|
I know I'm making sense here. This chain of events doesn't logically follow.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:18 |
|
|
# ? Apr 25, 2024 23:24 |
|
gently caress, didn't know deadline was tonight. Have 240 posts to read through. Will do so.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:20 |
|
Asiina posted:This...what? You asked for a reason why he'd do it as scum, that is the most logical one to me for why he'd do it as scum. I don't think it's a slam dunk by any means, all I was saying is that it made me also think he was scummier. And even after thinking more about it, I'm still not ready to completely rule it out. I'm torn on whether or not Pig gave them the key this time. Like, if they had a night kill, I'd say no way. But with no night kill maybe that would be how they are expected to win? If Pig didn't give them the key, I don't see a scum motivation.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:20 |
|
Asiina posted:I know I'm making sense here. This chain of events doesn't logically follow. What you are saying makes perfect sense. The difference seems to be our willingness to believe scum know the answers.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:21 |
|
King Burgundy posted:You asked for a reason why he'd do it as scum, that is the most logical one to me for why he'd do it as scum. I don't think it's a slam dunk by any means, all I was saying is that it made me also think he was scummier. And even after thinking more about it, I'm still not ready to completely rule it out. they line of logic that they would have the key because of no nightkill makes sense to me.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:22 |
|
Asiina posted:Fine on the first one, it's a pretty weak point as it is. The second and third don't really address the concerns which I guess were Gulag's concerns but I'm definitely on board with now. Re: you/KB, it's not like I've been continuously pushing that case/line of thinking after you backed down from it. I said it was something to watch. There's lots of things I keep in mind over the course of a game. Do you not do the same? Re: your last point, I'll say it again. The post that gets me is not the linking of the document and his vote. The post that gets me is his second post where he essentially implies no one else needs to read what he linked because he's already read it and there's nothing there. Is it possible that he's mistaken, helpful town? Sure. Would mistaken, helpful town make that second post? Even down to naming the end boss which he wouldn't have known except by reading the document he linked, not the sidebar he highlighted? I don't think so. I'm on mobile and the Awful app isn't allowing me to post the screenshot I wanted to, but if you look, it's from two different places. That's my point. To be clear, do I 100% know he's scum based off that? Absolutely not. But it's what's stuck in my mind since he posted it, so that's where my vote is.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:23 |
|
King Burgundy posted:On the lurker issue, here are the folks with less posts then Pig: I dont know who Mr.F is and forgot they were in this game
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:25 |
|
peramene posted:I honestly do not understand these day one circlejerks. Every single thread everybody's tossing poo poo around and I mean I've seen it grab scum day 1 okay cool but it seems like a LOT of work to bounce around all over the place and make hundreds of posts and then eventually nobody gets loving anywhere
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:26 |
|
who do we even have the numbers to kill
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:27 |
|
Except the name of the boss is in a big heading with larger font. Here's a screenshot because I know people are lazy. Skimming that, it's super easy to miss the line in the middle of the second paragraph about Sara joining you while still seeing the heading for the boss. I missed it when I skimmed to see if he was telling the truth. And again, why link this walkthrough that proves you wrong. You keep dismissing it, but it's the big reason why this doesn't follow.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:28 |
|
I'm not voting for Moat because I think he's town.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:29 |
|
Bifauxnen posted:I dont know who Mr.F is and forgot they were in this game Magnus Gallant
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:29 |
|
##vote tobbs
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:30 |
|
I'd vote for IS, I'd vote for a lurker I suppose, but honestly peramene has a point that with no NK a no lynch isn't really that bad an idea. ##vote IS
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:30 |
|
Kashuno posted:scum post.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:33 |
|
Asiina posted:Except the name of the boss is in a big heading with larger font. The point about the font being bigger is decent. I'll give you that. The screenshot I took and was referring to doesn't go that far down the page (I took it on mobile in landscape). You're willfully ignoring MY argument about his second post. But if I'm the only one who has a problem with this, then I guess I'll concede. However, at this point, unless VF is wrong, he's still the vote leader, so in your opinion, who's the better lynch?
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:34 |
|
I assume there is some mechanic in play that makes NLing a poor choice. scum have to have a way to advance their agenda SOMEHOW (maybe by accruing dark crystal points power and summoning meteor) or else the game can just sit in limbo forever
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:34 |
|
Yeah, I mean, I guess we could just level up, do the story and get jobs. With no night kill there isn't really any kind of ticking clock. But having said that, I have reason to believe there are kills in this game, even if no night kill. So it may not be that straight forward.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:34 |
|
Asiina posted:I'd vote for IS, I'd vote for a lurker I suppose, but honestly peramene has a point that with no NK a no lynch isn't really that bad an idea. Oh, I guess it's me. Well then. Why?
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:35 |
|
King Burgundy posted:Naw, she really didn't have any valid point even after I accounted for that. It just doesn't make sense without additional information/insight. Like for that pairing to make sense, there is a missing piece. Like really, for it to work, she'd have to be saying that I always drag the game out of joke phase. And that is not something I do on the regular. It's just impossible for me to have been trying hard during joke phase without participating in it. It's not like I can exist in my own bubble without interacting with others. Nah. Her opinion was consistent. It was wrong, as you point out, but it was consistent.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:35 |
|
##unvote
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:36 |
|
Because I made a case you didn't agree with?
