Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
a neat cape
Feb 22, 2007

Aw hunny, these came out GREAT!


There's only a quarter of the season left. Kind of. But it's week 12 so that means another round of QB rankings.

Once again this list is fluid and it's also my list. You can make your own threads if you have lists. This is mine.

1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Tom Brady
3. Matt Stafford
4. Carson Wentz
5. Kirk Cousins
6. Josh Allen
7. Joe Burrow
8. Derek Carr
9. Justin Herbert
10. Patrick Mahomes
11. Mac Jones
12. Lamar Jackson
13. Baker Mayfield
14. Kyler Murray
15. Teddy Bridgewater
16. Dak Prescott
17. Russell Wilson
18. Tua
19. Taylor Heineke
20. Daniel Jones
21. Jimmy Garappolo
22. Ryan Tannehill
23. Matt Ryan
24. Jalen Hurts
25. Ben Roethlisberger
26. Tyrod Taylor
27. Justin Fields
28. Trevor Lawrence
29. Trevor Siemien
30. Jared Goff
31. Zach Wilson
32. Cam Newton

I will not be updating after week 16. Or 17. I will wait until the end of the regular season for my final rankings.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

BrownThunder
Oct 26, 2005

EXTEND BEN!
Forever and ever and ever


Once again Ross' list is perfect

Blitz of 404 Error
Sep 19, 2007

TYBC



Can't argue, thanks for posting Ross

shirts and skins
Jun 25, 2007

What is love?
Baby don't hurt me
Don't hurt me
No more


1. Aaron Rodgers - Agreed
2. Tom Brady - Agreed
3. Matt Stafford - Agreed
4. Carson Wentz - Agreed
5. Kirk Cousins - Agreed
6. Josh Allen - Agreed
7. Joe Burrow - Agreed
8. Derek Carr - Hmm maybe...no wait agreed
9. Justin Herbert - Agreed
10. Patrick Mahomes - Double Agreed
11. Mac Jones - Agreed
12. Lamar Jackson - Agreed
13. Baker Mayfield - Agreed
14. Kyler Murray - Agreed
15. Teddy Bridgewater - Agreed
16. Dak Prescott - Agreed
17. Russell Wilson - Agreed
18. Tua - Agreed
19. Taylor Heineke - Agreed
20. Daniel Jones - Agreed
21. Jimmy Garappolo - Agreed
22. Ryan Tannehill - Agreed
23. Matt Ryan - Agreed
24. Jalen Hurts - Agreed
25. Ben Roethlisberger - Agreed
26. Tyrod Taylor - Agreed
27. Justin Fields - Agreed
28. Trevor Lawrence - Agreed
29. Trevor Siemien - Agreed
30. Jared Goff - Agreed
31. Zach Wilson - Agreed
32. Cam Newton - *Heavy sigh* agreed

Exemplary list as always

sweet thursday
Sep 16, 2012



There's a thing I don't like and a thing I do like. All in all, voted 5

Kirios
Jan 25, 2010



Voted 1 because Tom Brady wasn't #1. If you update your list to put the GOAT at 1 then I'll change my vote to a 5.

Bill Dungsroman
Nov 24, 2006



BrownThunder posted:

Once again Ross' list is perfect

Cavauro
Jan 9, 2008




Hmmmmm

Cavauro
Jan 9, 2008




one thing I like about the rankings is that they keep me "regular" with the nfl. i don't remember how far it is into the season until the qbs get ranked once again. Commenting on the rankings. NOT an argument. Simple comments.

a neat cape posted:

1. Aaron Rodgers
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

2. Tom Brady
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

3. Matt Stafford
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

4. Carson Wentz
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

5. Kirk Cousins
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

6. Josh Allen
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

7. Joe Burrow
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

8. Derek Carr
High.

a neat cape posted:

9. Justin Herbert
Low.

a neat cape posted:

10. Patrick Mahomes
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

11. Mac Jones
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

12. Lamar Jackson
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

13. Baker Mayfield
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

14. Kyler Murray
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

15. Teddy Bridgewater
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

16. Dak Prescott
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

17. Russell Wilson
Agree.
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

19. Taylor Heineke
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

20. Daniel Jones
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

21. Jimmy Garappolo
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

22. Ryan Tannehill
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

23. Matt Ryan
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

24. Jalen Hurts
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

25. Ben Roethlisberger
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

26. Tyrod Taylor
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

27. Justin Fields
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

28. Trevor Lawrence
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

29. Trevor Siemien
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

30. Jared Goff
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

31. Zach Wilson
Agree.

a neat cape posted:

32. Cam Newton
Agree.

Impossibly Perfect Sphere
Nov 6, 2002


Gotta agree. Mac Jones is nearly as good as Mahomes.

Magicpants
Sep 15, 2011


Certified Poster

I have held my tongue for too long. Knowing what kind of persecution I subject myself to, I must release my alternative rankings: these, the one true rankings! You have been lied to by the false prophet SA2K. Besides Mac being the 11th best QB in the NFL though, yes obviously that's correct. Mouseover only if your heart has enough courage to confront these harsh truths!


Greatest Ever GOAT #1 The Best Now And Forevermore aka The Belichick of QBs: Tom Brady
A: 2 Aaron Rodgers, 3 Lamar, 4 Mahomes, 5 Josh Allen, 6 Stafford, (Russ with finger), 7 Kyler Murray, 8 Dak, 9 Herbert, 10 Joe Burrow,
B: 11 MAC, 12 Kirk Cousins, 13 Derek Carr, 14 Ryan Tannehill, 15 Carson Wentz,
C: 16 Hurts, 17 Heineke, 18 Tua, 19 Baker, 20 Jimmy G, (Jameis), 21 Teddy B, 22 Tyrod,
D: 23 Matty Ice, 24 Andey, 25 Danny Dimes, 26 Russ without finger, 27 Cammy Cam, 28 Roethlisberger,
F: (Davis Mills), (Justin Fields), 29 Trevor Lawrence, 30 Zach Wilson, (Darnold), 31 Goff, 32 Siemien

GNU Order
Feb 28, 2011

That's a paddlin'



Magicpants posted:

I have held my tongue for too long. Knowing what kind of persecution I subject myself to, I must release my alternative rankings: these, the one true rankings! You have been lied to by the false prophet SA2K. Besides Mac being the 11th best QB in the NFL though, yes obviously that's correct. Mouseover only if your heart has enough courage to confront these harsh truths!


Greatest Ever GOAT #1 The Best Now And Forevermore aka The Belichick of QBs: Tom Brady
A: 2 Aaron Rodgers, 3 Lamar, 4 Mahomes, 5 Josh Allen, 6 Stafford, (Russ with finger), 7 Kyler Murray, 8 Dak, 9 Herbert, 10 Joe Burrow,
B: 11 MAC, 12 Kirk Cousins, 13 Derek Carr, 14 Ryan Tannehill, 15 Carson Wentz,
C: 16 Hurts, 17 Heineke, 18 Tua, 19 Baker, 20 Jimmy G, (Jameis), 21 Teddy B, 22 Tyrod,
D: 23 Matty Ice, 24 Andey, 25 Danny Dimes, 26 Russ without finger, 27 Cammy Cam, 28 Roethlisberger,
F: (Davis Mills), (Justin Fields), 29 Trevor Lawrence, 30 Zach Wilson, (Darnold), 31 Goff, 32 Siemien


Interesting list, here's my thoughts

Greatest Ever GOAT #1 The Best Now And Forevermore aka The Belichick of QBs: Tom Brady should be #2
A: 2 Aaron Rodgers should be #1, 3 Lamar should be #12, 4 Mahomes should be #10, 5 Josh Allen should be #6, 6 Stafford should be #3, (Russ with finger) should be #17, 7 Kyler Murray should be #14, 8 Dak should be #16, 9 Herbert yes, 10 Joe Burrow should be #7,
B: 11 MAC yes, 12 Kirk Cousins should be #5, 13 Derek Carr should be #8, 14 Ryan Tannehill should be #22, 15 Carson Wentz should be #4,
C: 16 Hurts should be #24, 17 Heineke should be #19, 18 Tua yes, 19 Baker should be #13, 20 Jimmy G should be #21, (Jameis) no comment, 21 Teddy B should be #15, 22 Tyrod should be #26,
D: 23 Matty Ice yes, 24 Andey no comment, 25 Danny Dimes should be #20, 26 Russ without finger no comment, 27 Cammy Cam should be #32, 28 Roethlisberger should be #25,
F: (Davis Mills) no comment, (Justin Fields) should be #27, 29 Trevor Lawrence should be #28, 30 Zach Wilson should be #31, (Darnold) no comment, 31 Goff should be #30, 32 Siemien should be #29


overall very close but i quibble with a couple placements

Eifert Posting
Mar 31, 2007

Most of the time he catches it every time.


Grimey Drawer

How dare

Probably Magic
Oct 9, 2012



Mostly good Ross list, but as bad a year as Tanny is having, I still think he's better than Daniel Jones. Also, while I heartily approve of how high Baker Mayfield is because I think he rules, he also has been having a lovely year even factoring in injuries and could probably drop a tad. Pretty cool ranking though, just happy to see it.

Quiet Feet
Dec 14, 2009

THE HELL IS WITH THIS ASS!?





I agree with half of these and disagree with the other half.

Cavauro
Jan 9, 2008




GNU Order posted:

Interesting list, here's my thoughts

Greatest Ever GOAT #1 The Best Now And Forevermore aka The Belichick of QBs: Tom Brady should be #2
A: 2 Aaron Rodgers should be #1, 3 Lamar should be #12, 4 Mahomes should be #10, 5 Josh Allen should be #6, 6 Stafford should be #3, (Russ with finger) should be #17, 7 Kyler Murray should be #14, 8 Dak should be #16, 9 Herbert yes, 10 Joe Burrow should be #7,
B: 11 MAC yes, 12 Kirk Cousins should be #5, 13 Derek Carr should be #8, 14 Ryan Tannehill should be #22, 15 Carson Wentz should be #4,
C: 16 Hurts should be #24, 17 Heineke should be #19, 18 Tua yes, 19 Baker should be #13, 20 Jimmy G should be #21, (Jameis) no comment, 21 Teddy B should be #15, 22 Tyrod should be #26,
D: 23 Matty Ice yes, 24 Andey no comment, 25 Danny Dimes should be #20, 26 Russ without finger no comment, 27 Cammy Cam should be #32, 28 Roethlisberger should be #25,
F: (Davis Mills) no comment, (Justin Fields) should be #27, 29 Trevor Lawrence should be #28, 30 Zach Wilson should be #31, (Darnold) no comment, 31 Goff should be #30, 32 Siemien should be #29


overall very close but i quibble with a couple placements

Chris James 2
Aug 9, 2012



first time all year i've been disappointed in your rankings, as such i had to vote 1. hoping for a good comeback in 2022 for the final rankings

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

sweet thursday
Sep 16, 2012



Going to need an emergency update on this one SA2K

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply