Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
peer
Jan 17, 2004

this is not what I wanted
about time someone stood up to all the people in this thread claiming only men are ever abusive

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

esperterra
Mar 24, 2010

SHINee's back




tbf I should have quoted this post with the edited quote in it

K. Waste posted:

Because they're systematically taught the opposite.

peer
Jan 17, 2004

this is not what I wanted
There's no contradiction between "men are taught women are theirs for the taking" and "women can be abusive too". There, it's now stated for the record, maybe it won't come up again

K. Waste
Feb 27, 2014

MORAL:
To the vector belong the spoils.

esperterra posted:

tbf I should have quoted this post with the edited quote in it

I can only say that, from my very basic understanding of domestic violence, what you're saying is true and worth putting out there. I didn't mean to suggest that only straight men can be garbage, but as a (mostly) straight man, as someone who's benefited inordinately from the privileges that come with that, I kind of see my responsibility as being more to critique patriarchy and the centrality of heterosexuality and masculinity in it specifically. I didn't mean to minimize abuse and coercion that takes place in homosexual relationships, and I apologize for that.

esperterra
Mar 24, 2010

SHINee's back




K. Waste posted:

I can only say that, from my very basic understanding of domestic violence, what you're saying is true and worth putting out there. I didn't mean to suggest that only straight men can be garbage, but as a (mostly) straight man, as someone who's benefited inordinately from the privileges that come with that, I kind of see my responsibility as being more to critique patriarchy and the centrality of heterosexuality and masculinity in it specifically. I didn't mean to minimize abuse and coercion that takes place in homosexual relationships, and I apologize for that.

100% fair and I also didn't mean to come off so snippy, either. This thread just rustles me as a woman, sometimes, by how easily people seem ready to imply anyone with a vagina is just a victim of men and that we're not all equally trash lol.

We cool bae!

teacup
Dec 20, 2006

= M I L K E R S =
I’m not even trying to “I CANT SAY THIS AS A MAN” but as a man I just recognise how incredibly tone deaf it would be for me to say “hey lesbians bash women too!!!”

Its probably just better for everyone for woman to stand up and bring that to light if those rates are true.

It is interesting though I always just figured the violence rates were heavily skewed towards men (whether hetero or homosexual) being the perpetrators. Is there a big difference between domestic violence rates in men on women in relationships vs. men on men in relationships? Do women secretly want to be as lovely as men but only feel able to if they can physically overpower their partner, thus it comes out in lesbian relationships?

People are the worst

esperterra
Mar 24, 2010

SHINee's back




teacup posted:

I’m not even trying to “I CANT SAY THIS AS A MAN” but as a man I just recognise how incredibly tone deaf it would be for me to say “hey lesbians bash women too!!!”

Its probably just better for everyone for woman to stand up and bring that to light if those rates are true.

It is interesting though I always just figured the violence rates were heavily skewed towards men (whether hetero or homosexual) being the perpetrators. Is there a big difference between domestic violence rates in men on women in relationships vs. men on men in relationships? Do women secretly want to be as lovely as men but only feel able to if they can physically overpower their partner, thus it comes out in lesbian relationships?

People are the worst

fwiw I am a lesbian.

From what I rememember last time I was a bit more well read on it, rates were highest in bisexual women, then lesbians, then gay men, with het men would theoretically somewhere after or equal to lesbians in that.

It's really hard to nail down tho as women are less likely to speak out about it, even less so than women in abusive hetero relationships. Men are also less likely to speak out about being abused by a woman as well so a lot of the stats and knowledge for abuse done by non hetero men for stuff like this aren't as accurate as one might want.

When not on my phone I can peep some more specific stuff, I'm going off memory from a while back atm.

Domestic abuse sucks and I wish we lived in a society where all genders and orientations were comfortable speaking out about it.

e: oh hey there's a whole wiki page just for abuse in lesbian relationships lmao

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domestic_violence_in_lesbian_relationships

not sure how up to date any of these sources are. and diff ones will have diff results ofc

esperterra fucked around with this message at 01:51 on Jun 14, 2018

Snowman_McK
Jan 31, 2010

Alhazred posted:

Using threats (he said that if they wanted work they had to have sex with him) to obtain consent is still illegal. So he wouldn't have been fine.

gently caress, missed that. That's what i get for skimming the article.

Which leads me to wonder where those 'casting sites' lie on this scale. There's a website called 'casting couch X' and its whole gimmick is young women coming in who'll do anything for the part. Sometimes its women who are established porn stars or went on to be that, but plenty of others never appear on any other sites.

K. Waste posted:

I can only say that, from my very basic understanding of domestic violence, what you're saying is true and worth putting out there. I didn't mean to suggest that only straight men can be garbage, but as a (mostly) straight man, as someone who's benefited inordinately from the privileges that come with that, I kind of see my responsibility as being more to critique patriarchy and the centrality of heterosexuality and masculinity in it specifically. I didn't mean to minimize abuse and coercion that takes place in homosexual relationships, and I apologize for that.

You didn't suggest it at all, no one did. Esperterra is arguing with people who don't exist in this thread.

teacup
Dec 20, 2006

= M I L K E R S =

esperterra posted:

fwiw I am a lesbian.

From what I rememember last time I was a bit more well read on it, rates were highest in bisexual women, then lesbians, then gay men, with het men would theoretically somewhere after or equal to lesbians in that.

It's really hard to nail down tho as women are less likely to speak out about it, even less so than women in abusive hetero relationships. Men are also less likely to speak out about being abused by a woman as well so a lot of the stats and knowledge for abuse done by non hetero men for stuff like this aren't as accurate as one might want.

When not on my phone I can peep some more specific stuff, I'm going off memory from a while back atm.

Domestic abuse sucks and I wish we lived in a society where all genders and orientations were comfortable speaking out about it.

e: oh hey there's a whole wiki page just for abuse in lesbian relationships lmao

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domestic_violence_in_lesbian_relationships

not sure how up to date any of these sources are. and diff ones will have diff results ofc

Yeah I gotta admit in general the more this stuff comes out (me too / times up / not just Hollywood stuff) the more I’m realising that people are poo poo and we don’t talk enough about it. Even during the original me too stuff my wife talked about how she was grabbed at a club when she was younger, I knew her at that time and we are married and I had no idea. My sister as well, like I was just clueless. And id like to think I care about this stuff. It needs to be like a huge cultural change in how we talk about it

chitoryu12
Apr 24, 2014

https://www.cnn.com/2018/06/13/entertainment/sylvester-stallone-investigation/index.html

Snowman_McK
Jan 31, 2010

They got all the way to the end of the story before mentioning that he's a famous actor who's still busily working at age 71. Usually that would be the opening line. good for them

Ghost Leviathan
Mar 2, 2017

Exploration is ill-advised.
Straight men are definitely taught almost entirely terrible and bad lessons about sex and relationships by media, peers and most social institutions in general since birth. Doesn't mean that people of other genders and orientations can't have problems with it, though there's probably not as much study and insight into other angles of things. It's probably at least partly related to the above problems in a lot of cases, at a guess. Also likely doesn't help with queer people being more vulnerable all round.

esperterra
Mar 24, 2010

SHINee's back




Yeah, I don't mean to undermine the hosed up ideals many boys get instilled with when it comes to women. Those societal gender roles play a big part in why men are often at (or at least perceived to be at) the forefront of issues like abuse or sexual assault, but they also unfortunately play a big part in people being quiet about other types of abuse, because we're all so programmed to think it's the big strong men that are the perpetrators of such violence, so there's those thoughts in the backs of people's minds that nobody will believe them if they say it wasn't a man this time, or if it was a man who was abused by a woman, etc.

I know I can get p heated in this thread, it's about a topic I think most people can and prob should get pretty heated about. But I don't mean to paint a picture that I think it's a thread full of people who only think men can be poo poo or only want to focus on men being poo poo. When we're on topic most of the stories that come up are about men and I get that. It's just some of the derails we head into over the course of this thing I do see generalizations creep out, either unintentionally or intentionally, and it gets under my skin in a special way I can't shake.

I just want to say I don't mean to demean or attack the opinions of any posters in this thread. I can just get salty when it comes to expressing my own.

Peaceful Anarchy
Sep 18, 2005
sXe
I am the math man.

Ghost Leviathan posted:

Straight men are definitely taught almost entirely terrible and bad lessons about sex and relationships by media, peers and most social institutions in general since birth.
Straight men aren't, for the most part, taught these lessons in a vacuum. Pervasive media and social institutions create negative expectations and models for everyone. When you present a model of relationships where one person dominates the other as ok it makes some people want to be the dominant person and others feel like its ok for others to act that way towards them and like they'd be wrong to complain. Gender roles are enmeshed in this so that men are more likely to see themselves reflected in an active role of control and women more likely to see themselves in a passive role, but changing the orientation of a relationship doesn't change people's views of how relationships as a whole work. A lot of people have the capacity to be lovely regardless of gender or race or orientation or wealth or anything else. What straight men have more than others is the opportunity to be lovely and in too many cases the opportunity to be excused for their shittiness, but an equal amount of non-straight or non-men would be (and when they can, are) just as lovely if they felt equally empowered to be so.

As to the wider conversation, if someone wants to focus on what men do wrong or what they're taught wrong that's one thing, but to take the statement

quote:

Why do people need to be educated not to trick or force people to do stuff
and rewrite it as

quote:

Why do [straight men] need to be educated not to trick or force people to do stuff
isn't making a statement on straight men, it's explicitly narrowing down the people with problems to straight men, charitably under the view straight men are so overwhelmingly the problem that nothing else matters, uncharitably under the view that only how straight men act really matters. In either case the context makes it no longer a person talking about what they view as the bigger problem and instead about denying the reality of a wider problem. It's frustrating not because men aren't the worst offenders or because "well what about the other abusers," but because it makes the discussion about men, when it should be about lovely behaviour (which is largely done by men).

Peaceful Anarchy fucked around with this message at 20:50 on Jun 14, 2018

the escape goat
Apr 16, 2008

Not to be an rear end or anything, but can we make this thread about the culture of hollywood again? This is... Not a great derail.

Though it's somewhat heartening that we're not getting daily updates on the fact that artists we adore are secret sex pests, ugh.

esperterra
Mar 24, 2010

SHINee's back




Agreed and agreed!

chitoryu12
Apr 24, 2014

the escape goat posted:

Not to be an rear end or anything, but can we make this thread about the culture of hollywood again? This is... Not a great derail.

Though it's somewhat heartening that we're not getting daily updates on the fact that artists we adore are secret sex pests, ugh.

The one for Will was kinda lovely for me because I've been listening to him for years and seeing him in concert whenever he was in town. In retrospect, it turns out some of his most hardcore lyrics were about reality rather than fantasy.

It also seems like it started almost a year ago and just nobody noticed. He was touring with Motionless in White and suddenly abandoned it mid-tour, driving back home to Seattle and claiming that he was tired of touring, he'd spent most of his adult life on the road in bands, and he wanted to go home and be with his family and work his record business. It seemed like a really lovely yet understandable choice and he started getting other electronic artists onto his record label. Artists like Aesthetic Perfection were having him guest on their poo poo and it seemed like he was really doing a solid for independent artists trying to break into the business.

Now reviewing the evidence that's come out, it looks like his actual motivation for skipping town without notice was the first allegations starting to surface, and his screen printing business was just a legal cover for his pimping. A former employee even says he was asked to fake record sale numbers to further cover his illegal income.

DC Murderverse
Nov 10, 2016

"Tell that to Zod's snapped neck!"

Chloe Dykstra posted an essay about emotional and sexual abuse while in a relationship with a fairly well-known Hollywood person. She doesn't name him but it's super incredibly obvious if you even follow nerd poo poo a little bit, and he's still growing in stature in Hollywood so his power-tripping has probably only gotten worse since the two broke up.

This is actually a great intersection between the power politics of relationships in Hollywood (she talks about him calling people to blacklist her and only hanging out with industry people or wanting to date other actresses) and the toxic relationship poo poo that people everywhere have to deal with (never letting her go out, not letting her have male friends, pressuring her into having sex when she didn't want to). She also has a great paragraph about the people who may disbelieve her or have no pity because it was a relationship she could have gotten out of:

quote:

And that’s the big question, isn’t it? If this person treated you so badly why did you stay?

Your guesses will probably include:
It wasn’t that bad. Memories can warp.
He was famous. She enjoyed the lifestyle. (For the record, I usually insisted on paying for dinner, thank you very much.)
She was dumb and/or weak and didn’t have the strength to stand up to him.

Here is my answer: I believed that, to borrow an analogy from a friend, if I kept digging I would find water. And sometimes I did. Just enough to sustain me. And when you’re dying of thirst, that water is the best water you’ll ever drink. When you’re alienated from your friends, there’s no one to tell you that there’s a drinking fountain 20 feet away. And when your self-worth reaches such depths after years of being treated like you’re worthless, you might find you think you deserve that sort of treatment, and no one else will love you.

Name Change
Oct 9, 2005


DC Murderverse posted:

Chloe Dykstra posted an essay about emotional and sexual abuse while in a relationship with a fairly well-known Hollywood person. She doesn't name him but it's super incredibly obvious if you even follow nerd poo poo a little bit, and he's still growing in stature in Hollywood so his power-tripping has probably only gotten worse since the two broke up.

This is actually a great intersection between the power politics of relationships in Hollywood (she talks about him calling people to blacklist her and only hanging out with industry people or wanting to date other actresses) and the toxic relationship poo poo that people everywhere have to deal with (never letting her go out, not letting her have male friends, pressuring her into having sex when she didn't want to). She also has a great paragraph about the people who may disbelieve her or have no pity because it was a relationship she could have gotten out of:

Sigh, just say who it is, I promise I won't tell

GrandpaPants
Feb 13, 2006


Free to roam the heavens in man's noble quest to investigate the weirdness of the universe!

DC Murderverse posted:

Chloe Dykstra posted an essay about emotional and sexual abuse while in a relationship with a fairly well-known Hollywood person. She doesn't name him but it's super incredibly obvious if you even follow nerd poo poo a little bit, and he's still growing in stature in Hollywood so his power-tripping has probably only gotten worse since the two broke up.

For people who aren't into nerd poo poo, it's probably about Chris Hardwick. gently caress being coy.

Edit: Just realized that the nerd backlash against her is going to be harsh :( God I hope she has a really great support network. gently caress that guy.

GrandpaPants fucked around with this message at 11:02 on Jun 15, 2018

esperterra
Mar 24, 2010

SHINee's back




Chris Hardwick has always seemed like a oval office to me.

R. Guyovich
Dec 25, 1991

chloe has been a target of harassers for a very long time. i imagine she can handle whatever fusillade will come of calling out the bad comedian people still like for some reason

Not Operator
Jan 1, 2009

Not A doctor, THE Doctor!
Was the 'long term girlfriend' Janet Varney, or was there someone else in between?

GrandpaPants
Feb 13, 2006


Free to roam the heavens in man's noble quest to investigate the weirdness of the universe!

Chris Hardwick is currently trending on Twitter.

DrVenkman
Dec 28, 2005

I think he can hear you, Ray.

GrandpaPants posted:

For people who aren't into nerd poo poo, it's probably about Chris Hardwick. gently caress being coy.

Edit: Just realized that the nerd backlash against her is going to be harsh :( God I hope she has a really great support network. gently caress that guy.