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:36 |
|
chaoslord posted:Nah. Her opinion was consistent. It was wrong, as you point out, but it was consistent. Have to agree to disagree then.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:37 |
|
GulagDolls posted:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ALEwLnq1ZrI ##vote IllegallySober
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:38 |
|
Votecount for Day 1 Moatillata (3): this is a stickup, Tobbs Gnawed, IllegallySober, King Burgundy, IllegallySober (3): GulagDolls, Bifauxnen, Asiina this is a stickup (3): Moatillata, Asiina (2): King Burgundy, Kashuno (2): BottleKnight, Murmur Twin Tobbs Gnawed (1): Murmur Twin, BottleKnight (0): chaoslord, Bifauxnen, Bifauxnen (0): Kashuno, jon joe, peramene (0): BottleKnight, jon joe, this is a stickup, GulagDolls, King Burgundy (0): Asiina, AnonymousNarcotics (0): Asiina, Infinitum (0): Bifauxnen, Murmur Twin (0): Tobbs Gnawed, Not Voting (5): Absurd Revolver, chaoslord, Mithross, Mr. F!, peramene With 19 alive, it's 10 votes to execute. The current deadline is January 22nd, 2017 at 11:59 p.m. EST -- that's in about 1 hour, 20 minutes.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:38 |
|
to be fair, once again i'm dealing with the consequences of living in florida and we have another massive storm(this time, maybe tornados) bearing down on us
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:39 |
|
King Burgundy posted:Yeah, I mean, I guess we could just level up, do the story and get jobs. With no night kill there isn't really any kind of ticking clock. yeah, with scum knowing all the job details, they can plan for an ideal build and work their way up to a kill soon, I'd imagine.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:39 |
|
Absurd Revolver posted:to be fair, once again i'm dealing with the consequences of living in florida and we have another massive storm(this time, maybe tornados) bearing down on us So plenty of time for mafs then
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:41 |
|
Asiina posted:Skimming that, it's super easy to miss the line in the middle of the second paragraph about Sara joining you while still seeing the heading for the boss. I missed it when I skimmed to see if he was telling the truth. So why is it impossible that scum moat skimmed it, saw a lead to a different answer, and posted it? You proved it was misable by skimming. I think it would be an easy thing to do of any alignment. It's a null imo.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:41 |
|
IllegallySober posted:Oh, I guess it's me. Well then. Why? Cause I think you were trying to play both sides when KB and I were arguing, and because I think that if you're continuing to argue this Moat case even after considering that he provided his own way to be caught then that is bad and scummy. I don't necessarily blame people who aren't thinking about it too hard and have since checked out since I pointed out it didn't make sense, but you've heard the argument on why it's not a logical case and are continuing to push it.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:41 |
Hello thread, I am hopped the gently caress up on painkillers, antibiotics, and etc as my foot is now officially doctor certified infected~ Catching up on thread. If you have any major cases you would like to link to me, please let me know. Will be here until deadline King Burgundy posted:On the lurker issue, here are the folks with less posts then Pig: D1 Pushes for Lurker Lynches are dumb and bad, and I always put the people who do this firmly in the "Probably Scum" category "Oh these people are making a good case on my scumbro, better push a lurker lynch" "Hey guys, I know we can't all agree, lets lynch a lurker today!"
|
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:43 |
|
Asiina posted:Cause I think you were trying to play both sides when KB and I were arguing, and because I think that if you're continuing to argue this Moat case even after considering that he provided his own way to be caught then that is bad and scummy. You did see my reasoning as well right? Like the only reason you think it's illogical is because you seem sure scum didn't get the answers. You already think Moat made a mistake. He could have made that mistake as scum if they had the answers. I don't want to fight hard for IS here, because I liked Gulag's first two points. But I do want to defend my own opinion which seems similar.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:44 |
|
Infinitum posted:Hello thread, This is KBs normal personal crusade nothing too weird imo
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:45 |
|
this is a stickup posted:##vote tobbs ##vote tobbs
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:45 |
|
chaoslord posted:So why is it impossible that scum moat skimmed it, saw a lead to a different answer, and posted it? You proved it was misable by skimming. I think it would be an easy thing to do of any alignment. It's a null imo. Except if he's scum and skimmed it then he would have thought B was the "most correct" answer so why bring that as a possibility? Wouldn't that make him want it more to be A? If he thought there were just enemies in the cave then A would have been the answer that gets us hurt for not attacking first.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:45 |
Moatillata posted:This is KBs normal personal crusade nothing too weird imo I am all antilurker as well, I'm just making the comment that this sort of discussion is normally tabled until D2 usually.
|
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:46 |
|
Infinitum posted:Hello thread, FWIW, I know you are a medicated, but I wasn't pushing the lurker cuddle there. I was providing info for those who were. My post followed other people talking about it, like this one: Moatillata posted:Rn I would Lynch sticky or maybe a lurker I'm always willing to vote one of course, because gently caress lurkers, but just saying.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:47 |
|
Asiina posted:Cause I think you were trying to play both sides when KB and I were arguing, and because I think that if you're continuing to argue this Moat case even after considering that he provided his own way to be caught then that is bad and scummy. Okay, so I'm playing both sides on...what, exactly? With a single post I made where I said it was something to watch? Rather then continuing to argue with Asiina about this, I'll open it up to the group: do you believe I'm completely misguided to be suspicious of precisely this post? Moatillata posted:Nothing in the cave except enemies and the boss djinn no reason not to go balls to the wall Like I said, if I'm the only one who thinks this is scummy, then fine. I'll unvote, which I guess would make me the new vote leader. If you're going to vote me to be the lynch today, though, at least let me buy a job (since I wasn't going to do that today) and I'll share whatever it gives me.
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:47 |
|
Sticky is not here and he should be He is scum imo If I am wrong may the scum team strike me down
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:48 |
|
|
# ? Apr 25, 2024 23:24 |
|
sorry to hear about your foot friendo
|
# ? Jan 23, 2017 04:48 |