Hal Incandenza posted:

Put me down as a replacement unless you really can't find a ninth

Scientastic posted:

It’s late here and I’m going to bed, but this is for that disturbing bird picture, that thing haunts my nightmares

##Vote Tommu

Spokes posted:

dmboogie shares his initials with Dave Matthews Band--an even stronger force of evil. Truly infallible logic

##vote dmboogie

Spokes posted:

Wow, I thought you were joking at first since it’s just day 1 but I guess you should stick to it when you make a

Syrias Accusation

Somberbrero posted:

Scientastic is pinging me a little bit for trying hard this early but also I don't think it's productive to vote out engaged players. All this said with the obvious caveat that it's less than 24 hours in.

Somberbrero posted:

Scientastic is pinging me a little bit for trying hard this early but also I don't think it's productive to vote out engaged players. All this said with the obvious caveat that it's less than 24 hours in.

Somberbrero posted:

Why does it take two posts to decide if you want to vote me tommu? It's not like you're hammering.

Somberbrero posted:

Of course I lack conviction, I said as much in my post. The goal was to start conversation and I did.

sandnavyguy posted:

I dunno y’all, that seemed like a standard “let’s leave vote phase now that 24 hrs have passed” post so I don’t think I’m ready to hop aboard the somber traincar yet.

IllegallySober posted:

I’m starting to get tired and hungry and nap time is close. gently caress it.

Scientastic, of the players in the game, who would you:
- Doc
- Mason
- Vig?

Tommu, same question to you.

Scientastic posted:

What did Textbook think of Tommu calling out Somber? Don’t know, no comment

What did Textbook think of the fact that Tommu didn’t vote when he made his point, but waited a little bit? Don’t know, no comment

What did Textbook think of my case against Spokes? Don’t know, no comment

What did Textbook think of the fact I immediately retracted? Don’t know, no comment

What did Textbook think when Somber voted for the brand new player? Don’t know, no comment

What did Textbook think when he was called out by name? Holy poo poo, I’m not lurking, what the gently caress dude, there’s just been nothing to comment on, but I am definitely checking the thread for mentions of my own name, that counts as playing, right?

textbookOrigins posted:

Thread's been dead all goddamn day, this is hilarious.

The "cases" were all weak and forced, because this is day one. I didn't think there were any cases worth making, yet. I do not agree that there was plenty to comment on. Plenty to take note of for later, but nothing substantial enough for a case.

(I got called out my last game for checking when people were active on the forums and just not posting in the game thread. I'm not doing that anymore, but I'm still almost always hoping someone else will in my followed threads. There's nothing else to do, what with the everything. So it's... not hard to respond when I see "oh, a new post!" What the gently caress? Look at the posting times between you two, wow, doesn't that look coordinated??? Pff)

Somberbrero posted:

I think the way you vote is very brave and important

Scientastic posted:

That wasn’t my intention, I don’t care about the way you voted. My point was that someone (can’t remember who, can’t be bothered to check) thought it worthy of comment, but that TO didn’t.

textbookOrigins posted:

That's really cute! I am not fooled.

##vote Scientastic

Call OMGUS all you want! You do. Thank you so much for trying to act like an actual mafia parent.

textbookOrigins posted:

Lurkers should chime in one way or the other so that their opinions can be catalogued for later. Otherwise the lurkers should be replaced with people who can at least be present for the game.

Somberbrero posted:

Textbook got riled up there real quick, would vote.

textbookOrigins posted:

How in the absolute gently caress do you figure that? You want receipts for when I flip town.

textbookOrigins posted:

I mean, at this point I do think Scientastic would ping town if investigated, but I don't think it'd be because he's town.

textbookOrigins posted:

Because I think scum can win better as lurkers.

textbookOrigins posted:

So ... posting is... bad?

textbookOrigins posted:

Go back to sleep so you can pay the gently caress attention next time you wake up! Thanks!

Scientastic posted:

No it’s not

textbookOrigins posted:

"Wait, what? Why do you think Tommu's playing it safe?"

I think he was content to put me under the hammer and go to sleep and that if I hadn't said anything -- if I hadn't been volatile and defensive and wanting him to pay attention -- we'd be in nap time right now, weaker for it.

Somberbrero posted:

everyone besides boogie is above 10 posts. relax.

textbookOrigins posted:

Spokes posted:

All that said, I think text is playing weirdly defensive but at least he's here. It feels like boogie read through it and got ready to make a case, saw people lining up against textbook, and decided to just bide his time

##vote dmboogie

Spokes posted:

It's not just a "low posts = scum" thing, it's that he hasn't done anything helpful at all, got prodded into mentioning he was reading through, and then disappeared (again) when it seemed like things were starting to pick up speed against an easy target.

Somberbrero posted:

I think you're wrong. I've gone back and forth on you but scientastic was correct to push you as a candidate. Your reaction was disproportionate, which means you're either just a volatile/nervous town player as Roy said, or you're nervous scum. Town players have a responsibility to scum hunt and that's what scientastic did.