Weirdly it's been fairly supportive on Reddit so far, at least from what I saw. No doubt there are people trying to support him or 'asking questions' but I'd like to think the support outweighs the backlash.

GrandpaPants
Feb 13, 2006


Free to roam the heavens in man's noble quest to investigate the weirdness of the universe!

Who's the woman that Chloe mentioned?

Quote-Unquote
Oct 22, 2002



Don't worry Hollywood, you're not alone: the UK just ruled that sticking a camera up a woman's skirt without her consent is not a crime

Macdeo Lurjtux
Jul 5, 2011

BRRREADSTOOORRM!
Outside of the Nerdist Reddits Hardwick isn’t very popular there for a number of reasons. A lot of it to do with gate keeping and general overexposure.

Crackbone
May 23, 2003

Vlaada is my co-pilot.

GrandpaPants posted:

Who's the woman that Chloe mentioned?

Speculation is Felica Day.

Apparently Wheaton is a giant shitstain as well According to people speaking up for Chloe.

Crackbone fucked around with this message at 16:18 on Jun 15, 2018

Bust Rodd
Oct 21, 2008

by VideoGames
Gotta say, “people suffering from mental illness can’t consent to the sex they want/crave” is perhaps the single hottest take I’ve read in this thread and as a someone whose mental health is both a big part of my life and the lives of my partners please go gently caress yourself until parts start to fall off.

asecondduck
Feb 18, 2011

by Nyc_Tattoo

Crackbone posted:

Speculation is Felica Day.

Apparently Wheaton is a giant shitstain as well According to people speaking up for Chloe.

I mean, it could be that Day/Wheaton didn't know the true nature of Chris and Chloe's relationship. I guess we'll see. Probably gonna be a lot of statements going out today about this.

Popoi
Jul 23, 2000

Not Operator posted:

Was the 'long term girlfriend' Janet Varney, or was there someone else in between?
It was her, based on the time frame and what I remember from listening to Nerdist stuff back then.

chitoryu12
Apr 24, 2014

Bust Rodd posted:

Gotta say, “people suffering from mental illness can’t consent to the sex they want/crave” is perhaps the single hottest take I’ve read in this thread and as a someone whose mental health is both a big part of my life and the lives of my partners please go gently caress yourself until parts start to fall off.

Should mentally ill people attempting to self-harm be capable of consenting to harmful sexual practices as a way of fulfilling their desires for pain and injury? Should mentally ill people be able to consent to a relationship in which they enslave themselves to a "master" who has free reign to physically hurt them and create a dependent relationship?

We wouldn't let someone who's been drugged, drunk, or mentally disabled do that because they're in an altered state of mind. What makes a chemical imbalance in their brain different? And what's the moral difference between someone who intentionally gets someone drunk to convince them to have sex and someone who seeks out bipolar people with PTSD to convince them to engage in physically dangerous sexual practices?

Sir Kodiak
May 14, 2007


chitoryu12 posted:

We wouldn't let someone who's been drugged, drunk, or mentally disabled do that because they're in an altered state of mind. What makes a chemical imbalance in their brain different?

I think, hope, the point being made is that we don't actually put a blanket ban on consent for people who use drugs, drink, have mental disabilities or mental illnesses, etc. Instead, there's a factual investigation as to consent based on the specific details of the relationship and events. That said, I wasn't reading "people suffering from mental illness can’t consent" as a blanket statement in any of your previous comments that Rodd is presumably responding to.

And man does the case you mentioned seem like one that needs some vigorous factual investigation by the courts. Sounds really hosed up.

GrandpaPants
Feb 13, 2006


Free to roam the heavens in man's noble quest to investigate the weirdness of the universe!

Quote-Unquote posted:

Don't worry Hollywood, you're not alone: the UK just ruled that sticking a camera up a woman's skirt without her consent is not a crime

Not so fast: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/upskirting-bill-law-blocked-criminal-offence-christopher-chope-tory-mp-a8400686.html

chitoryu12
Apr 24, 2014

Sir Kodiak posted:

I think, hope, the point being made is that we don't actually put a blanket ban on consent for people who use drugs, drink, have mental disabilities or mental illnesses, etc. Instead, there's a factual investigation as to consent based on the specific details of the relationship and events. That said, I wasn't reading "people suffering from mental illness can’t consent" as a blanket statement in any of your previous comments that Rodd is presumably responding to.

And man does the case you mentioned seem like one that needs some vigorous factual investigation by the courts. Sounds really hosed up.

Yeah, you can't really put a blanket ban on consent with zero tolerance. Otherwise, what happens if two people get drunk and have sex, or two mentally ill people have sex? Did they rape each other? How could you even prosecute that?

But what you can look at is signs of one person taking advantage of another's altered mental state. According to accounts from the victims, they suffered from depression, bipolar disorder, anxiety, possibly past traumas, etc. William identified these people, often encouraged them to drink and do drugs while he remained sober (he suffered from severe drug addiction in his youth and consumes nothing but cigarettes and caffeine now), and convinced them to have hardcore and painful-to-damaging BDSM sex. He sought out girls whose mental illness led to them making self-destructive decisions or seeking validation to the extent that they would easily be manipulated into a permanent dom/sub relationship, then pimped them for cash. He technically has written records of consent, but the consent came from girls who were in an altered mental state due to their illness and may have felt like they had to serve him and continue receiving attention and validation from him even if it meant being taken to extremes they weren't prepared for. One victim specified that even though he never outright raped her, the violence of his play sessions made her too terrified to refuse him.

Where my personal life comes into it is that my ex reminds me a lot of these girls, and it gives me some more insight that a person who hasn't been in a relationship with a person like this wouldn't have. The symptoms of borderline personality disorder include an exaggerated fear of abandonment and over-the-top emotional reactions to everything, so she actively seeks out permanent kink relationships like DD/LG because she craves the attention. I think part of it is because her incredibly abusive childhood left her seeking a sort of "do-over" where she could be a kid again, cared for and having no real responsibilities beyond pleasing her dominant. She was also driven to self-harm and did so occasionally when we were together, so the desire for pain during sex was likely part of her general desire for pain.

When we were together, I felt extremely uncomfortable with her desires for BDSM like this because I knew about her past and her mental illness, and I felt like her desires were partially or even mostly driven by her trauma and disorders. What William did was make the other decision: take advantage of someone like that to provide him with a target for abuse, one that technically provided consent but really shouldn't have been able to give it.

Peaceful Anarchy
Sep 18, 2005
sXe
I am the math man.

Wouldn't expect anything less from that guy

quote:

The Thatcherite MP was first elected in 1983 and has previously voted against equal marriage, an amnesty of men convicted for homosexual acts, filibustered a bill to make revenge evictions an offence and called for the minimum wage to be abolished.

Autechresaint
Jan 25, 2012

GrandpaPants posted:

Who's the woman that Chloe mentioned?

Someone else who is familiar with the people and situation mentioned it was someone named Michelle Morrow. No clue who that is, don't know if it's 100 percent accurate.

El Gallinero Gros
Mar 17, 2010
Well, never watching or listening to anything with Chris ever again.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Capn Jobe
Jan 18, 2003

That's right. Here it is. But it's like you always have compared the sword, the making of the sword, with the making of the character. Cuz the stronger, the stronger it will get, right, the stronger the steel will get, with all that, and the same as with the character.
Soiled Meat
Awww poo poo, son:

https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/nerdist-removes-chris-hardwick-references-site-alleged-abuse-claim-1120557

quote:

"Chris Hardwick had no operational involvement with Nerdist for the two years preceding the expiration of his contract in December 2017. He no longer has any affiliation with Legendary Digital Networks. The company has removed all reference to Mr. Hardwick even as the original Founder of Nerdist pending further investigation," a Legendary spokesperson said in statement on Friday.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply