Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
HerStuddMuffin
Aug 10, 2014

YOSPOS
It's so funny how people talk about the price of bitcoin like it's something that's decided by market forces and isn't blatantly manipulated.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

HerStuddMuffin
Aug 10, 2014

YOSPOS
This way it will be more convenient to round them up and take them to the reeducation camp bitcoin seminar.

HerStuddMuffin
Aug 10, 2014

YOSPOS

scott zoloft posted:

hmm even after that news about the chinese exchanges the speculative internet dollars are still going up....
It's almost as if the price isn't grounded in reality but is just an arbitrary number that a handful of people set to whatever they want in order to fleece rubes...

HerStuddMuffin
Aug 10, 2014

YOSPOS
How much does it cost an established miner to mine a coin these days? I would guess (out of my rear end) much less than the current market price. Therefore... if it's trivial to turn coins into cash, why aren't people selling massively until the price adjusts to the cost of production? I cannot think of a reason, but I'm not financially educated at all, and I'm also kind of dumb with money.

I am perfectly willing to hear that I'm wrong and an idiot and I'm asking completely the wrong question, but please then educate me on why I'm wrong so I may understand this.

I realize that the people who have been saying that withdrawing cash is difficult to impossible will just tell me that the exchanges are artificially inflating the rate by restricting the flow of cash out of the exchanges, so I'd like to hear primarily from the other side of the debate.

HerStuddMuffin
Aug 10, 2014

YOSPOS
That assumes most of the market is comprised of money launderers, and not a lot is made up of miners. Is that he case? I understand (maybe?) the difference between the price of bitcoins ($5000 per coin currently, give or take?) and the value of bitcoins ($0) but I'm taking the standpoint of a miner. If mining is profitable, I should sell the coins I mine so I can expand my operations, mine more and make more profits. Sitting on a promise makes no sense. But that's only the case if I can actually get real cash for my coins, not theoretical cash according to some exchange that won't let me cash out. If cashing out is easy, why aren't I cashing out?

HerStuddMuffin
Aug 10, 2014

YOSPOS

Blade Runner posted:

A vast majority of the mining market is made up of Chinese mining farms due to strict regulations on conversions of Chinese money to USD, with the butts coins being a convenient way of sidestepping that.
Ok, so Chinese miners can't convert coins to cash easily, and they comprise most of the miners. That makes sense, their coins are tied up because they can't liquidate. Have they tried sending emails to random strangers abroad to ask for their assistance in turning their coins into cash in exchange for a cut? I heard it works for Nigerian princes.

In all seriousness, Chinese peasants don't own bitcoin farms, and a lot of rich Chinese people have relatives abroad. Is getting the wallet passwords out to a trusted family member in Canada really that hard?

HerStuddMuffin
Aug 10, 2014

YOSPOS

Paladinus posted:

But get this, they'll just buy bit pennies, a faster working crypto, with their butts to pay for groceries and stuff. It's like withdrawing cash from your visa, only you have to wait a week to do that. It's extremely cool and is in no way a problem for bitgroins.
I know you're being facetious, but ham's tried that argument (and you are making fun of that) and it was bullshit even then. If you need another currency to handle day-to-day transaction, then that coin would displace bitcoin and remove it from the marketplace. It would only be good for bitcoin in the sense that it would put it out of its misery. Doing business in cryptocoin, whatever specific one you use, is already a hassle because it's like doing business in a foreign currency inside your own country, which is simply insane to expect of the general public. Have you seen tourists handling foreign currencies, regardless of nationality and country visited? To affirm that people would voluntarily use not one, but two or more kinds of weirdollars in their daily life is moronic beyond words.

And evil weasel, thank you for the explanation, but it takes me back to my conundrum. Since Chinese miners want cash, and they have to sell abroad because they want USD, not yuan, and it's trivial to turn coins into cash through the exchanges, how aren't they crashing the US price to the production cost of bitcoins in China or thereabout?
I'm still left with three explanations: either the price is manipulated out the wazoo, or it's not so easy to cash out, or miners are a small fraction of the market.

HerStuddMuffin
Aug 10, 2014

YOSPOS
Why does it have to crash? The coins aren't going anywhere, they don't go bad like tulip bulbs, they're already not anywhere anyway since they're virtual, what's stopping them from sitting, unwanted, in a ghost town of an exchange, forever on offer at a high price nobody will ever pay because nobody even remembers they exist? Asking seriously, here.

HerStuddMuffin
Aug 10, 2014

YOSPOS
Exactly how many tons of coal does it take to mine a bitcoin these days if a $5000 price tag is a net loss, holy loving poo poo!?

HerStuddMuffin
Aug 10, 2014

YOSPOS

Uranium 235 posted:

Why do you assume that the Chinese want USD and not yuan?
They're using mining as a way to get their wealth out of China, circumventing the government regulations, as per the post I was responding to? Selling their coins for Chinese currency would completely defeat the point.

HerStuddMuffin
Aug 10, 2014

YOSPOS

Lime Tonics posted:

so how do i cash out my 2.13 bitcoins without having to buy drugs or let the app access my browsing history?

into real money? like even bolivars or worse.
Someone posted a picture of a bitcoin ATM on page 55 of this thread. The obvious solution is to locate the closest one to you, press the cash withdrawal button, enter the details of your wallet and voila, the machine converts at the current exchange rate and spits out cash. Truly easy.

Or maybe it's not that easy because unlike a regular ATM that does these operations routinely and under a minute from card in to cash out, these bitcoin machines require extensive proof of your identity, and take half an hour or more to confirm the transaction because the blockchain stuff is a clunky mess, if they're able to spit cash out at all. If there's no cash in the machine, you're not getting blood from that stone.

So, which is it more likely to be?

HerStuddMuffin
Aug 10, 2014

YOSPOS
On the one hand, by entering the coin trade you relieve another sucker of their position, but by exiting before the music stops and you're left holding the baglive grenade, you're condemning another sucker to take your place. It's morally gray at best, and probably a worse and worse idea, from a practical standpoint, as time goes on.

HerStuddMuffin
Aug 10, 2014

YOSPOS

Return Of JimmyJars posted:

Coinbase.com makes it stupid easy to withdraw and purchase bitcoin. Do you need help wiping your own rear end too?


Is that from November last year or even older? I heard transactions took a long time to process but that’s just ridiculous :v:

HerStuddMuffin
Aug 10, 2014

YOSPOS
Serious question, if it’s notorious that you can’t get money out of bitinfex, why do people buy into it? I thought it was the same wishful thinking that makes them believe that crypogs will surely be useful for something, some day, but there are other exchanges, presumably some of which allow cash withdrawals right now?

HerStuddMuffin
Aug 10, 2014

YOSPOS

Liquid Communism posted:

Because, as PT Barnum said, there's a sucker born every minute. Same reason people buy into pyramid schemes, or penny stocks, thinking they're the One True Captain Of Industry smart enough to get out with a profit.
Yes, sure, they’re fools, just itching for someone to part them from their money, I get that. But they look at the various options they have to do that, and they see two (for simplicity) exchanges. One allows them to cash out if, by some miracle, they turn a profit when their amazing investor savvy makes them billionaires, and the other one doesn’t. It’s just a blackhole. Money goes in, worthless tokens come out.

Why do they drop their cash in that second pit?

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

HerStuddMuffin
Aug 10, 2014

YOSPOS
400% gain but, agreed, he hasn’t actually made any money until he closes his position and gets the cash.

  • Locked thread