Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
My ASUS 670 DC2 TOP that just arrived is incredibly unstable, the drivers will crash after a few minutes in Skyrim and even with a hefty underclock it crashed to dekstop after about half an hour. And it seems there's quite a few others popping up on Nvidia's forums.

I wouldn't recommend these anyone to anyone at this point, I'm thinking of exchanging it for the regular DC2.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
No, the driver crashes, forcing both screens to black (both connected via DVI, but it also happened when I unplugged one) for 2-3 seconds, once it recovers the performance is about 20% of what it was previously but the GPU is running at 100% until you tab out and back in (which does not help in full screen windowed mode).

At first I was running Process Explorer to monitor VRAM, I then installed AfterBurner to get temps. I rolled the driver back to 301.34 and ran without any monitoring. It continues to happen, almost like clockwork.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

Socialism posted:

Got the exact same error with my 670 DC2Top. Mine crashes after a couple rounds of Heaven 3.0 - GPU-Z shows max core clock of 1280MHz, temp of 79c and voltage of 1.175.

It doesn't seem to be an isolated problem (http://forums.nvidia.com/index.php?showtopic=230198 as well as several other threads indicating the same problem, changing to PCI Express 2.0 does not solve this for me). Google says it's unstable OC, which if true would be a shame given that we're paying extra for supposedly binned/stable OC.

I'd like to wait a bit and see if it's a driver/setting related issue. I don't really mind having to tone down the clock/voltage a bit, since its acoustic performance has completely exceeded expectations.

edit: shockingly - I'm not sure if this was actually a fix or a fluke - the card correctly downclocks when running my two monitors of different resolutions (Apple Cinema Display using displayport + a 1080p monitor using HDMI). Fingers crossed...

update: welp I reinstalled the latest nvidia drivers, restarted, and ran Heaven with Normal tessellation and 4x AA (instead of default no Tess/0x AA) and it was fine for 15min+. PC Gaming :suicide:

update #2: Asus GPU Tweak causes a Red Screen of Death(? it's mentioned above), confirmed problem on Asus forums. Don't install this POS on god

I'm going to underclock to the regular 670 stock speeds and try some games that are more stable than modded Skyrim and see how it does when I get home. I will probably RMA it regardless because I paid for that overclock like you said. The cooler is pretty awesome, that was why I considering trading down to the regular DC2

VV It is too early to say, I wouldn't judge it just yet. Given how rare they are still it was discouraging to see several posts on this exact model on Nvidia's forums.

Hamburger Test fucked around with this message at 10:58 on May 30, 2012

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

Hamburger Test posted:

I'm going to underclock to the regular 670 stock speeds and try some games that are more stable than modded Skyrim and see how it does when I get home. I will probably RMA it regardless because I paid for that overclock like you said. The cooler is pretty awesome, that was why I considering trading down to the regular DC2

VV It is too early to say, I wouldn't judge it just yet. Given how rare they are still it was discouraging to see several posts on this exact model on Nvidia's forums.

I went a different route instead. I downloaded the Heaven benchmark (haven't touched one of these since I was 15), and found that my card benchmarks reliably at -20MHz. Which allows it to reach 1202 with GPU Boost or something? It is still a pretty solid overclock compared to stock, but I can't say I'm happy with it. At -15MHz it didn't last half way through the benchmark and a few textures started glitching at stage 2. Since I did -15 before -20 I don't think it was heat buildup, the GPU temperature never passed 76C anyway.

I found a screenshot of someone having success bumping the voltage up, but I have no idea whether that is something I dare touch; especially since I am still considering the RMA.

Also here is something I don't quite get. Afterburner claims the memory reaches 3005 MHz at the most, but the specs for the 670 says it is supposed to use 6.008 GHz VRam. What is going on here?

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
Update on my 670 TOP. I decided to return it for a full refund, since the RMA process apparently takes about 3-4 weeks on average. I just hope they don't try to restock it before letting ASUS test it. I did tell the rep about the issue up front, so I don't have any qualms about it.

New card arrived and it benches at +40 MHz, and has an equally higher boost as well. So it's actually stable (so far) at 1306 MHz though I'm not sure I'll want to keep it that high, it's certainly no longer quiet at that speed.

Judging from posts in this thread: http://www.overclock.net/t/1259425/asus-670-directcu-ii-top/540 ASUS seems to have been a little too optimistic with their selection of chips to go into this model. Most are good, but more than a few are unstable at "stock".

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

KKKLIP ART posted:

So from reading this thread, people seem to be having problem with the Asus TOP GTX670 cards, is there anything I should know to look out for or not do? It should be here tuesday or wednesday.

If it is bad the driver crashes giving you a black screen for a few seconds until windows recovers, how that manifests in games depends on the game. Diablo 3 handles it gracefully and lets you continue after a few seconds - but your frame rate will tank, BF3 does not and becomes unresponsive.

Hamburger Test fucked around with this message at 07:56 on Jun 2, 2012

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

HalloKitty posted:

Don't know where 10% is coming from, all the reviews I saw show the 670 beating the 680 by a very small amount (1-3% or so) on every test

I think he means at the actual 670 stock speeds, not the factory overclocked "stock" speeds.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

Factory Factory posted:

Asus's DCII 670 is quieter under load than a 690 is at idle.

I love the DCII 670 now that I have one that doesn't crash the drivers. It is worth noting that (the TOP version at least) will probably pass 70C and downclock itself unless you change the fan profile. In my case I can keep it below 70C and still not be able to hear it over my case fans.

I think they exhaust most of the air inside the cabinet, so if you actually decide to SLI two of them you might want to make sure you have the airflow sorted.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
I read about it in the thread I linked earlier on overclock.net, at first I thought it was FUD; but I observed the core clock dropping a bit in MSI Afterburner when the temperature passed 70C. I can't remember if it was overclocked at the time or not, but if it was it would have been Afterburner.

E:
Actually, I'll test it out with no fan profile in GPU-Z when I get home. Should be pretty easy to see.

E2:
Easy to see, a little harder to screenshot. Only 13.1 MHz, but it happens at 70.0C in both Skyrim and Diablo 3.


No other GPU tools loaded, this is just a plain factory overclock.

Hamburger Test fucked around with this message at 17:31 on Jun 4, 2012

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

Alereon posted:

hooking up a $650 videocard to a power supply that costs 5% of that?

13.8% on sale.

SeaSonic is a drat good brand, altho spending a little more for a gold rated one would be reasonable if you can drop $650 on the videocard..

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

lovely Treat posted:

High res texture pack at that resolution will be filling up that 1.5GB.
People were filling 2GB at 1920x1080 with texture packs.

I'm running the official High Res texture pack, as well as a few other visual mods at 2560x1440. My VRAM usage rarely goes over 1.5GB, it's usually in the 1.4 area though which would be a problem for this guy. But 2GB at 1920x1080 sounds like hyperbole, or people who install 4K grass textures.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

Badmana posted:

What program are you using to determine vram use?

I'm only using the HD pack, some nude mods, and all the unofficial official patches.

I run ultra settings 2560x1600 with no AA/AF and it runs 60 FPS solid and averages ~80% GPU usage. I can add a little AA/AF but it tends to hiccup outdoors and I can't really notice the extra graphics anyways.

MSI Afterburner. And yea, it sounds like you'd be right near the cap without AA. You should be able to crank up AF I believe. There's also a mod that reduces some of the textures in the HD pack without giving up a lot of the visuals, since some of the textures in that pack are also larger than they need to be.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

The Lord Bude posted:

I think there is still a use case for a 780, or a pair of 760s, at the extreme end of 1080p performance. Now if someone said they wanted 3 780s in tri SLi, then I'd try to talk them down, because that literally wouldn't be providing them any benefit at all.
This seems eerily fitting:
http://blogs.windows.com/windows/b/...per-second.aspx

3x4k posted:

With all settings on “High” except shadow detail and particles, we were able to maintain 62-67fps average, peaking over 70fps. We were both able to experience this awesome gaming setup for several minutes each before the PSU would reset due to power overload. Perhaps we didn’t have 50 watts to spare. We reached our goal and were able to see into the future of multi-mon gaming. Now that’s a great day at work!

Here are some statistics for this demo:

GPU cores: 3 x 2,048 = 6,144 total cores
Rendered pixels per second = 11,520 x 2,160 x 60 Hz = 1,492,992,000

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

Digital Jesus posted:

I'll mess around with it tomorrow. My Swiftech pump seems to be on its way out (only 6 weeks old, drat it) so the noise from that is making it harder to really tell (and driving me loving crazy).

This was a while ago with the current pace of this thread. Your pump probably has an air bubble in it, if you email Swiftech about it they will give you instructions on how to possibly remove it. Personally I have just put the case on it's side until I can be arsed with the procedure, and actually have some distilled water on hand to top up the reservoir.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

Agreed posted:

Word of warning, don't buy the 780, they're going to knock like $170 off the price and you're going to feel dumb as heck.

Is this a serious prediction? Because I'm sitting here hoping for nVidia's response to the 290, since I would prefer to stick with them for now. If it doesn't come though, I can wait for the custom cooled 290's.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
My French is so rusty it may as well not exist, so going with the Google translate it sounds like they attribute PNY's low return rate to their sales mostly being in the lower end which generally have a lower failure rate?

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
Anecdotal evidence for the AMD / nVidia software bonfire:
https://forums.geforce.com/default/topic/573811/nvidia-streamer-service-may-be-freezing-your-pc/

That started happening to me last week. On top of that GeForce Experience itself often took up most of a core when nothing else was going on, removed that piece of poo poo for now.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

Agreed posted:

No, just a long, storied history of "NO, YOUR BRAND loving SUCKS!" back and forth.

It came up a couple of days ago again that nVidia's drivers were more stable, and then the counter. This is just another piece of evidence that both companies release lovely software; it's pretty even in my experience when adding it all up. I think ShadowPlay is neat, but it's not worth dealing with GeForce Experience.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

spasticColon posted:

When you say reference do you mean it has the crappy reference cooler on it but the GPU temp only peaks at 58 C while under load? :stare:

As a dedicated PhysX card, which shouldn't tax a 670 too much.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
I think AMD still have issues with new games more often, if you don't play a lot of games at launch you'll probably not run into more issues with one's drivers over the other's.

Personally I value performance/noise higher than performance/price and if the lower power draw on the new nVidias holds true, then that's probably enough for me to pick nVidia again. I also tend to keep my cards a bit longer than most in this thread, and with a high tax on electricity I might make the difference back.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

Stanley Pain posted:

Flip AMD/NVIDIA at will and you have the truth ;) It gets even worse if you're running Crossfire/SLI.

Anecdotal of course, but I remember more high profile releases that had problems on AMD than nVidia. Without going into the slap fights that arose over them or the quality of the games themselves, RAGE and Watch Dogs come to mind with nVidia coming out ahead, and I can't come up with anything clearly favoring AMD.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

FSMC posted:

It's really strange. I have no reason to upgrade from my 660ti. All I want to 4k 120khz(for 3d), but that way to much for any graphics card in the near future. So there is like a dual reason for me not to upgrade, my current graphics card is powerful enough for any games and any new graphics cards aren't powerful enough for what I really want.

That's ridiculous.

There are significant upgrades in between these two scenarios, and your dream scenario is not possible currently for reasons other than GPU power.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
I was almost sure I was going to grab a 980, since I was almost committed to getting one of the 34" 21:9 screens. But with the price on that 970 I'm now contemplating "settling" with one of those and staying with my K-IPS while I hope Displayport 1.2a with Adaptive sync becomes standard before I cave in to upgrade urges.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
Just found a MSI GeForce GTX 980 Gaming about 1300-1600 DKK or 200-300$ below other offerings. There goes my willpower. Fingers crossed they don't catch it before it's confirmed.

webhallen.dk

Note, still more expensive than 970 around these parts, but not by much.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
The original site is Swedish, and on that section the price is at the level of other custom 980s.

I haven't gotten an actual order confirmation yet which I think is when it becomes legally binding. Shops here usually send a "bestilling" confirmation before the the "ordre" confirmation. Both words translate to "order"...

There are some intricacies about "offer" and "invitation to make an offer" in consumer law, but I'm probably not going to fight too hard for it if it falls through.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
drat. The vendor caught their pricing error, so I won't be getting the MSI 980 at 40% off. Ordered the MSI 970 at a different shop, saved ~40$ and won't have to wait 3 weeks for stock. This is going to be so awesome 670 to 970 at 1440 - and will finally be rid of that loving coil whine that has been building up over the last 8-9 months.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
On the other end of the scale:
http://www.guru3d.com/articles_pages/msi_geforce_gtx_970_gaming_review,7.html

quote:

GeForce GTX 970 or 980 - On your average system the card requires you to have a 500 Watt power supply unit.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

Icept posted:

They cancelled my order as well :D

Where did you end up ordering from, Komplett?

Yea, Komplett and ProShop were the same price but Komplett actually have stock.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

HalloKitty posted:

Lower cost, lower power consumption, often higher benchmarks than even a 290X.

It's basically crapping on the 290 from all angles, with the minor exception of one: memory bandwidth. If you're gunning for very high resolutions, this can help.

Even at 2560*1440 the 970 comes out ahead most of the time. It doesn't seem like the memory bandwidth is as limiting for this chip as it has been previously.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

Agreed posted:

Can someone with one of these and the ability to capture framerate do just that with something like one of the Metro games' benchmarks with PhysX off and PhysX on? I'm hoping that the scheduling and execution efficiency improvements will do the necessary heavy lifting to make it so that juggling workloads isn't so finicky, but then I think about how I don't think their memory compression for textures is going to do all that much to help with the conventional memory bottleneck for CUDA calculations.

But I don't know and I'm not buying one just to find out, the 780Ti is playing Divinity: OS, Wasteland 2, and Defense Grid 2 just fine thank you, haha. Jeez, what a waste. Make fun of me if I buy a GTX 980 at all before I put the box of parts that wishes to be my next system together, please? But in the meantime let's see what we can find with regard to PhysX and minimum and maximum FPS this generation, from some less demanding titles (old batman) to more demanding titles (new batman, Metros, if you really want to gently caress it up Alice Returns with that damned pepper shaker)... There's time to mock unnecessary purchases, we'll cross that bridge if/when we come to it :shepface:

Edit: AMD users of course feel free to respond but unfortunately I don't think that'll tell us what we're looking for here since the per-thread is kind balls and that can cause minimum framerate dips just as easily when the right combo of wrong stuff happens. Hopefully this is significantly enough an Intel-favoring forum thanks to the value offered that we can see some more "definite" data points?
Will this do?

MSI Gaming 970 at "stock", i5 4670 at 4.2GHz, MetroLLbenchmark
code:
Options: Resolution: 2560 x 1440; DirectX: DirectX 11; Quality: Very High; Texture filtering: AF 16X; Advanced PhysX: Disabled; Tesselation: Very High; Motion Blur: Normal; SSAA: OFF;
Off:
code:
Run 0 (D6 )
Total Frames: 8720, Total Time: 171.1792 sec
Average Framerate: 50.98
Max. Framerate: 104.19 (Frame: 3158)
Min. Framerate: 10.24 (Frame: 348)

Run 1 (D6 )
Total Frames: 8733, Total Time: 171.2828 sec
Average Framerate: 51.02
Max. Framerate: 82.01 (Frame: 7070)
Min. Framerate: 22.83 (Frame: 5946)

Run 2 (D6 )
Total Frames: 8710, Total Time: 171.2798 sec
Average Framerate: 50.89
Max. Framerate: 83.42 (Frame: 7066)
Min. Framerate: 21.30 (Frame: 6169)

Average Results
Average Framerate: 50.67
Max. Framerate: 104.19
Min. Framerate: 10.24

On:
code:
Run 0 (D6 )
Total Frames: 8076, Total Time: 171.1748 sec
Average Framerate: 47.21
Max. Framerate: 106.30 (Frame: 3076)
Min. Framerate: 10.10 (Frame: 1358)

Run 1 (D6 )
Total Frames: 8070, Total Time: 171.2819 sec
Average Framerate: 47.15
Max. Framerate: 79.99 (Frame: 6654)
Min. Framerate: 22.83 (Frame: 6102)

Run 2 (D6 )
Total Frames: 8007, Total Time: 171.2645 sec
Average Framerate: 46.79
Max. Framerate: 74.84 (Frame: 6634)
Min. Framerate: 20.15 (Frame: 7069)

Average Results
Average Framerate: 47.00
Max. Framerate: 106.30
Min. Framerate: 10.10
The curves are very similar, but with PhysX on there's a significantly higher variance but it still looks playable. imgur doesn't accept .svg and I'm too lazy to find a program to convert them unless you really want to see them.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
PhysX off:
https://mediacru.sh/d4f8849be18f/focus

PhysX on:
https://mediacru.sh/de416781ae56/focus

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

Agreed posted:

No co-processor at all, strictly the 970?

Yea, just the 970 - it is factory overclocked however but I'm guessing that wouldn't factor in much. I haven't actually played any of the Metros even though I have owned them for a while. I totally mean to but I just haven't been in the mood yet. I am looking forward to trying Borderlands:PS with PhysX however.

E: oops, meant to edit the above post.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

1gnoirents posted:

Hey what are you using for the graph? The fraps viewer I used was kind of annoying

Those are actually produced by MetroLLBenchmark. I did just install RivaTunerStatisticsServer with MSI Afterburner to see if it could do the stats for me, but it turned out I didn't need them.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
These shortages are odd to me. I've seen Komplett in Scandinavia list something like 83 MSI 970s in stock once, every other time I have checked they have been at 100+.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
Had a strange issue with MSI's 970. After couple of hours the VRM fan apparently went full tilt, only I don't think you can see the speed of it anywhere so I had to take the side off and inspect every fan to find out which one it was. It continued to spin at full speed even after a reboot and manually changing the speed in Afterburner. Only a complete shutdown managed to stop it. The main GPU fan was idle and all temperature readers from GPU, CPU and motherboard were in the mid 30s.

I hope this isn't going to be a recurring issue.

Hamburger Test fucked around with this message at 00:19 on Sep 25, 2014

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
Looks like Talion from Shadow of Mordor to me.

Hamburger Test posted:

Had a strange issue with MSI's 970. After couple of hours the VRM fan apparently went full tilt, only I don't think you can see the speed of it anywhere so I had to take the side off and inspect every fan to find out which one it was. It continued to spin at full speed even after a reboot and manually changing the speed in Afterburner. Only a complete shutdown managed to stop it. The main GPU fan was idle and all temperature readers from GPU, CPU and motherboard were in the mid 30s.

I hope this isn't going to be a recurring issue.

https://forum-en.msi.com/index.php?topic=183618.0
Looks like I'm not the only one

That's the MSI Gaming branded 970 on the most recent official driver.

Hamburger Test fucked around with this message at 09:27 on Sep 26, 2014

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!
I used to transcode video to a PS3 while playing World of Warcraft on an i5 750 :v:

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

TomWaitsForNoMan posted:

So what are the generally accepted quietest coolers? ASUS Strix and MSI Twin Frozr?

Those two plus the Palit non reference are all very quiet, not quite sure about Gigabyte's.

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

Kornjaca posted:

According to the MSI forum mod:


"Re: MSI GTX 970 fan issue
« Reply #100 on: Yesterday at 19:48:06 »
MSI is aware of this issue. And I hope they will do something about this, otherwise this series or this card will be their failure, at least for the first week/s since release. :undecided:

I can't say anything about this,apart from the fact I feel sorry for you and obviously I'd be frustrated like you being unable to use the card normally. My luck is I never went for just released series of GPU/motherboards."

https://forum-en.msi.com/index.php?topic=183618.100

I like how enthusiastic the moderator is regarding the future of the 9XX series/card is, and especially how he indirectly advises the customers not to buy MSI's newly released products.. on MSI forums. You just don't get pr like this anymore.

So to answer your question, I have no idea which card is better, but I would stay away from MSI for the time being, at least until they fix the fan issue.

Worth noting that the mods are not MSI employees as far as I can tell.

I reported this issue Thursday last week. After rolling back to 344.11 I ran into the issue where the main fan didn't spin even tho it was supposed to be doing 100%, a nudge made it run "normally".

I then reinstalled 344.16 and haven't had any issues since. I haven't tried flashing the BIOS.

And to the temperature discussion. Mine idles in the low 30's at just about the same temps as the motherboard. I really wouldn't worry about having the fans running at idle - unless of course that alleviates the other problems. Should note that I have a 350D with 2 front 140mm fans, but they don't really go aboive 7-800 rpms.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Hamburger Test
Jul 2, 2007

Sure hope this works!

BurritoJustice posted:

Looking around the net all 900 series cards had fan problems with the old drivers. Which is why NVidia pushed out a new driver a couple hours after release. If you just use 344.16 you shouldn't have problems.

Also it amuses me that you consider 50 under idle to be hot considering that the reference models run at 80c, as have graphics cards for years. A card that does 60c under load is very chilly.

I said I rolled back to 344.11, that was because I was having a problem not because I thought that would be an awesome idea.

It could be that I nudged the fan just right, it could be that some specific order of uninstalling and reinstalling fixed it - or I could just haven been lucky these last two days that the problems have not returned yet and that they will as soon as I start playing Shadow of Mordor (after work).

When it works it is a very good cooler, can barely hear it and stays just over 60c in high workloads. Does BF4 in 2560x1440 Ultra (2*AA instead of 4*) at 70+ fps.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply