Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
OwlFancier
Aug 22, 2013

Relevant Tangent posted:

Hitler didn't gently caress

Was he conserving his sex power?

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Prester Jane
Nov 4, 2008

by Hand Knit
So I have been thinking for some time about how to explain my perspective what Q Anon is doing, how he is appealing to people successfully, and what his apparent goals are. It is my contention that Q is not a single individual but a small group of individuals with access to a reasonable amount of resources, and I believe the most likely culprit to be Russian intelligence. Q is using an extremely elaborate form of a type of occult/paranormal scam that I call the "Nostradamus Hustle". All other examples of the scam that I am personally aware of are pretty straightforward demonstrations of a person with a personality disorder grifting on the gullible, and these operations are almost always either solo operated or operated by a very small group with a very clear way to make money off of the scam. Q Anon is the only time I have ever seen someone operating this scam without a clear financial incentive. It's not a very easy scam to pull off and psychopaths with enough talent to do so are just not easy to come by.

The Nostradamus Hustle functions by first creating a stylized form of gibberish that contains disjointed words and phrases, and then convincing people that secret information that indicates how future events will turn out can be had by decoding your gibberish. In the case of Nostradamus he accomplished this task through the use of quatrains; whereas in the case of the people behind the Bible Code they essentially use a mathematical formula that transforms the Torah into a word search, and in the case of HalfPastHuman (the people behind the infamous WebBot that was very popular during the height of the 2012 doomsday fad) they generate complete gibberish that is claimed to be the result of an algorithm that tracks changes over time in how people use language online. I have included an example of each below:



( I used an example of the Bible Code generated using the King James Bible instead of the Torah for ease of understanding)

A sample of a Web Bot ALTA report posted:

These areas also indicate that [revenge assassinations] will be taking place over the latter third of
2010 and throughout most of 2011 at a planetary level as those [thought/presumed (to be) guilty]
of ['murdering' terra] are themselves [punished] by some very {ed note: probably justified}
[unbalanced persons]. Note that there are pointers for a [wave of assassinations] that seemingly
are being [engineered], and whose target will be [Jesuits] and other [jewish/zionists minions] of the
[church (of the sorcerers - aka roman catholic papists)]. That this area is buried within the [oil
volcano] side effects is unusual. There are extensive cross links over to TPTB entity. Within the
termination points here, there are many pointers to [attempts (some successful, some not)] against
the [gangs] of the [banksters (aka -rose protected, and stone buddy boys)]. At least one of the
successful [executions] is indicated to be [within sight/smell of] the [oil volcano].
The [oil volcano] sub set continues to gain data in support of the [ill winds] area, and still is gaining
support for those sub sets indicating that 1.289+ billion people will [perish] as a direct result of the
[ill winds] and the [oil volcano]. This area also continues to be tied into the [israeli mistake] sub set
in the Terra entity, the Populace/USofA entity, and the GlobalPop entity.
Noting that the [oil volcano] was created by the [zionist funded, crown owned British Petroleum
(same group that paid the CIA to put the Shah of Iran into power in 1953 among other crimes
against humanity)], it remains to be seen whether more of the [sticky dirt] of the [planetary
poisoning] will yet come to rest on the [shoulders] of the [israelis] as events progress through the
[torments of Summer] and into the [tortures of Fall, 2010].
Against the [officialdom claims] of a [cleaned well, ready for use] to be [available/accomplished in
August], the data suggests that this [claim] will also be [exposed] as [hollow] and [duplicitous] by
mid August as [nefarious (geologic) manipulation] comes [to the surface] of the [public
consciousness]. {ed note: this area is tied into the Populace/USofA entity and SpaceGoatFarts
entity by cross links that terminate in the 'big gains' of public awareness for the woo-woo
community starting in July.}
In the [ill winds] sub set newly acquired supporting layers are several indicating that in at least one
instance the [ill winds] will be so [dense/heavy] that they will be [stopped (at the) base] of a
[mountain range]. This is indicated to create a [lake of death air] at the [base of the mountains] in
what is also described as a [v-shaped (half vesica) depression]. This is not a box canyon as there
is egress to and from this area, but for the [heavy winds] the [depression/hollow] will form an
[atmospheric-lake bed].
This [lake of death air] has a major [road way] that comes over or through the [mountains], and
descends into an area that is currently [lush] with [plants]. The data shows that the [plant and
animal life] of the [region] will also die, along with [many humans] who will either be [trapped] in
the [lake of death air] or will unwittingly [travel into it]. Further the data shows the [heavy death air]
is so [toxic] that [even worms] will perish under it. This is but a single instance of thousands of
detail layers about the [ill winds] and their effects on the planet.

As you can see in the above examples the general format of the scam is pretty straightforward- create a bunch of gibberish and then convince people somehow that your gibberish contains actionable information about future events. Once you've gotten enough people to buy in you can basically keep the scam running indefinately so long as you pay constant attention to your audience and always feed them exactly what they want to hear. The only downside to this particular scam is that it requires an all-consuming focus on your audience, you can't simply half-rear end things or just throw things out in the proper format. You have to expend continue oil significant effort to keep prodding your audience into going along with giving you money, and in order to do that your audience has to be being told what they want to hear. (This is why 8 years ago the Web Bot was constantly talking about the 2012 doomsday scenario, whereas now it's mostly focused on cryptocurrency speculating. What the audience wanted to hear shifted and the person running the Web Bot shifted their scam to accommodate.)

The evidence that leads me to conclude that Q Anon on is a Russian intelligence is complicated; in the first place I've never seen a Nostradamus Hustle conducted purely for shots and giggles without any attempt to acquire financial gain or public attention, the psychological toolkit required to successfully run this scam basically only appears and individuals who would use this scam for some sort of personal gain. Running a Nostradamus hustle is a pretty all-consuming affair, at least one individual operating the scam must be extremely tuned in to everything their audience of suckers is saying or doing in order to keep the scam running. In the second place I've never seen a Nostradamus Hustle that seemed designed specifically to drive Compaction Cycle's among Narrativists- while Narrativists are a frequent target audience for this sort of scam, it's usually just to relieve them of their money. I've never before seeing a Nostradamus hustle that was seemingly set up just to provide a venue for a huge number of Narrativists to compact over and over. Normally people running this scam try to avoid Compaction Cycles because it shrinks their customer base.

I also think that the selection of first 4chan and now 8Chan to operate this scam on only make sense if it's a Russian intelligence operation. As Uglycat can attest, it is much easier for a small group of individuals to manipulate consensus on the 'chans then people realize. The entire project chanology was launched via a campaign of creating false consensus on 4chan that was engaged in by the hacker group Marblecaek. I believe that Russian intelligence operatives arehanging around Q Anon threads and strategically posting to drive the conversation in a desired direction, I believe this is why they probably switched from 4chan to 8Chan. Once Q Anon started to pick up steam it was getting too much attention on 4chan for the manipulators to handle, so they switched to the much lower traffic 8Chan in order to make their task easier.

Personally I don't think there is any specific endgame or specific goal for the Q Anon scam, I think they are just going to run it as long as they can to keep driving Compaction Cycles and keep Americans radicalizing. Eventually the scam will probably come crashing down once Mueller indicts Trump, and when that happens their are going to be a great deal of extremely furious and confused Narrativists who will be extremely amenable to adopting any new radical Narrative (particularly one that provides an outlet for the violent rage they will be feeling at that point) that appears within the right-wing media echosphere. In essence even once the Q Anon scam falls apart, Russian intelligence will still profit handsomely because it will still be very easy for them to just insert whatever desired narrative (or perhaps even another Nostradamus Hustle) into the same audience.

Prester Jane fucked around with this message at 14:37 on Mar 27, 2018

Feinne
Oct 9, 2007

When you fall, get right back up again.
Another piece of evidence in favor of potential Russian involvement is the nature of the false narrative, while it's running it seeks to make the still-functioning parts of US politics look less valid and then when it eventually dies it'll invalidate everything else as well.

OwlFancier
Aug 22, 2013

That isn't a Russian thing though, the US's political landscape includes plenty of people who want to dismantle people's belief in the ability of the government to do anything.

Feinne
Oct 9, 2007

When you fall, get right back up again.

OwlFancier posted:

That isn't a Russian thing though, the US's political landscape includes plenty of people who want to dismantle people's belief in the ability of the government to do anything.

True, and there's also always the potential that whoever's behind this has a payday in mind that they just feel like they need a lot of setup to get to.

OwlFancier
Aug 22, 2013

They might just also be someone with too much time on their hands and a following of crazy internet nerds.

chitoryu12
Apr 24, 2014

Would a Russian have used "Matlock" as a password or something actually in Russian?

Prester Jane
Nov 4, 2008

by Hand Knit
Personally I think the Russians are the most likely culprits, but it's entirely possible that there is someone else behind it. It wouldn't take state actor level resources to pull this off, there's plenty of billionaires and/or political actors that would be perfectly capable of executing an operation like this. I am about 99.9% certain that this is a scripted op being conducted by multiple individuals in a coordinated fashion though. While it's conceivable that this could be the work of a lone troll, it is my conclusion that the balance of evidence very strongly suggests otherwise at this time.

This does require a pretty sophisticated understanding of American politics to execute though, it's current function at present is to enable a huge and diverse group of Narrativists to psychologically live within their personal Inner Narrative if in an environment where they are practically drowning in Narrative Dysphoria. Under any context having this many people be this disconnected from reality for any appreciable period of time would cause significant disruption in the affected population. Under present conditions it is highly likely to continue driving the emerging wave of violence that we are seeing play out at present.

It's like a strongest sustained wind blowing on a bonfire. It keeps increasing the flame and heat the longer it goes on until eventually the bonfire escapes the fire ring.


Edit:

chitoryu12 posted:

Would a Russian have used "Matlock" as a password or something actually in Russian?

Not an unfair question, but the kind of people who are this manipulative are also often extremely hubristic.

Also:


https://twitter.com/prayingmedic/status/975899309383172096?s=20


Double edit: This RT interview makes it painfully obvious that Q Anon is a Russian psyop imo.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tBI_dTY4fsc

Prester Jane fucked around with this message at 17:04 on Mar 27, 2018

dpf
Sep 17, 2011

It might be Discordians doing this, maybe.

WeedlordGoku69
Feb 12, 2015

by Cyrano4747

DangerousDan posted:

It might be Discordians doing this, maybe.

This would be sort of uncharacteristic of them, Discordians tend to be pretty benevolent.

Prester Jane
Nov 4, 2008

by Hand Knit
I personally think everyone interested in understanding the psychological manipulation that underlies the Q Anon phenomenon should take the 5 minutes to watch the video below. This is a Narrativist walking you through how minor little coincidences provide her with Narrative Validation- thus enabling her to psychologically exist within the fantasy world of her Inner Narrative. Note the genuine psychological relief and earnest optimism for the future that she is experiencing as a result of having her Inner Narrative validated. Also know that she is clearly not alone and having this specific reaction to the DoD tweet, as numerous other individuals in the replies to that tweet are clearly experiencing the same euphoria that she is. When the Q Anon delusion is eventually taken from her she will experience a tremendous sense of disorientation, rage, fear, and hopelessness. She will be exceedingly vulnerable at that point to becoming highly radicalized/pushed into taking more dramatic action, and she will not be alone.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-_jy9XWrtVk


From the perspective of the woman in that video (or really anyone who has latched onto a source of Narrative Validation this deeply) attacking Q Anon is akin to attacking her personal sense of security and joy, (her source of hope for the future)and she will react by lashing out viciously against anyone who makes her doubt the authenticity of Q. As she is a representative example of the norm of Q supporters, you can see how insanely easy it is for Compaction Cycles to occur in this social environment. Anyone who challenges the reality that Q is presenting will be rapidly forced right out of any group of Q supporters, steadily driving the radicalization of the affected communities.

For those curious Q Anon threads on freerepublic.com are currently some of the most active threads on the website, frequently getting over 2000 replies in short order.

Prester Jane fucked around with this message at 19:24 on Mar 27, 2018

Luigi's Discount Porn Bin
Jul 19, 2000


Oven Wrangler
Aside from Matlock, Q also disappears for weeks at a time, which seems to go against the idea that it's a professional.

It's possible that Q is a Russian psyop or targeted gangstalking or whatever, but it wouldn't require billionaire-level resources. You just need a hard-right true believer or two with a decent amount of time on their hands and not a lot of scruples. There's no shortage of people who have MAGA'd their brains into a place where they'd fake insider info for the greater good of redpilling the normies, financial incentives or not. Could be a couple of PJW's lackeys from the Infowars supplement marketing department - there are many ways to profit off radicalization and rising paranoia among right-populists that don't involve either being Vladimir Putin or setting up a Patreon for your bullshit.

Also, an interview with RT doesn't mean much. They feed off whatever batshit conspiracy-mongering is going on at the moment, and are all that much happier if it undermines the US. They've done bits on chemtrails and HAARP as well.

Prester Jane
Nov 4, 2008

by Hand Knit

Luigi's Discount Porn Bin posted:

Aside from Matlock, Q also disappears for weeks at a time, which seems to go against the idea that it's a professional.

It's possible that Q is a Russian psyop or targeted gangstalking or whatever, but it wouldn't require billionaire-level resources. You just need a hard-right true believer or two with a decent amount of time on their hands and not a lot of scruples. There's no shortage of people who have MAGA'd their brains into a place where they'd fake insider info for the greater good of redpilling the normies, financial incentives or not. Could be a couple of PJW's lackeys from the Infowars supplement marketing department - there are many ways to profit off radicalization and rising paranoia among right-populists that don't involve either being Vladimir Putin or setting up a Patreon for your bullshit.

Also, an interview with RT doesn't mean much. They feed off whatever batshit conspiracy-mongering is going on at the moment, and are all that much happier if it undermines the US. They've done bits on chemtrails and HAARP as well.

These are all very fair points. My contention with the RT interview is that it demonstrates that both Q and Russian propaganda are at least on the exact same page with regards to both each other and the general narrative they are pushing about Trump being in a covert war against the Deep State. It could certainly be just opportunism on the part of our RT, but that wouldn't necessarily explain why Q seems to parrot the Russian line on pretty much everything without fail. To me it seems very likely that the Narrative's that Q and Russian psyops are pushing are identical because they are acting more or less in coordination. It could be just crass opportunism on both sides, but I personally doubt it at this point.

Also Q's occasional disappearances would not necessarily preclude the actions of a competent actor, you need your Mystic to be somewhat unpredictable and inaccessible in order to make his messages more important when he does send them.

Personally I don't think you need any more than a small team of perhaps 10 individuals to create the Q Anon phenomenon and to create false consensus around it on the chans, but I do feel that it would require a pretty specialized set of talents in order to do so, to say nothing of the in-depth knowledge of American politics and culture that are on display. What I'm saying is it would mostly require some specialized know-how that doesn't come cheap, but but beyond that it doesn't require anything particularly special or resource intensive.

Ratoslov
Feb 15, 2012

Now prepare yourselves! You're the guests of honor at the Greatest Kung Fu Cannibal BBQ Ever!

I think all you need to do to be Qanon is be someone who's good at writing nonsense and cold-reading /pol/ jerks, and who also reads a lot of politics. The suckers want to believe.

OwlFancier
Aug 22, 2013

It could as easily be a product of monkeys on typewriters, lots of people on the internet try to make memes and go viral, that one eventually succeeds doesn't suggest a cunning plan as much as an inevitability of sufficient attempts.

Dr. VooDoo
May 4, 2006


Prester Jane posted:

These are all very fair points. My contention with the RT interview is that it demonstrates that both Q and Russian propaganda are at least on the exact same page with regards to both each other and the general narrative they are pushing about Trump being in a covert war against the Deep State. It could certainly be just opportunism on the part of our RT, but that wouldn't necessarily explain why Q seems to parrot the Russian line on pretty much everything without fail. To me it seems very likely that the Narrative's that Q and Russian psyops are pushing are identical because they are acting more or less in coordination. It could be just crass opportunism on both sides, but I personally doubt it at this point

It could just be Q is running with the whatever is pumped out by Russia on his own. Remember a bunch of MAGA chuds already buy into everything the Russian misinformation campaign pushes. This could just be Q, buying into that already, role playing as a deep state spy or whatever and just saying the same poo poo and then dropping gibberish on top that can be tied into anything once something happens. It could be ink blots and /pol/ would find out how they tie into current events after the fact

Uglycat
Dec 4, 2000
MORE INDISPUTABLE PROOF I AM BAD AT POSTING
---------------->
My experience with QAnon's marks is...
they believe Putin is sexy
they think Trump's uncle is a time traveler with access to Tesla's secret tech
they believe trump is both savior and god-emperor for life.

If that is a commonly held set of beliefs and preferences across folk whose ears are being whispered in from this direction... it points to the whisperers.

Uglycat
Dec 4, 2000
MORE INDISPUTABLE PROOF I AM BAD AT POSTING
---------------->

LORD OF BOOTY posted:

This would be sort of uncharacteristic of them, Discordians tend to be pretty benevolent.

There was a day when the facebook discordian group lost 20,000 accounts overnight. It was a few months back. There was a large network of facebook sockpuppets that used that group to build their credibility as 'real actual humans.'

Prester Jane
Nov 4, 2008

by Hand Knit

Ratoslov posted:

I think all you need to do to be Qanon is be someone who's good at writing nonsense and cold-reading /pol/ jerks, and who also reads a lot of politics. The suckers want to believe.

I fully agree with everything except the bolded bit. Knowing how to construct and write this specific sort of nonsense is actually a specialized skill that (in my experience) has been developed over a period of time through trial and error in individuals who possess the skill. Running a successful Nostradamus Hustle is not something that just any amoral sociopath with the right motivations can pull off, the skillset required is fairly rare in my experience.

OwlFancier posted:

It could as easily be a product of monkeys on typewriters, lots of people on the internet try to make memes and go viral, that one eventually succeeds doesn't suggest a cunning plan as much as an inevitability of sufficient attempts.

I'm approaching this from the angle of studying the downstream impacts of Q Anon, as well as how those downstream impacts tie into the larger geopolitical picture. It doesn't require an actor with an agenda to get something desired to go viral on the internet, however I strongly contend that it almost certainly requires an actor with an agenda to have these kinds of specific downstream impacts on the overall conservative narrative. Four or five months ago it was exceedingly rare to see a Q anon reference on freerepublic for example, whereas now it is a very hotly discussed topic that virtually all of Freep is very familiar with at this point. In my view it is these Downstream a fax in conjunction with the apparent coordination between Q and the Russian government when it comes to the narratives they are pushing that leads me to very strongly suspect that this is the result of a purposeful actor with an agenda, and not just a highly talented troll.

From my perspective watching how Q Anon operates is a bit like taking a walk through the forest and coming across a double row of 40 trees planted in a perfectly straight line. While those trees are very much still part of the forest, and while it is almost certain that the rest of the forest was Planet through entirely natural means, I would contend that this double row of 40 trees was almost certainly planted by human hands. To me Q Anon stands out as almost certainly being of artificial origin and being conducted with an intended purpose.

I mean it's entirely possible that those trees found out that way through entirely natural means, I just find it to be extremely unlikely. Likewise would I view how Q operates and the downstream impacts he is having, I see a manipulator with a purpose. I will fully can see that that could just be an artifact of my schizophrenia, percieving purpose behind otherwise random occurrences is definitely a feature of my illness. Not the last with that caveat I still very strongly contend that Q Anon is the result of a deliberate act with an agenda, and that Russia is the most likely culprit. I could be entirely wrong and hope that as events play out we find out eventually one way or another.

Prester Jane fucked around with this message at 20:33 on Mar 27, 2018

OwlFancier
Aug 22, 2013

But right wing hysteria and conspiracy nuttery is self perpetuating though. The major change over the last decade or so is it migrating from the fringe radio to the main narrative, but that's a fairly logical progression if you consistently campaign on lies and religious fundamentalism though.

There has been a consistent effort to detach the voting public from reality by a significant section of the right, but once that is achieved, not every effective push on the conspiracy front needs to originate from them or be consciously directed by some central authority. What has been created is a bunch of detached people prone to believing in the bizarre and fanciful and hopped up on right wing talking points, that they then regurgitate and create their own stories on those themes which serve as the talking point du jour doesn't indicate a conscious direction, it's right wing fanfiction, formed out of a morass of satanic panic and store brand religious imagery and age old racism and nationalism with a side of too many videogames and tom clancy novels, and the fact that all it achieves is chaos suggests that it isn't under anybody's control.

Luigi's Discount Porn Bin
Jul 19, 2000


Oven Wrangler

Prester Jane posted:

Personally I don't think you need any more than a small team of perhaps 10 individuals to create the Q Anon phenomenon and to create false consensus around it on the chans, but I do feel that it would require a pretty specialized set of talents in order to do so, to say nothing of the in-depth knowledge of American politics and culture that are on display. What I'm saying is it would mostly require some specialized know-how that doesn't come cheap, but but beyond that it doesn't require anything particularly special or resource intensive.
10 is kind of pessimistic. I'm not gonna say uh like I could totally be QAnon if I wanted to, you guys, but they don't exactly have a prohibitive schedule, and they don't have all that much political insight that couldn't be gained from reading the garden variety right-wing conspiracy poo poo that I voluntarily subject myself to most days, plus watching Fox News every now and then. That they end up pushing a lot of the same talking points as Russia says more about right-wing alternative media than about Q in particular. Seems totally plausible that a sufficiently dedicated single person with some sockpuppets could do it. I do think more than one person has posted as "Q," though, just based on a shift in writing styles that happened around the new year.

Anyway, there's any number of wannabe internet prophets that have been going on forever with little or no monetary support. Nancy Leider's not getting any of that cheddar these days and I don't see SaLuSa posting a Bitcoin address for tips. Though there's a more obvious mental illness component there - those two probably believe every word they say because they think it's coming from aliens. Q is cynical on some level, the question is how much.

Zero_Grade
Mar 18, 2004

Darktider 🖤🌊

~Neck Angels~

This reads like Gamefaqs directions to reaching the secret boss in an obscure and poorly-translated late-90's JPRG.

Prester Jane
Nov 4, 2008

by Hand Knit
Before we continue on with this debate I just like to note with wry humor that we are in such a bizarre situation that it would seem that Occam's razor cuts in favor of this being the work of a solitary eccentric genius who is successfully manipulating the worldview of millions of people instead of some sort of political actor with an agenda accomplishing this task.


OwlFancier posted:

But right wing hysteria and conspiracy nuttery is self perpetuating though. The major change over the last decade or so is it migrating from the fringe radio to the main narrative, but that's a fairly logical progression if you consistently campaign on lies and religious fundamentalism though.

There has been a consistent effort to detach the voting public from reality by a significant section of the right, but once that is achieved, not every effective push on the conspiracy front needs to originate from them or be consciously directed by some central authority. What has been created is a bunch of detached people prone to believing in the bizarre and fanciful and hopped up on right wing talking points,

I would argue that the net result of all this has been the creation of a population that is ripe for exact sort of psychological manipulation that Russia has been specializing in for the past decade. While it is certainly true that the Republican Party spent the better portion of a half-century stacking cordwood and pouring fuel on this bonfire, Q Anon is giving it some serious oxygen.

quote:

that they then regurgitate and create their own stories on those themes which serve as the talking point du jour doesn't indicate a conscious direction, it's right wing fanfiction, formed out of a morass of satanic panic and store brand religious imagery and age old racism and nationalism with a side of too many videogames and tom clancy novels, and the fact that all it achieves is chaos suggests that it isn't under anybody's control.

I would argue that the goal is to increase chaos though. If this is indeed Russia then their goal would be to destabilize a foreign adversary by sowing chaos within the target population. It doesn't really matter so much the specifics of exactly how that chaos manifests, it will be injurius to the United States no matter what. This sort of psyop is perfect for sowing the specific kind of confusion amongst a targeted population that Russian psyops have been refining how to foment and exploit for the past decade or so. And for the price of a small crew of 10 people or so (very generous estimate) they would be getting a very high return on their investment in this case.

From this perspective Q Anon would be just a more elaborate form of the exact sort of psychological warfare that we already know that Russia is engaging in against the US via social media and the internet. It would be a natural evolution for what they're already doing.

Prester Jane fucked around with this message at 21:05 on Mar 27, 2018

OwlFancier
Aug 22, 2013

The issue is that a country's dysfunctional political system self destructing because of the shortsightedness of its own political actors works as an explanation without involving Russia. Russia has a different political system so it isn't affected in the same way. What you have is the republicans losing control of their own campaign methods at the same time as capitalism accelerates into crisis across the globe and the prevailing political consensus loses support as a result. All of those things interconnect and may be mutual causes of each other, and all of them create an ideological vacuum which needs occupying as people search for new ways to understand the world and explain why it's the way it is, a sense of resentment against the powerful both in government and out of, and a loss of the ability of the establishment voices to actually control the narrative as people lose faith in them as trusted sources of information.

That leads pretty easily into conspiratorial kookery and far right ideological bents. The end result of posting vaguely right wing conspiracy flavoured extracts from github on the chans is just that everyone starts becoming more conspiratorial, I don't think they're meaningfully directing anyone, it's just that the places they're posted are right wing shitholes and the thinking that goes on there is a gestalt of the general right wing infosphere, so obviously when people start posting their AMAZING DECODINGS of what these posts mean, they do it within that reference, that reference that has been created by elements way bigger than Russia, global changes that were the result of vast forces acting over decades that arguably nobody really controls. But Russia didn't create the political atmosphere we live in, it didn't fill the chans full of broke brained pseudonazis, and it didn't create the long and proud tradition of insane conspiracy theories and right wing paranoia that have been hallmarks of the US political scene for a very long time. It also didn't collapse the western political consensus or push its economy into crisis. All of that basically just happened. If it's under anyone's control it's quite a lot of people who probably aren't really cooperating with each other.

It's not the person throwing the matches that's responsible for the fire, as you say, when the fuel's been stacked up for decades. Though I would argue this is more like someone throwing petrol bombs into an ongoing forest fire. Sure technically it's contributing but really what's already there is pretty horrible to begin with. Even if you find out that Russia secretly employed the petrol bomber, getting rid of them isn't going to solve the problem.

OwlFancier fucked around with this message at 21:23 on Mar 27, 2018

TapTheForwardAssist
Apr 9, 2007

Pretty Little Lyres
I've been casually dropping into r/greatawakening and its hilarious watching them rationalize their way around anything that contradicts the Q narrative. For example, Q has supposedly indicated that Hilary Clinton has been indicted and is under house arrest, but then why has she been on a public speaking tour in India? Among the theories are
a) she's skipped town and gone to a country less-likely to extradite her (though India has had an extradition treaty with the US since 1997
b) Trump has cunningly *let* her go to India because it'll be easier to send the SEALs to black-bag her and extraordinary rendition her to GITMO, with the added possibility that somehow arresting her in the US would lead to rioting in the streets but snatching her from Mumbai would be no biggie.

As always, it's applicable to take a look at the Wikipedia article on When Prophecy Fails, a scholarly examination of a UFO cult in Chicago that was awaiting the end of the world, and what happened to them when the world obviously didn't end.

quote:

Festinger and his colleagues infiltrated Keech's group and reported the following sequence of events:

Before December 20. The group shuns publicity. Interviews are given only grudgingly. Access to Keech's house is only provided to those who can convince the group that they are true believers. The group evolves a belief system—provided by the automatic writing from the planet Clarion—to explain the details of the cataclysm, the reason for its occurrence, and the manner in which the group would be saved from the disaster.
December 20. The group expects a visitor from outer space to call upon them at midnight and to escort them to a waiting spacecraft. As instructed, the group goes to great lengths to remove all metallic items from their persons. As midnight approaches, zippers, bra straps, and other objects are discarded. The group waits.
12:05 am, December 21. No visitor. Someone in the group notices that another clock in the room shows 11:55. The group agrees that it is not yet midnight.
12:10 am. The second clock strikes midnight. Still no visitor. The group sits in stunned silence. The cataclysm itself is no more than seven hours away.
4:00 am. The group has been sitting in stunned silence. A few attempts at finding explanations have failed. Keech begins to cry.
4:45 am. Another message by automatic writing is sent to Keech. It states, in effect, that the God of Earth has decided to spare the planet from destruction. The cataclysm has been called off: "The little group, sitting all night long, had spread so much light that God had saved the world from destruction."
Afternoon, December 21. Newspapers are called; interviews are sought. In a reversal of its previous distaste for publicity, the group begins an urgent campaign to spread its message to as broad an audience as possible.

I'm just inordinately tickled that when an alien failed to come to the Chosen, their immediate reaction was "well, maybe that clock is fast..."

Prester Jane
Nov 4, 2008

by Hand Knit

OwlFancier posted:

It's not the person throwing the matches that's responsible for the fire, as you say, when the fuel's been stacked up for decades. Though I would argue this is more like someone throwing petrol bombs into an ongoing forest fire. Sure technically it's contributing but really what's already there is pretty horrible to begin with.

On this point I think we are in full agreement. I think where we disagree is that the person throwing the petrol knows what they are doing and has an agenda, and that the person throwing petrol isn't acting alone. Russia's just exploiting a mess we ourselves created, we already know that they're doing this in a wide variety of ways, Q Anon would just be a moderate evolution in everything they are already doing. (One more way they're trying to destabilise our country.) If Q Anon's pushed narratives were not aligning so perfectly with Russian propaganda goals, and if Russian propaganda outfits were not clearly supporting Q anon from time to time ( to say nothing of the fact that the rwm figures pushing Q Anon are the more Russia connected ones) I would be of the opinion that this was all just the work of a very talented troll. However everything taken in context points very strongly to Russia in my view.

For example here is Alex Jones telling you very plainly that he is a self-aware Russian stooge:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9qX5ZbZJrY4

And we have the fact that info awards has word for word republished over a thousand RT articles over the past three years without so much as a peep of complaint from RT ( they have play dries material from practically everyone, but RT is by far the biggest source they steal from):

Observer: Alex Jones stole content from kremlin-backed Russia Today.


The Observer posted:

The Russian state-sponsored website Russia Today (RT), the self-proclaimed “first Russian 24/7 English-language news channel which brings the Russian view on global news” provides a fascinating window into what pro-Russian news looks like. Currently boasting headlines like “Putin: US wants to disrupt upcoming Russian election” and “US Congress to spend $4.6 bn for ‘reassuring NATO allies’ as anti-Russia hysteria mounts,” the site spins information (or misinformation), drawing self-described “paleoconservative” InfoWars’ Alex Jones. As it turns, Jones’s far-right fandom may have gone a step too far.

As reported by Buzzfeed News, InfoWars re-published over 1,000 RT articles within the past three years without the Kremlin-backed outlet’s permission. InfoWars’ plagiarism is evidenced by data from Buzzsumo, a social tracking website that monitors content as it is shared online. Although InfoWars included credits in the articles’ bylines, a representative from RT told Buzzfeed that they did not receive permission to perpetuate such content.


The FBI has been investigating collusion between Infowars, Breitbart, and Russia Today since last spring:

McClatchy D.C. Bureau posted:


Operatives for Russia appear to have strategically timed the computer commands, known as “bots,” to blitz social media with links to the pro-Trump stories at times when the billionaire businessman was on the defensive in his race against Democrat Hillary Clinton, these sources said.

The bots’ end products were largely millions of Twitter and Facebook posts carrying links to stories on conservative internet sites such as Breitbart News and InfoWars, as well as on the Kremlin-backed RT News and Sputnik News, the sources said. Some of the stories were false or mixed fact and fiction, said the sources, who spoke on condition of anonymity because the bot attacks are part of an FBI-led investigation into a multifaceted Russian operation to influence last year’s elections.



And finally here we have Alex Jones Shilling for Q Anon and clearly tying this all together it is narratives that favor Russian propaganda objectives:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K6BXPFZjK2s


So while I definitely could be wrong, I don't think it's much of a leap for Russia to be behind Q Anon. In all honesty I think it's a Perfectly Natural Evolution of everything we already know that they're doing. It makes sense that they would be continuing to experiment and finding more successful/elaborate ways to destabilise a target population by manipulating the narratives that dominate the political discussions of that target population.

Prester Jane fucked around with this message at 21:59 on Mar 27, 2018

Luigi's Discount Porn Bin
Jul 19, 2000


Oven Wrangler

Prester Jane posted:

For example here is Alex Jones telling you very plainly that he is a self-aware Russian stooge:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9qX5ZbZJrY4
He certainly flies into a roid rage about Schiff calling him a Russian stooge, but I don't see how you're getting "yes, I'm a Russian stooge" from this.

It's certainly possible that Russia's behind Q or that, per Uglycat, it's some kind of targeted gangstalking operation. But I'm not sure this is a necessary explanation. I don't think there's much question that the Russians benefit from destabilizing narratives and right-wing radicalization in the US, but the "cui bono" question isn't enough. You have to go further than that, and further than the general impression of hidden agency, or you're falling into the same bias-governed conspiracy trap as QAnon's target audience. The question should be, what's the best explanation given the available phenomena? What's the balance of probabilities of "Q is a weaponized Russian-backed internet prophecy sockpuppet cult" versus "one of a thousand fly-by-night 4chan insider LARPers developed a following and decided to run with it"? I think the latter sounds totally plausible. A large effect doesn't always mean a proportionately large cause - this is a cognitive bias as well. Meanwhile, Q seems to have a much better command of the English language than the usual confirmed Russian propaganda efforts. Maybe you can chalk this up to his usual stilted writing style, but he definitely seems to be a few cuts above "Woke Blacks" and the like.

Prester Jane
Nov 4, 2008

by Hand Knit

Luigi's Discount Porn Bin posted:

He certainly flies into a roid rage about Schiff calling him a Russian stooge, but I don't see how you're getting "yes, I'm a Russian stooge" from this.

Clinical narcissists like Alex Jones (it came out during his divorce hearing that he has a formal diagnosis of NPD) have a very particular way of reacting when you accuse them of something that they are both guilty of very afraid of being found out for. Specifically, they have that reaction. More or less every time. If you have experience dealing with narcissists , that video is one hell of an obvious tell.


quote:



It's certainly possible that Russia's behind Q or that, per Uglycat, it's some kind of targeted gangstalking operation. But I'm not sure this is a necessary explanation. I don't think there's much question that the Russians benefit from destabilizing narratives and right-wing radicalization in the US, but the "cui bono" question isn't enough. You have to go further than that, and further than the general impression of hidden agency, or you're falling into the same bias-governed conspiracy trap as QAnon's target audience. The question should be, what's the best explanation given the available phenomena? What's the balance of probabilities of "Q is a weaponized Russian-backed internet prophecy sockpuppet cult" versus "one of a thousand fly-by-night 4chan insider LARPers developed a following and decided to run with it"? I think the latter sounds totally plausible. A large effect doesn't always mean a proportionately large cause - this is a cognitive bias as well. Meanwhile, Q seems to have a much better command of the English language than the usual confirmed Russian propaganda efforts. Maybe you can chalk this up to his usual stilted writing style, but he definitely seems to be a few cuts above "Woke Blacks" and the like.


Necessary explanation? No. But in my view it is very much the most probable one based on the context in which this is all occurring. Also based on my experiences having fallen for several examples of the Nostradamus Shuffle myself over the years, and having Bend The Insider of a cult Network that was at one point discussing amongst ourselves how to execute this exact scam. Based on my experiences Q Anon is more than a little bit beyond what you would expect to see from just some random genius troll.

I am fully grant you that Q Anon's writing is a cut bove what you see from the average bottom tier Russian troll, but that also makes sense because Q Anon wouldn't be a bottom tier Russian operative. It would require at least one individual with both the requisite psychological toolkit to create the gibberish posts that supporters fawns over as well as enough insight into the American psyche to target it so well.

dpf
Sep 17, 2011

Uglycat posted:

There was a day when the facebook discordian group lost 20,000 accounts overnight. It was a few months back. There was a large network of facebook sockpuppets that used that group to build their credibility as 'real actual humans.'

Those casualties were likely just successful Discordians.

Renaissance Spam
Jun 5, 2010

Can it wait a for a bit? I'm in the middle of some *gyrations*


I think I lean more towards this being an individual or small group running Q Anon; creating an inner story that other conspiracy theorists have bought into.

PJ you described how when you were in your otherkin cult the group would reaffirm certain concepts or ideas in order to establish their own stories and I think something like that is happening here; someone with a tenuous hold on reality (or perhaps a desire for attention) started the Q posts, possibly in hopes of eliciting some kind of action from the audience and as people bought in they evolved the concept, leaning into the theories in order to reaffirm their role as a mysterious deep operative.

I definitely can see the potential for the Russian angle but I think the password and the fact Q posts promote reverse engineering and passive activity ("oh this is what Q meant" or "don't worry everyone, Trump is gonna fix it") it feels less like an active operation and more someone playing into a fantasy.

Prester Jane
Nov 4, 2008

by Hand Knit

Renaissance Spam posted:


PJ you described how when you were in your otherkin cult the group would reaffirm certain concepts or ideas in order to establish their own stories and I think something like that is happening here; someone with a tenuous hold on reality (or perhaps a desire for attention) started the Q posts, possibly in hopes of eliciting some kind of action from the audience and as people bought in they evolved the concept, leaning into the theories in order to reaffirm their role as a mysterious deep operative.

FWIW that is more or less exactly what I thought the first dozen or so times I ran across Q Anon material, it was only after observeing Q Anon for several months that I came to the conclusion that it was very likely a Russian psyop.


quote:

the fact Q posts promote reverse engineering and passive activity ("oh this is what Q meant" or "don't worry everyone, Trump is gonna fix it") it feels less like an active operation and more someone playing into a fantasy.
I understand what you are saying here and it's not that you're technically wrong, it's more that you are approaching this from a position of not understanding how how manipulators or large-scale manipulations operate on a practical level. ( Ironically you are being too rational about this and rational thinking is a serious impediment to understanding the world of the pathological)

The "reverse engineering" behavior is a key feature of the Nostradamus Hustle and is a vital part of how this sort of psychological manipulation functions. You need people constantly going back to your gibberish looking for a fresh hit of Narrative Validation. I would ask you to go back and watch the earlier posted video of the woman describing her thought processes as she has her belief inQ Anon affirmed. She's getting a dopamine rush, she's basically getting high off of this, and while it's not as powerful as a drug high it's still a very addictive emotional experience that can create a dependency. Building that dependency is a key feature of how the Nostradamus Shuffle works- whenever your target audience is feeling insecure they come back to your material for a fresh dose of the feel goods.

And that is also all that a hypothetical Russian operative would really need to achieve here. Just give as many people as possible a path to living in their delusions and becoming emotionally dependent on your material for doing so. If you achieve that your target population will inevitably continue radicalizing and causing disruption for everyone around them , especially once the delusion is eventually removed from them. They will react like addicts who have just had their stash taken from them, and it is not going to be pretty.

Everything else beyond that is just gravy. There doesn't need to be a specific plan or detailed objective for the future except to take advantage of whatever opportunities organically arise. Narrativists will inevitably sow chaos into any culture or population in which they managed to gain significant control. The boring narrative it's you have, and the more Compaction Cycles said Narrativists have undergone the more chaos they are inevitably going to create for everyone who has to deal with them in real life.

One way of looking at this is that Russia is essentially playing what is called "positional chess", they don't have any specific or a detailed strategy they're just making very good moves and waiting for opportunities to exploit to emerge from their opponents mistakes. Fanning the Flames of radicalization of the United States with something as simple as an internet deception operated by a small handful of individuals would be a very good positional move.

I hope this debate isn't derailing the thread too much and if it is I'll stop, but in defending this position I've been steadily accruing some interesting little bits of information that seem to support my general thesis here. For example this political article I have some interesting tidbits.

Politico: Russia pushes more "Deep State" hashtags. posted:



The Hamilton 68 dashboard launched in August to track activity in a network of 600 Twitter accounts identified as being Russian-influenced. Some of those accounts are official Russian state propaganda, like RT or Sputnik; others are bots; and still others are independent voices consistently sympathetic to the Kremlin. While these 600 accounts represent just a fraction of Russian-influenced activity on Twitter, the idea is that they can provide insight into larger Kremlin efforts.

Typically, Schafer said, activity within the network of accounts has two purposes: first, to promote divisive social issues — whether around race or religion or abortion — and, second, to then hook followers onto accounts tweeting about them. That way, messages about issues important to the Kremlin, like Syria or Ukraine, can be mixed in.


........


Going forward, Morgan said he would be particularly watching the #qanon hashtag, also called “The Storm,” which refers to a wild “deep state” conspiracy theory that has grown popular in the far reaches of 4chan’s message boards. The theory, apparently originally posted by an anonymous commenter called “Q,” is a reference to an October 2017 reference Trump made about the “calm before the storm,” and posits, among other things, that the president has set in motion a plan designed to take out the deep state forces currently arrayed against him and arrest Obama, former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and Sen. John McCain.


[URL=https://www.reddit.com/r/TopMindsOfReddit/comments/7osggb/topminds_too_woke_to_realize_whos_pushing_this_q/] I also came across these interesting quotes about the (now-closed) official Q Anon Forum on Reddit:


Reddit thread about Russian bots pushing the Q Anon hashtag posted:


So.

Brand new sub appears and grows by around 800-1k members per day. Many of the accounts were started at the same time, are brand new, and they're posting well over 200 new threads per day and thousands of comments. I have never seen a sub grow this quickly.

Within a couple of weeks of this sub beginning, the moderators of this sub (that claim to be in direct contact with "Q") land an interview on Infowars. The moderators have brand new accounts when this interview occurs. A couple of days after the Infowars interview, Alex Jones shills for the sub and the moderators on his personal Twitter feed.

And now a week later, Russian government shill accounts are pushing ""Q" hard.

What an odd series of coincidence.


Same thread posted:

A lot of the posters on the cbts subreddit seem to be older (50s and 60s) and very religious. They seem to be new to Reddit and are not technologically savvy and constantly make religious references.

I definitely think that Russians are pushing the Q narrative (evidenced by the securing democracy data) but I think that we are seeing the demographic that is being reached by this conspiracy mongering

Same thread. posted:


I'm still not convinced that those are real people behind those accounts to be honest. Real in the sense that they're posting, but not real in that I think the vast majority are bots and/or paid trolls.

I think you're right on target though regarding the demographic that's being targeted, which is older people and Baby Boomers. That's a theme that they're pushing really, really hard along with the religious bullshit. There's an apocalyptic, end of times, take up arms tone that I'm seeing too....... It's a nasty combination, really dangerous rhetoric.

quote:

It would have to be an alt right supporter that has a ton of free time, programming ability, in depth experience in social media manipulation, and connections to Alex Jones and Infowars. And that's not taking in the possibility that these are trolls, not bots. If those are trolls someone is compensating them, and that takes money. And even then, how much manpower does it take to create 800 bots per day? Is that something a single person can do in their parents basement?

And then there's the issue of Russian government shill accounts picking it up and making it their number one hashtag. At the very least that indicates that the Russian government is aware of the "Q" conspiracy, and has taken steps to amplify it using their shill accounts.

I went and found the reference interview with the CBTS mods, the actual interview starts at about 6 minutes 30 seconds in.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RT9H4EA31s4

This just doesn't look like an organic grassroots upwelling of crazy to me, this looks like a very elaborate form of manufactured consent. Interested to hear Uglycat's thoughts on all this.

Prester Jane
Nov 4, 2008

by Hand Knit
Finding more interesting tidbits that seem to indicate that Q Anon is a Russian psyop.

Media Matters: Major fake news website YourNewsWire cites "The Storm" conspiracy theory to push fake stories.

Media Matters posted:

A fake news website that has been classified as a Russian proxy by European Union officials is claiming that a 4chan user who purports to be from the White House was its source for a story.

On January 31, following a collision between a train carrying Republican members of Congress and a garbage truck in Virginia, YourNewsWire published a fake story headlined “White House: GOP Train Crash Was ‘Deep State’ Assassination Attempt” that claimed “White House sources” had told it that the incident “was a false flag orchestrated by the Deep State in an attempt to avoid the release of the FISA Abuse memo.” The article added, “According to QAnon, the White House staffer who has predicted the future with remarkable accuracy in the last two months, the Deep State is running scared and attempting to cover its tracks.” And on Twitter, in response to a user who questioned the accuracy of the article, the website’s Twitter account responded, “QAnon is the White House source.”

........


“QAnon” refers to a conspiracy theory known as “The Storm” that started making rounds on 4chan and 8chan message boards late last year. The conspiracy theory claims that a person known as “Q” who claims to be a “high-level government insider” has been writing posts, or “crumbs,” to “covertly inform the public about POTUS’s master plan to stage a countercoup against members of the deep state.” The scope of the conspiracy theory has now expanded to include all kinds of events, such as the fire at Trump Tower in early January, and has even been invoked to accuse model Chrissy Teigen and her husband, singer John Legend, of pedophilia.

This is at least the second time the website has cited QAnon for a fake story. On January 4, it claimed in a fake story that according to QAnon, “Trump’s recent announcement that he is going after high profile child traffickers is directly linked to” a fire on the estate of Bill and Hillary Clinton (Trump has also made no such announcement). YourNewsWire has also claimed that certain events were “predicted by QAnon,” has promoted conspiracy theory website Infowars’ hyping “The Storm,” and has embedded tweets pushing the conspiracy theory in its articles.

YourNewsWire, which was founded in 2014 and is based in Los Angeles, has come under fire for repeatedly publishing fake stories such as the Centers for Disease Control claiming that the flu shot was causing a “deadly flu epidemic,” a dying former MI5 agent confessing to killing Princess Diana, and actor Keanu Reeves claiming that Hollywood uses babies’ blood to get high. Some of YourNewsWire’s fake stories were some of the most viral fake stories of 2017, according to a BuzzFeed study. The website has also been classified as a Russian proxy by the European Union's East StratCom Task Force, a task force established to fight Russian propaganda.

I readily admit that nothing I have presented here is Smoking Gun proof, but I feel there is nonetheless a very strong case to be made that the most likely culprit behind Q Anon is Russia. At the very least Russian psyops certainly seem to be acting like Q Anon one of their own, and Q Anon certainly goes out of his way to promote Russian narratives about pretty much everything.

Cactus
Jun 24, 2006

It's Snowden :tinfoil:

hobbesmaster
Jan 28, 2008

Cactus posted:

It's Snowden :tinfoil:

Snowden being bored and trolling 4chan leading to massive conspiracy theories would be the best.

TapTheForwardAssist
Apr 9, 2007

Pretty Little Lyres
More crumbs!

quote:

976
Mar 28 2018 22:14:46
Q
!xowAT4Z3VQ
825890
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/201...estigators.html
Wonder who leaked this.
Fire in the hole.
Q

977
Mar 28 2018 22:16:18
Anonymous
825909
>>825890

Seeing a lot of your leaks lately friend!

Good to have a friend leaker for once!
Mar 28 2018 22:17:17
Q
!xowAT4Z3VQ
825929
>>825909
HRC 2.12.09
Very BAD!
Q

978
Mar 28 2018 22:20:40
Anonymous
825987
>>825929
>>824969
Did you see codemonkeys message?
Mar 28 2018 22:22:25
Q
!xowAT4Z3VQ
826012
>>825987
/GA/ is dead.
Q

Bip Roberts
Mar 29, 2005

goddamn this dudes thing is dumb as hell

TapTheForwardAssist
Apr 9, 2007

Pretty Little Lyres

quote:

HRC 2.12.09
Very BAD!

The QTards are trying to figure out what happened on either 2 December 2009 or 12 February 2009.

One popular guess is that there was a plane crash in New York state on 12 February 2009 that killed a human rights activist who worked on Rwanda:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colgan_Air_Flight_3407

quote:

Alison Des Forges, a human rights investigator and an expert on the Rwandan genocide. ...
...she worked as a researcher on Rwanda for Human Rights Watch in the years before 1994; when the genocide began, she alerted the world to the danger that threatened Rwandans like her friend Monique Mujawamariya, who managed to escape Hutu killers partly through Des Forges’ efforts on her behalf; in the early weeks of the genocide she lobbied the Clinton White House, unsuccessfully, to intervene (according to Samantha Power’s “A Problem from Hell,” Clinton’s national security advisor, Anthony Lake, replied to Des Forges’ urgings, “Make more noise!”); she later documented the genocide as extensively as any other writer, in her 1999 book Leave None to Tell the Story

To hear the right wing go on about it, you'd think that Hillary Clinton is the third-leading cause of death in the US, slightly behind heart disease and cancer.

TapTheForwardAssist
Apr 9, 2007

Pretty Little Lyres
For an alleged high-level covert operative, Q spends a buttload of time hand-holding worried suburbanites:




EDIT: apparently "/GA/" is assumed to be "Great Awakening" so this is some kind of rumble in the Q community that Q's internet presence is under cyber-attack or something, thus the freaking out across multiple boards and channels.


This is way too complicated to figure out, but I idly wonder what the economic impact of Q is, given that a bunch of the YouTube analyses, blog pages, etc. are all selling ad-space. Given how huge this is to a fuckload of idiots, I woudn't be surprised if this is getting into the millions of dollars of ad revenue spread out over a large number of accounts. I mean it's not centralized or something where "Q" would personally be drawing in a large chunk of the money, but it's providing right wing welfare beer-money to a small army of pundits.

I'm baffled that people are getting tons of views for *30 loving minute* videos where they ramble about individual Q drops. So a non-zero number of people are spending hours looking at a screen of memes and news-clippings while some mouthbreather speculates wildly.

TapTheForwardAssist fucked around with this message at 05:41 on Mar 29, 2018

Gazpacho
Jun 18, 2004

by Fluffdaddy
Slippery Tilde
I got confused and thought this thread was about the "you take 'em to court!" guy.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Lote
Aug 5, 2001

Place your bets

TapTheForwardAssist posted:

The QTards are trying to figure out what happened on either 2 December 2009 or 12 February 2009.

One popular guess is that there was a plane crash in New York state on 12 February 2009 that killed a human rights activist who worked on Rwanda:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colgan_Air_Flight_3407


To hear the right wing go on about it, you'd think that Hillary Clinton is the third-leading cause of death in the US, slightly behind heart disease and cancer.

Basically any date you come up with around late 08 or early 09 will have some significance wrt Clinton if you look hard enough.

Life is full of coincidences. My mother’s good friend from high school worked in the Pentagon in the outer ring with an outside window where the plane hit on 9/11. Luckily, he had a government trip that morning, and he didn’t go into his office. He got on a flight to LAX instead — AA77. :eng99:

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply