Fuckface the Hedgehog posted:

Are we still following tradition of turbolynching Anidav day 1?

SHALASHASKA HAWKE posted:

lol at thinking skill has any place in this dumb party game

Asphyxious posted:

Rude and also incorrect.

After all I did for town that game, the disrespect was unconscionable.

Mr. Humalong posted:

This is the dumbest thing I’ve ever seen

MysticalMachineGun posted:

Being the weekend posting will still be sporadic - got parenting to do - but I do agree with this

MysticalMachineGun posted:

That requires a bit of meta that I'm out of the loop on, before this week I hadn't mafia'd in years.

hambeet posted:

Is this a vote for soag because it’s a dumb argument or do you have more meat?

The Before Times posted:

It's a dumb argument AND it's just weird for someone who is an experienced player to drill down so hard on day 1 and derail the conversation completely

Fuckface the Hedgehog posted:

None unfortunately. I thought it might lead to some clues as to if it was legit scum trying to throw shade or a townie slapfight.

Now I'm annoyed i only have one lynch vote a day, and the whole thing has made me dumber for it.

Venom Soag posted:

I finished my hike and none of you fuckers are closer to making up your mind

Just Lynch me already and when I flip town at least you'll know that the people who are clearly not out for me (Gaspy, fuckface) are probably not town and that some of the people gunning hard for me ( beets Anidav ) might be scum


##vote venom Soag

Fuckface the Hedgehog posted:

Alright, pure stream of consciousness post incoming:

Honestly, the bif/soag/gaspy thing I don't know. It could be a mastermind plan between the three of them, or it could be gaspy and soag being loud fuckers because, well, they are loud fuckers and bif has either gotten caught arguing with them or is using it as distraction. It looks to be a make lots of noise on day 1 tactic.

Humalong straight off the bat accused me of being scum, and hasn't said much of any consequence since, with the exception of accusing gaspy and soag. Its just been low content noise posts. Ive never played with them, but they seem to be pulling the same thing soag is on bif, just less annoying. Humalong accusing gaspy and soag quickly early on would allow them to quote that later to distract if the heat gets on them and they need a distraction

So im guessing Hymalong, Anidav, Vote1 and Tommu have been pulling the low content short posts to keep out of contention and try not to be turbolynched.

MMG, Hal, and SHALASHASKA HAWKE started off strong and have gotten real quiet.

Beet is lurking, you're lurking, Ive been lurking and Cloner has been lurking. Ive been lurking because i haven't played in a while, and wanted to have a think and see what people busted out with, which probably was a mistake.
I'm of the opinion that the lurkers may have roles, but beet is probably a better player than that, and I'm not good at mafia. I don't have a good read on you, The Before Times.

soag is pretty loud about lynching bif, but at this stage its a crapshoot.

I want to say soag and gaspy as scum, but I cant tell if its because they are scum and trying to muddy the water or because i want them to shut the gently caress up.
I think Humalong because of as i wrote earlier.

But at this stage who knows? we will have to read more into it.

Bifauxnen posted:

Hint: it's wrong

Are you meaning to look at uninvolved people who had been posting more before? Cause that might not be a bad take except it gives Gaspy an out

Venom Soag posted:

Calling it now: watch the next scum trick, it's going to be accusing me and Gaspy of working together

MysticalMachineGun posted:

I thought you and Bif slapfighting was more of the scum tell if you ask me

MysticalMachineGun posted:

To be honest though I'm feeling two things right now:

1. Confused
2. That I'm town

MysticalMachineGun posted:

Seriously TBT, your whole case here is "Soag said someone would post something specific, and you know what MMG did? He... posted! Scum tell!".

Next post after this is scum, rock-solid.

Anidav posted:

Weird to ignore meme poster birdstrike in your white noise list.

Venom Soag posted:

Wait for bif to come in now telling us all how this is a stupid move and she wants no part of it and we're all idiots she's not going to vote beets

Then when it looks inevitable she'll bus him so she can be all like, see I wouldn't vote for mybscumbro I must be town!!!1

Anidav posted:

Sorry but why are you voting for cloner, the actual newbie while giving a pass on MMG who you say reads as a stressed newbie (when they aren't new to mafia) and also giving a pass to Fuckface who also isn't a newbie for what effectively is a very similar case on each? (weird posting)

I would feel the opposite here fyi, I would give a pass to cloner for being new and certainly look into Fuckface, maybe MMG but they died pretty early last game. Not an excuse not to vote for them but it sucks you know?

Day 1 suss is with fuckface and maybe TBT for saying that weird lupenlist thingo was good but I dunno on the odds of them rolling non-town 2 games in a row and i believe they are busy irl atm moving house or something. MMG distant 3rd.

Lets look at this post again.


This came out on page 14.

So let us look at the posts prior to page 14 that were apparently strong.

I read through all this poo poo and I think the real joke phase ended on about page 7.

MMG Prior to page 14 -

This is MMG "starting off strong" from pages 7-14 according to Hedgehog.

Hal Prior to page 14 -

This is Hal "off to a strong start" from pages 7-14 according to Hedgehog.

Birdstrike prior to page 14 -

Ect Ect.

When you break the "strong starts" section down to the components I simply disagree. Unless you mean strong start as in post quantity? But why bother mentioning quantity? It's mostly poo poo posting. Then Fuckface's original hunch is Humalong at this point for low content posting? But your strong starts are also low content posts and memery????

You are playing duck duck goose here but why?

##vote fuckface

I also feel slightly suss on Vote 1 for basically drawing straws with the awkward posters and picking one to vote for.

Fuckface the Hedgehog posted:

why do you keep saying lunch instead of lynch?

Venom Soag posted:

hambeet posted:

hage, sex, location?

MysticalMachineGun posted:

Gaspy saying he'd trust himself over a cop claim is scummy as poo poo - yeah, we could have a false cop claim but someone coming out with a cop claim D2 is putting a big target on themselves. If they cop claim D2 and survive the night, it's pretty clear to trust them.

Gaspy saying flat out he wouldn't trust a cop claim sounds like a scum set-up for D2, and Gaspy having played lots of mafia I wouldn't put it past them as a play.

MysticalMachineGun posted:

D1 is entirely about throwing poo poo at the wall to see what sticks. I'm throwing poo poo with some basis in posting and getting called out for it.

In fact, I've been called out almost every time I've loving posted. Almost like scum went "who should we turn the thread against today?" and settled on a few posters including me

Venom Soag posted:

Mate every single post you've made has required digging two miles uphill to try and explain why you're not as scummy as you look

MysticalMachineGun posted:

Of course, always down for a lunch

We have 54 minutes to go and there's already tremendous heat on me. If I hammer fuckface and they're town I'll be dead about an hour into D2

Fuckface the Hedgehog posted:

Because he is scum, along with gaspy, who fake roleclaimed.

Cloner of the Elks posted:

News just in: Claiming to have a role isn't a roleclaim

Venom Soag posted:

Tbt

Go back two pages and you'll also see a very dodgy attempt by MMG to sway the vote towards Gaspy through a very very dubious long game conspiracy theory

I think it might be relevant in the future

The Before Times posted:

Claiming you have a specific role is a roleclaim because it then leaves it open for someone else to counterclaim

MysticalMachineGun posted:

True, but in a non-role frenzy setup like this it's a big call

Venom Soag posted:

how do you have this information

SHALASHASKA HAWKE posted:

what happens if I do this? I think ##unvote

SHALASHASKA HAWKE posted:

what happens if I do this? I think ##unvote

The Before Times posted:

wyat the fycj ar eyou ding

hambeet posted:

chill, he's just giving room for someone to vote if they're paranoid about hammering

hambeet posted:

it cuts off before she says "years".


cursed

Tommu posted:

##vote tommu

Venom Soag posted:

He was also pushing the MMG wagon pretty hard yesterday, accusing MMG of being scum, prompting me to detail reasons why I thought MMG was scum,

then when MMG was like, EVERYTHING I SAY GETS READ AS SCUM!!, elk was like 'welp it's mafia it happens to everyone'... I feel at though, if you really believed someone was scum, the correct response is 'yeah, because you're scum mate'

Asphyxious posted:

Also also, they spend a lot of time asking other people to justify their reads and then their biggest contribution was voting for me because I was mean to them.

That’s not contributing, it’s not even playing mafia really,

Tommu posted:

Birthday weekend got in the way of last game day but im reading forward

Venom Soag posted:

Unless his scumbuds were too busy having birthdays and being retrenched

Anidav posted:

I dunno about casing another "newbie" Gaspy. It was a miller this time but this one has only been in 2 games unless you absolutely believe there is some coaching going on.

New people just seem to post weird and I guess that includes people who've taken long breaks.

Also I don't get your sudden meta discussion truce at all. Is it a case of loving with people day 1 then offering an olive branch later?

All you've done is frazzled a bunch of people and make the game unfriendly to new players. A trend that carries over to your voting pattern.

A trend that so far has not been pro-town.

The question is if scum is to be found within your slippery Sherlock Holmes act or Soag's Rick Sanchez act.

Both are characters well past their peak.