Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
Infamous Sphere
Nov 8, 2010
Blargh oh my god yes, I have read fanfiction, in a way it's a guilty pleasure/so bad it's good thing. I can't read trashy romance though. Fanfiction..oh god..some of the anatomical limitations are..well..let's just say these women don't very much und
I originally posted this in Ask/Tell but it was suggested that I post it here instead. I apologise ahead of time if it's not right for this subform.

Infamous Sphere posted:

Hello!
I am Infamous Sphere, and I have a review show where I review LGBT movies and tv shows (and period dramas, but less relevant for this section.)
I'm thinking of doing an episode on Dignity and Respect, a comic relating to Don't Ask, Don't Tell. As a consequence, I've been looking up a bit of information relating to DADT policy, seeing as I am a) Australian, and b) don't have anything to do with the military. I've been trying to find information about whether DADT affected reporting of sexual assault. I've found some stuff that supports that, but of course, when googling it, I found an absurd amount of conservative websites suggesting that the repeal of DADT caused an increase in sexual violence, something that....as far as I know is not supported by either common sense or any statistics out there.

Anyway. I figured it would be interesting to get some further background.
Were you in the military when DADT was in effect? How did it affect you/the people you knew? Are you LGBT? Do you serve in the military currently - how has the treatment of LGBT people and the amount of LGBT people in the service changed since DADT was repealed? Are you/were you in another country's military, and if so, how are LGBT people treated there/was there ever a DADT style policy? I've asked one guy who's bi and served once when DADT was in effect and once when it wasn't - he wasn't out either time as far as I know. I think even after DADT was repealed he didn't come out for various reasons.

There's a bit in the comic that suggests that harassment was very strictly punished (so insinuating that someone was gay would get you in trouble.) I have a sneaking suspicion that this kind of bullying wasn't as carefully policed as the comic suggests - and that the military wasn't magically devoid of gay jokes at the very least. Thoughts?

Pre-emptive thanks for any contributions :)

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Woof Blitzer
Dec 29, 2012

[-]
Nobody cared.

Kung Fu Fist Fuck
Aug 9, 2009
everyones gay underway

vains
May 26, 2004

A Big Ten institution offering distance education catering to adult learners
gay chicken is a full contact sport

Flikken
Oct 23, 2009

10,363 snaps and not a playoff win to show for it

Teflon Don posted:

Nobody cared.

Justin Godscock
Oct 12, 2004

Listen here, funnyman!
Joining the military is the gayest thing you can do so I don't understand why politicians in the 90s freaked out over it.

ded
Oct 27, 2005

Kooler than Jesus
I served under DADT when it was new and knew guys that were gay and bi. No one loving cared.

Vasudus
May 30, 2003
yeah nobody cared for the 10 years they were talking about doing it either

whatevs

Booblord Zagats
Oct 30, 2011


Pork Pro

Teflon Don posted:

Nobody cared.

Yeah, my brother said his squadron had a few gay maintainers and ord guys back in late 90s and no one gave a poo poo because they were actually good at their jobs.

And also, gay guys don't marry strippers and bar chicks, so there's way less FRG drama which is always cool

Laranzu
Jan 18, 2002
Circa 2007.

We had a guy in our berthing that went by Gayjay.

He was super gay.

No one cared.

Booblord Zagats
Oct 30, 2011


Pork Pro
Also, gay wingmen were the loving best. When I'd go to San Diego or LA on the weekend, my buddy who was a gay SP would wingman for me and he could screen fatties, drunk friends and uggos like nobody's business. Also how I learned gay bars have way better bartenders. Dudes can make an Old Fashioned like you would not believe

Victor Vermis
Dec 21, 2004


WOKE UP IN THE DESERT AGAIN
We got our DADT repeal brief right after weigh-ins, so everyone was in their itty bitty green shorts and probably feeling more vulnerable than usual. A few guys were livid. Homosexual anal rape was their biggest concern. They were seriously distraught and believed a "tummy tucker" (?? their term) was going to creep into their barracks room while they slept and... suck their dick? Some saw this as a slippery slope: If gays are okay today.. Are animal fuckers and pedophiles going to be okay tomorrow? Others, while visibly uncomfortable, were content to declare that it was a violation of their religious beliefs.

To be fair, half the room didn't give a poo poo. A few laughed and called the others out for being absurd. But this just made them even angrier. The angriest guy in the room also happened to be the fastest-promoted among us. The Marine Corps isn't inherently homophobic, it just values retard strength above all other attributes.

And so The Marine Corps is inherently retarded. And Homophobia is retarded.

You don't need to be able to crank out 20 pull-ups to fend off a faggoty cum burglar.

Victor Vermis
Bravo Range

Victor Vermis fucked around with this message at 02:22 on Jul 25, 2016

Nice and hot piss
Feb 1, 2004

Enlisted back in 04 and we had an openly bi dude when we deployed.

The worst thing that happened was he had a porno mag called "black inches" that he left in the back of one of the humvees he was in.

Godholio
Aug 28, 2002

Does a bear split in the woods near Zheleznogorsk?

MassivelyBuckNegro posted:

gay chicken is a full contact sport

Zeris
Apr 15, 2003

Quality posting direct from my brain to your face holes.
Add these to your list, thanks

Are you mad they still haven't come out with gay-equivalent awards yet

Which bathroom do you use

Was it hard to piss in a portashitter when all the dick drawings gave you raging erections

Were you known as a ringer in gay chicken tournaments

Was it weird loving dudes on deployment and giving no reply when the other guy's like "no homo"

Cut or uncut

EBB
Feb 15, 2005

im gay

iyaayas01
Feb 19, 2010

Perry'd
So just in case you were wondering why that comic was made when the real answer to how DADT impacted the force was

Teflon Don posted:

Nobody cared.

the answer is, because DoD is retarded and insists on providing "training" for every little thing under the sun that is clunky and poorly executed. Also because it gives them something to point to whenever Congress asks them why aren't they doing more about "x" (the latest example of this would be all of DoD's response to sexual assault)

UP THE BUM NO BABY
Sep 1, 2011

by Hand Knit

Zeris posted:

Was it hard to piss in a portashitter when all the dick drawings gave you raging erections

Mike-o
Dec 25, 2004

Now I'm in your room
And I'm in your bed


Grimey Drawer
Gay dude in my last unit. Infantry unit. Openly gay, no one cares, not even command because they could have kicked him out before DADT was repealed but didn't. There's my anecdote welp cya later.

Mad Dragon
Feb 29, 2004

There was a guy on the boat who said he was gay to get out of going on a deployment. He probably wasn't, but he didn't go on that deployment. :shrug:

PookBear
Nov 1, 2008

I was in right at the end of DADT and the only time I ever heard if it being used was people trying to quit bootcamp

PookBear
Nov 1, 2008

Victor Vermis posted:

The Marine Corps isn't inherently homophobic, it just values retard strength above all other attributes.

And so The Marine Corps is inherently retarded. And Homophobia is retarded.

Nice and hot piss
Feb 1, 2004

"I can't train drill sergeant, I keep thinking of massive dicks smacking my face while you're PT'ing us!!"

PookBear
Nov 1, 2008

tbh I think dadt should be applied to every sexual orientation, political party, and sports ball team.

I dont care if your a straight christian, but if you preach to me you get kicked out

MullardEL34
Sep 30, 2008

Basking in the cathode glow
Seems like the thread to ask this question. Is there a gay version of the Dependa?

A Bad Poster
Sep 25, 2006
Seriously, shut the fuck up.

:dukedog:

MullardEL34 posted:

Seems like the thread to ask this question. Is there a gay version of the Dependa?

Nostalgia4Butts
Jun 1, 2006

WHERE MY HOSE DRINKERS AT

same here, couple gay dudes and ladies in my unit, they were in various states of outness and no one cared.

if you were someone that cared about why you don't like gay people enough to talk about it in public then most people would probably hate you in the military.

during DADT (before I was in the unit) two girls had parked an m997 in a field somewhere and started going to town on each other until they were caught by the BC

they got booted.

Bogarts
Mar 1, 2009

MurderBot posted:

"I can't train drill sergeant, I keep thinking of massive dicks smacking my face while you're PT'ing us!!"

There was a guy in my basic who told the drill sgt he was gay to get out. Really awkward "battle buddy me while I talk to the DS" moment. Best part was he was engaged and his girl was 5 months pregnant. Ended up staying past when we graduated because getting kicked out apparently takes forever in basic.

UP THE BUM NO BABY
Sep 1, 2011

by Hand Knit
All the dudes claiming to be gay to get out just saw the writing on the wall and I'm kind of jealous I didn't start claiming I liked the dick in order to avoid the massive (metaphorical) dicks the army threw at me daily. For DADT relevance I joined a year before it was repealed and literally nobody cared, even in the infantry.

Blackchamber
Jan 25, 2005

I was harassed endlessly in A-school to the point that I nearly had to be held back and put in the next class when my roommate, who did everything he could avoid even being in the room with me much less sleep in the same room as me, told everyone that I was gay. I am not gay and at the time I was dating a girl in the class behind mine. Later on he sort of apologized when he saw me at a party with her. As far as leadership/command was concerned, they didn't care that anyone would be gay or harassed, only that if I left the class it would have been too small to continue on and that would have caused a stink to explain why 4 people with above 95% averages get held back at the same time.

After I got my major qualification, people join and then immediately get out so they can go civilian where the money is, I stood up in the briefing room and told everyone that I was in fact a super peter-puffer and I should be discharged asap. My crew leader told me that they require proof to kick you out so I sat back down.

I actually worked with a knew a few gay people, and yeah nobody really cares unless you are some slack-jawed hick.

The day DADT was repealed we had just gotten back from deployment and my friend decided to take some of that sweet tax free money and buy his whole family tickets to something or other, anyways he calls home and gets the answering machine and simply says he had a 'big surprise' to tell them later and he'd call back. Given the timing I told him to call and leave another machine so his family didn't get confused.

Zeris
Apr 15, 2003

Quality posting direct from my brain to your face holes.
Nice

Infamous Sphere
Nov 8, 2010
Blargh oh my god yes, I have read fanfiction, in a way it's a guilty pleasure/so bad it's good thing. I can't read trashy romance though. Fanfiction..oh god..some of the anatomical limitations are..well..let's just say these women don't very much und
Thanks for all of the responses everyone! It's always interesting to get some background directly, as opposed to going on various news articles etc. What I'm getting from this is that there were a variety of different experiences under DADT - for some people it was loving awful and for some people it didn't make any kind of difference. So variable. I guess it depends on your chief/who you're working with/where you are?

iyaayas01 posted:

So just in case you were wondering why that comic was made when the real answer to how DADT impacted the force was

[nobody cared]

the answer is, because DoD is retarded and insists on providing "training" for every little thing under the sun that is clunky and poorly executed. Also because it gives them something to point to whenever Congress asks them why aren't they doing more about "x" (the latest example of this would be all of DoD's response to sexual assault)

Makes sense. The comic does seem incredibly disconnected to everything I've read, and also disconnected to how people relate to each other as human beings who exist in the world. It seems like it was made by aliens.

Pesticide20 posted:

All the dudes claiming to be gay to get out just saw the writing on the wall and I'm kind of jealous I didn't start claiming I liked the dick in order to avoid the massive (metaphorical) dicks the army threw at me daily. For DADT relevance I joined a year before it was repealed and literally nobody cared, even in the infantry.

Enforcement of DADT/what counts as proof seemed to vary so much? I did see an anecdote where somebody said that his CO said that she'd only dismiss someone for being gay if they gave her two polaroids of them giving a BJ and their face was visible in both of them - but then there's also poo poo like someone getting dismissed for having some vaguely gay AOL account so I dunno.

Vasudus
May 30, 2003
commander's discretion is a helluva thing

Nostalgia4Infinity
Feb 27, 2007

10,000 YEARS WASN'T ENOUGH LURKING
man I wish I served in one of those units where nobody cared :sigh:

UP THE BUM NO BABY
Sep 1, 2011

by Hand Knit

Nicetalga4Meltdown posted:

man I wish I served in one of those units where nobody cared :sigh:

Should've gone infantry

Mike-o
Dec 25, 2004

Now I'm in your room
And I'm in your bed


Grimey Drawer

Pesticide20 posted:

Should've gone infantry

Godholio
Aug 28, 2002

Does a bear split in the woods near Zheleznogorsk?

Nicetalga4Meltdown posted:

man I wish I served in one of those units where nobody cared :sigh:

Aircrew, bro. Probably could've had a straight fellow flightsuiter roll as a plant wingman.

Nostalgia4Infinity
Feb 27, 2007

10,000 YEARS WASN'T ENOUGH LURKING

Godholio posted:

Aircrew, bro. Probably could've had a straight fellow flightsuiter roll as a plant wingman.

It was really only one or two NCO's at Kadena that were the problem. My overwhelming experience was that no one gave a poo poo. But those poo poo heads managed to make my last 6 months there hell once my "secret" went wide. Things were much better at Holloman, my first sergeant actually talked to me about it like I was a human being and helped get me a DOS rollback to separate a year early since I was heading down a bad path in part because of my experience at Kadena. I'm glad to hear that for most people it was a non-issue but I guarantee it wasn't like that for everyone. I'm glad the policy is gone. The worst part was not being able to stand up for myself or talk to anyone about it aside from my parents via Skype.

It might not have been a huge people for many but it certainly wasn't a nonissue either.

Booblord Zagats
Oct 30, 2011


Pork Pro

Nicetalga4Meltdown posted:

It was really only one or two NCO's at Kadena that were the problem. My overwhelming experience was that no one gave a poo poo. But those poo poo heads managed to make my last 6 months there hell once my "secret" went wide. Things were much better at Holloman, my first sergeant actually talked to me about it like I was a human being and helped get me a DOS rollback to separate a year early since I was heading down a bad path in part because of my experience at Kadena. I'm glad to hear that for most people it was a non-issue but I guarantee it wasn't like that for everyone. I'm glad the policy is gone. The worst part was not being able to stand up for myself or talk to anyone about it aside from my parents via Skype.

It might not have been a huge people for many but it certainly wasn't a nonissue either.

Yeah, I was told that being gay in the AF was easily the worst. All the Jesus fish in the parking lot at Edwards seemed to confirm

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Woof Blitzer
Dec 29, 2012

[-]
Every year I go to NAS Lemoore and all the fighter pilots are Mormons.

  • Locked thread