gimmick) the Beats Audio speakers/woofer, since I don't have a TV and use my laptop as my media player. Again though I would probably just invest in some decent speakers if the Thinkpad's are garbage.

Another plus is that it comes with a year warranty (which I would have had to pay for on the HP) and an option for a 3yr one. I'm starting to lean towards that Lenovo...
I'm buying a E540 instead of the HP Envy 15 I was waffling over for weeks. The poo poo reviews of the Envy keyboard and touchpad are what swayed it. One review mentioned an annoying habit of regularly not registering keystrokes. That poo poo's not cool.

I have no access to the B&N configurator, but on the plain Lenovo site, you can configure the E540 with a 1920x1080 screen for $120 more than what you'd pay on Newegg. Which I'd really recommend, coming from three years of 1366x768. It's aggravating for anything but the most basic tasks. 15" at 1080p is about right. i5 is also okay.

Adding more memory yourself shouldn't be much of a problem and probably cheaper than the minimum $80 you'd pay Lenovo for the upgrade to 8GB.

I was assured in this thread that the Edge series is decent enough, although the trackpad is a joke. I'll find out later tonight when I go pick it up, if you can wait that long for first impressions.


And I came as close as possible to fairly comparing Beats and Non-Beats Audio laptops with my DM1-3xxx and my sister's DM1-4xxx. Both are built completely on the same framework, with the same innards as far as audio is concerned. Beats audio was just differently branded driver software and the logo printed on top. Conclusion was that the Beats Audio one sounded noticably worse out of the box. It's a marketing gimmick. There are also indications that switching off Beats Audio intentionally turns down the bass to look better in comparison (!) I can't tell you which speakers are better, but please don't conclude anything based on that label.

sector_corrector
Jan 18, 2012

by Nyc_Tattoo
I have a piece of poo poo HP Pavilion G4 that I bought from a friend 2 years ago, and the battery is basically dead. Like, I get 10 minutes off the plug sort of dead. I really hate everything about the computer, and have a winfall of about $800 unexpected dollars that I'm considering putting towards a laptop.

There are a few complicating factors:

>My gaming rig is getting on in years. I know it's a bad idea to buy a gaming laptop, and don't plan to, but could I get something within $800 that would comfortably run Dark Souls 2 and wouldn't be an absolute beast to carry around?

>Apart from potentially wanting to play a few games, my demands are pretty light. Mostly word processing, and maybe occasionally graphic design work on Photoshop. The most important factors otherwise are battery lie and (silly as it sounds) a satisfying keyboard.

>What's a fair price to sell my POS HP for? Since the battery is dead, and I paid 300 dollars for it, I'm considering asking $100 and making clear that it's coming with a dead battery that would need to be replaced.

blowingupcasinos
Feb 21, 2006
If you want an email box and a way to play Dark Souls 2 you could buy a PS3, Dark Souls 2, a chromebook, and have a couple hundo leftover. You could also build a gaming PC for $600 and maybe play Beast Souls on it. Gaming laptops are really meant for people that do a lot of traveling and need gaming for their sanity. Otherwise they're pretty much losing propositions and/or for people that don't want to be told they can't game everywhere.

A Good Dog
Jan 19, 2007
bee
Let me know what you think. I'll probably do more research over the weekend before I actually buy one. I'm hope to get one that will last a bit longer than the year and a half life of my old garbage Toshiba Satellite that was a graduation gift.

Anyone have any thoughts on the Lenovo Z series? There's a drat good deal on the B&N site for a Z510 and it's pretty tempting.

sector_corrector
Jan 18, 2012

by Nyc_Tattoo

blowingupcasinos posted:

If you want an email box and a way to play Dark Souls 2 you could buy a PS3, Dark Souls 2, a chromebook, and have a couple hundo leftover. You could also build a gaming PC for $600 and maybe play Beast Souls on it. Gaming laptops are really meant for people that do a lot of traveling and need gaming for their sanity. Otherwise they're pretty much losing propositions and/or for people that don't want to be told they can't game everywhere.

I understand that. That's why I said I don't want a gaming laptop. However, my question was if I could get a general purpose productivity laptop that can run stuff around Photoshop (hence, no Chromebook) if necessary, which is about the maximum of my requirements, and also handle some modern games on low settings.

I guess I should also specify that I have no interest in anything apart from Windows, since I'm so used to it.

sector_corrector
Jan 18, 2012

by Nyc_Tattoo
Also, any opinions on this:

http://www.amazon.com/Lenovo-IdeaPad-59385901-15-6-Inch-Touchscreen/dp/B00F0RC024

There's a deal on it at a local Office store for a little bit under $500. I'd be willing to sacrifice on the ability to run games for a huge reduction in the price of other machines I've been looking at.

Hadlock
Nov 9, 2004

How does the price of that laptop compare to what's on the :siren:B&N gold link?

You may be very disappointed in a bottom of the barrel screen on a midrange laptop with the lowest resolution available, especially on such a large screen, on that laptop. There are better laptops out there.

A Bad King
Jul 17, 2009


Suppose the oil man,
He comes to town.
And you don't lay money down.

Yet Mr. King,
He killed the thread
The other day.
Well I wonder.
Who's gonna go to Hell?
Does anyone have a suggestion for a laptop capable of playing some of the current generation of games while remaining under $900?

To Vex a Stranger
Mar 15, 2004
Rawr!
I'm about to start a four month project with work out of town. I just got the Heroes of the Storm alpha and I'm kind of hooked... Would like to be able to play that at the hotel (company doesn't like when you install software that's not approved on their machines).

I looked at the Yoga 2 and it looks decent enough, but my friends are urging me to the Y510P. I want portability, and don't really give a poo poo if the game 'looks good.' I just want it to run, and then I want the machine to be ok to sit on my lap and send emails and just dick around on the internet, while not breaking the bank. Was hoping to get something that would last me a few years as well.

So basically, low end graphical capabilities (DotA 2, D3, Heroes of the Storm) lightweight, sturdy are what I'm looking for. I think I get a slightly better discount on Lenovo through my company than the B&N link, and I also get like a 5% discount on Macs, but I would much rather stick on Windows than grab a macbook air. I have a 13.3 inch monitor for work, but I'm not entirely convinced that's big enough, though I may not need something bigger.

SO MANY DECISIONs :(

Nostalgia4Dogges
Jun 18, 2004

Only emojis can express my pure, simple stupidity.

Finally got my Sager 8268-S! This thing is slick. Let me know if you guys have any questions about it or want pics etc

TheHotCarl
Dec 14, 2003
Bulk Male Playmate of the Month: January, 1967
I'm looking into buying a new laptop for general use, basically as a semi-mobile desktop. I'm looking to spend $600-$800, and have been looking at the T440p. All of the reviews say the trackpad is really awful though, and while I plan on using a mouse most of the time I don't really want to spend money on something that has a bad trackpad. Does anyone have experience with the current gen of these? How bad is it?

Calidus
Oct 31, 2011

Stand back I'm going to try science!
I have had my T440p for two days now. The 1080 IPS screen is pretty amazing, it looks almost as good as my dell ultrasharps. I had some problems with the machine not waking up from sleep but those went away after finishing all the system updates. I don't understand all the trackpad hate, unless you are serious trackpoint user then I would miss the physical buttons. The trackpad feels accurate and 2 finger click gesture for right click is actually really nice. Keyboard is +A as usual with thinkpads, blacklight is nice, as it the small red LEDs for fn and mutes keys. The battery life was when installing applications and updates was floated between 3 to 4 hours total. Intel's Wifi connection has been pretty solid.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

DrDork
Dec 29, 2003
commanding officer of the Army of Dorkness

Calidus posted:

The trackpad feels accurate and 2 finger click gesture for right click is actually really nice.
This is something that confused the hell out of me on my P34G: no two-finger click gestures by default. Even though the hardware and software all natively support it, I had to go into the registry and toggle an entry to enable it--at which point it popped up in the control panel with all sorts of options. Do companies really think that removing built-in interface options like that is something people want?

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply