Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
In the mood for some mafia. Sign me up!

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
Only scum discuss 'hits'

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
Mortal Kombat voice:
Round. One... FIGHT

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
What's the hilarious thing if cheese sandwich gets lunched? I'm scared he's town and you're all dog piling him :ohdear:

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
now all we need is you other hungry lunchers to unvote, you bastards

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

Quidthulhu posted:

Two vets making rookie scum mistakes, wrap it up folks!

wraps for lunch? :grin:

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

dmboogie posted:

too many people in this game imo

are you offering yourself as sacrifice to the dark lunch gods?

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
Hum is so hooked on lunching a cheese sandwich and I'm not sure I buy it

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

b-minus1 posted:

This is a scum post.

You're a scum post :colbert:

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

Pussy Quipped posted:

Also I think cheese is very town

At least I'm not the only one, gently caress

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
Claiming death proof is just asking for a lunch though, right? I'm certainly not a seasoned player but any means, but if he's telling the truth and we vote to lynch him, we don't lose any townies (because he won't die) and we then know he can be trusted. And if he's not death proof then he'd just die a liar.

Or am I completely wrong here because if so please explain

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
Talking about amnistar btw

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

Akarshi posted:

If we lunch Amnistar though we'll lose a day. And since he claimed third party survivor, it's not really to our benefit to trust him in the long term because all he wants is to survive till the end. He doesn't care about whether town wins, scum wins, or some other third party wins.

Seems like a good way to avoid being lynched is to just claim that role then, even if it isn't true. Which then makes me think - is the claim genuine or are we all being played?

Just a standard game of Mafia, I guess

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

Amnistar posted:

The world may never know!

Honestly I gotta know, man. If you're death proof then I'd be happy with this. If you're not, well gently caress

##vote Amnistar

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

Jeabus Mahogany posted:

gonna slam down my guts while checking post histories in alphabetical order

ASF - low-content, null
Akarshi - town lean
Amnistar - Don't wanna test their claim D1, aware that might be falling into their trap
Angelwolf - lotta questions without opinions, apparently if we vote Amni and it fails they'd be happy about it? Scum lean
b-minus1 - low-content but pings town right now
chaoslord - low-content, very little that isn't commentary, scum ping
cheese sandwich - town lean
dmboogie - null
flerp - town lean
Jen X - ugggggggh
Jonathan Fisk - town lean
Kashuno - ugggggggh
Leith Maclaine - town ping
Lumpen - unfortunate town lean
Moatillata - coasting, scum lean
Mr. Humalong - has tied themselves into the Jen/Kash thing in a way that I hate
Pussy Quipped - was leaning town but am less sure on this read
Quidthulhu - town lean
SalTheBard - I buy their claim, town lean
SHALASHASKA HAWKE - null
spacing in vienna - town lean
Toalpaz - Their vote on Lumpen where they seem to be trying to buddy up to me pings me. Scum ping
xiw - town lean
xopods - scum lean
Your Personal Muse - town lean

What is it you (or I) don't get?

The guy said he was deathproof. I've admittedly played only a few Mafia games but on my understanding, generally making this claim means they're either proving they're town or trying to avoid being lynched by making it seem others are wasting their vote by targeting them.

I said I'd be happy if it turned out he was deathproof because I figured that would make him a trustworthy town :confused:

Having said this, i am not familiar with specific win conditions so maybe this is throwing me off something fundamental

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

Amnistar posted:

So, I am claiming survivor as ly alignment. This is an alignment that is not town or scum, but a 3rd party that wins if they are alive when the game is over.

Right, so if we attempt to lynch you and we fail, then we know your claim is probably genuine.

If we attempt to lynch you and succeed, and you flip town, I'd be sad.

But there's only one way for us to definitely find out (ie, you die) and evidently it makes me look like scum to want to know.

The only person really sticking out to me as scum right now is hum but not quite enough for me to throw a vote at him.

