Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
Some Guy TT
Aug 30, 2011

a very short history-
before 1895- bunch of stuff only history nerds are gonna care about and isn't really relevant today i don't want to see anyone bring up neo-confucianism unless you're making fun of some dumb article the last unified government was called joseon for reference
after 1895- japan takes over because late joseon really really sucked and pisses most of the koreans off but not the top ten percent who become collaborators and are still hated to this day

SOUTH

1945-1948- united states takes over after world war ii and because they are ignorant racist morons assume that the koreans actually enjoyed being a colony it doesn't help that the only people who know how to speak english are collaborators and syngman rhee who figures out that the united states will let him murder whoever he wants as long as he says theyre communists
1948-1953- syngman rhee manages to piss everyone off with his random political murders but luckily the korean war happens at which point his fall back defense of blaming communists for every bad thing in the universe becomes somewhat more plausible
1953-1960- everyone discovers that syngman rhee is a moron when it comes to administrating anything thats not a death squad and becomes senile to the point that people just start ignoring him mostly because he keeps wanting to restart the korean war
1961-1979- park chung hee comes to power and uses his powers of incredible deductive brilliance to conclude that protectionist economies are good which of course no democratically elected leader could have ever figured out even though literally everyone in the country was taught about this in japanese administered schools
1980- 1987- up until here the united states had been pretty good about convincing south koreans that they actually needed a dictator and could have democracy later when they were more mature but then chun doo-hwan shows up and just acts like an rear end in a top hat for no reason but we back him anyway and welp thats pretty much the main reason why anti-americanism even exists in south korea now
1987-1997- in between the end of the cold war and the seoul olympics the united states realizes they can't realistically back a dictator again so democracy happens but woops the first two presidents end up being right wing assholes
1997-2007- kim dae jung goes from former democracy activist to president but frustratingly doesn't dismantle as much of the governments worst institutions as was expected roh moo hyeon puts more effort to it but gets knifed in the back by basically everybody
2007-2017- lee myung bak becomes president and tries to undo the country's democratic progress but is limited by having to use normal police instead of soldiers because shooting at protestors is now considered impolite park geun hye is elected almost entirely on a platform of first woman president (SOUND FAMILIAR) and turns out to be an even dumber version of lee myung bak who is even more widely hated by everyone except her cult of personality which consists of septagenerians who to this day wander the streets of seoul every weekend waving american flags because shes park chung hees daughter
2017-2018- roh moo hyeon's old buddy moon jae in becomes president and starts locking people up in as decorously a fashion as he can to the wild cheers of the crowd who are becoming increasingly annoyed that he is not instituting full communism now no not north korean communism the good kind of communism speaking of which

NORTH

1945-1948- soviet union comes in and observes that everyone hates japan so they put kim il sung in charge because he hates japan too
1948-1953- kim il sung works really hard to get people to like him by putting collaborators in jail and passing popular laws unlike syngman rhee kim il sung actually knew how to administer worth a poo poo so north korea was the obvious winner in the frankly inevitable civil war that followed but we couldnt have anything like that
1953-1994- north korea continues to be communist and they invent juche which is mostly just posthoc rationalization for their continued power they then proceed to very impolitely refuse to collapse like the rest of the communist countries did at the end of the cold war so the united states refuses to recognize their existence and north korea starts building nukes mostly just to make us pay attention to them
1994-2011- kim il sung dies and his son kim jung il signs the agreed framework which doesn't go anywhere then he tries teaming up with kim dae jung to bring sunshine to the world which doesnt work because neither kim dae jung nor roh moo hyeon are willing to tell george bush to gently caress off then lee myung bak comes to power and we stop pretending like peace is even a theoretical goal anymore
2011-2018- kim jeong eun comes to power and initiates economic reforms that have vastly improved the living standards of most north korean people no im serious you dumb loving trolls even the un reports admit this anyway he is now trying to take advantage of trumps ego to work out normalized relations and the media is busy telling us how this is very bad because we should want to have an unambiguous undefined relationship with a country that loves to talk up how much it wants to nuke us

DISCUSS

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Baloogan
Dec 5, 2004
Fun Shoe

IWW Online Branch
Apr 20, 2016

by Nyc_Tattoo
https://www.belovedshirts.com/products/kim-jong-un-sweatshirt

Peanut President
Nov 5, 2008

by Athanatos

(and can't post for 15 days!)

I don't know anything about korea but I wanted to offer a non-shitpost and also ask why South Korea is completely loving insane

Fat-Lip-Sum-41.mp3
Nov 15, 2003
The news loves stories of Kim Jong Un executing people with military hardware but did any of this poo poo actually happen?

http://www.foxnews.com/world/2017/09/20/kim-jong-un-plucks-teen-sex-slaves-from-schools-north-korean-defector-reveals.html

I mean this girl says her whole school was ushered to the loving soccer field to see a dozen people lashed to AA guns and blown apart.

R. Guyovich
Dec 25, 1991

Fat-Lip-Sum-41.mp3 posted:

The news loves stories of Kim Jong Un executing people with military hardware but did any of this poo poo actually happen?

http://www.foxnews.com/world/2017/09/20/kim-jong-un-plucks-teen-sex-slaves-from-schools-north-korean-defector-reveals.html

I mean this girl says her whole school was ushered to the loving soccer field to see a dozen people lashed to AA guns and blown apart.

defectors are paid huge sums of money for their stories and the more outrageous the stories the more money they get.

Red and Black
Sep 5, 2011

The myth of consensual reintegration

North Korea: "I consent."

South Korea: "I consent."

United States: "I don't."

Isn't there someone you forgot to ask?

https://twitter.com/TimothyS/status/1035162138090848257

Darkman Fanpage
Jul 4, 2012

Fat-Lip-Sum-41.mp3 posted:

The news loves stories of Kim Jong Un executing people with military hardware but did any of this poo poo actually happen?

http://www.foxnews.com/world/2017/09/20/kim-jong-un-plucks-teen-sex-slaves-from-schools-north-korean-defector-reveals.html

I mean this girl says her whole school was ushered to the loving soccer field to see a dozen people lashed to AA guns and blown apart.

quote:

In what heinous example, she recalled standing in a crowd of 10,000 people assembled to watch the execution of 11 musicians who allegedly made a pornographic video. Security guards ordered the viewers to leave their classes and stand in a stadium around the men, who were tied up and gagged

how is this different from what evangelical christians would do if they had their way?

Bastaman Vibration
Jun 26, 2005

i didnt become familiar with tim shorrock's reporting until years back, and man oh man did that change the way my younger former shitlib self felt about the situation. best Corea reporter ever

Calibanibal
Aug 25, 2015

how is this different from what i would do if i had my way

Red and Black
Sep 5, 2011

I think a lot about this tweet

https://twitter.com/CSISKoreaChair/status/1006278197690994689

Some Guy TT
Aug 30, 2011

Peanut President posted:

I don't know anything about korea but I wanted to offer a non-shitpost and also ask why South Korea is completely loving insane

could you be more specific because theres lots of different things you could be referring to there


just a reminder that actual honest to god chuds cheer for trump at rallies whenever he talks about how great he is for ratcheting down tensions with north korea

who the hell is "peace treaties actually bad" supposed to appeal to if even the chuds arent going for it

Algund Eenboom
May 4, 2014

https://twitter.com/isgoodrum/status/1006197035588964352

Victory Position
Mar 16, 2004

Some Guy TT posted:

a very short history-
before 1895- a Korean king gifts a really sick sword

ftfy

R. Guyovich
Dec 25, 1991


i was gonna post the thread in the first reply here. it's good.

Fat-Lip-Sum-41.mp3
Nov 15, 2003

The excerpts in this "let's trick millennials into reading a book" thread are from Peasant Protest & Social Change in Colonial Korea by Gi-Wook Shin, right?

Plutonis
Mar 25, 2011

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ybRXKeWdII

Famous TV Dad
Nov 1, 2011

i remember watching a great academic talk around the time kim jong-un took over that was about how the regime in NK came about, its mindset, and why it does what it does. it was awesome and i wish i could find it again.

Some Guy TT
Aug 30, 2011

R. Guyovich posted:

defectors are paid huge sums of money for their stories and the more outrageous the stories the more money they get.

where they sell the stories is also important there are way more north korean defectors in south korean media to the point there are entire variety shows centered around the gimmick but the stories they tell are way more subdued because theyre more easily fact checked and also you cant really have a round table discussion about people getting machine gunned in soccer stadiums before people start cringing about how incredibly dumb the story sounds

defectors also disagree between themselves about stuff a lot even in that context because its hard to remember the difference between urban legends and actual facts this isnt some special korea thing either try throwing together some random americans and ask them whether welfare queens are real or whether a woman really sued mcdonalds for spilling coffee on herself or whether the government knew about 9/11 ahead of time and youre going to get all kinds of crazy answers


idiots who think political barriers can be breached via pop culture need to be forced to watch this clockwork orange style

i really really really hate the meme of how hallyu wave is going to cultural conversion north korea into good hardworking capitalists you get this because a lot of defector narratives go "i was starving then i saw a south korean tv show where people had food" and shallow dumbasses choose to believe the second half of that sentence is the important part

Riot Bimbo
Dec 28, 2006


I think it was a Vox video about NK i watched a year or two ago that talked about some of the cultural elements of Juche as being directly inherited from Japanese imperialism, including the racial stuff that runs as an undercurrent through it.

I never know if i should trust Vox, but is that roghly true? Does the structure of Juche owe a bit to Japanese occupation?

coathat
May 21, 2007

dinoputz posted:

i didnt become familiar with tim shorrock's reporting until years back, and man oh man did that change the way my younger former shitlib self felt about the situation. best Corea reporter ever

He’s cool and is the undisputed king of the boomers

ScipioAfro
Feb 21, 2011
why do western libs hold up macron or trudeau as center left poster boys when moon exists? If i wanted to be like “no full communism now is bad, lots can be achieved with reform/electoral politics!!!” then moon is a much better example, but i see zero new yorker prices about him or whatever.

etalian
Mar 20, 2006

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kMi7Jkay0fY

Pener Kropoopkin
Jan 30, 2013

ScipioAfro posted:

why do western libs hold up macron or trudeau as center left poster boys when moon exists? If i wanted to be like “no full communism now is bad, lots can be achieved with reform/electoral politics!!!” then moon is a much better example, but i see zero new yorker prices about him or whatever.

Because Moon is too left wing for them.

coathat
May 21, 2007

ScipioAfro posted:

why do western libs hold up macron or trudeau as center left poster boys when moon exists? If i wanted to be like “no full communism now is bad, lots can be achieved with reform/electoral politics!!!” then moon is a much better example, but i see zero new yorker prices about him or whatever.

Because they are opposed to peace in Korea.

A Gnarlacious Bro
Apr 25, 2007

by Jeffrey of YOSPOS

Some Guy TT posted:

could you be more specific because theres lots of different things you could be referring to there


just a reminder that actual honest to god chuds cheer for trump at rallies whenever he talks about how great he is for ratcheting down tensions with north korea

who the hell is "peace treaties actually bad" supposed to appeal to if even the chuds arent going for it

Liberals

Riot Bimbo
Dec 28, 2006


The only reason dems soured on the iraq war was because of political opportunism against Bush and the troop surge that happened under obama should prove that. Dems loving love war and are only somewhat restrained by an anti war base but they ignore that as much as they can

etalian
Mar 20, 2006

basic hitler posted:

I think it was a Vox video about NK i watched a year or two ago that talked about some of the cultural elements of Juche as being directly inherited from Japanese imperialism, including the racial stuff that runs as an undercurrent through it.

I never know if i should trust Vox, but is that roghly true? Does the structure of Juche owe a bit to Japanese occupation?

It was the cleanest race:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TDm4KSGn8Sw

Basically Imperial Japan Co East Asia Prosperity Sphere was responsible for many Juche ideals especially racial exceptionalism beliefs.

Red and Black
Sep 5, 2011

basic hitler posted:

I never know if i should trust Vox, but is that roghly true? Does the structure of Juche owe a bit to Japanese occupation?

I'm pretty sure this is just a dumb theory peddled by B R Meyers that most historians disagree with

etalian
Mar 20, 2006

The parody account is always amazing

https://twitter.com/DPRK_News/status/1034297157296287744

https://twitter.com/DPRK_News/status/1033086800259104769

https://twitter.com/DPRK_News/status/1028026352140779521

etalian
Mar 20, 2006

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eCKSR0JArUQ

Algund Eenboom
May 4, 2014


It's actually run by some weirdo democrat who hates North Koreans

bob dobbs is dead
Oct 8, 2017

I love peeps
Nap Ghost

Algund Eenboom posted:

It's actually run by some weirdo democrat who hates North Koreans

isnt it popehat dude

Algund Eenboom
May 4, 2014

It is in fact run by an ultracatholic libertarian

https://web.archive.org/web/20180211194529/https://twitter.com/DPRK_News/status/962443069659459584

https://web.archive.org/web/20180210170808/https://twitter.com/dprk_news/status/962365629939507200





His astonishing argument seems to be that United States media is TOO NICE to North Korea

Typo
Aug 19, 2009

Chernigov Military Aviation Lyceum
The Fighting Slowpokes

Chomskyan posted:

I'm pretty sure this is just a dumb theory peddled by B R Meyers that most historians disagree with

like who

Typo
Aug 19, 2009

Chernigov Military Aviation Lyceum
The Fighting Slowpokes
my favorite part of juche is it was so great and appealing faraway romania tried to copy it

Typo
Aug 19, 2009

Chernigov Military Aviation Lyceum
The Fighting Slowpokes

basic hitler posted:

I think it was a Vox video about NK i watched a year or two ago that talked about some of the cultural elements of Juche as being directly inherited from Japanese imperialism, including the racial stuff that runs as an undercurrent through it.

I never know if i should trust Vox, but is that roghly true? Does the structure of Juche owe a bit to Japanese occupation?

it's likely cuz lots of ppl who started the dprk went to school in japanese occupied korea, but I suspect at the end of the day ethno-nationalist states only has a few available variants so dprk just happened to have one which resembles 1940s era japansese fascism

etalian
Mar 20, 2006

Chaebols are pretty cyberpunk especially how in S Korea Samsung owns random stuff like amusement parks and hotels.

Typo
Aug 19, 2009

Chernigov Military Aviation Lyceum
The Fighting Slowpokes

HOLY poo poo HOMEWORKER EXPLAINER IS THIS U????

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Red and Black
Sep 5, 2011

Typo posted:

like who

Ardennes posted:

I am just going to post full thing from proquest.

The Cleanest Race: How North Koreans See Themselves—and Why It Matters
B.R. Myers, Brooklyn, NY: Melville House, 2010. 200 pp. ISBN: 978-1-933633-91-6.
B.R. Myers’s The Cleanest Race is an unreliable work. Beginning with the preface, one
finds misrepresentation. Singling out North Korean Review, Myers makes the incredible claim
that those associated with the journal “do not understand Korean well enough to read [North
Korean] official texts” (12). What is the basis of this allegation when the NKR founder is originally
from South Korea and a significant number of the journal editors and those who have
published in it are native speakers of Korean? Reading requires discernment, but Myers makes
rather odd translation choices, for example, “Homeland Liberation War” for choguk haebang
cho˘njaeng and “jackals” for su˘ngnyangi (39, 40). Choguk literally means “ancestor country,”
which has a male bias. North Korean texts use “fatherland.” Moguk or o˘mo˘ni choguk is motherland.
As for su˘ngyangi, it is a dhole, a species of wild dog found in Korea, unlike the jackal,
chaek’ol or chyak’al in Korean. North Korean sources render su˘ngnyangi in English as “wolf.”
The real problem, however, is Myers’s alleged discovery that North Korean ideology is
rooted in Japanese fascism. Replacing the official Juche ideology with his own idea of “paranoid,
race- based nationalism,” he says, “[North Korea has] an implacably xenophobic, race-
based worldview derived largely from fascist Japanese myth,” and, “They [the Hirohito cult
and Kim Il Sung cult] are fundamentally alike, because they derive from a fundamentally similar
view of the world” (109; emphasis in original). One does not have to be a professional his -
torian or professional logician to see that there is something wrong here. Basically, what Myers
perceives as fascist—a term he uses regularly though simultaneously claims is “too vague to
be much use”—are the conceptions of racial purity, blood- based nationalism, and unity of
nation and territory. None of this, however, is exclusive to fascism, as European thought in
the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries shows. But comparison to Japan must be addressed.
Japanese fascism was ultranationalist and racist, but its xenophobia differs from that of
North Korea. Japan presided aggressively over a multiethnic East Asian empire, and the State
Shinto doctrine of Kokutai, which Myers never explores, ordained Japanese imperialism as a
divine cosmopolitan mission to assimilate and sublimate world culture into Japanese culture.
Moreover, Kokutai made Hirohito a direct descendant of the Shinto gods. North Korean ideology
and the Kim Il Sung personality cult bear no likeness to this whatsoever. Unlike Japanese
fascist ideology, North Korean ideology is built upon exaggerated secular heroic legend,
not myth. Myth involves dragons, fairies, ghosts, goblins, gods, spirits, sprites, incantations,
spells, and so forth. Myth is the world of supernatural beings and phenomena. This is not
generically applicable to the North Korean state legends that Myers lists as “Mother Korea
and her children,” the “parent leader” (Kim Il Sung), the “dear leader” (Kim Jong Il), “foreigners,”
and the “Yankee colony” (South Korea).
Confusion with language, comparative ideology, and myth and legend are not the only
problems in this book. There is also a real failure to understand Korean cultural and political
history. Myers, for instance, casts as “bizarre and comical” anecdotes about Kim Il Sung
acquiring his “best ideas” in his sleep (36). In traditional Korean culture, particularly in peasant
culture and shamanism, dream states bear wisdom. North Korea began as a mostly poor
peasant country with a peasant- majority Workers’ Party of Korea. Although the Soviet
164 NORTH KOREAN REVIEW, SPRING 2012
Army–initiated North Korean system did not place political faith in the peasantry, this was a
decisive social group—exploited, illiterate, and landless—that the party incorporated into
state power based on the united front policy. Myers says in passing, “Little [Japanese] propaganda
reached the illiterate majority of the [Korean] population, who often had to be brutally
coerced into complying with Japanese demands” (28). Yet he never considers how mass
poor- peasant psychology affected ideology.
Myers also neglects Korean Neo-Confucianism, asserting that the North Korean Juche
axiom “Man is the master of all things,” in his translation, is humanist (46). The axiom is an
ancient anthropocentric principle derived from Chinese Confucianism. Myers, however, is
convinced that Confucian thought—which had a more than 500-year history in Choso˘n Korea
from 1392 to 1910—has no carryovers in North Korean ideology. One should note that the
supernatural Kokutai doctrine rejects the idea of humans as masters. As for Soviet Stalinist
influence after the Soviet Army liberation in 1945, it is a non- presence for Myers. This is so
even despite his citing sections of the unpublished manuscript of Tatiana Gabroussenko’s Soldiers
on the Cultural Front, a literary history that proves with empirical evidence that North
Korean literary policy and literature are greatly indebted to Soviet Stalinism and Soviet socialist
realism. Gabroussenko’s findings are never mentioned, for they complicate Myers’s fixation
with the fascist claim.
But Myers not only avoids inconvenient facts. He engages in psychoanalysis when he has
no publication record in the field. “I am not qualified to analyze the cult (or anything else)
from a psychological standpoint,” he says (110). Nevertheless, he goes on to assemble
pastiches of ideas from different psychoanalytic schools—universal archetypes (Jung), her -
maphro ditism and denial of death (Becker), mother fixation (Fromm), and phallic mother
(Freud)—arbitrarily imposing them on North Korea.
In his preface, Myers says, “By far the most common mistake [...] has been the projection
of Western or South Korean values and common sense onto the North Koreans” (73, 75,
80–81, 109, 110). But projection and dismissal are precisely what Myers is doing in The Cleanest
Race. He brushes off all established associations of Communism, Confucianism, and Stalinism
with North Korea as “various fallacies,” never arguing his case, just making assertions
to be accepted on faith. This is dogmatics, not academics. Altogether, everything about North
Korean ideology in this book is about fascist derivation or fascist correspondences. This is a
book full of eclecticism, error, and contradiction. Revealingly, the fundamental claims Myers
makes were first presented in opinion columns and reviews for The Atlantic (2004 and 2008),
The New York Times (2003 and 2006), and The Wall Street Journal (2006 and 2008). The Cleanest
Race is not about how North Koreans see themselves. The book is an extended opinion
column. —Alzo David- West, Aichi Prefectural University

  • Locked thread