Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
Who Killed WCW?
Eric Bischoff
Hulk Hogan
Vince Russo
Jerusalem
View Results
 
  • Post
  • Reply
MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

Lone Rogue posted:

It's a disappointment the matches were so short. Some of them sound like a lot of fun and it's a good idea in concept. In concept.

Bret vs. Saturn and Kidman are interesting matchups. I want to see Scott Hall vs. Lash LeRoux badly. Hennig/Jarrett must have been a fun match, even if quick.

I would like to see the WWE or even TNA do a monster sized tournament. No 8 Man Tournament. A big huge one where it engulfs the show into nothing but Tournament matches. We all love Beat the Clock, so I think this would be good in giving us an excuse to watch good wrestling matches.

Some of them do, but most just sound horrible. I also double Hennig/Jarrett was that good since Hennig gave zero poo poo throughout his WCW career and especially after the Flair feud ended.

Miller vs Leroux? Ugh.

Hall vs Sid? Yikes.

Sting vs Knobs?

Buff Bagwell vs STEVIE RAY? Holy poo poo, I need to see that match. I have no memory of it, it must have been something else.

There's a handful of interesting matches, and just a huge helping of horrible.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
The low point of the WCW Heavyweight Title, and its worst champion: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YHsa3tOVlIA

It isn't who you'd think!

Just think, he'll be back on TNA TV soon to feud with Eric Bischoff.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

STAC Goat posted:



I also loved that double elimination tag tournament and the tag division in general at the time. And I loved the idea of the giant rear end World Title tournament, even if it just fell apart in execution. I love the idea of big tournaments, but it takes a good booker to tell that story with the proper pacing so it doesn't all fall apart or just burn out.

By the time, do you mean 1999, or the nWo era? In the first half of 1999, WCW had a great tag division. But from 1996-2000, WCW had a really bad tag division. The Steiners were way past their prime. Harlem Heat were never really a good team because Stevie Ray was so awful. And the belts were often just on the Outsiders as a vanity thing. On top of this you had stuff like Sting vs The Giant in a singles match for the tag titles.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
Proof that Flair, even in his old age could wrestle a broomstick to a *** match.

HIS OPPONENT, HAILING FROM NEW YORK CITY, VINCE RUSSO!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pb34HzbvElA

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
I found something better. I hope I haven't already posted this, but I don't think I have...

WAR GAMES 2000: RUSSO'S REVENGE!

http://www.youtube.com/user/hitman2010#p/u/5/Kcdlj0urAg0

I just wish when Tony said "The rules are" he followed it up with "Simple."

Since there is nothing simpler than War Games staggered entrances in a 3 tiered cage where a wrestler must retrieve the belt from the top cage and then escape to to the door in the 1st floor with the belt to win.

Sound like the lightning round of almost every Nick game show of the 80s and early 90s to anyone?

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

Dylar Addict posted:

Slime doesn't fall on anyone so no

This was WCW in 2000. Goo was falling out of the ceiling nearly every week! You also had people finding prizes in boxes, wild and crazy kids doing stunts onto crash pads, and all sorts of nuttyness!

I think I know all of Russo's secrets.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

LividLiquid posted:

That's actually incredibly simple. Get the belt, leave with the belt. What's difficult about it? The only thing they hosed up was everything else.

No it isn't.

First of all, it involves THREE CAGES. You need to climb up the structure through three cages to get the belt. So, you've combined a cage match with a ladder match. On top of this, the second cage is full of weapons. So you've combined a weapons match, a cage match, and a ladder match.

Then you add in the War Games teams. So you've got a Team based Cage match combined with a ladder match combined with a weapons match. War Games has Royal Rumble entrances, so you have a Royal Rumble style staggered entrances in a team based triple cage/ladder/weapons match.

On top of this, the teams had to qualify for the match, and some of the matches were handi cap matches.

THAT IS loving COMPLICATED!

In its most simple form, wrestling matches are: Two Guys Fight in a ring.

In its most simple form this match is: 8 Guys who enter at different times fight while attempting to climb up three cages to get a belt and then attempt to escape with the belt.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

Captain Charisma posted:

I don't feel like watching it, but is that where Goldberg speared Russo out of the cage, but Russo was holding the belt

I thought this was the match that happened too but was surprised when it wasn't.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
DDP did another Figure 4 Daily interview today, and this time instead of just talking about YRG for half an hour, he talked about WCW too! DDP interviews are the best since even if he's gone a bit insane with organic food, he's got this positive energy that is always awesome to listen to even if he is just plugging something.

First, he told the story behind THE BEST DIAMOND CUTTER EVER: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=keMz1rAUlIc

Basically, this was during the build up to Bash at the Beach 98, so they wanted to keep putting DDP over strong, so they put him with Eddie, since who better to make someone look awesome?

Backstage Eddie suggests they do a Diamond Cutter out of a powerbomb. DDP asks him how the gently caress they could do that. "Just get me on your shoulders, give me a boost and I'll do the rest."

DDP's reaction, according to him was a total shoot, he was so excited that it worked that he started celebrating right then and there, and then pinned him.

He also said his favorite match with Savage was the first one where Savage put him over. Why? Because before the show Arn asked him what he wanted to do in the match and Savage says "I want to take the Diamond Cutter" offering to put DDP over at a time when Savage put NO ONE over clean, and almost no one over in general. The reaction was so huge that night that they had to go with it from there.

Edit: Also here's a pro tip if you are a big DDP fan and are on Facebook. On his last time on F4D he said he doesn't mind friend requests on facebook, but please at least send him a message too to let him know you are a fan and why. (Otherwise he just ignores the friend request.) So a few subscribers did so and sent him a message about why they were a fan and particularly happy memories of his matches, or if he had inspired them in some way...

And the genuine people got a message back from DDP, or comments on pictures they had posted, or stuff like that. And not just a thanks, but pretty lengthy, detailed replies that showed he had actually read their message and their profile. To me, that's really loving cool.

MassRafTer fucked around with this message at 11:56 on Jan 23, 2010

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
After listening to DDP last night I wanted to rewatch his excellent match with Sting from Nitro in March of 99. Instead, I found this, a match full of Vince Russo calling cards.

Sting and DDP vs The Total Package and David Flair

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4H96ZOxhTX4

Watch this match. The entrances are much longer than the match itself. It's No DQ for whatever reason, there's a beheaded teddy bear, partners who hate each other, and even Bobby Heenan has no idea what is going on.

Edit: But after you watch that, watch this:

Sting vs DDP for DDP's WCW Title. It was from April, not March so I had trouble finding it. This is a great, long TV match.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RRjAsdlwPU4

MassRafTer fucked around with this message at 03:38 on Jan 24, 2010

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

LividLiquid posted:

Do any of you have any reason to believe that the New Blood were supposed to be anything but heels aside from, "I want WCW to have been dumber than they already were, god dammit!"

New Blood were always the heels. If you think otherwise you're a loving retard.

Because the entire storyline was "THE OLD GUYS ARE HOLDING THE YOUNG GUYS DOWN" which makes the OLD GUYS LOOK LIKE HEELS. And the way Bischoff talked up the era made it sounds like the young guys were going to be babyfaces. On top of this, the initial promo Russo and Bischoff cut laid it out that way too. The old guys were huge dicks who were holding the young guys down.

And because most of the old guys were heels before the era began and Kidman and Vampiro were babyfaces.

MassRafTer fucked around with this message at 11:43 on Jan 24, 2010

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
The entire New Blood stable was not supposed to be faces nor were the old guys all supposed to be heels.

But people are forgetting the context of the time and what THE PEOPLE IN CHARGE SAID ON THE RECORD. The entire idea of the first Nitro of the reboot was to recapture the 18-35 demographic they had lost.

Eric Bischoff was asked by Meltzer the next night on Wrestling Observer Live what he planned to do about how "uncool" WCW had become in the eye of the casual fan, specifically young viewers. Bischoff specifically said that the WWF had changed in a way WCW couldn't change, since TNT and TBS wouldn't allow the same sort of adult product.

But instead, WCW could do things that challenged the fans, did things they couldn't predict, and surprise them.

Obviously, Jeff Jarrett was not intended to be a face. But the idea behind the Hogan/Kidman feud was that younger male viewers would tune in and see this old guy cutting a pretty heelish promo on a young guy (after Bischoff and Russo had exposed how he "held people down") and Kidman wouldn't stand for it, and go after Hogan. Guys like the Filthy Animals were supposed to very much be cool tweeners who did heelish things for a reason to both babyfaces and heels.

Remember, this is the time when SHADES OF GREY ruled all and Russo still to this days believes faces and heels in the traditional sense don't exist. Look how heelish the faces are in TNA, how often they cheat, overwhelm the heels with numbers, and how no one knew who the heels and babyfaces were at many times in TNA's history. They also tried to over reach toward the smarks with lots of insider references and storytelling. Bischoff specifically admits this and thinks it was a mistake.

You also had very divided leadership at the top in WCW. Bischoff and Russo hate each other. When Bischoff was on WOL in 2001, he was nearly gleeful in laughing at Russo's failures. Just look at how quickly the whole thing fell apart when the shades of grey poo poo didn't work and no one got behind guys like Kidman. The New Blood had fallen apart by New Blood Rising, and the only real remnant of the story was the Bash at the Beach shoot angle which was supposed to be the climax of Hogan using his political power to screw the young guys.

Edit: I think a lot of the confusion came about from usual internet hyperbole. The shades of grey and framing of the old guys actions as heelish, and some of their heelish actions became THE OLD GUYS WERE ALL ALWAYS MEANT TO BE HEELS and the tweener and face New Blood members became ALL THE YOUNG GUYS WERE SUPPOSED TO BE FACES when the reality was Russo's beloved shades of grey.

MassRafTer fucked around with this message at 00:10 on Jan 25, 2010

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
The scissors incident saved wrestling fans from having to see Sid vs Vader at Starrcade and gave us the gift of Ric Flair vs Vader. Arn Anderson was stabbed for our sins.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
It was a stupid, pointless bump. Well, maybe it has a point. To set up the incredibly obvious Kanyon heel turn on DDP. But it was really stupid and really thoughtless.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
I forgot Goldberg used to commentate on MMA shows. If you have Sho2 you can catch the Cung Le/Frank Shamrock fight right now with Goldberg on commentary.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

Lone Rogue posted:

A lengthy court case for allowing WWF talent into a WCW building?

The truth is, what Triple H neglects, is the true legal trouble is what DX, who are WWF contracted talent, would say/do while on TNT television. There is nothing stopping them from sucker punching WCW talents, injuring staff or more importantly, saying vulgarities to the moon. What, was WCW going to put a camera on them but mute them?

And then, what about getting them out of the building? Not easy. It would have been absolute mess.

Great TV, but an absolute mess.

You know what would stop them? The law and going to jail for assault.

And if they just bought a ticket and sat in the crowd they'd be fair game to be shown on TV given all the disclaimers on your tickets and in the building.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

The American Dream posted:

So, I was thinking about the DDP love going on in this thread and I think another one today. I was just flipping around the channels and DDP was in the Devils Rejects on IFC (but with not positive black hair.) DDP still rules 10 years later.

He's also in Carny Wilson's reality show on GSN.

I don't understand how he remains so positive while doing that :(

I have no idea why, but WCW loving up Berlyn was one of the things that pissed me off the most about the company. Alex Wright was never a great worker or promo, but that gimmick and the videos leading up to it were really cool and it seemed like something that would take off.

And they hosed it all up by not having any control over their talent.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

Captain Charisma posted:

HHH did a radio interview back then saying Ric Flair was a washed up dinosaur that should retire.

Well it's not like HHH had tremendous power and was one of the bookers like Cornette was then...

Oh. Yeah.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
Thinking about Berlyn and DDP made me wonder this:

If you followed WCW at all, what about WCW brought you the most joy, and the most rage?

Joy: Diamond Dallas Page. I don't know how they pulled off such a perfect push with DDP. They hosed it up a bit by turning him heel, but he was pretty good at that too. He was this perfect mix of "Wow, he's just a normal dude..." then he'd do a crazy lucha move and you'd go "But I could never do that." and of course Diamond Cutter, BANG.

Chris Jericho's heel turn: Him beating up Penzer and apologizing several shows in a row was grand. Collecting trophies was grand. Going to the library of Congress was grand. And the whole Malenko mascarading as Ciclope/Halloween was the icing on the cake.

Mike Enos: For some reason I was a big mark for Mike Enos. Enos vs Child Murderer from Souled Out 99 is one of my favorite, run of the mill not that special, WCW mid card matches.

The transition from Raven vs Benoit to Raven vs Benoit vs DDP. Raven vs Benoit was a really hot feud, and when Benoit won the blow off, there wasn't much more for them to do... until Raven got involved with DDP while he was feuding with Benoit a month later. This is my favorite three way feud of all time, and DDP vs Raven vs Benoit from Uncensored 98 would rank as my favorite 3 way for years to come.

and of course, the Sting vs Hogan storyline. It was all so perfect. It would take
several pages to write down all of the reasons why it ruled.

Rage: As mentioned a few posts up, Berlyn. Idiots.

Sting joining the nWo: Way to slap the fans in the face. Sting is the lone savior of WCW who the fans desperately want to see kill the nWo for 15 months and then he just joins the Wolfpac 5 months after Sting vs Hogan. This made me really angry at the time, because as a fan I got emotionally invested and seeing Sting turn into Just Another Guy in the Wolfpac on top of that was baffling.

Bret Hart: Is he a heel? Is he a face? Is he in the nWo? Do I give a poo poo? Not anymore!

Savage's two one night title reigns: I wasn't a big Macho Man fan, but he was way more captivating than any of the former WWF Old Guys. He won the title from Sting in 98, which was annoying. But, hey, I still like Macho Man. Then he loses it to Hogan the next night.

Then Macho wins the belt in 99... and loses it the next night to Hogan. Again.

Eric Bischoff's talk show. During the Leno feud, Bischoff had his own talk show that is mentioned elsewhere in this thread. It was nWo Nightcap and it was ATROCIOUS. And it lasted 10-15 minutes in several Nitros and Thunders. I rarely switched to Raw, but the second time it aired I turned on Raw.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
Well, that joke is as dead as Louie Spicolli.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
TNA also brought in local radio host Danny Bonaduce for a dark match, who WCW had also brought in.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
The Nitro girls were good for ratings, shocking as it may sound.

And the best SURGE product placement was when they would use a giant SURGE can in hardcore matches.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

MyStereoHasMono posted:

Guys I was supposed to go to bed two hours ago and have been up reading the OP and then that link to the funny WON quotes.

Sorry I'm sure this has been expressed a million times and I will read the entire thread tomorrow, but I just had to say right now this WON link might seriously be the hardest I've ever laughed in my entire life. Several times I have been loving crying here.

I've been debating posting this since it is so large, but it is now posted online and maybe seeing Dave tear apart WCW can get a few more people to subscribe. Here is his review of Halloween Havoc 92 which was hilarious and kind of sad at the same time. If people enjoy this stuff, SUBSCRIBE! It is 9.99 per month for the Observer, Figure 4 Weekly, tons of audio shows, a huge archive of audio, a huge archive of Figure 4 Weekly newsletters, an archive of 4 years of Observers, and a back issue from 92 (going into 1993 with the debut of Raw) every week. https://www.f4wonline.com ~!

Dave Meltzer's Wrestling Observer Newsletter posted:

WCW is in a state of systematic destruction. Real wrestling talent is being exchanged with talent that doesn't have the experience or seasoning, or in some cases, even the talent, to hang in a major league operation. It doesn't appear to be a concern as long as the new talent seems willing to work cheaper than the experienced talent, or simply has a relative in high places. Even that wouldn't necessarily be so bad if the company was going on course with a viable new direction and needed fresh new talent and had the leadership that will teach and groom the newcomers into being legitimate talent. Unfortunately, that also isn't the case. The "old stale" talent gets more response than the "fresh new" talent. In 1993, WCW looks to be falling to the level of the last few years of the AWA, both in terms of talent, product quality and overall interest.

Halloween Havoc wasn't the worst PPV in history, although it was among the worst. The WWF has put on shows that were terrible from start to finish. Two of them were Wrestlemanias. This show was only terrible from the middle point of the show to the finish. The first half was good, particularly when it came to wrestling action, although the lack of direction and terrible main events made the feeling coming out of the show as being worse. Even on the worst WWF PPV show, when it was over you knew what direction the company was going in and there were ideas for new match-ups that would be upcoming. They usually worked to end the show on a positive note. WCW once put on a PPV card, the Great American Bash, in which the match-ups going in looked horrible on paper, were by and large even worse in reality, had the main event changed two weeks before, then confused the fans by turning both participants during the main event and the most over babyface at the show was a heel who had just been fired two weeks earlier. But as bad as that show was and as bad as things looked after the 1991 Great American Bash, WCW still had a larger television viewing audience, a stronger syndicated network, better overall talent and more potential for future interest. The Bash of '91 was worse than the Havoc of '92, but the company is coming out of the Havoc of '92 in its worst condition ever. During the 1991 Bash it was like watching a promotion take many steps down the road to oblivion. The second half of Havoc was the visual example of watching the fat lady sing for the promotion. People will be pointing fingers at each other all week trying to put the blame on someone else for how this turned out. But one thing is clear. Based on every imaginable criteria to judge, Bill Watts' reign thus far has been a failure. It's not just a bad PPV show. It's hardly just losing some name talent with more losses to come. It's not the morale problem. It's the lack of direction. The change in philosophy has gone from going from no philosophy to even less concept of no philosophy. Nothing is being built for the future. No ideas are being built for a concept for the future. It's just scatterbrained 1970s ideas and concepts thrown out so fast that even if they weren't outdated, which some are, they still are being grounded out in a manner which they couldn't work. Turns are decided upon, started, then dropped in the middle. So are storylines. Characters are dropped, then brought back as if they weren't dropped, and buried once again. Title belts are given to wrestlers who have already made it clear they are leaving the promotion for God only knows what reason, and then they leave the promotion. The turns that do happen, come out of nowhere with no storyline and angles that make no sense. A man is made world champion simply because of his skin color because of a mistaken antiquated notion about how that will draw black fans to pro wrestling matches, which is now beginning to set off a new low is race-baiting angles. Every criticism of Titan Sports and every way that WCW was supposed to set a new direction and a new course for this business has been exposed as a fraud. Every statement on steroids has been exposed as nothing but hot air, which was only made worse when Jim Ross spoke of "the other guys" having the posers. While Watts proclaimed that WCW was going back to wrestling, "the real deal" and needing to bring credibility back to the product, on his first PPV show that he was willing to take full responsibility for (previous shows he was willing to blame his predecessors because wheels for those shows were in motion before he got there, even though in the case of the Bash, he was in charge from start-to-finish for all the television build-up of the show) we heard announcers talking about anti-venom, a snake chewing on a man's cheek, a string of ref bump finishes, a major no-show, the most blatant example of bait-and-switch advertising in recent PPV history, and finishing off with the destruction of the credibility of the every major singles title in the promotion.

The show live at the Philadelphia Civic Center drew an estimated 7,000 fans. Best guess would be close to 5,000 of that paid and around an $80,000 house or almost exactly the same figures the WWF drew at the Spectrum the previous weekend. The gate was probably the largest of the year for WCW (War Games in Jacksonville was the biggest house thus far in 1992 at $72,000). The live reports were that the show was even worse live than on PPV (at least on PPV, even though Jesse Ventura's match analysis was non-existent, he was funny as hell which made things entertaining amidst the three hours of slow death), I'd guess they did wonders long-term for themselves in the Philadelphia market. The crowd was up for the opening PPV match, but very little else afterward.

A. In the dark match, Erik Watts & Van Hammer beat Vinnie Vegas & Diamond Dallas Page in 12:00 when Watts pinned Page with an Oklahoma side roll. -*

1. Tom Zenk & Shane Douglas & Johnny Gunn (Tom Brandi) beat Arn Anderson & Bobby Eaton & Michael Hayes in 11:02 when Gunn pinned Hayes with a Thesz press. This match had a good amount of heat, although the crowd was heavily cheering the heels. Many people mistakenly labeled the fans as "heel fans," but that's a misnomer because they didn't cheer the heel in any other match. Match varied from solid to kind of sloppy, depending on if Gunn or Hayes were in or not. Eaton did a great clip spot on Douglas to start some quick heat, and a kneedrop to Douglas' legit injured ankle (he hurt it six days earlier at a TV taping) along with a figure four. Well-paced opener and really the four guys who could work dominated the time, but there was nothing spectacular or out of the ordinary about the match. Gunn made the hot tag and they did a six-way before hitting the finish. Crowd booed the finish heavily. **1/2

2. Rick Steamboat pinned Brian Pillman in 10:35 after a double reversal coming off a hot-looking sunset flip off the top rope by Steamboat. The action was very good, but it seemed they were just getting into it when they went to the finish. These guys could have used a little more time to do the PPV quality match that this looked to be on paper. Still, at this point, the show was pretty good. ***1/4 Then came Bill Watts as the bearer of good news. After Missy Hyatt did her shtick of trying to find out who the referee the heels would pick for the Rude-Chono match with the segment ending with the idea put across that it would be a secret until match time, and the totally undramatic "Team Japan" picked Kensuke Sasaki to be the ref, Bill Watts came out for his "get himself over to the marks interview" to announce Terry Gordy was suspended for a contract violation and would be out of the tag title match (Gordy actually quit the promotion that morning) and replaced by Steve Austin, and that "we just found out" it'll be Harley Race (as if the viewers were just told, which they did hint as Race walked by Missy as she was doing her shtick into Rude's dressing room) and Sasaki as the referees. Watts also said that there had been a court injunction and Rude wouldn't wrestle twice, but they are allowing Big Van Vader to wrestle Nikita Koloff and defend Rude's U.S. title for him. This was handled poorly because the storyline made no sense, and if in the storyline they were going to use this excuse, the heels should have at least the last two weekends before the show hinted of going to court to block it. It's like they wanted to advertise Rude working twice, wanted to have Vader destroy Koloff to make fans forget about him and to set up Vader and Rude feuding over the U.S. belt, but didn't have a clue as to how to logically get there so came up with an idea off the top of someone's head which must have required 20 seconds of thought.

3. Ironically, Vader's destruction of Koloff was probably a better match than Rude would have had with Koloff, but it destroys title credibility when a champion can pick someone to defend the title for him. Vader, who gained about 25 pounds (to around 400) because of being idled by knee surgery, won with a power bomb in 11:53. **3/4

4. Windham & Rhodes retained the NWA/WCW tag titles going to a 30:00 draw with the two Steve Williams', Dr. "Yogi Berra of wrestling" Death and Stunning Mr. Austin. It actually lasted 30:31. Jesse Ventura was really funny on commentary. The work was good but there was no crowd heat which made the match seem worse than it really was. Austin is technically and athletically very good but his weakness when it comes to charisma was apparent in such a long match. The match seemed to have no storyline, it was just a series of solid maneuvers going back-and-forth with no crowd reaction. The storyline going in of Windham and Rhodes having problems seemingly was dropped cold, although the announcers did acknowledge it. The fans not being educated to submissions makes it hard to do a technical wrestling match and go this long and have it get over. In addition, since Williams & Austin aren't a team, it was kind of pre-ordained that there wouldn't be a title change, which also made things drag in such a long match. Rhodes bled from a cut that was re-opened from an accident that took place earlier in the week. At about 28:00, they did a false finish with a ref bump by Randy Anderson. First Windham had Austin pinned, then Williams lariated Windham and Austin was pinning him and ref Nick Patrick counted to three and the bell rang. Anderson overruled Patrick and re-started the match and Rhodes schoolboyed Austin for Anderson counted two, but the bell rang anyway. They then brawled for a hot 90 seconds or so of near falls before time ran out. ***

Next was the Paul E. Dangerously/Madusa skit. Actually it started out with Harley Race and Van Vader doing an interview. Dangerously came out and thanked them for defending the title for Rude and said he'd give them half the payoff which, if they let him go on any longer, would have turned Race & Vader face because shouldn't they get the entire payoff. Well, Madusa came out and after a too brief build-up, was fired by Dangerously, basically called a bitch and a hooker, and Paul E. continued with the most heavy-handed put-downs on women imaginable. Madusa, who by this time was close to being the most over babyface in the building, kicked Paul in the head. Paul claimed his word was his contract and he could beat her with one hand tied behind his back (smells like an 11/18 match at the Clash because I don't want to put money on the odds of Dangerously lasting through Starrcade at this rate). They did a pull-apart brawl with Dangerously going nuts on the mic. Even though the previous match was technically good, it did put the crowd to sleep. This woke everyone up and could have been the turning point of the entire show as it drew tremendous heat. However, the turning point followed immediately.

5. Rude beat Chono via DQ in 22:33 so Chono retains the NWA title. The match that destroyed the show. The match that destroyed the NWA title in the United States. The only thing positive to say is that it's a good thing this wasn't televised in Japan. I wonder if this was the first time in wrestling history where two wrestlers, in their first meeting ever, had a potential match of the year, and then in their first rematch, had a potential worst match of the year? Before the match, Gary Capetta introduced Seiji Sakaguchi as NWA President, Hiro Matsuda and Manobu Nakanishi as a member of the Japanese Olympic team from Barcelona. Ross at this point commented about how glad he was he didn't have to pronounce those names. Can you imagine that comment from another perspective? Let's say Bruce Baumgardner went to the next card at Sumo Hall, and the New Japan announcer and didn't even talk about who the guy is and blew it off with a remark like "Boy I'm sure glad I don't have to pronounce those American names." There was no reaction at all to the two referees, an angle that had been built up on television. Madusa, fired minutes earlier, came out with Rude anyway. After a coin flip, Race was chosen to referee in the ring, Sasaki outside the ring. So this was the most screwed up match imaginable. The supposed top heel in the United States comes to ringside with a just-turned babyface who had just been fired minutes earlier but is still there anyway after being fired, with no plausible explanation. Ross and Ventura did address the subject, but there was no answer that made sense and their attempt, saying that Rude had apparently chosen Madusa over Paul E., only served to make Rude theoretically a babyface, although in reality it made him another wrestler that nobody seemed to care about. To make matters stranger, the heel ref, Race, was officiating right down the line. At least that was good, because a full-fledged heel ref performance would have made this match even worse. Well, Rude wasn't a babyface here. Neither was Chono. The only babyface was Ric Flair, since the first 5:00 consisted of "We Want Flair" and "Whooo" chants that the announcers couldn't acknowledge. Chono was clearly way off because of his pinched nerve in his neck. Rude seemed disgusted. I'd guess part of it was because it became apparent he was over nowhere near the level that he probably thought he was, since nobody cared about anything that involved the match and instead used his match as a way to chant for a guy who left the promotion 16 months earlier. To make matters worse, Ross and Ventura blew the announcing here because they never explained and exclaimed when Chono put on his various submission holds, so it seemed like it was all dead time. And to make it even worse, early in the match when Chono put on a submission, Ventura made the comment about how Rude would never submit, and Ross, who I guess didn't want to disagree, agreed with him, which basically told the viewers that all the submissions were a waste of time because a guy like Rude would never submit. Once it's established that the "big stars" are never going to submit, you've killed the entire concept of submission holds, which is exactly what happened in this country about ten years ago which created the illusion that everything but high spots can be labeled as restholds and makes it much harder to work an effective and realistic match. Thus only gimmicks and high spots get over, neither of which are realistic, and then they complain because the heels don't have heat, and it's because the style doesn't allow anyone to take the product seriously. The crowd didn't understand the holds live, but the holds had never been put over previously on television, where fans are educated to the nuances, so why should they have? I guess wrestling fans are supposed to have ESP, since Rude and Chono knew what they were doing, everyone else should have figured it out without being told as well. This made the match seem even more like it was going nowhere. At 19:00, when they should have been building for a finish, a fight broke out which diverted everyone's attention from a supposed world title match. Both guys by this point must have figured it was hopeless, because as they worked to the finish, they were missing spots. Chono kicked Race in the face when Rude ducked. Race went out of the ring and Sasaki tried to help him up. Chono then threw Rude over the top rope and Rude landed on both Sasaki and Race knocking them both down. Rude got back in, hit the Rude Awakening, but there was no ref to count. Chono made a comeback, caught Rude in the STF, and Sasaki jumped in the ring and called for the bell to apparently signal Chono the winner via submission, although neither announcer acknowledged the word submission even existed in our language. Race overruled Sasaki and declared Rude the winner via DQ. Boy, that was a novel finish that nobody had ever seen before. Race than tried to attack Sasaki and Sasaki did a few slams on Race, who still took those picture perfect bumps, then dropkicked Rude out of the ring. Truly a disaster in every way. One of the worst world title matches ever on PPV. -***

6. Ron Simmons pinned Barbarian in 12:41 with a powerslam to keep the WCW title. Simmons came out with an entourage of about two dozen people which only made him seem like a heel. There may be good reason behind pushing Simmons as one of the top babyfaces, but it's painfully obvious he's no world champion. Barbarian is even less of a #1 contender and only caused to expose what Simmons wasn't. The match and lack of crowd reaction for a world title match brought this point home. Simmons was working injured. Barbarian did a long cobra hold, and Jesse Ventura showed he didn't watch Atlanta wrestling on cable while living in Minnesota by not knowing the Mongolian Stomper and Mark Lewin's dreaded "Shinninomaki," which, incidentally, is actually named after a Tokyo train station." Anyway, Ross noted that this move causes unconsciousness. What he forget to say, is it only causes unconsciousness among the live audience, not to the wrestler in the hold. Work was sloppy and crowd was dead. There was a good near fall when Simmons kicked out of the diving head-butt. One of the worst world title matches ever on PPV tm. 1/4*

Next up was an interview with Bruno Sammartino, Erik Watts and Ron Simmons, with the idea that Watts would "get the rub" from standing alongside the wrestling legend and the current world champion. This got a lot of heat with a lot of people. This Erik Watts push is out of control.

7. Sting pinned Jake Roberts in 10:34 of a Coal Miners Glove match in the spin the wheel deal. Jake is a tremendous personality. One of the best in the business. But he's suffered to many injuries to be able to work on top as a singles wrestler in a group where fans expect action. Jake has also killed Sting to the point he's risking being almost dead. I understand the number of fan letters Sting has gotten over the past two months has suddenly plummeted, and he got a very much un-Stinglike lack of a pop coming out. Sting worked on Roberts' left arm most of the way. After a missed Stinger splash, Roberts hit the DDT. Sting got up before Jake could climb the pole and got elbowed. Second time he got up he did a swing around the pole and climbed up to get the glove. At the same time, Cactus Jack ran out with the snake bag. Jake held the snake and Sting came down with the glove and Sting hit Roberts with the glove and Roberts pulled the snake to make it look like it was biting his cheek and was pinned. Pin got no pop at all because Roberts distracted everyone from it with the snake. Unfortunately, the snake actually did gnaw on Roberts cheek and he bled, which wasn't supposed to happen. I thought they were turning Roberts face, but that wasn't the idea. Roberts ran to the dressing room with a snake being held to his cheek while we heard all about the anti-venom backstage. The finish made a bad main event even worse. 1/4*

This note in particular cracked me up.

quote:

A fan at ringside was wearing a WBF tank top when the show started, but the shirt mysteriously turned into a WCW crew shirt. Good to see paranoia about clothing being worn by fans isn't limited to those at Titan Sports.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

Pneub posted:

So you... thought Stunning Steve was charismatic?

In promos and skits, and certain matches I would say he was. But definitely not all the time, and Pillman definitely brought more of the charisma when they teamed.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
I really don't blame Sullivan that much for his run in 2000. It was really bad, but when 4 of your best workers leave and several other wrestlers sit on the side lines (including Sting) you are going to have some awful TV.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

LividLiquid posted:

The only time I ever stopped watching WCW was during Sullivan's reign. I sat through so much loving horrible bullshit, then one day I saw The Dog (Al Greene on a leash, literally acting like he thought he was a dog) taken seriously in a match. I stopped watching until about a month before Russo came back. Sullivan's loving terrible.

The reign you're thinking of, however, belongs to Nash. 1999 from February to September.

I remember Ric Flair and Terry Funk having a really good feud during that period and a really good match at Superbrawl. I don't remember a single feud that good booked by Russo. On top of that he booked Hogan like he should have been booked. In semi finals against old guys or in Nitro main event tags teaming with young guys like Vampiro to try and elevate them.

It was one of the few times where I thought "You know, Hogan is being booked pretty well."

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

Super Ninja Fish posted:

The reason there was a US title tournament for Storm to win is because of Russo coming back and stripping all the titles. Russo most likely gave Storm that push. What Russo giveth, Russo can taketh away.

No, that was a different US title tournament. Storm signed about 2 months after that tournament.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

Super Ninja Fish posted:

There were two US title tournaments back to back? I didn't remember that.

Upon looking, Storm won the title one week after Bash at the Beach 2000. Hogan and Bischoff left but Russo had to be still in charge at the time.

Russo took a 3 week vacation between Bash at the Beach and New Blood Rising is I remember correctly, during that period Johnny Ace and Terry Taylor had the book.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

Lone Rogue posted:

I'll give you Sting and Luger. Hennig too, he was there for a very short time. Nash, Macho and Konnan made sense. Oddly, so did Disco.

Michaels in DX was 32.

The Wolfpac had the following members:

Randy Savage: 46
Kevin Nash: 39
Konnan: 34
Hennig: 40
Elizabeth: 38
Luger: 40
Sting: 39

Of those, Konnan was the only one who looked like he lived the gimmick, Kevin Nash was kind of "cool" and the rest were middle aged guys (and girl) who made NO SENSE in what was a part of a two year old gimmick.

So I can see why fans saw DX as young and hip and the Wolfpac was mocked for being geezers.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

Dragging Iron Feet posted:

Apparently cost em $150,000 as well, and they didn't advertise it. Say what you want about TNA, but they haven't done anything that stupid...yet.

In the very least it was built up on TV. Not very well, but it was built to.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
Awesome quote from the new back issue of the Observer:

Dave Meltzer on or around 12/14/92 posted:

Greg Gagne was introduced to the guys backstage at the Center Stage tapings on 12/7. He's expected to become a new member of the creative team. Rumors there will be another key addition. If you ask what Greg's qualifications are considering that even though the AWA was a very successful promotion at one time, it's television and overall product was always years behind the rest of the country and it only thrived when it was a monopoly promotion in a town and collapsed under competition many years ago in all its markets. However, Greg was a third-string quarterback when he played college football and the son of a famous wrestler. That should make him qualified for any job in this business.

A few paragraphs later:

quote:

Ron Simmons' new music sucks.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

LividLiquid posted:

If you think anything on those PPVs holds a candle to the worst of New Blood Rising, you're drunk.

I think King of the Ring 99 and Fall Brawl 98 come very close or maybe fall below NBR's depths. NBR at least ends with a decent match and begins with a spot fest even if it was stupidly overbooked. I'm not sure if those shows insult the fan's intelligence the way NBR does though. But Fall Brawl does pretty much kill WCW's best gimmick match dead which is saying something.

Honestly, I think Fall Brawl 98 would be perfect for the March Sunday Nitro.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

CombineThresher posted:

Raven was in that stable too, so they probably both had major contact highs from just being around him at that point.

Raven was long gone from WCW at this point. The stable you are thinking of is the short lived "Dead Pool."

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
The biggest problem with making WCW a brand was the timeslot of 11 PM on Saturdays was going to be really limiting. So even if it did happen, no WWF draw was going to want to be in WCW because it would really hurt their pay, their money from live gates and PPV would go way down even if WCW was doing some house shows and PPVs early on. So if you were a WWF guy you had every reason to be against it because you might end up there!

With the Invasion itself, yeah it could have gone better. Vince probably should have seen what other people saw and bitten the bullet signing expensive talent early. One of the most striking things about the March 2001 Observer Lives is the prediction that guys like Nash, Hogan, Flair, Goldberg etc would sit out about a year and then when Vince needed something new to spike ratings and buyrates they would be WAY more valuable then than they were at the moment, and would have been getting their sweet WCW money in the mean time.

Signing Nash and Hogan would have been meaningless in the Invasion compared to bringing them in later for shorter term roles, but Flair as the WCW mouth piece and Goldberg as the center piece would have been pretty big.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!
Sting has been in talks with WWE since WCW died, but his demands are never something they want to meet. I think they were close when Goldberg was in, and they didn't want to add ANOTHER part timer to the roster.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

MyStereoHasMono posted:

Is Sting still capable of a good match? I know back in 99/2000 Sting was still capable of putting on classics (especially his April 1999 match with DDP), but that was ten years ago now. Ive seen what he looks like now and its not very pretty.

He's capable, but like he was late in WCW he is rarely motivated and generally just coasts with exceptions where he's facing someone especially motivated or great. He's past 50 now, so he's limited.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

maniacripper posted:

You guys should watch the Guest Booker with Jim Cornette, he makes some really good choices and reasons for them, plus Cornette is awesome and sounds awesome all the time.

But, what we really need to ask ourselves is how things would have gone down if the WCW had purchased the WWF.

AAA would be the biggest wrestling company in North America.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

Wazzu posted:

Jim Cornette is a great guy, but we all need to keep in mind that he's a relic of the carny days, with a southern mentality, and when he ran a company (SMW) it failed because he was stuck in the past.

He was one of the bookers during the WWF's rise during the Attitude era, and the product got a lot more Russoriffic after he left creative. So he's not just this old school relic, he was a big part of the Attitude Era.

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

Dragging Iron Feet posted:

I never actually saw OVW when it existed but I did hear that the show was a lot better when Heyman took over.

I don't think I've heard more than one or two people say this. Except for the people who really liked the reeeeeeeaaaaaaalllly long Punk vs Albright matches.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

MassRafTer
May 26, 2001

BAEST MODE!!!

LividLiquid posted:

His role in TNA pre-Russo produced some really good stuff.

His first week on the job his character lost all credibility because of the stupidly way he was booked with the Jarrett title win and his reactions. It was utterly retarded. "Durr you aren't going to get away with this Jeff! Ok, I guess you will, but you know what? I'm gonna give you a month off from defending and have four guys compete for a title shot on the next PPV!"

Ok enough non WCW talk!

Here's a fun WCW moment, Arli$$ appears on Nitro. This is seriously one of the weirdest WCW segments. He's introduced as the actor who portrays Arliss a character who is a sports agent. But, after that they act like he really is a sports agent.

As a bonus you get a Randy Savage promo and his valets, one of whom you may recognize!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Y6_WNB64s0
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VDcwnqD_148

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply