Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
(Thread IKs: fart simpson)
 
  • Post
  • Reply
tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

Kefahuchi_son!!! posted:

Serious post:

I know almost nothing about China except what generalities come across the western (non-Us) media and a couple of history books (mostly pre-19th century).
Everything i read or see about current China has made a very negative impression on me. It makes me think of a nightmare amagalmation of the worst of capitalism and communism with extra nationalism on top.
So if anyone has recommendations of books or media that challenge this prejudice and give a more nuanced view it would be very helpful.

Disclaimer:

I'm far left in most of my political positions and frequently vote for an orthodox communist party.
I've frequently found myself in the position of having to talk about the USSR and why it was not an "empire of evil" but i can't find a silver line when China is the subject.

So shatter my misconceptions and possible low-key racism .

If you just want to check out a good book about China, I recommend China Road by Rod Gifford. If you want to learn Chinese culture on a macro scale, check out Harvard's China series on edX. I double checked my collection of English books/audiobooks about China, frankly most of them have negative spin.

For the record China has never committed to Communism as serious as other countries. There is always a Confucianism chassis doing heavy lifting for the state machine underneath the Communism and/or Capitalism skins. And the Chinese for the most part prefer Confucianism over whatever the import concepts even though "Confucianism" as a brand is tainted in Chinese conversation. What they really meant is "Sinicism" when they say Confucianism.

tino has issued a correction as of 00:20 on Dec 18, 2018

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
Does Somali has unified government and process monopoly of state violent now? Or the Chinese just handshaked with one of the warlords and get to fish without harassment from the nearby pirates?

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
It's not concentration camp, they are basically the Laogai system (reeducation thru labor) that was disbanded in 2012. A TLDR version of Laogai is that it's basically lighter/minimum security prison faculties China doesn't want to call prison.

When you think about it, Laogai was phased out by Hu at the end of his term and brought it right back by Xi at his 2nd term.

tino has issued a correction as of 14:48 on Dec 19, 2018

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
Nah China will exchange default projects for operation ownership of ports for civilian/military dual use and never call them military bases.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
Well hikers build proper alcohol stove with beer cans.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/1077225810329825281?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
Just access all your China threads from the user control panel, that way you can never be sure the irony level of the thread.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
Xi's face always look so dead.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
You know how 2019 can top 2018? Rare metal to be discovered in the Diaoyu Island.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
You really don't need to go to Marx to explain Deng. Dengism = authoritarian politically + protected free market + minimize military budget to ally with US. There are plenty of examples from warring period and later dynasties.

Nothing Deng has said strike me he believe in grand theories.

Edit: also army required unconditional royalty to the party, not the state.

tino has issued a correction as of 21:45 on Jan 2, 2019

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
Tiananmen played a direct role in the Eastern block countries folded so fast a couple years later because most people at power realized they had to commit to tank to continue the communist dictatorships. And people who still believe in Marxism couldn't bring themselves to do it.

What happened in China was actually a lot closer to a palace power struggle than a ideological struggle, not trying to excuse Deng here. I was reading up on the Cixi and the failure of Hundred Day's Reform. Cixi actually was for the reform, she was just against losing power and control. Guangxu was her handpicked successor she raised herself from an toddler, after her son and husband had died. Guangxu really was her closest person. But when both sizes were moving toward a palace coup, the more powerful and merciless side inevitably won. And afterward Cixi had to lean on the conservatives because all the reform fractions had been killed along with Guangxu. I see quite a bit of similarity between Cixi/Guangci and Deng/Zhao Ziyang relationship. Neither Cixi nor Deng ever had political legitimacy. The main difference being Cixi sat on her rear end and did a slow reform afterward while Deng came out of retirement 4 years later and manually forced the economic reform schedule back on rail, with military backing.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

Typo posted:

Deng had enormous political legitimacy with the exception of the years 1989-1993


He was "retired" before that. Also he built the central polibureau system to prevent Mao style dictator. The system kinda lasted 20+ years.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

Typo posted:

Unfortunately Xi does not exert almost absolute control over North Korea, on the contrary Chinese leverage over North Korea is actually pretty weak. China has being pressuring the DPRK to tune down its nuclear program to no avail. The value of the DPRK as a buffer state is also fairly weak especially when the tail wags the dog too much.

Still better than letting NK fail and getting swallowed by the south and turn into another unified Vietnam.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
Taiwan doesn't have high tech stuff to steal.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
Somebody turn that panda pic into a thread icon.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
Nah Lin Biao was very reluctant to be the No. 2 of Mao, because Mao historically had jailed/killed a few Number Twos in the past. His escape was forced hand by his stupid son.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

sincx posted:

He should've flown to Seoul. Much closer.

It was totally unplanned, he didn't know what he was doing and the plane made a turn on air.


Typo posted:

WRONG!

His escape was because he had already shown his hand in being revisionist seeking to overthrow Mao!
Well you can say he lost his chance (after his daughter snitched on him), it doesn't invalidate what I said, Lin Biao believed that making him Number Two would put him on an inevitable course to face off against Mao. And his prediction was right. My main point was that he was not an ambitious man, if given the chance he would rather stay back as the leader of the top 10 generals. Unfortunately Mao gotten rip of most people more senior than Lin (i.e. Liu Shaoqi and the Korean War hero general Peng). so he had to be the next one at bat. Historically, the only way to avoid downfall in such situation is call in sick for the rest of your life.


quote:


He mobilized over 700,000 soldiers without telling Mao about in an incident prior to the coup, it was obvious an attempt to test if he can lie, deceive and manipulate loyal PLA soldiers into assisting his illegal seizure of power. Mao had decided to remove him because he had made his ungrateful disloyalty open despite being trusted and appointed Mao's heir!

While the coup was his son's idea, it was no doubt conducted with the knowledge and support of Lin Biao himself. Lin was also an arch-Confucian and it is likely that he never believed in Socialism and was merely using it as a tool to facilitate his own power-hungry motives.

700K soldier doesn't mean a lot if you don't have access ot the army inside Beijing and Zhongnanhai. His son probably thought he was Li Shimin reincarnated and tried to force the emperor's cloth on his dad.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

Sheng-Ji Yang posted:

ok the typo gimmick is funny now taht everyone is responding to him seriously

I use a text only Chrome extension "decrease productivity" at work, I don't see the avatar of the poster I reply to. So I play this thread straight face.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
Zhou is a handsome guy.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
I woke up to 90 new posts of Shen Yun chat. Also found out Lowtax is (not) paying alimony?

If Shen Yun is back by Falun Gong, then Falun is already more successful than Scientology.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

mila kunis posted:

https://www.ft.com/content/8f08f824-1a5f-11e9-b93e-f4351a53f1c3

Huawei's done in europe. New cold war with goverments bowing to imperial pressure for who gets to sell what where


Don't post link that's behind loving paid wall.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
Id that really Xi? I have never seen any emotion from him. Also yeah the manspreading guy is photo bombing Xi.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
No just read the manga. You can finish it in 2 weeks.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

Xaris posted:

so what's the deal with Tencent and CCP. like tencent is just throwing barrels of cash buying up western gaming stuff. is there some particular endgame there with tencent/ccp with building foreign database and doing facebooky poo poo, or do they just figure they can get more profits out of buying a bunch of western game studios?

Trying to get rid of their cash inside China and own more concrete things. That's my guess.

BTW, I have a classmate who used to made WM software and sold his business to tencent and became a management. He said the most popular battle royale mobile game from tencent are not allowed to make money even though its the most popular game, because the party is not giving the approval. He didn't say approval of what but I assume to sell microtransaction? I don't play mobile games.

tino has issued a correction as of 12:11 on Feb 1, 2019

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
I feel the opening chapter of the Communist Manifesto deserve a Conan style monologue, and a loving epic score. Get Han Zimmer on the phone.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
Beijing residences will never say anything bad about the CCP government because the insane amount of wealth they have acquired in the last two decades through property inflation directly tie to the stability of the CCP aystem. They are the first 1% beneficiary of the current system.

When I said residences, I meant actual Beijingren and Shanghairen who have the hukous.

This is an unspoken contract stuck by the party and the residences to avoid another Tiananmen. This is the CCP version of building a state of art colosseum to provide free entertainment. If your entire capaital city population are middle class you don't get people walking on the street en mass. I haven't seen China specialist discuss it.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

BrutalistMcDonalds posted:

uwe boll is clearly taking advantage of chinese film subsidies :lol:

https://twitter.com/CarlZha/status/1092184805989470208

Capcom finally reveal Ada Wong's back story.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

Modest Mao posted:

how many people in this thread even learned via traditional. I did. simplified did not look, at any point, like a time saver.

There's no evidence that Taiwanese kids have some cruel, extra labor adding years to learning how to write. It takes exactly the same amount of time.

Also lol @ 10,000 characters my man. Most educated people TODAY know less characters than that total. 点 or 點 it still takes up the same brain space - there aren't that many characters that combined into one like 麵/面

It's like suggesting taking the 'u' out of colour made americans literate or something. It's bonkers and you're going in the 'is an idiot' pile with R. except lower tier because you obviously do not speak a sinic language

Simplified standardize shorthand ways to write components of characters that traditional users are already doing in fast hand writing and combines similar characters are that only slightly different in meaning. It's better simply because every character has get on an interrogation chart to make its case that why it need to be exist. This goes for most writing system reforms in most cultures/countries.

Of course it doesn't matter now when you only use keyboards to input Chinese. It reminds me of the expensive canal New York dug to stimulate trade and it was made obsoleted only decades later by the inversion of railroad.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

Fallen Hamprince posted:

The advantage of simplified characters is mostly that they’re frequently much easier to write then their traditional counterparts. Many of the simplifications already existed before ‘Simplified’ was formalized as a standard set of characters, as shorthand used when handwriting. This btw is why Japanese Kanji share some of the same simplifications. Of course everybody now just uses keyboard input so it’s irrelevant. Simplified does not reduce the number of characters except to remove calligraphic variants of the same character.

If the PRC leadership had really wanted to make Chinese literacy easy they’d have swapped out writing systems entirely for a syllabary like Zhuyin. This would have the disadvantage of making untransliterated Classical Chinese literature unreadable to non-specialists, but Classical is already difficult for modern Chinese speakers to read, let alone write. It would also make typesetting way easier.


A pure sounding system doesn't work for Chinese because there are too many words with the identical sounds. If you use zhuyin or pinyin to input Chinese you should know that there are some combination of sounds bring up 20+ words for selection. I believe this is a ptoblem with Vietnamese writing but that's just what I heard, maybe Vietnamese is more like Cantonese which have more variety of sounds.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

Xelkelvos posted:

Adopting a mix of characters with zhuyin would probably be the most effective amelioration to that issue, but beyond that, it's largely just solved by context. Spoken language already has this issue, doesn't it?

I think the difference is that spoken Chinese/language use limited set of words while literature Chinese use more words. Also when you are speaking, you can use selective emphasis of sounds and gestures to help you.

Also current Chinese writing system already include the sound information. Right half of a character usually carry the sound information; and the left half carry the contest. That's why you can use a single character to express a word. For example most of the provinces have a single-character name. Now if you reduce the word to just sound you can not do that anymore. For example on Chinese license plate, you use "粤A" to represent plates from Guangzhou, if you just write "Yue A" you have no idea which Yue is this. And "Guangzhou" would take up too much space. Also there are more than one city called "Guangzhou".

tino has issued a correction as of 20:39 on Feb 5, 2019

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

Xelkelvos posted:

You say "usually" which means this isn't a universal case. Then there's the weird case of foreign words/names in text that's transliterated. I know sound-alikes are used, but what determines which character is used besides its sound and how would one know that it's a foreign name rather than a real phrase? If it's just context, then wouldn't that resolve a lot of similar issues regarding homophones in Chinese that become homographs in a purely zhuyin system?

Nobody above the level of grade school literacy would mistaken a foreign transliterated name to a Chinese word. There a set of strict translation rules mainland media has to follow. Unless you are talking about Hong Kongnese way of intentionally making a foreign name look and sound like Chinese.


quote:

Your license plate example, doesn't make sense here afaict and language on license plates isn't really something one uses as an example of written language as there's all sorts of ways to display that information in a clear way than just a single letter/character. Is there more than one province of Guangzhou? I'm not surprised there's more than one city with that name, but the same applies in practically every country. Hell, there are cities in the US that have the same name as states.

And like I said, there's always using a mix of zhuyin and characters like how Japanese uses kana and kanji is probably the ideal solution to minimize homophone issues while retaining any linguistic subtleties.

You don't even know if Guangzhou is a city or a province, why am I wasting time with you. LOL.

Japanese writing is a bad example because it's the most complicated writing system of the world. Part of the problem is that it still borrow too much from a foreign writing system (Chinese) while its words pronunciation sound nothing like Chinese. So you ends up with using Kanzi for the core meaning but can not reuse them to help with the sound. Korean writing is example of good writing reform, Japanese is not.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
If normal animation is too expensive even for china, there is no hope for animation.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
I have been wondering if the Uighurs camps are different from Mao's anti rightist educational camps from the 60s.

I don't remember seeing any picture of the righist camp, at least we have some picture of the Uighurs camp. Btw its impossible for me to spell the word "Uighurs" correctly without looking up the word. Why can't English have more consistent spelling.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

Xelkelvos posted:

Uyghur is also an acceptable spelling fwiw

Hopefully in a few decades,it changes to Weeger or weegur for better branding.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
Stop loving quoting twitter.

Is this how bbs forums get with the millennials?

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
Which body has the best "erradically running infant" tracking?

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe
I wonder if India is uplifting any percentage of her poor out of the slum or the rich to poor ratio remain the same.

Anyway Marx was right, probably turn out to be more right than Einstein.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

Mantis42 posted:

Well Britain's moment of triumph was Waterloo. They had fought almost continuous wars with France and it was the deep reserves of capital their modern banking system provided that allowed them to outlast Napoleon. They were even heavily subsidizing the other Coalition powers. With their largest colonial rival weakened they swallowed the world. It wasn't a complete victory, the world was still multipolar, but it remained so precisely because the UK's economic revolution was exported and imitated by other Europeans, America, and eventually the world.

Similarly, the World Wars mark the end of a certain type of Capitalism, the colonial-settler phase. America was most suited for the new forms of imperialism that replaced it, I guess. Its a globalized neoliberal Capitalism inaugurated with the Bretton-Woods System and international organizations like the UN.

Right now China is the only power offering an alternative to neoliberalism and the only one seriously investing in green tech. They're building a lot of goodwill in certain African nations, who's populations are set to explode. America isn't leading anybody.

American Capitalism only works in an expending market. Once the entire globe is saturated with liberal capitalism the big fishes have to start eating the small fishes, hence the financial crisis. To quote something I heard on youtube, we are at the full swing of the Second Glided Age.

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

SaTaMaS posted:

India has also been a source of CEOs for US tech companies, meanwhile I'm sure China will stop depending on intellectual property theft for tech innovation *any day now*.

I am sure they do it already but it would be stupid for the Indians not landrush the western ideas and build their own Fortnite.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

tino
Jun 4, 2018

by Smythe

Lightning Knight posted:

Do China and India still have contested borders and poo poo?

They do during elections.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply