Register a SA Forums Account here!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us $3,400 per month for bandwidth bills alone, and since we don't believe in shoving popup ads to our registered users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
  • Post
  • Reply
Jul 28, 2007

And I Helped!

I think its about time for Bryan Singer to step aside and hand over the reigns.

X-M:A spends more than half the film with various character building interactions, most of which work and I appreciate, but since we've also got a plot to worry about, we're constantly cutting to watch a travelogue of the villain squad collecting members. Nothing actually happens for 3/4ths of the film and the villains are so poorly defined (with one exception), and frankly poorly chosen (only two of the "horsemen" make any sense at all from a "I want the most powerful" perspective) that you don't really care about the final confrontation all that much, which it turns out is a good thing because it's completely underwhelming.

The bottom line is that Singer flat out cannot direct action worth a drat. His best X-film, X2, rode a great script to glory but here the screenplay is pretty pedestrian and he just doesn't have the talent to elevate the material.

Some seriously dodgy CGI in a lot of places. I know that's an easy thing to toss off in a review but I was actually astounded at how bad the green-screening was at times. It was like looking at a blockbuster from 10+ years ago in spots.

The film is also entirely too long...and yet not long enough. Not enough of the run time is spent giving us a reason to really care about the outcome other than the usual shorthand of "Earth is in danger, don't you like Earth???" that we get from lazy screenwriters so often. But the film commits more than 20 minutes to a side-jaunt for literally the sole purpose of giving us a very brief cameo that we all know is coming. Absolutely nothing else about this waste of screen time matters in the slightest.

The acting is all fine-to-good (with the exception of Jennifer Lawrence, who is sleepwalking through this sucker) and I liked most of the character interaction scenes and some of the humor lands (though not all of it).

It's just a serviceable summer popcorn flick without much to recommend it, honestly. X2 and First Class remain the best of the X-films, but I think it's time for Singer to tap out.

Edit: Forgot to mention John Ottman's score! It's pretty good, with liberal re-use of his X2 theme (as has become standard), but it isn't stellar. Fits the film fine.


ComposerGuy fucked around with this message at Jun 5, 2016 around 04:02


Dec 30, 2004

Hey, you want a toothpick?

I hate to do this, but I should just quote ComposerGuy and call it a day.

Quicksilver can solve literally any problem, but essentially is just used once, just like DoFP.

It's terrible writing all around and boring as hell. Regardless of how you feel about superhero movies, you know they ain't supposed to be boring.


May 5, 2003

You need chaos in your soul to give birth to a dancing star

Lipstick Apathy

ButtWolf posted:

Quicksilver can solve literally any problem, but essentially is just used once, just like DoFP.

Any problem except the getting to Magneto part which would be the second time they "used him" and the third time when he clowned Apocalypse until he got his leg broke. Maaaaaybe not quite as over powered and underutilized as people describe him.

This was a live action version of the 90's cartoon and had everything from Nightcrawler's red jacket to a trip to the shopping mall and a battle against Apocalypse.

I really liked the way the handled Angel and the Weapon X scene was perfect.

If you grew up watching and loving the cartoon it's a fun movie not so much for fans of modern grim dark DCCU or the every movie same movie MCU.

The soundtrack was also period appropriate and well done.

4/5 for fun and nostalgia

Hitlers Gay Secret
Mar 7, 2010

The Third Reich's under new -- and better -- management.

Hasn't word reached Camp Pendleton yet?

College Slice

The line where Jean Grey walks out of Return of the Jedi and says "we can all agree that the third movie always sucks", she's right. Both The Last Stand and Apocalypse can be considered the worst films of their series. Granted this is a lot more tolerable than The Last Stand, but the fact that Brian Singer ripped off a scene from Tails Gets Trolled is enough to show that his time is up. He may have given us the first real superhero movie years ago, but it's clear he doesn't know how to do the genre anymore.


  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply