Rarity posted:

Please can all players help me adjust back into mafia by filling in the following survey

1) My name is Amnistar
2) I am a Sagatarius
3) I have been playing mafia since 2007 I think?
4) My meta is going hard after someone day 1 then lurking.
5) My favourite 90s kids cartoon is Sonic
6) My role alignment in this game is Town

Amnistar posted:

Still reading the thread but throwing in my answers to this as I'm reading to make Rarity happy.

Scientastic posted:

Fixed now, thanks Tommu

Disappointing to say, I collapsed the dayvig waveform and have gone from both dayvig and non-dayvig at the same time to definitely not a dayvig

Scientastic posted:

My initial reaction to this was that I absolutely am that sort of person, but then I thought about it, and I don’t think I quite understand: what exactly am I going to be smug about?

b-minus1 posted:

I was looking forward to the tunnel on amni

Toalpaz posted:

I don't honestly believe bif is shooketh over day 1 interaction rarity.

sandnavyguy posted:

Good morning g—

Jesus there’s 160 posts in here already? Y’all been busy

tpink posted:

Rarity posted:

Can you say why you find that entrance to be scummy?

Rarity posted:

Ah sorry Amni, I missed it. I think you're reaching here. If you'd said this hours later and sandy still hadn't contributed then you'd be onto something but since posting he's been engaging with the thread so I've got no issues

sandnavyguy posted:

Thanks rarity!

I think we are in the transition out of jokephase, and Amni is being townie Amni and applying pressure to all and sundry to test the waters, which is a good idea. Keep scumhunting Amni, but I’m town.

As for me, I’m more of a passive town D1, I’m on the lookout for performance art and lurkers to inform my vote opinion.

b-minus1 posted:

It’s day 3. And that’s when I solve the game

Scientastic posted:

This is an 18 player game, surely you should be theorising 8 scum?

Scientastic posted:

That would be very chaotic

sandnavyguy posted:

Amni, was there actually a case on scientastic? Is it just the vig comment? I’m not seeing anything else.

Scientastic posted:

Fixed now, thanks Tommu

Disappointing to say, I collapsed the dayvig waveform and have gone from both dayvig and non-dayvig at the same time to definitely not a dayvig

Toalpaz posted:

vigilante is still a town role, even at night.

Scientastic posted:

Also, non-dayvig doesn't mean nightvig, it just means I didn't get a dayvig, this is dumb

hambeet posted:

that's like getting super picky.

hambeet posted:

lol



actually no, i'd like you to elaborate as to why amni.

Scientastic posted:

In fact, I’ve just had a read of Amni’s posts, and it all looks conspicuously terrible

tpink posted:

No. I’m saying that in a game with 18 players, if I am scum, there’s like 5+ targets I would go after on day 1 rather than try to engage with the one poster who thrives on D1 analysis and will try to take apart everything I say (like what you’re doing with beet now). I don’t know what your past history with him is. I’m just telling you what I would or would not do in that hypothetical situation.

tpink posted:

On Sci, I think that vig thing would have been an incredibly dumb scum slip so I dunno. Seems somewhat unlikely.

hambeet posted:

lol. i'm not interested in their responses?! yet have responded to nearly each and every one.

ironically, i don't think you are paying attention.

are you just trying to find someone to jump onto to polarise and hope it takes off? you picked the wrong horse bucko.

Rarity posted:

Please can you explain this again cause I didn't see it at the time and I still don't now

hambeet posted:

no i'm engaging bif because her argument didn't make sense, her response to people picking at it doesn't make sense nor does it seem townie and the way she keeps trying to throw shade on my pushing her is super suss.

so what would you call that amni? in your own words.

Rarity posted:

It's pretty clearly playing off his previous post though?



So are you saying that Sci accidentally let on he has a nightvig or that he is purposefully breadcrumbing a nightvig?

hambeet posted:

lol the sci scum slip is dumb. and what's your read on rarity. it's weak, but what is it?

stop saying these random things.

tpink posted:

I mean it’s literally the equivalent of posting “I have a night kill.” I don’t disagree that that’s a possible way of reading his post. I just refuse to believe that any scum would be dumb enough to post that. Again, maybe there’s some weird meta read going on where you are convinced that he just couldn’t help leaving that crumb to gloat later, but without knowing that meta, it seems far-fetched.

Rarity posted:

So he set up the dayvig joke on purpose just so he could breadcrumb a scum claim to mock us all for later?

Rarity posted:

The Schrodinger's dayvig post was at 7:23 am BST. Sci joined the discord 7:35 am BST. How does this fit your theory?

hambeet posted:

okay sorry, you are 100% right. i didn't phrase that correctly. i've only phrased it that way when i just responded to you, then though, never to bif. to bif i've pointed out solely that i disagree with her 'jab'.

so can you try again to explain how i am engaging with her to make her look bad? spoilers: my argument would be that she's doing a fine job of that herself.

Rarity posted:

You said he setup the joke on purpose so he could scum claim but he didn't know his role until after he setup the joke. How does this make any sense to you?

DGK2000 posted:

I uh... no. No. NO. It was very clearly him saying either is a dayvig or he isn't. A binary thing. And a science joke. You've latched on to something that isn't A Thing.