Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
(Thread IKs: Nuns with Guns)
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Not to linger too long on cinema robbie but a lot of the time when straight white dudes who are way too obsessed with idpol (and for the record i dont think idpol is inherently invalid just unsure how else to phrase it) try to get on the 'ah, so you're being HOMOPHOBIC/RACIST/SEXIST' they mostly reveal how limited and stereotypical their view of those groups are. like the one saying brunch is weak/feminine is bob, and then he's associating it with gay dudes.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

id take brentalfloss over those white guys who said the nword over the double dragon soundtrack. thats absolutely the most embarrassing nerdcore music thing i can remember the internet being into

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Augus posted:

the original animaniacs had a joke about Rush Limbaugh going to hell lol
there was a joke in the original cartoon where they were looking at a map and wakko went
"Man, we're lost."
"Wakko, this isn't a map, this is the Republican Party platform."
"Yeah, we've really lost our way as a country."

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

happy anniversary to the worst tweet of all time

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

really thats the issue of most books/plays that are taught in school, you aren't allowed to find any humor or humanity in it, its just The Important Work. theres no real attempt to teach that it was made by a person with their own interests and first got popular because people genuinely found it relatable or interesting, its treated like moses came down from the mountain with it.

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Terrible Opinions posted:

There is also the issue that at least in what American education I've directly taken part in school is way less about actually analyzing the work, and a lot more about decoding how your teacher thinks about the book and then writing to that. It's possible that I just got a lot of lovely teachers by chance, but it seems like those sort of "write what I already think or be deducted points" types are more common than not. At least figuring that out around the middle of sophomore year made the rest of high school and college way easier.
yeah, american schooling is garbage at teaching how to approach something and read it on its own terms, or how to interpret art. on the trivial side of things its why americans are so obsessed with things like the 'canon timeline' and 'watch orders' even when its clear the actual material doesn't really care about a coherent timeline, and on the more serious side of things its why you get a bunch of people who view movies about toxic behaviors being bad as like, aspirational fantasies. fight club, wolf of wall street, etc.

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

sex and the city is one of the most successful and influential tv shows ever made its not an underappreciated classic

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

It doesnt mean that at all lol.

People have been sent so many death threats they attempted suicide for like, writing 17 year old x 18 year old fanfic, lol,

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

The reality of it is both terms just mean the worst version of the 'other side' they can imagine, and also its all pointless online bullshit because its not like weird fanfic is going anywhere. Literally the only opinion you should have is 'you probably shouldnt write fanfic where jimmy neutron anal vores his dad, OR send the jimmy neutron anal vore guy death threats because its not like that solves the problem' and if your opinion on it goes beyond that you desperately need to log off.

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Like theres definitely a real bullying element to all this, like that genshin impact game has a pair of sworn brothers people like to draw making out cause 'sworn brothers' can be very winkwink in chinese culture but westerners see 'brothers' and think incest, so theres an obvious clash there, and teens dont know how to behave.

I bring it up cause the official twitter for the game retweeted ship art of them and... instead of getting mad at the devs people started trying to harass the artist, lol.

But at the same time dragging people who arent online enough to know what the gently caress any of this is is just weird and awkward, and is basically just intentionally stirring up the hornets nest. Like fuller did not sign up to get yelled at about which my hero academia ships are problematic.



RareAcumen posted:

I know they're a week old but this whole time I thought people were talking about a specific group of people on twitter because I found these in another thread. Is this conversation not about the same people?
There is no 'one group of people.' Its not like theres some big proship discord where everyone talks about how much they love childporn. Its just random pockets of people yelling at each other about a random variety of things because twitter is designed to get you to hate everyone around you. When you see terms like this its easy to think theres some organization to this, but there isnt whatsoever. Which is why people are just yelling at the worst versions of each other.

Some of those people are in the right, some arent, some are taking it way too seriously even if they have a point, some take it extremely seriously and are extremely wrong, and that goes for both sides.

That guy framing it as 'proship = pedo' is basically the same thing as the fuller thing, trying to drag people who dont know anything into their dumb internet culture war.

Endorph fucked around with this message at 10:56 on Mar 19, 2021

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

my experience with this drama is i had a friend who's mildly internet popular, who had old fanfic up on a site and got yelled at for it (they wrote it when they were 17, it was just generic romance fanfic between two teenagers, no sex) and then it turned out the person yelling at them and trying to stir up drama was a hardcore fetishist who did nothing but commission art of anime girls in diapers.

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

josh04 posted:

Used to be that this stuff happened on separate websites with their own rules, so if a creepy-rear end adult turned up in your space for teens, they could be banned. Now everyone involved is on twitter with, in theory, one set of universal rules.

yeah, and that's a lot of it. plus the issue of stuff that isnt morally objectionable but there's no where to put it where you can like, convalesce with people who signed up for it. making art where you explore heavier stuff to deal with your own baggage is pretty normal, but twitter is just a giant pile where some stranger you dont know sees 'this story has sexual assault in it.' no context for how its handled or why is there, just that it exists.

not even talking about fanfic here cause ive seen actual published authors or like, people making comics get yelled at for that too. making that stuff is normal, not wanting to see that stuff is normal, these two people are put in the same site where theyll stumble across each other randomly with no prior warning. its inevitably gonna lead to conflict even in a perfect world where no bad actors exist.

Endorph fucked around with this message at 12:59 on Mar 19, 2021

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

tbh when i want 'action manga with female characters who do stuff' shonen manga isnt really gonna be my port of call, cause like, its shonen, aimed at teen boys and the editorial staff is mostly old dudes. ofc it has lots of female fans/female authors but still, there's a weighting going on there.


sexpig by night posted:

yea it's not an e-celeb thing it's just a fame thing, people sadly realize they have a pretty sizable audience that includes young people who look up to them and the whole 'loving groupies' element of fame seems like a pretty fun perk. I mean, as scummy as it is Dan's on the less repulsive side of this by at least waiting until the fans are legal I guess (I wanna be clear that grooming like this is 100% not good and also an abusive thing and this is in no way me 'defending' Dan doing this nasty rear end poo poo).
eh, id definitely say a certain part of it is that 'e' celebrity opens it up to people who might not be conventionally attractive or charismatic, who in turn might not have much experience with romance/sex. plus it being on the internet means its way easier to get access to random people half-jokingly talking about how attractive you are or w/e. put that all together and it seems designed to basically boost the bad impulses celebrity already brought.

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

yeah and i mean like, plenty of childrens cartoons have sex jokes that kids arent gonna get and im not gonna say the staff of animaniacs are groomers for putting in a joke about fingering the artist formerly known as prince. you just have to not be a weirdo about it (difficulty: impossible)

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Yeah thats weird

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

actually in the very very early days didnt the gamegrumps literally call their fans 'cumsluts'

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Antifa Turkeesian posted:

It’s weird to see a genuine accusation mixed in among posts complaining about how Game Grumps isn’t as good as it was and about how they make too much money from merchandise, and all the replies talk about this like it’s another complaint about how they’re not funny any more.

It’s like the posters don’t understand the gravity of what they’re posting about and are treating it as another thing to complain about because they don’t like game grumps vs something genuinely bad.
i mean there's a big dossier on every bit of drama from 2020 and there's poo poo like 'stole a fan's art without permission and refused to give credit' and 'randomly stuck epilepsy-bait in the middle of a video with no warning and legit sent somebody to the hospital' mixed in with 'they accidentally uploaded a mario party video with the wrong name'

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Garrand posted:

The first text was sent literally a month before she turned 18. Like, I'm all for not loving your fans and the age gap is creepy but there comes a point where adults make their own decisions.

texting a teenage fan with the very obvious intent of eventually having sex with them, when you're 42, is weird. and you can tell the intent was to eventually have sex with her cause he ghosted her as soon as he got what he wanted. if she was just someone he happened to know and they eventually started a sexual relationship why would he suddenly vanish into the ether? but if the 'goal has been achieved' it makes sense.

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

like heres a good barometer: if you knew your college-aged daughter just had sex with and then got ghosted by a famous 40-year-old youtube man who shed been texting since she was 17, how would you feel. i have the vague suspicion your reaction might not be 'well, adults can make their own choices.'

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Kaiser Mazoku posted:

If two legal adults want to have a casual hookup then I fail to see what the problem is. Maybe I'm missing something here.

1) she was not a legal adult when they met and he was over twice her age.
2) theyd been talking for years but he literally stopped talking to her as soon as they had sex

if you put these together, its extremely loving creepy. not a literal crime or literal pedophilia, but extremely loving creepy. something can be creepy as poo poo without being illegal. there's a weird thing when these accusations come up where people try and finangle together whether or not a literal crime was committed and if it wasnt then everything's okay. but no. everything is very much not okay.

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

and also people talking in serious tones like 'does this WARRANT cancellation...' is really funny cause this dude could have literally actually hosed a child and thered be two weeks of hushed tweets about it and hed lose a few thousand subs and then hed go right back to his job like nothing happened, like every other time a youtuber got 'cancelled' in the past 4 years

jontron should have just waited a couple years to bust out the race science

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Dutchy posted:

Yeah leaving aside anything else I hate this development of "power dynamics" as just anyone loving outside of their caste. I've seen more people talk themselves into woke anti-miscegenation in the past couple of years than I ever thought possible

what the gently caress are you talking about

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Kaiser Mazoku posted:

...Eh, I dunno, I'll have to wait for more evidence to come out before I can form a solid opinion. That's not to say Dan is 100% a spotless angel here, but I also want to be careful not to strip women of their agency. (Assuming, of course, she was okay with the one-and-done hookup)
well, considering shes the one leaking this stuff and making the callout posts to begin with, ill leave it to your skilled deduction to sort out, sherlock

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Yardbomb posted:

I just wish people would stop posting their evidence on future mass-shooter forums. Other than that, horrible and I want to be shot in the back a dozen times.
look at how many people are crawling out of the woodworks on every other forum to defend him, even on this ostensibly woke and 'believe women' style forum, and you have an answer to why they went to a subreddit that exists entirely to hate on them.

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

the era where joss whedon was a woke feminist everyone respected and if you made fun of him you were sexist was such a hosed up time for society

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Augus posted:

A Walt Disney Animation Studios movie that was conceived, directed, and written by white people who then brought POC on board later to “touch up” the script.
People really falling for the whole “woke Disney” schtick hard.
i dont think the criticism was 'raya is woke dont compare it to avatar,' the criticism was 'not everything that has asian influences is the same'

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

at this point i just feel bad for contra. like every week she makes a giant thread about how shes quitting twitter and then she comes back to yell about cancel culture some more. someone desperately needs to install a siteblocker for her that they dont give her the passwords for.

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Motto posted:

The fact that the victim has been asking for anyone to speak to them daily for well over a year now while the people directly involved got constant praise from their peers probably didn't help the response to someome finally chiming in with "well, things are very hard" while still not directly acknowledging the actual person.
yeah, gita sucks as do all the game journo scumbags like austin walker who rushed to circle the wagons for the rape apologist kotaku editors/writers. this isnt hard.

the logic on 'why its hard' sucks too. for starters, she called the article 'mostly factual,' when the article itself has been criticized by some of the victims as basically characterizing them as asking for it. for instance, one person is characterized as 'flirted with boss, he got handsy in ways she didn't want him to' when her story is 'i did no flirting and he molested me.' so no, gita is not being 'misinterpreted by disingenuous racist twitter posters,' she just sucks.

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

but sure, a tweet chain that makes a rape victim feel like this

https://twitter.com/alienmelon/status/1376683790983045120

is good, actually

https://twitter.com/alienmelon/status/1376668571355340804

she also blocked lawhead, lol

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

i feel like jesus representing the trangressions of a privileged class doesnt fit the bible

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Impermanent posted:

:me, being principled: i think that the two black people in the same industry as this white lady should have sacrificed their careers to fix this
that isnt at all what im saying. im saying that if she didnt have anything useful to offer, she shouldnt have made the thread. and if she was going to make the thread, she should have talked to lawhead about it first, because any mention of it from a big game journo sends a wave of harassment to lawhead. and if she made the thread, she shouldn't have blocked lawhead when lawhead said 'i think its bad that im getting harassed to death'. like why are you completely ignoring all that?

also, im saying austin walker can just not tweet 'i support lawhead' and then days later rush to kiss the kotaku editor who oversaw this stuff's rear end when he leaves kotaku. he can just not get involved.

i dont think suggesting 'maybe dont stick your nose into this poo poo if you arent prepared to do anything' is demanding people sacrifice their careers. getting involved without any resolve to do anything just makes it way worse. and im not blaming them for not sticking their necks out over something that happened at a site they dont work at anymore/never did, im blaming them for riling up the hornets nest and playing both sides when they didn't have to. that isnt a hard thing not to do!

Endorph fucked around with this message at 04:19 on Mar 31, 2021

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Impermanent posted:

that's fair actually. it just looked weird that those were the two specific names you mentioned - walker's hardly the only significant person who congratulated totilo recently. papaishu, seamoosi, charlie hall, cecilia (of course) shreier, etc. all congratulated totilo, for example. whereas gita conspicuously didn't. just got a bad vibe but what you said makes sense actually.
walker specifically tweeted 'i believe lawhead' then was congratualting totilo days later, which is why i mentioned him over the others. i didn't know of anyone else who did that specific thing, tho ofc there were a ton of people all over totilos replies when he quit kotaku so id believe some others did.

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

egg tats posted:

I wonder why out of the 10s of game journalists who wished that dude the best - many of them with way more rear end kissing than a single tweet - Austin walker is the one you're focusing on here?
because he specifically made a tweet saying he believed and supported lawhead, and then did that days later. as ive already said. rogers sucks poo poo too, by the way. as does, iunno, klepek, another random dude who was asskissing the kotaku editor. they're all garbage. im not 'specifically focusing on walker,' he's one name that came to mind because of one specific thing he did, that was noticeably different from what other people did.

and im not 'calling on her to condemn her former coworkers,' im saying 'maybe making a rape victim want to kill herself is bad, and the stunning insight of 'kotaku doesnt want to take down the article that theyve refused to take down for over a year' is not worth making a rape victim want to kill herself.' maybe, blocking the person you're speaking on behalf of once you've stirred poo poo in their direction and misrepresented their wants, is also bad? might need to workshop that one but it seems solid.

like people keep ignoring those points for... some? reason? even though they're the entire issue here.

Endorph fucked around with this message at 10:02 on Mar 31, 2021

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

DoctorWhat posted:

At what point do you become responsible for a stranger's mental health?
at the point where you start making authoritative claims about their situation that are blatantly untrue?

she didn't 'defend herself against the internet mob.' she made claims that lawhead specifically did not agree with and did not represent her situation, while obviously talking about lawhead's situation. you're framing it as what gita did was unquestionable but the mere act of doing it is the problem, but that isn't true. the way she described the article as 'mostly' factual was the fault, and framing it as 'lawhead will only be satisfied with the article's deletion' is false when lawhead's said multiple times she's accepted kotaku will never do that and just wants a few passages edited out.

and again, couldn't she have reached out and talked to lawhead about how to handle it?

or maybe she could have talked to lawhead after the thing became a drama fire and lawhead specifically voiced displeasure with what jackson said? again, not the fact that jackson said anything, the raw text of what she said. because she didn't do that either. she blocked her as soon as lawhead said anything.

Endorph fucked around with this message at 17:27 on Mar 31, 2021

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009


if george had responded to 'and what do you have to do?' with 'all i have to do is be careful about criticizing the government' that would have ruled

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

RoboChrist 9000 posted:

Yeah. :/
I mean from what I can gather, I'd be very surprised if those emails or the audio recording aren't fake. But the testimony of the former chat mod is really damning.
the 'former' chat mod is still listed as a mod in the discord which seems strange, plus theyve changed when they were fired a couple times if you go through their tweets

this whole thing just seems all over the place

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Dapper_Swindler posted:

interesting. so maybe there is some truth to all of it.
I don't think a lawyer really means anything in that context. If it's fake, he'd need a lawyer too. If it was just 'he's loving fans' that'd be one thing but there were allegations of him giving people STDs without telling them he was positive, that's hosed up enough to justify a lawyer if it's a baseless accusation.

The basic vibe I get is 'he did sleep with fans but the 'SHOW ME UR TITS' and 'he gave people STDs' stuff was faked.

Endorph fucked around with this message at 05:43 on Apr 4, 2021

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Neddy Seagoon posted:

Pepe Le Pew's entire thing has always been sexual harassment, so it's not really great optics for a character anymore.
no, they mean its weird to cut out pepe le pew but include the gang of serial rapists from clockwork orange.

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

I mean calling people who disagree with you about a youtuber nazi psyops is also being a bully op

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Also i agree about taking down her old videos but lol at 'she should delete her youtube channel entirely!!!'

She says dumb poo poo sometimes but do you really think an attractive white woman left the altright sphere to make *more* money? Like whether or not shes left enough for you the idea that shes a secret nazi grifter is ludicrous. The openly nazi grifters make more money. Jontrons subs went up when he went full race science and broke away from all his old friends. Ian Miles Cheong went from random eurogamer listicle writer to being the gamer alt-right guy and got a ton more money for it.

Like im not saying you have to love her or anything like i said i think she says stupid poo poo sometimes too but cmon. The grand master plan of making less money and having everyone call you a nazi if you say idpol alone is a narrowminded way of viewing the world? If she wanted an easy ride, more money, and more friends shed still be making vids about gamergate being cool

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply