|
Lead out in cuffs posted:my story you titled your story off of the title of another thread on these forums, which means it was basically fanfic to me. don't do that.
|
# ? Aug 14, 2014 07:29 |
|
|
# ? Sep 13, 2024 12:29 |
|
the wildest turkey posted:You guys have gotten soft so I gotta assert my TD dominance. The wise Thunderdomer knows: she does not need to be a good writer to avoid the losertar. She only needs to be better than the worst writer. Anathema Device posted:Could I please get a crit? I want to know if the interactions between the characters made sense. Character interaction: I felt this was good, for the most part. I didn't quite get the reason she was in the convent until a closer read. She was forced there, some kind of defeat while trying to defend her land? I get the feeling that she couldn't, for instance, leave if she wanted to leave, but I wasn't entirely clear on the reason why. Wasn't a big detriment, though. The animosity she has toward the abbess is pretty clear, though I wasn't as sure how the abbess felt about her until the end. The feeling I got in the beginning and middle is more wary, while at the end, it's both a kind of respect but a desire to see her fully convert and give up the magic. I wasn't sure what feeling to take away from the third scene. It didn't seem incongruous, but I wasn't clear on what it was telling me, in a sense. The abbess seems interested in her but also interested in her conversion, while the main character sticks stubbornly to the magic that's a part of her despite going along with convent work--that's what I got from it. Hopefully, you can compare that to what you were going for, and get an idea of how well that worked. More generally, I liked the depiction of both Christianity (I'm assuming) and the pagan religion as correct and functional, so it comes across as more of a difference of culture and their own natures as opposed to a religious disagreement. I don't have a ton to say, because I did generally enjoy it. Since starting lines are a thing of mine, though, I was thinking about yours, and I had a variation on it that I think works a little better at presenting the dichotomy you were going for. It wasn't until I read a lot later (and I was still thinking about the beginning line) that I realized it was a nature/church thing. "There was no birdsong to wake me. I woke to the ringing of bells." I think that's a little more effective, because it makes the birds being replaced by bells a little clearer--in your story, it seems a bit more like the bells happened to wake her up instead of the birds that day, as opposed to bells waking her up because she doesn't hear the birds like she used to when she lived outside the convent.
|
# ? Aug 14, 2014 07:31 |
|
Djeser posted:I don't know a whole lot about the abstract construction of humor beyond that, so I'm going to link you to two things. First, this is from a tumblr about learning from the errors of webcomics, but the humor aspects are still applicable in fiction in general. Second, something that I think has generally good humor, Welcome To Night Vale, which is a podcast styled like X-Files community radio. Thanks for the pointers and references! (My thanks seemed inauthentic with a period and overly enthusiastic with an exclamation point.)
|
# ? Aug 14, 2014 16:46 |
|
AaronMFK posted:My thanks seemed inauthentic with a period and overly enthusiastic with an exclamation point. Just stop using punctuation altogether and let God sort em out I challenge the next person who posts to a brawl
|
# ? Aug 14, 2014 16:55 |
|
Number 36 posted:Just stop using punctuation altogether and let God sort em out You ain't $#!+, sir. Challenge accepted.
|
# ? Aug 14, 2014 17:07 |
|
Pitiful you are, and meaningless. By the flesh and by the blood shall your heart sink in my darkness.
|
# ? Aug 14, 2014 17:11 |
|
Allow me to introduce myself, Number 36. I'm Number 1.
|
# ? Aug 14, 2014 17:33 |
|
Number 36 posted:I challenge the next person who posts to a brawl Ironic Twist posted:Challenge accepted. I'll judge this. You nerds seem to like to chat a lot. Look at you filling up the thread with your poop-mouthed drivel. Use 750 words to write me a story about a mute main character. Tell his story through his/her gestures and actions. Don't wuss out by having other people talk for him/her or explain what s/he's doing. This is due Friday, August 29th. Sometime in the evening. PLEASE FOR THE LOVE OF GOD TAKE THIS SERIOUSLY. work on several drafts over your almost two-week time limit. don't rush and write it all on friday. i will be able to tell. If either of you fail to submit, I will make your archive account background goatse. furthermore, both of you are decent writers with a lot of potential, so you should both fear losing. write the best god drat story you can.
|
# ? Aug 14, 2014 17:41 |
|
sebmojo posted:I will do crits for two newbies from last week. No-one wants a crit? Tsk.
|
# ? Aug 14, 2014 23:36 |
sebmojo posted:No-one wants a crit? Tsk. I'd take a crit, but I don't think I qualify as a newbie. Seriously new writers, crits are the best. Take this man up on his offer.
|
|
# ? Aug 14, 2014 23:41 |
|
sebmojo posted:No-one wants a crit? Tsk. Meinberg posted:I'd take a crit, but I don't think I qualify as a newbie. Ah, I didn't realize you were asking for volunteers. I'd absolutely like to hear criticism of anything I write here from anyone who wants to offer it.
|
# ? Aug 14, 2014 23:48 |
|
Duke of the Bump posted:After School Programs (1108 words)
|
# ? Aug 15, 2014 01:48 |
|
sebmojo posted:Thanks so much! Could you explain what you mean by "blocking"? I don't think I've seen the term used this way before and can't find anything about it. Like, how is it different from normal narration? BTW a plasma globe is one of these
|
# ? Aug 15, 2014 02:21 |
|
Duke of the Bump posted:Thanks so much! Could you explain what you mean by "blocking"? I don't think I've seen the term used this way before and can't find anything about it. Like, how is it different from normal narration? Blocking is a theatrical term where you describe in detail the movements of your characters, as though you were a camera watching them. It's an easy habit to get into but it reads very ploddily. Take it to fiction farm if you want to discuss it further. Anyone else for a crit? vv noted sebmojo fucked around with this message at 04:18 on Aug 15, 2014 |
# ? Aug 15, 2014 02:24 |
|
You still haven't done a crit for my brawl in the farm yet Sir Mojito
|
# ? Aug 15, 2014 02:55 |
|
Echo Cian posted:A bunch of crits, including mine: You, sir, are a respectable and upstanding citizen. Which is why I apologize for subjecting you to the following: In.
|
# ? Aug 15, 2014 07:15 |
|
It is Friday afternoon in my part of the world. Signups close Friday night.
|
# ? Aug 15, 2014 09:47 |
|
In.
|
# ? Aug 15, 2014 10:40 |
|
In.
|
# ? Aug 15, 2014 10:51 |
|
sebmojo posted:No-one wants a crit? Tsk. I'm only sort of a newbie, but I'll take one.
|
# ? Aug 15, 2014 12:50 |
|
That's Friday night! Let this be a vague indication of when 'Monday morning' is. Of course, the best way to not be late is to be early, instead of all waiting until the last five minutes and trying to run under the wire at the same time. SIGN UPS CLOSED
|
# ? Aug 15, 2014 13:25 |
|
I will do some crits for last week if anyone is interested.
|
# ? Aug 15, 2014 18:14 |
|
SurreptitiousMuffin posted:That's Friday night! Let this be a vague indication of when 'Monday morning' is. Of course, the best way to not be late is to be early, instead of all waiting until the last five minutes and trying to run under the wire at the same time. Your Friday afternoon/evening happened while I was asleep. Can I still get in? I started writing a thing and everything.
|
# ? Aug 15, 2014 18:33 |
|
Anathema Device posted:I will do some crits for last week if anyone is interested. I'll take one. I wasn't really happy with my entry but I'm not entirely sure where it went wrong.
|
# ? Aug 15, 2014 19:02 |
|
God Over Djinn posted:Your Friday afternoon/evening happened while I was asleep. Can I still get in? I started writing a thing and everything. Flash Nepotism Djinn is in or I shall be cross with you, Muffin.
|
# ? Aug 15, 2014 19:13 |
|
Grizzled Patriarch posted:I'll take one. I wasn't really happy with my entry but I'm not entirely sure where it went wrong. My first thought when I read this was “Oh, another Wendigo story.” It has all the elements: a cold, secluded place, a missing person(body), a bad-rear end dude who knows what's up, and a leader disbelieving or covering up the Wendigo attack. On top of that, you use a lot of common descriptions and phrases (smell of fresh-baked bread, blinking until his eyes adjusted to the darkness, didn't answer right away.) What makes this Wendigo story different from other Wendigo stories? How do you choose your descriptions? So – I'm going through an italicizing all of the descriptions I've read before, and striking out the ones which I don't feel add anything to the story. If you're going to keep an italicized phrase, really consider whether it's the best detail you could give, or just the easiest. Grizzled Patriarch posted:The Windigo (804 words) Overall this story is passive; the Windigo makes stuff happen and your characters react. Give them some agency – let them make things happen. Does the boatswain set off an a rescue mission? Support the captain in declaring Baycroft a loss? Does the captain feel torn at all about just writing off one of his crew? Maybe something entirely different and far more original happens. What does work in this story is the boatswain's dialogue, and the captain's fear. I definitely get a feel for both characters despite how short the story is.
|
# ? Aug 15, 2014 20:45 |
|
Anathema Device posted:I will do some crits for last week if anyone is interested. Yes please.
|
# ? Aug 15, 2014 21:36 |
|
I, too, would like to be in.
|
# ? Aug 15, 2014 22:25 |
|
God Over Djinn posted:Your Friday afternoon/evening happened while I was asleep. Can I still get in? I started writing a thing and everything. Your protagonist is a rapper. Their instrument is voice. Genre: fantasy. Tyrannosaurus posted:I, too, would like to be in. Any less than a respectful depiction of the art will get you tarred and feathered. That goes for both of you.
|
# ? Aug 16, 2014 03:24 |
|
May I get a flash rule?
|
# ? Aug 16, 2014 03:32 |
|
yeah, muffin is hella old, of course he'd close sign ups right before he went to bed at 7:30. \/ SHUT UP AND WORK ON YOUR BRAWL crabrock fucked around with this message at 05:51 on Aug 16, 2014 |
# ? Aug 16, 2014 05:26 |
|
Like at least post a time zone, "Friday night" covers an entire 24 hour period without a time zone
|
# ? Aug 16, 2014 05:32 |
|
Fair.
|
# ? Aug 16, 2014 05:53 |
|
Number 36 posted:Like at least post a time zone, "Friday night" covers an entire 24 hour period without a time zone lol get hosed Flash me muffin
|
# ? Aug 16, 2014 06:05 |
|
Anathema Device posted:May I get a flash rule? Number 36 posted:Like at least post a time zone, "Friday night" covers an entire 24 hour period without a time zone THAT IS THE WHOLE POINT. I AM BEING INTENTIONALLY VAGUE ABOUT DEADLINES SO PEOPLE TRY TO GET THEIR WRITING DONE EARLIER RATHER THAN LEAVING IT UNTIL THE LAST MINUTE. edit: sebmojo posted:lol get hosed SurreptitiousMuffin fucked around with this message at 06:15 on Aug 16, 2014 |
# ? Aug 16, 2014 06:08 |
|
Mojo in case you missed it, I edited your flash rule slightly. The old rule was a little too easy for a man of your talents, and a little boring to boot. The first version of the rule was only there for 3-4 minutes but I'm just making sure.
|
# ? Aug 16, 2014 06:25 |
|
Please, no bad stories this week, mercy mercy me.
|
# ? Aug 16, 2014 06:33 |
|
docbeard posted:And sadly, Phobia escaped the headsman's axe only to fall in - Hey guys I'm back. I'm in for this week to... Oh. Signups have closed. *walks back out.*
|
# ? Aug 16, 2014 07:17 |
|
Someone brawl me. I need to redeem myself, like everything that just happened is some cliche Rise and Fall story.
|
# ? Aug 16, 2014 07:24 |
|
|
# ? Sep 13, 2024 12:29 |
|
You skipped out on our brawl last time. Let's fight.
|
# ? Aug 16, 2014 07:32 |