CCKeane posted:

Look if you want to read 20 pages of a language that just barely resembles English as we know it, might I recommend this thread after doing a content game?

Personally, I find battles fun, and hope we get COOL WEAPONS.

Amnistar posted:

Then my vote is where it should be.

Monathin posted:

Bifauxnen posted:

this is the meta vote you take away from last game? You fool!

##vo-

oh wait there's like 75 posts now gently caress, hold that thought

MegaZeroX posted:

Sigh. This is super townie AA. If AA was being agreeable and actually looking like he was reading the thread then I would vote him in an instant, but this is his town meta.

MegaZeroX posted:

I've literally never been in a mafia game without AA. They are the strongest person I can actually read.

MegaZeroX posted:

The only scum game I have reference for is AA being SK in VTuber mafia, and I remember him looking like he actually read the thread there. He was also super agreeable, but as my second game with them I didn't realize how out of the ordinary it was.

CCKeane posted:

I feel like combat focused stuff is helpful, as it might make it easier to root out scum based on successes/failures in combat, if we're a loaded squad.

I'd say weapons, armor, medicine, drat the rest! Throw everything else into a big pile of POOP

Unless you're good at those idk.

Dragonatrix posted:

Mega being the current voteleader is a bit annoying. It's mostly based on meta stuff, which I don't really think is such a great tell in the first half of D1. Of course, he's not really doing himself any favours by tunneling so hard on AA for meta reasons that are maybe just post-hoc justifications if I followed all that correctly. That combined with a quick two sentences discussing people other than AA is just plain bad. I'm inclined to think more scummy than it should be, but less-so than AA.

Bifauxnen posted:

lmao

Amnistar posted:

If you are feeling overwhelmed:
1.) Ignore combat until tonight. It only matters if you get picked.
2.) Submit a build action. If you dont know what for do soothseer or whichever is highest. Pick whichever of the 2 options sounds cooler.
3.) Hunt scum like a normal game.

King Burgundy posted:

I know the reason.

MegaZeroX posted:

Wow that is a nice way to have a lot of words to say "I don't know about anyone other than Mega." Like, this feels like the equivalent of a Lumpen list with "null" for everyone except for one person labeled scum LMAO.

They are among the most prolfiic posters and this is basically the extent of their scum hunting. Making a case against me, then for literally every other point, going "oh geez I don't know"

Amnistar posted:

##unvote


Still think it is likely that mega is scum but they are posting and active, making it more likely they will slip and reveal further information. I think I would rather we eliminate one of the lower posters day 1 that have come across as scum.

##vote hunt11

Hunt get some good reads out.

Amnistar posted:

Hitting the scum using lurking earlier is less painful than later though?

Mr. Steak posted:

see, this brings me right back around to thinking bif is scum. i know from past experience that this is her genuine opinion, and she brings it up in practically every game. that's why i find this earlier post of hers super off:


her genuine reasoning for wanting to withhold town reads really should carry over to claiming building projects.
let alone my logic before about how there's no way to accurately analyze the percentage results even if everyone claims their project, the fact that bif doesnt even consider that this sort of "massclaim" would benefit scum, when her normal thought process is that even claiming townreads can benefit scum, comes across to me as very off from her normal thinking.

to break it down cuz i think im being long-winded:

bif thinks townreads are dangerous to claim willy-nilly because it gives scum a more accurate view of town's overall perspective, thus making it easier to choose a towny person to NK, and also safe options to push for a mislunch.

that logic *should* carry over to build plans. basically, townreads are to nightkill, as project-claims are to sabotage. claiming our projects will make it a lot easier for scum to sabotage effectively, with extremely minimal benefit to town in return.

again, the main thing that pings me is she never even seems aware of this possibility, which is weird because of her deeply-ingrained similar opinions on townreads.

##vote bif

Amnistar posted:

Please remember build is not seperate from combat and submit your build action your discord chat.

Monathin posted:

Hunt's participation hasn't been great but as someone who literally did this in the last soldiers game as the leader with GGN's inactive posting, swinging onto lurkers, especially D1 is a dumb call and it's worth pointing out people who are bailing from votes to try and poke lurkers.

Monathin posted:

Hunt and Dragon currently aren't on the vote list.

King Burgundy posted:

So an interesting question would be, if we were to vote a lurkerish person, who would you want it to be?

Amnistar posted: