New around here? Register your SA Forums Account here!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $10! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills alone, and since we don't believe in shady internet advertising, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Pththya-lyi posted:

The Dementors latched on to every muggle under the age of 40. That's why we're all so depressed!
Pfft, good luck sucking out my soul. I'm a software developer.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

RoboChrist 9000 posted:

Wizards are objectively a superior class of being to muggles.

Except this superior class of people doesn't understand simple mechanical devices and thinks a monetary system based on prime numbers is a swell idea.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

RoboChrist 9000 posted:

Harry and Hermione and even Ron and others have no problem. It is a question of desire, not ability. Wizards choose to be luddites. A muggle cannot choose to cast a spell.
Don't need to. Let's see how Voldemort copes with a missile.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.
Turns out they're just round rocks covered in gold paint, because anyone who doesn't understand numbers on banknotes can be fooled by anything.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

LIVE AMMO COSPLAY posted:

Hermione is Ron's future property, it would be improper of Harry to react to her with anything other than lukewarm British distain.

Keep calm and Harry on.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.
Yeah, one of the questions I've always had was, has anyone just tried shooting Voldemort? You spend all your time dicking around trying to beat him with magical shenanigans, which doesn't work because he's better at it.

So just loving shoot him. Glock glock.

Or figure out where he is and have the Minister of Magic tell the muggle PM that they need a drone strike on such and such house, and don't worry, we'll Obliviate the memories of anyone who notices.

That scene where Fudge is meeting with the PM, and Fudge says how it's hard because the bad guys can do magic too should've ended with the PM going, ".... You know we have snipers that can kill targets from a thousand yards, right?"

Presto fucked around with this message at 20:34 on Feb 13, 2022

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Nissin Cup Nudist posted:

Someone should just send a letterbomb to Malfoy and see what happens
Talk about a Howler.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Jazerus posted:

wizards are very stupid

This should be the subtitle for the entire series.

The Harry Potter Saga: Wizards Are Very Stupid

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Jazerus posted:

Base Upgrades Available:
*Astronomy Tower (+20% Astronomy)
*Potions Lab (+20% Potions)
*Dueling Hall (+20% Defense Against the Dark Arts)
*Magizoo (+20% Animagus Transformation)
*Slave Quarters (+10 House Elves)

Can I level up my house elves like imps in Dungeon Keeper? Level 10 imps were great.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.
It's been established that house elves can teleport pretty much anywhere, so why not have some teleport onto Voldemort's face and stab him through the eye sockets?

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

reignofevil posted:

One consideration is that any plan to kill Voldemort buys you like twelve years recovery time tops.
Sure but now you have 12 years to hunt around for horcruxes.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Boba Pearl posted:

Better than the goatfucker I guess? I prefer celibate to cross species animal husbandry.
Jeez, you gently caress *one* goat....

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Cranappleberry posted:

Samuel L. Jackson would have defeated Voldemort in a single movie.
I have had it with these muthafuckin' basilisks in this muthafuckin' disused girls' bathroom!

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.
It's been shown you can cross from England to France in a pickup truck with an outboard motor bolted on the back.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Buttchocks posted:

Hogwarts: A Holocaust History
Hogwarts: A History of Violence

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Sydin posted:

He dates Ginny for a bit in Book 5 and then gets into a big fight with her and they break up, I guess.
Which was a result of Harry drinking the luck potion.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.
How does anyone know if the sorting hat isn't just picking houses randomly? Or it knows someone should be in Hufflepuff but it puts them in Slytherin just for a laugh.

What I'm getting at here is, is the sorting hat just a huge dick?

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.
Come to think of it, why go through the convoluted scheme to maneuver Harry to win the tournament if the goal was just to get him to the portkey?

You're posing as a professor, and you've got his trust. Tell him you to meet you in the forest, get him to grab the port key, done.

Or poo poo, just take him by sidealong apparition, which we learn later is a thing.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Jazerus posted:

the grounds are warded against apparition and portkeys. the third task required dumbledore to make a hole in the wards so that the stupid portkey could bring the champion outside of the maze. it occurred to no one that if someone set the portkey's destination to elsewhere it would be a massive security breach

Which is why I said to get Harry to come to the forest, which is outside the grounds. :colbert:

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Jazerus posted:

yes...crouch jr. made the portkey, which could only function because dumbledore had to lower the wards for the day or whatever. a random portkey thrown at harry on the first day of school would have just bounced off, because portkeys don't function at hogwarts. at least part of the forest is within "the grounds" so he couldn't have lured harry off of the grounds trivially, either.

of course, on the other hand, harry goes to hogsmeade and anyone could have nabbed him there
Nah, there was a plot point somewhere, I can't remember where, where someone went into the forest to apparate away, so it's outside the can't-apparate-here line.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Mx. posted:

i went to a school with a house system but it was australian so it was 100% determined by who did best in sports carnivals
Back up.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.
Come to think of it Dumbledore always knew that Harry was being treated like poo poo at home. I forget which book it is, but in one of the Dumbledore-explains-the-plot sections, he says something about how when Harry first arrived at school he was less well-fed than he (Dumbledore) would have liked.

But I guess telling the Durseleys to stop being dicks is too much work. Maybe suffering builds character.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

ToxicFrog posted:

I mean, it's loving magic, there's no reason you couldn't have fancy sportscast overlays even for the live audience showing the current location of the flying walnut and stuff without leaking that information to the players.
The omniocular industry won't let them.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Pththya-lyi posted:

I don't get the sense that JKR has actually read much fantasy, though. I don't recall her mentioning any other fantasy authors she admires,
She said she doesn't like fantasy and didn't realize Harry Potter was fantasy.

I am not making this up.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

amigolupus posted:

Then I remembered this is the same guy who visited an abused 11-yeard old in an orphanage and wrote him off as pure evil and never tried teaching him about the ethics of using magic against others.

And dumped him into a house with a bunch of other power-hungry goons, because a hat said so.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Rotten Red Rod posted:

Note all three of them pair off with a man, lose their personality, and become Mom.

(And killed off screen, in one case )
One on them loses her magical ability because she's pining over a man.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.
James could've just clocked Voldemort upside the head with his fist and saved everybody.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Edgar Allen Ho posted:

Dean Thomas brought his SNES to the dorms every year. Harry and Ron weren't invited to play because they're jackasses.
There was some hand-wavy bullshit at some point that hi-tech stuff doesn't work at Hogwarts for ~reasons~. I'm not sure what the cutoff is. Like, surely a pen or pencil would work, right? So why make everyone use ink quills?

Also, something I just thought of is, if you're from a muggle family, and your letter arrives that says you've been accepted at Hogwarts, do you have a choice in this matter? Do the parents get a choice? Can they say LOL, no, I want my child to have skills they can actually use, or do the wizards just wipe their memories and cart their kid off whether anybody involved wants it or not?

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.
This reminds me of an interview with Terry Pratchett where he said he once got a letter from an aspiring writer who said they didn't read any books because they didn't want to be influenced by other ideas. The interviewer asked how he responded, and Terry said, "I told them they should read all the books they can find".

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.
Hermione and Fleur acted as decoys Harrys using polyjuice potion in that one book.

So, assuming that a) Harry has balls and b) polyjuice potion goes that far......

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

YaketySass posted:

Pottermore article on how Polyjuice doesn't affect genitals or boobs
But in the movie Hermione-as-Harry removes her bra. So now I don't know what to believe.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Barudak posted:

Yer a unit of measurement, harry
Nah, Harry isn't Oliver Smoot.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Asterite34 posted:

To be fair, it's not the worst idea to not tell the kid with the World's Most Readable Mind about all the activities of your clandestine Antifa cell.

They just went about it in the worst imaginable way
Well Dumbledore tried to fix Harry's most readable mind.... by sending him to be taught by the person he hates most in the world (who is also a lovely teacher).

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

OPAONI posted:

There's nothing in HP lore to suggest the magic wouldn't work just as well if the wand was up your rear end.

How do you do the swish-and-flick?

Edit: Sourcery is kind of someone actually going the "why doesn't someone just shoot Voldemort" route. All the Discworld wizards assume that the only way to beat a powerful wizard is with more magic, forgetting the awesome power possessed by someone with a halfbrick inna sock.

Presto fucked around with this message at 03:06 on Feb 21, 2023

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.
Yeah but then you can just shoot him again.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.
Oh say can you see Voldemort, if you can then my hair's too short.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Schwarzwald posted:

Isn't the whole joke in Discworld that magic is trivially easy to perform (and that wizards dress it up in ceremony to prevent its widespread adoption)..?

It's very easy to do... once.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.

Ghost Leviathan posted:

Rudcully comes off as taking the piss of a D&D wizard when he has a huge bog oak staff and a crossbow that can impale three elves at once.

In Soul Music there's a line about how he rarely uses his staff for magic, because anything you can't defeat by beating it with a 6 foot oaken staff probably isn't going to be affected by magic either.

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.
Remind me, was the Goblet of Cock and Balls before or after the Odor of the Penis?

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Presto
Nov 22, 2002

Keep calm and Harry on.
Wasn't that because the Dutch edition uses RAZ, and someone said, you know, the Dutch word for 'black' is 'zwart' and welp.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply