Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
Most Overrated Stat Compiling QB
Aaron Rodgers
Drew Brees
Tony Romo
Philip Rivers
View Results
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Impossibly Perfect Sphere
Nov 6, 2002


Aaron Rodgers vs Drew Brees vs Tony Romo vs Philip Rivers

Toughest Choice in Sports

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Kirios
Jan 25, 2010




Unlike the other three Philip Rivers is actually bad, so definitely him.

corn on the cop
Oct 12, 2012

Break what must be broken, once for all, that's all, and take the suffering on oneself.

― Corey Dostoyevsky

it's brees, op

Paint Crop Pro
Mar 22, 2007

We must accept finite disappointment, but never lose infinite hope.




Tony Romo is cool as hell, and I am sad he never won a SB.

Athanatos
Jun 7, 2006

Est. 1967


Kirios posted:

Unlike the other three Philip Rivers is actually bad, so definitely him.

fartknocker
Oct 28, 2012

Damn it, this always happens. I think I'm gonna score, and then I never score. It's not fair.




Wedge Regret

gently caress Tom Brady

FizFashizzle
Mar 30, 2005









it's absolutely brees

Magicpants
Sep 15, 2011



even if we accept that rivers is worse than brees (which itself is laughable), no one likes rivers so he cant be overrated. meanwhile brees is gonna sneak into the hof for game managing a bunch of really good teams. imho brees is the worst qb the saints have ever had.

C-Euro
Mar 20, 2010



Soiled Meat

FizFashizzle posted:

it's absolutely brees

Somewhere on my computer is an audio file of Lloyd Christmas ranting about Brees being a fraud.

I don't know why he recorded it or posted it, nor do I know why I downloaded it, but it's on here somewhere.

YOLOsubmarine
Oct 19, 2004

When asked which Pokemon he evolved into, Kamara pauses.

"Motherfucking, what's that big dragon shit? That orange motherfucker. Charizard."



Magicpants posted:

even if we accept that rivers is worse than brees (which itself is laughable), no one likes rivers so he cant be overrated. meanwhile brees is gonna sneak into the hof for game managing a bunch of really good teams. imho brees is the worst qb the saints have ever had.

Sean Payton is probably a top 3 coach of all time to build such a successful team out of a game manager.

Kirios
Jan 25, 2010




C-Euro posted:

Somewhere on my computer is an audio file of Lloyd Christmas ranting about Brees being a fraud.

I don't know why he recorded it or posted it, nor do I know why I downloaded it, but it's on here somewhere.

dude

you've gotta post that poo poo. don't tickle our balls like that.

Magicpants
Sep 15, 2011



YOLOsubmarine posted:

Sean Payton is probably a top 3 coach of all time to build such a successful team out of a game manager.

in this thread, I will agree with you to prove my point

if you post a thread about sean payton being a top 3 coach, then in there i will fight you tooth and nail that brees is more responsible for his success

YOLOsubmarine
Oct 19, 2004

When asked which Pokemon he evolved into, Kamara pauses.

"Motherfucking, what's that big dragon shit? That orange motherfucker. Charizard."



Magicpants posted:

in this thread, I will agree with you to prove my point

if you post a thread about sean payton being a top 3 coach, then in there i will fight you tooth and nail that brees is more responsible for his success

Not unexpected.

indigi
Jul 20, 2004

picture me workin McDonald's!
I'd rather pull a mac on you
sorry Ms. Jackson, but I'm packin


Pillbug

Brees, but with a few more seasons I think Rodgers can overtake him

AndrewP
Apr 21, 2010

Ball Hard Enough.


Definitely Brees in terms of stat compiling

indigi
Jul 20, 2004

picture me workin McDonald's!
I'd rather pull a mac on you
sorry Ms. Jackson, but I'm packin


Pillbug

YOLOsubmarine posted:

Sean Payton is probably a top 3 coach of all time to build such a successful team out of a game manager.

cant really be a top 3 HC when you allow your defense to be putrid historic garbage for like six years in a row

YOLOsubmarine
Oct 19, 2004

When asked which Pokemon he evolved into, Kamara pauses.

"Motherfucking, what's that big dragon shit? That orange motherfucker. Charizard."



indigi posted:

cant really be a top 3 HC when you allow your defense to be putrid historic garbage for like six years in a row

drat, good point, guess Ill have to reconsider that sincerely held and expressed opinion.

Athanatos
Jun 7, 2006

Est. 1967


I think Brees gets a pass because the Super Bowl win

King Hong Kong
Nov 6, 2009

For we'll fight with a vim
that is dead sure to win.



Lets just agree that Payton is a top 3 coach at setting up an overrated QB to compile more stats.

indigi
Jul 20, 2004

picture me workin McDonald's!
I'd rather pull a mac on you
sorry Ms. Jackson, but I'm packin


Pillbug

Athanatos posted:

I think Brees gets a pass because the Super Bowl win

cheated, doesnt really count

thrilla in vanilla
Oct 9, 2012





I dont know if anybody other than Ross actually thinks phillipe is good so he cant be overrated. Its Rodgers because you can change his last name to fraudgers

Doltos
Dec 28, 2005
Probation
Can't post for 3 days!


Rivers and Romo were great

Magicpants
Sep 15, 2011



thrilla in vanilla posted:

I dont know if anybody other than Ross actually thinks phillipe is good so he cant be overrated. Its Rodgers because you can change his last name to fraudgers

a compelling argument but i counter bfrauds

indigi
Jul 20, 2004

picture me workin McDonald's!
I'd rather pull a mac on you
sorry Ms. Jackson, but I'm packin


Pillbug

Doltos posted:

Rivers and Romo were great

for me to poop on

indigi
Jul 20, 2004

picture me workin McDonald's!
I'd rather pull a mac on you
sorry Ms. Jackson, but I'm packin


Pillbug

I gotta ask why Russel Wilson isnt an option

Julius CSAR
Oct 3, 2007

Switches Set


I want to say Rivers but I also want to say Brees

Heated Gaming Moment
Feb 27, 2016

YOSPOS




What about Cousins? Hell pass Romo in yards and TDs the next 20 games or so

Heated Gaming Moment
Feb 27, 2016

YOSPOS




Oh wait. No one really highly rated Cousins nm

Paint Crop Pro
Mar 22, 2007

We must accept finite disappointment, but never lose infinite hope.




Heated Gaming Moment posted:

Oh wait. No one really highly rated Cousins nm

Ummm if you look at these ~*Advanced Stats*~ you will see he is actually very good.

*Posts 200 graphs*

really queer Christmas
Apr 22, 2014

Have you heard the good word?


Paint Crop Pro posted:

Ummm if you look at these ~*Advanced Stats*~ you will see he is actually very good.

*Posts 200 graphs*

Fails the only test that matters 👁

Paint Crop Pro
Mar 22, 2007

We must accept finite disappointment, but never lose infinite hope.




really queer Christmas posted:

Fails the only test that matters 👁

Nah, he passes that test too.

fartknocker
Oct 28, 2012

Damn it, this always happens. I think I'm gonna score, and then I never score. It's not fair.




Wedge Regret

Paint Crop Pro posted:

Nah, he passes that test too.



Needs another measurement

C-Euro
Mar 20, 2010



Soiled Meat

Kirios posted:

dude

you've gotta post that poo poo. don't tickle our balls like that.

I am dumb about file hosting, where can I host a random MP3 with the least hassle?

Amy Pole Her
Jun 17, 2002


Jimmy has both bill AND toms phone numbers* tho

*from 2018

Kalli
Jun 2, 2001




Kirk Cousins is just a diet Matt Ryan, so he can't be more overrated then him.

PupsOfWar
Dec 6, 2013



Magicpants posted:

even if we accept that rivers is worse than brees (which itself is laughable), no one likes rivers so he cant be overrated. meanwhile brees is gonna sneak into the hof for game managing a bunch of really good teams. imho brees is the worst qb the saints have ever had.

Somewhere, aaron brooks looks up at the stars in wonder

PupsOfWar
Dec 6, 2013



indigi posted:

I gotta ask why Russel Wilson isnt an option

Russ has only become a stats monster relatively recently

Kalli
Jun 2, 2001




Russ will have the most career hand offs on 2nd and 10.

Darth Brooks
Jan 15, 2005

I do not wear this mask to protect me. I wear it to protect you from me.


Paint Crop Pro posted:

Tony Romo is cool as hell, and I am sad he never won a SB.

I got to see peak Madden and now get to see peak Romo.

The answer to the thread is Aikman BTW.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

indigi
Jul 20, 2004

picture me workin McDonald's!
I'd rather pull a mac on you
sorry Ms. Jackson, but I'm packin


Pillbug

each Super Bowl ring confers 34% resistance to Label Overrated so Aikman is immune Im afraid

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply