bewilderment posted:

Without spoilers, the 'rules' of the game actually make it extremely close to a game of Werewolf.

As noted though, the difference is that in a traditional game of Werewolf, you'd consider it a 'town win' if you died but the town overall survived and so you might intentionally sacrifice yourself to prove a logical point. That's less likely to occur here.

I bought the game myself, so this LP can consider it a seller. I'm only up to 'day 3' myself.

As noted, despite the group's misgivings, the Follow the Cop strategy that was put forward - Cop reveals on day 1, Doctor protects the Cop, nobody is lynched without the Cop's say so - is actually optimal if the werewolves have no special powers, with the only strong counterstrategy in a 'normal' game being trying to convince the townsfolk that actually someone else is the Cop.