I hope my line of thought here is understandable

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

Jonathan Fisk posted:

Why? votes are cheap

Because for all I know, he could be town. I don't think what I've read so far from him is enough just yet for me to explicitly point my finger

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

spacing in vienna posted:

Is Angelwolf one of the newbies, then? Because I thought we had two or three in the game but gently caress if I know, I can't remember why I thought that

My first forums game was in gbs recently. I played a while back in irc, about 10 or 11 years ago (Werewolf) and it was wildly different

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

spacing in vienna posted:

A Sometimes Food, what are you when you aren't food?

Scum :v:

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

Your Personal Muse posted:

You should vote him

Easy there, trigger-finger

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

Your Personal Muse posted:

Yeah I’m sorry getting two votes on ASF would be dangerous

My mistake, votes are harmless

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
I get the idea we're not getting a lunch today

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
Mr. "loose-canon" Humalong, what is it with your constant yet random voting? Are you doing it so you can drop the hammer and go "oops, random vote time lol!"?

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
I'm going to bed in a minute anyway so ##unvote

##vote Mr. Humalong

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
Why isn't it revealed what Shalashaska Hawke's role was when they died?

Like, the other ones we're told what they are but why not Hawke?

also good job on the lunch yesterday, 1 scum down on day 1!

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

flerp posted:

because u janitored him u piece of garbage

i have no idea what this even means

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

xiw posted:

There's a role 'janitor' which when it does nightkills hides the body, so we don't get to know who the killed person was. Sometimes when the janitor dies we get all the flips. You sometimes see janitoring as part of another role so it's a general term for preventing flips on death.

oh! So we know who died, but not what their role or their alignment was.

Goddamn this whole arrangement is crazy. Thank you for explaining.

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
still suspicious of Hum.

##vote Humalong

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
if there's one thing Hum has consistently done this entire game, it's lying out of his rear end

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

Sounds like something scum would say :thunk:

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

Leith Maclaine posted:

How do you know Sal's claim?

Because he said it, at a guess

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

SalTheBard posted:

I'm a loud tracker, my tracking results are announced in thread instead of by PM. Anyone I track gets announced in the thread, however I don't trust my results because Fisk was NOT the person I submitted.

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

Mr. Humalong posted:

You and Jeabus for sure. ASF, Angelwolf, maybe Sal as well.

Can you explain this?

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
Also gently caress, how many posts do we need??

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

Mr. Humalong posted:

yeah you're scum

I meant PQ and jeabus

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

xopods posted:

Okay, after reading a few people at random I've decided on Springtime in Vienna for my content-generating slapfight. Yes, I know that's not really your name, but it's the name of a Tragically Hip song, and I'm a good patriotic Canadian boy, so it's your name to me now.

Anyway, she's got enough content to provide slapfight fodder, hasn't posted D2 and could probably use the excuse, and might actually be Scum.

Point 1: Looking over her D1 posts she seemed to be paying more attention to the Deathproof claims than the investigative ones. You know who really cares who's Deathproof? Scum.

##vote SiV

Uhh, she dead dude. Just vote hum like everyone else

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
Unless you don't want to of course

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream
Unless there's some kind of undead uprising I'm unaware of.

You know, b a s t a r d r o l e s and whatnot

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

xopods posted:

I now think Angelwolf is scum for the same reason I initially said SIV. Focused on the people claiming deathproof and not on the people claiming investigations.

xopods posted:

Also, if anyone has a dayvig they should shoot Amni at some point to test his claim.

:thunk:

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

a dmc delorean
Jul 2, 2006

Live the dream

xopods posted:

Hello, disingenuous.

Focusing on deathproof claims while ignoring the investigative ones is the scummy thing. The fact that I'm mentioning Amni's claim now isn't the same thing.

If you go back to my D1 I was extremely lazy overall but was mostly interested in the investigations and Lumpen's backup claim.

You're still lazy now and not even paying attention to who's dead and who's alive

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply