Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Dixville posted:

What about grain free?
There have been FDA reports of heart disease connected to grain free diets. It is not generally recommended to feed these diets right now. There is just too much we don't know about why this is happening. Here is more info:
https://www.fda.gov/animal-veterina...etween-diet-and


We literally know exactly what's causing this and it isn't just grain-free diets; there are plenty of legume-heavy (vegan, for instance) diets that are coming up in this, too. The uptake of taurine is being blocked by large amounts of legumes in carnivore pet foods. The percentage of pets it effects is almost 0. The DCM you're referencing but for some reason not getting into here is literally based around the lack of taurine available to the dog/cat/fox.

Homemade is amazing. Raw is great. Kibble is fantastic for lots of dogs, too.

If anyone wants to talk about pet food from someone who has spent years researching it, worked with several pet food companies, and has worked elbow to elbow with vet nutritionists in creating specialized food plans for animals in zoos, at home, and everywhere in between, feel free to PM me. I will talk animal food all day long.

E: If your pet's food is leaving much to be desired, speak to veterinary nutritionists who devote their lives to what goes into your pet not general practice vets. They aren't hard to find and almost all of them take phone calls for simple questions like "what value does pork kidney have for my dog?" and will work remotely with you. Your GP vet may be the one pulling the blood and sending information to the nutritionist, but your GP vet does not get the depth of education in this field that the specialist vet does. I'm also happy to direct people to them, so just hit me up if you need it.

Fluffy Bunnies fucked around with this message at 06:14 on Apr 22, 2020

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Facebook Aunt posted:

There is no definitive answer to how many calories "a cat" needs, no. A maine coon can be like 18 pounds and not overweight, while some other cats top out at like 6 pounds as adults and are perfectly healthy. Some cats are crazy active, other cats snooze all day and can get by with fewer calories.

You have go by results. If your cat is bony feed more, if your cat is chonky feed less.



Cats require 30 calories per pound per day to maintain a healthy weight, with a value play of 25-35 depending on cat activity level. Most lazy cats require right at 30 calories per pound; so a 6 pound cat would require 180.

listrada posted:

What is the general opinion about free feeding vs meal times, and urine food vs regular food? IIRC the old thread said to always feed prescription food if prescribed even if it wasn't super high quality, but what's the opinion of the food isn't prescribed?

Okay, so - one of my two kitties experienced some food insecurity before I got her and would freak out if she ever saw the bottom of the bowl, so I just got a big dog dish and kept it full. Over the past few years, her food anxiety has gotten much better, but we've kept free feeding because neither cat is fat (well, they're both a little tubby but not fat-fat) and I like the convenience.

The problem is that the boy cat recently started having peeing problems. Sometimes he'll pee for a long time and lick himself a lot when he gets out of the box. No blockages, yet. The vet says it's idiopathic cystitis or FLUTD (same thing?), and it could be caused by stress and/or being tubby.

So - stress: the house isn't very stressy, but the girl cat can be a dick to him sometimes. They coexist fine and play together occasionally, but we do not have kitten cuddle puddles going on. This might be more of a behavioral question, but does anyone have any ideas for how to make the girl cat be less of a dick?

Anyway. Back to the diet question for the diet thread: the vet said that switching to meal times and to a urine food "might help" prevent bouts of cystitis. Obviously I want to do the right thing to keep the cat healthy, but I don't love this idea because free feeding has worked pretty well and we have a high quality non-urine food that everyone really likes (Scrumbles). Finding a high quality food in the UK was so hard that I'm worried about finding a specialty food that doesn't suck.

If the vet had said "definitely switch to a urine food" I'd definitely do it, but since she didn't I feel a little lost here. Goon hive mind, what should we do? Do mealtimes with rx food? Free feed dry during the day and maybe do rx wet food at night? Keep the same food and put feliway diffusers all over the house?

stop free-feeding your cats before "tubby" turns into "diabetic" and "diabetic" turns into "urinary crystals"; which eventually usually turns into "kidney failure". If you can afford wet, feed wet. If your cat freaks out over an empty bowl; try putting toys in said bowl so they redirect into playtime.

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

sunaurus posted:

I know there are people here with way more pet experience than me, so I'm hoping to get some advice regarding my 4 year old dog, because she has been having issues with her anal glands for over a year now.

For some background, this is her food history:
1) 2016: Orijen puppy
2) 2017-2018: Orijen adult
3) 2019 - 2020 spring: Royal Canin medium adult
4) 2020 spring - now: Royal Canin hypoallergenic

We switched away from Orijen due to the DCM danger, but shortly after she started getting Royal Canin medium adult, she started having constant issues with her anal sacs not emptying at all. We went to a bunch of different vets and eventually figured out that the problem was a combination of her anal glands being in a slightly irregular position and her poop being a just bit softer than normal (not diarrhea or anything, it was a very subtle difference in consistency).
We managed to solve the issue for a while by switching to Royal Canin hypoallergenic, because that food completely dried up her poop and made it really firm. It had that effect on her all summer, but it stopped working about a week ago - her poop has become softer again.
What's even worse is that it's quite obvious that she doesn't enjoy eating the hypoallergenic food at all. She usually has an endless appetite, but with the hypoallergenic, she sometimes leaves food in her bowl for hours. Orijen kibble used to even motivate her enough to be used as a reward for training, but she has no interest at all in the hypoallergenic kibble. We recently started using Specific dog treats to reward her instead, but I suspect those are the cause for her poop being softer again, so I think we will need to stop.

Basically, I'm looking for some advice on alternative foods to try. I don't think she had any soft poop issues on Orijen, so I'm almost considering trying it again, but I will never forgive myself if she gets some heart issues as a result. Ideally, I'm hoping to find some food that will harden up her poop while still being tasty enough to be used as a reward. I realize that all dogs are different so there's no immediately clear answer, but there are really a lot of different brands available. Maybe someone could share some recommendations in order to narrow down the list of options?

The risk for DCM is still incredibly low, but hey. You care about your dog. I'm not gonna dig on you for that.

I'm a big fan of Blackwood's large breed fish and Sport Dog Food's tracking dog at the moment. How big is she? What's her energy level like?

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

sunaurus posted:

Thanks! I'll try to see if I can find those brands for sale anywhere.

She's a Cardigan Welsh Corgi, so I think she's just bordering on medium size. She weighs about 14kg. I don't really have any good baselines for comparison in terms of energy levels, but our usual routine is one or two play sessions during the day and a 2-3km walk every evening, and that doesn't really tire her out at all. She only really gets tired when playing with other dogs for hours or when we go for long hikes on weekends.

Try sport dog food's herding dog; you can get it directly from them or on chewy. As a CWC, she's super low risk for DCM (it's mostly been larger dogs; retrievers and up) but again. You're worried about your little long girl. That's cool.

She sounds pretty chill for a corgi. That's a good girl.

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

MikeyTsi posted:

My vet's advice when I was feeding orijen was that if I was concerned to supplement additional taurine. You can get it as chewable tablets.

Various universities studying DCM's link with legumes have stated that this is not an acceptable measure if the food is continued to be fed. Increased doses of taurine have not improved uptake in effected animals.

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Nood. cats don't need rice.

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Organza Quiz posted:

Honestly I think sticking with a known brand like Iams or Fancy Feast (if you can stomach Nestle) is safer, I don't think there's a ton of regulation of cat food here.

yeah feed fancy feast or like, purina

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Facebook Aunt posted:

LOL I printed out the giant list of best/good/acceptable foods in the previous version of this thread and wandered the aisles of the pet store trying to find something affordable that my cat would eat. She's a trash cat and the more expensive the food the less she seems to like it.

And now the thread is all gently caress it just get friskies or whatever it doesn't matter. :haw:

I mean we may as well.

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Organza Quiz posted:

The old wisdom was "more meat is better", the new wisdom (as far as I've been able to figure out anyway) is cat food is very badly regulated so just about any old joe can make a trendy meat-filled grain-free holistic all-natural food but it won't necessarily have the right nutrients, so stick to something well-established unless you're really sure there's enough science and testing involved.

yeah sure purina is aafco and that's always been a great way to measure pet food

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

MikeyTsi posted:

Cats are different. They don't synthesize taurine like dogs so sufficient amounts need to be included in their diet; this got figured out for them in like the 70's? With dogs there is something that impacting their ability to synthesize taurine or absorb it, or something like that, I haven't read what the latest research is.

Cats are obligate carnivores, so their should be no grain in their food and little to no vegetable matter at all (think about their standard prey, basically all the plant matter they would get would be what would happen to be in the GI tract of what they've caught). Any cat food that has grain is a marker for something that's low quality.

The big thing with "by-product meal" is that it can be poorly defined, and is usually going to be in a food that's also going to be full of other fillers like grain that they won't be able to process properly.

Cats typically have a problem getting enough moisture, so a wet food is preferred over a dry food.
that
Personally, we feed our feline overlords Orijen dry during the day and Tiki Cat canned food in the evening, I've also fed stuff like Merrick and Solid Gold. Any dedicated pet food chain (I like Pet Pros and Mud Bay) that doesn't carry bottom-tier foods will probably be able to give good recommendations, heck I think even PetSmart and Petco have both signed on to not carry low-tier brands in the interest of pet health.

There used to be a pet food ratings thread but I'm sure it's horribly out of date. I'm not sure what outside ratings sites there are for cat food at the moment.

The old pet food thread really wasn't that out of date. Most of the brands haven't really changed much of their formulation in years. A lot of those of us who know what we're talking about and have long-term experience in either formulating pet food or understanding the formulation of it just got sick of being told that we were wrong/stupid/etc when we were giving veterinarian-backed answers or we've literally been studying pet nutrition professionally. So we gave up and gently caress it, let the goon cats eat purina.

In serious mode instead of "lol whatever": tiki cat and orijen are pretty fantastic. I will always be pro-raw for cats for owners who want to learn it (there are great recipes online, wonderful fb groups, and I'm always just a PM away). But those are really, really good alternatives to raw.

I wouldn't feed Merrick or Blue Buffalo to my worst enemy's animals just because they constantly seem to have recalls and issues. 4Health cost me a $500 vet bill and permanently shut me off on Diamond manufactured foods, too, but there are some people who do great with them.

Petsmart is still carrying trash like bil-jac and pedigree and so forth. Petco's big thing is "no artificial stuff! look! it's all real food!" which is about as bottom line as I would ever want to feed anything. It kind of blew my mind that people latched on to that as a good thing, but it's a common marketing tool in human groceries too, so hey, sure. Familiarity brings money.

We don't have Pet Pros or Mud Bay so I can't really speak on them. Cats don't really have a problem getting moisture so much as we make it hard for them to do so. Cats aren't (usually) big into drinking water. They'll drink it, but like most obligate carnivores, they prefer to get a lot of their moisture from their prey. Ultimately, that's why I'm so pro-raw specifically for cats. You can add water to their ground meat and mix it up and really shove that water down their little throats to keep them from making a crystal factory in their bladder.

WhatEvil posted:

holy gently caress cats are hard

My first question isn't regarding any of what you posted. It's what's your budget per month to feed these two?

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

WhatEvil posted:

Honestly it's hard to say. Like I'm not working right now but my wife is, we have savings, but eventually I'll be going back to work (I hope) and then we can probably afford to feed them really good stuff, like your Tiki Cat or this stuff:

https://www.homesalive.ca/cat/food/dry-and-kibble/farmina-n-d-prime-kitten-cat-food-chicken-and-pomegranate.html

Which seems like it might be the fanciest stuff I've found, with the best ingredients.

Until then I just want to get them something that's good for them but isn't going to cost us a shitload.

I think for now I'm somewhat settled on Orijen Cat & Kitten for dry food and a split between Romeo and Authority for wet:

https://www.petonly.ca/romeo-chicken-catch-of-the-day-recipe-grain-free-adult-canned-cat-food

https://www.petsmart.ca/cat/food-and-treats/wet-food/authority-pate-entree-kitten-food-51030.html

Hopefully these are decent choices.

Of those two at the bottom, I'd go authority.

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Boogalo posted:

If your cats are good weight and eat the food then you're doing fine, no reason to switch.

I'm not sure how the grain free issues in dog food carried over to including cats, but cat food is enriched with taurine already to avoid that problem. If anything, if it is an issue, i'd imagine slightly increasing the amount in formulations would take care of it, but being a grain free feeder, its not something I'm concerned about.

At the end of the day, feed your cat whatever they will reliably eat. I go for grain free with a low incidence of recalls and high calorie density so i'm feeding small amounts and don't have to store a ton. In some cheaper foods I'd be feeding 2 cups a day while pricier ones are 1/2 a cup or less so the costs even out pretty well too.

Enriching with taurine doesn't avoid that problem. It has been shown conclusively that additional taurine does not assist carnivores uptaking significant amounts of taurine blockers like legumes.

But not every animal has that problem.

Tiki cat is good stuff.

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Gangringo posted:

I just inherited a cat and we have instantly become bros. I want to spoil him terribly and give him as long of a healthy life as possible. At the moment he is eating freshpet chicken recipe and loving it.

I would like to continue feeding him fresh food. I was wondering if anyone has experience or knowledge of the various fresh food delivery services for cats, like mom nom, cat person, or Darwin's. Anything I should know about feeding fresh food?

darwin's has had a lot of recalls. nom nom is like, crystal meth for literally every animal I've ever seen eat it. freshpet is fine just avoid the ones with legumes.

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

MikeyTsi posted:

Urinating a lot is a sign of kidney issues. Get your cat in to the vet.

op is making kibble soup, cat is prob okay.


El Mero Mero posted:

Does anyone have an opinion of the reviews/analysis on catfooddb.com or catfooddb.com?

not familiar with it. what are you considering?

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009


It's good stuff. Tiki Cat might be a little cheaper without sacrificing quality, though.

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Gangringo posted:

My aunt has a very old dog with a very sensitive digestive system. Currently she cooks poached chicken, rice, and mixes it with dog food to make sure it has more complete dog nutrition. Is there any sort of supplement mix that works well so she can add it to whatever she cooks that will make it dog food?

Look into Just Food For Dogs DIY. What she's doing isn't helping.

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Cretin90 posted:

Just a quick sniff test (heh) to make sure this food is fine.

2 year old indoor cat we adopted ten days ago. We’ve been feeding him the poo poo the shelter was feeding him, Purina Beyond wet and Purina Beyond grain free (etc) dry. We’d like to make the switch to healthier food. He’s a healthy weight and hasn’t indicated any issues other than maybe being slightly gassy and his poop smelling like the end of the world (but what else is new).

https://www.chewy.com/weruva-paw-lickin-pals-variety-pack/dp/169209
https://www.chewy.com/solid-gold-indigo-moon-chicken-eggs/dp/112136

I was interested in the Dr Elsey cleanprotein stuff but 59% protein dry food seems.. excessive.

that's a hell of a concentration of protein

Weruva is a big hit around here. Solid Gold is very decent.

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Cretin90 posted:

Any suggestions over solid gold for a generic/no special needs adult cat diet?

I'm really enjoying Acana right now. It's not perfect, but it's good stuff.

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

powerfulbuttranger posted:

So, is raw or freeze-dried not as much a risk as it seems like it would be? I mean, contamination is contamination, cat food or human food. No? Raw is raw.

Animals in the wild eat it raw bc it's fresh and they have to, but doesn't mean it isn't at risk for bad bacteria.

P.s. Don't bother telling me I'm stupid, I know.

Can you get a little more exact with what you're asking here? Because I'd like to help, but I'm a bit confused. And for dogs or cats?

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

powerfulbuttranger posted:

I'm sorry. I was standing there in the store at the time, two bags in my arms, like an idiot.

This is for cats.

I see people talking up orijen and other foods that contain raw or freeze-dried ingredients. Is it not a risk for them to be eating that? Why wouldn't it be?

So, cats and dogs have different systems than we do. While there's still a possibility of illness, it's there in kibble and everything else they eat, too. They have an incredibly good system for killing off pathogens that make us sick: it's why you see strays eating 3-day old roadkill and not really getting sick from it. Is that ideal? Nah. But still, they can do it. We can't.

Having raw fed cats a lot (especially cats, I'm a huge proponent for raw-fed cats, it just takes some learning to do it), I've never had one get sick. I run their meals through my grinder, bag, tag, and freeze. When I want to feed them, I remove a bag and go on ahead and let it thaw in cold water. Once thawed, I portion it between the cats and give it to them. In an hour, I throw out anything not eaten.

For the stuff in the bags, freeze-drying destroys any surfaces that pathogens might form on. The "raw coated" stuff that orijen does is more gimmick than anything else. They're just kinda spraying it with raw cat food juice and then, if I remember correctly, they go ahead and re-cook it so it isn't just molding in your bag. Which is gross.

I dunno if FA is talking about Freshpet or another one of the fresh foods, but yeah. It's just bringing pet food up to human cleanliness standards.

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Hirayuki posted:

Sorry if this has been covered; I skimmed the thread, but didn't see anything about this. It might just mean I'm in the wrong thread, though. Warning: bummer ahead.

Our pup Stanzie is 17½ and has been poorly for a while simply due to old age. She started to decline sharply this week. First she stopped eating her dry food, but wolfed down a plain omelette (two eggs, nothing more); then she would only nibble at an omelette; now she half-heartedly nibbles and then immediately spits it out. She's too weak to sit up or stand on her own, and seems so anxious about her positioning even when supported that she will not eat. We can only offer her food when she's laying on her side, which is always. We give her water by syringe on the side of her tongue, or she wouldn't drink at all. (As it turns out, she will lick CBD oil out of my hand, but not lap water.) She's in no pain as far as we can tell, and not mean or snappish. Just worn out.

We know this can't go on for much longer, but want to keep feeding and watering her as tolerated until her poor body finally gives out. Is there anything at all you can recommend for some easy-to-feed nutrition? Some kind of goop we can squirt onto her tongue like we do her water? That does seem to work. We'll gladly cook/formulate from scratch.

Beech Nut whole meat baby food. It's just meat and broth blended down.

Talk to your vet about your options. 17.5 is incredible. I'm dealing with two hospice cases at once myself. It could be simple dehydration or a surprisingly easy fix. Old dogs are often quick to drop but can pull themselves back up. A feeding tube may also be an option.

Hutla posted:

My god, quit torturing her and call an in home euthanasia service. Letting your dog slowly expire from starvation and dehydration is cruel beyond measure.


A lot of places do not have these, especially during the pandemic.

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

LeeMajors posted:

So my 8yo standard poodle had a grade 1 heart murmur at her last yearly appointment and she's been on Acana Singles for like 7 years due to severe colitis. Her first vet recommended switching to a grain free diet back in 2014 or so after several severe bouts of colitis with melena. I hadn't even heard about the possible DCM link and we've never had any dietary issues we knew of and thus we've never discussed diet with her vet of the last 5 years. She had a rough time with colitis at that time and then dx of Addison's we've been treating successfully and without issue since.

So we heard about this possible grain-free link with DCM (which hasn't developed yet apparently) but she's started showing some exercise intolerance and I'm starting to get a little worried.

It's so hard to find reliable information on good balanced diets and I'm thinking of switching over to the wholesome grain formula or over to some other food to try and prevent any further damage, if indeed that is what is causing it.

E: I'm thinking of transitioning her to Hill's Adult Sensitive Stomach and Skin Large breed--I remember my folks having good success with the prescription Hill's with their pets. Any thoughts?

Hills is garbage but if you have a sensitive gut, you have a sensitive gut. Go with what she'll eat.

What's your budget like?

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Buff Hardback posted:

We still rank Orijen pretty highly for cat food, right?

Mine are currently on Instinct by Nature's Variety but that was more a limitation of Chewy not selling it due to Orijen taking the ball and going home. Now that they've got Orijen again, I really don't see a downside to switching, but just wanted a second opinion.

Wet orijen is better than dry orijen but orijen in general is a good food.

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Arsenic Lupin posted:

I'm caught between two cat food problems.

1. Cat needs urinary-diet food; he's 11.
2. Cat gets the shits whenever he eats corn products.

I'm not trying to do grain-free, but the vet-grade cat foods I've seen have corn byproducts; they also don't offer a variety of flavors. Cat is a picky rear end in a top hat who won't eat the same food all the time.

Go raw. This is the common solution to your problem. Urinary diets typically have a bit more salt to them to encourage water retention/drinking. Raw is full of moisture. Or, if you feel dicey about raw, canned food or fresh food is good, too.

What kind of crystals does kitty have?

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Rectovagitron posted:

I've never had a picky dog before so am kind of at a loss.

My dog is a 1.5 year old 33lb Jindo that we've had since she was 4 months old. She had pneumonia and kennel cough when we got her (but is very healthy now), and the place we adopted her from had her on a raw-ish diet of Honest Kitchen's whole-grain stuff and some local frozen raw chicken for dogs, plus some added vitamins + probiotics.

Our vet recommended (and I preferred) switching to kibble instead of any raw food, both for the convenience, science behind it, and friends who are vets recommending kibble. But, our dog hates everything, and is not food motivated.

So far we have tried (at least):
- Several kinds of Royal Canin
- Hill's Science Diet
- Purina Pro Plan
- Eukanuba

We've tried a mix of wet and dry foods, just dry, just canned, making her do tricks for food, using food dispenser toys, only having food available for short amounts of time, and just about everything. We always do 2 weeks of transition time then at least 2 weeks of dedicated time on a food to see if she settles down with it.

She hates everything except the Honest Kitchen whole grain rehydrated food. She is the kind of dog that will spit out a treat if she is distracted by a squirrel, or excited in general. With Pro Plan, she'd just pick out the nuggets and barely graze everything else. Her weight is stable, and her vet is a little concerned that she is on the thin side, but she isn't losing weight so the vet isn't concerned about that.

Nonetheless, I'd prefer to have her on something more mainstream and less marketed at the raw/grainfree crowd, and would prefer a brand that did AAFCO testing instead of just formulation. Is there anything else we can try, or are missing here?

Honest Kitchen follows AAFCO guidelines. Get a better vet that doesn't expect you to shovel corn into a dog that clearly hates it. Give your 33 pound dog the food she likes if you can afford it. If not, I'm happy to try to help you more. If this is "WELL THE VET SAID-" talk to a nutritionist. I'm happy to give you phone numbers if you want'em. They're veterinarians that specialize in food and not holistic bullshit or "purina told us that they're good".

I wouldn't feed any of that list above other than Honest Kitchen.

Editing to add: https://www.thehonestkitchen.com/thk-blog/what-is-aafco This is all absolutely true. Check out NRC guidelines while you're at it and compare NRC vs AAFCO. NRC actually goes further in-depth. AAFCO is just the bare minimum to keep your dog's body from eating itself.

Second edit: Your dog is fine on grain-free and grained foods and a bunch of other stuff unless she's allergic to something in the food. Vets are using DCM as a huge "OH NO" scare and it's far less likely than the insulin resistance (that eventually became diabetes) dogs gained on heavily grained (primarily corn) diets that relied on grains for proteins/fillers.

DCM exists. There are a lot of other issues that have a higher percentile chance of happening (though still much lower than anyone should be strongly concerned about unless their individual pet shows symtpoms) than DCM because of lentils, peas, and such.

Fluffy Bunnies fucked around with this message at 21:55 on Jun 28, 2021

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Cretin90 posted:

Recommendation please. My 10 lb 3 year old cat consumes about 200 calories of food per day.

I currently feed him Weruva https://www.chewy.com/weruva-paw-lickin-pals-variety-pack/dp/169209 1 can/day
https://www.chewy.com/solid-gold-indigo-moon-chicken-eggs/dp/112136 1/4 cup/day

I’m looking to switch to the healthiest all wet/canned I can get for $100/mo or less. Any suggestions? If I switch to 2/day Weruva canned it’s over $200/month which is just too much for me to stomach for one 10 lb cat. Not set on all wet I just hear it’s healthier due to keeping the cat more hydrated, feel free to correct me. :)

It is. Any allergies?

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

WombatCyborg posted:

Couple pages back but saw something that made me think the question, pricewise, how does raw diet feeding cats compare to like, decent cat food?

depends on your area and your storage capacity. I've got two huge deep freezers, a meat grinder, a really great butcher shop that thinks I'm a crazy girl, and I'm a little bit insane when it comes to pet nutrition.

If you're buying from publix vs weruva wet, probably about the same for your average sized cat.

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

gay for gacha posted:

I have a three year old Great Dane. When we got her we she had really bad pustules all over her skin. We worked with several vets and discovered she had a food allergy to chicken. Our vet put us on royal canine but any time we tried to transition off she would start getting allergies again. I started thinking that maybe there was some by product or something that gets into the food that was causing this. Anyhow, after about a year we found a food that she wasn't allergic to and unfortunately it's a grain free food, Pro Pac Ultimates Overland Grain-Free Red Beef & Potato. At the time the vet just said it was fine to use since we couldn't find anything else, but I've been worried about heart disease from grain free diets. In my ignorance I've been adding scoops of cooked rice to her food because I thought the problem was the grain, but now I've read the thread and realize it's the other ingredients in the food.

I'm looking for a new dog food one that preferably has grains and will keep my dog happy and healthy. She has a very high activity level, she runs around every day we walk a few miles a day together, and we even do agility (though much slower than the other dogs).



I was thinking about these foods
Annamaet option formula

Natural balance beef and brown rice

Earthborn holistic ocean fusion


It's one beef food and two fish foods. I was thinking about fish because we give her fish treats and cod skins and she loves them and doesnt seem to react. On the other hand, when we were doing the dog food dance a few years ago she reacted to beef foods, but since we are on a beef food now it seems logical to try.

Am I thinking about this correctly? Is there another thing I should try? I just want to do what's best for my dog.

then speak to a nutritionist that is board-certified.

Earthborn was one I worked with for years but recently Midwestern (who makes it) has been getting pinged a lot for loving up and in need of recalls so I no longer recommend it. Acana has a lot of decent fish varieties.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Fluffy Bunnies
Jan 10, 2009

Kilometers Davis posted:

Hey just double checking, my 12 year old dog has been on acana grain free poultry (can’t remember the exact name right now) for 5+ years. She’s super athletic, happy, beautiful coat, barely any stomach issues since switching to it back then. I should just keep her on it right? I know about the issues, at least from when I read about them when the big blowback against grain free happened, but I also know if a food seems right for a dog you should probably stick to it.

don't change your dog's food if she's doing good on it. the DCM thing is largely overblown and represents an incredibly tiny amount of dogs. this thread's title is awful and doesn't explain anything. I've spent more time in here helping people than I intended to because the OP made a lousy first post and hasn't really shown back up to do a goddamn thing to help people find good food.

If your dog works on Acana, keep her on Acana. And show us your girl. And give her a good pat for us.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply