|
Baron Bifford posted:I haven't found anything in the interviews or Blu-ray commentaries or production diaries that suggests a deeper meaning behind the rape imagery. Unfortunately, this is why your essay reads like the "History" section of a Wikipedia article.
|
# ? Nov 27, 2015 11:37 |
|
|
# ? May 17, 2024 18:30 |
|
Not true. I threw in a few personal opinions here and there.
|
# ? Nov 27, 2015 11:58 |
|
People are information processors: what goes in is changed on its way out. The motivations of an artist can be insightful but are not the full extent of their output. The "correct" answer to the mod challenge was to acknowledge a well-known subtext, but you missed the point by basing it on interviews and production diaries instead of the film. This dependence on creator intent is the basis of the silly Superman argument. The apolitical intentions of Detective Comics Comics, real or not, are irrelevant when it comes to political consequence. If Superman refused to give an opinion on Muslim refugees entering America, it would raise a number of disturbing questions.
|
# ? Nov 27, 2015 13:13 |
|
I think Biff has well and truly beaten this mod challenge by basically staring everyone in the thread down with his unflinching moral absolutism. The best possible outcome of the challenge is to give him that gif of Dredd staring into the fire as an avatar, as I think we've proven by now that no one embodies that image more than ol' Biff here. "She had her chance... to surrender." _______\__________________________________________ Shanty fucked around with this message at 14:56 on Nov 27, 2015 |
# ? Nov 27, 2015 14:20 |
|
Snowman_McK posted:This is amazing commitment to a gimmick. It's incredible. "I want to discuss movies and what they mean, but only in respects to the mechanics of the plot, not the delivery of the plot or it's deeper implications." If it floats your boat sure, but don't pretend you're into interpretation, you're at best perceiving the movie, not interpreting it.
|
# ? Nov 27, 2015 14:39 |
|
Well its gotten people to obsessively post about it/him for pages now, including an extended discussion about an unrelated movie from 3 years ago. It's kind of funny how the general comic thread can't escape cyclical Man of Steel discussion, but in the actual thread about the franchise people just want to dissect a single person's opinion and psychology and the movie is forgotten.
|
# ? Nov 27, 2015 14:53 |
|
The phrase "let's agree to disagree" is something that goons don't understand.
|
# ? Nov 27, 2015 15:00 |
|
Baron Bifford posted:Every gangster that Dredd kills is a cycle of violence ended.
|
# ? Nov 27, 2015 15:32 |
|
Baron Bifford posted:The phrase "let's agree to disagree" is something that goons don't understand. The phrase is understood well enough to know when not to use it.
|
# ? Nov 27, 2015 15:39 |
|
Every gangster that Dredd kills is a cycle of violence ended. _______________________\_______________________________
|
# ? Nov 27, 2015 15:40 |
|
BrianWilly posted:Timeo Danaos et Dona Ferentes I feel like the KKK, Judge Dredd, and cognitive wizardry overshadowed what a great essay this is. Thank you for writing this.
|
# ? Nov 27, 2015 15:47 |
|
This thread got weird fast and I'm excited to be on the ground floor. I am unironically excited for Batman v Superman. Can't wait for Superman to snatch Lex Luthor's weave.
|
# ? Nov 27, 2015 16:18 |
|
Baron Bifford you're a beautiful creature and don't let anyone ever tell you otherwise. Just keep on truckin' buddy.
|
# ? Nov 27, 2015 17:07 |
|
When I first put this Mod Challenge through to you, Baron Bifford, I wanted to see exactly what you would come up with with such an easy topic. I hoped you might put aside how you currently analyze movies and try flexing some new muscles. I hoped that everyone involved in the sub-challenge would have a fun time writing silly essays for bad movies (not saying the three submissions were silly, they're all very well done), and yours would be the icing on the cake; a thought-out essay on a classic. Then I saw your PMs. Then I saw your response to the posts in the thread. And then you submitted your essay. If I was a college professor, I would give you somewhere in the C to C- range, because you did what I asked of you. You wrote a short essay on the subject of sex in Alien. What you did not do was understand the point of the mod challenge. I wanted you to go beyond what the director or script writer said in the commentary and see what the movie had to say about sex to you. There is no one way to interpret a movie or its themes, and you were not being ridicululed because you went against others' interpretations. Your essay may as well be a list of facts about the movie in bulleted form, it would serve the same purpose. Due to your lack of understanding of the point of the Mod Challenge and the essay you provided, you have failed. Were this any other Mod Challenge a ban would already be queued for you, waiting for approval. In this Challenge, though, I am not the final word. The three Sub-Challenge essays submitted by Jenny Angel, Hbomberguy and BrianWilly are all better than yours. All of them understood the purpose of this Challenge, and wrote three strong essays on movies that probably don't deserve them. But that's the key; their essays were still strong and made sense without needing to refer to the director or the screenwriter's comments. The allowed themselves to think critically and find deep ideas in shallow water. So without further ado, the winner of the Subtext Sub-Challenge is... Hbomberguy! With victory comes responsibility, however. It is up to you, Hbomberguy, to decide Baron Bifford's fate. Will he recieve a ban? A custom title to wear as a badge of shame? I leave the decision to you. As promised, the three of you also get your choice of a new custom title or archives upgrade (since you all have PMs already). Any custom title you may want must fit the file size allowed, and must be PM'd to me for upload by an admin. Thanks to everyone who participated for participating. I hope everyone reading had fun reading the great essays submitted, and I hope you all keep posting crazy poo poo in the threads to come. GonSmithe fucked around with this message at 03:39 on Nov 28, 2015 |
# ? Nov 27, 2015 17:16 |
|
Have him executed. He has failed.
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 04:15 |
|
Congratulations, Hbomberguy! Your essay was wonderful and you deserve it. I'll take Archives, please.
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 04:21 |
|
GonSmithe posted:I wanted you to go beyond what the director or script writer said in the commentary and see what the movie had to say about sex to you. GonSmithe posted:
GonSmithe posted:you were not being ridicululed because you went against others' interpretations. GonSmithe posted:A custom title to wear as a badge of shame?
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 04:28 |
|
Baron Bifford posted:Goons just don't know how to let go.
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 04:43 |
|
Baron Bifford posted:This is what you asked of me: You're already dead stop stop
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 04:57 |
|
Absolutely delicious.
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 04:59 |
|
:_
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 05:13 |
|
If he reregs, we'll know immediately who he is because of his posting style, right?
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 05:14 |
|
Corek posted:If he reregs, we'll know immediately who he is because of his posting style, right? How could we know anything about his posts if he doesn't explain it to us himself?
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 05:16 |
|
...Did he just fall on his blade before final judgment was rendered? Farewell, Wanda avatar. You annoyed me well-ish.
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 05:30 |
|
My man Baron posts like an anime villain just mind controlled him into bashing his skull against a wall till he dies My man Baron posts like a sovereign citizen getting tased six words into his dramatic courtroom speech My man Baron posts like he ain't about to take this probation lying down, and is already putting together a twelve point plan to blame this and other misfortunes in his life on a randomly selected minority group
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 05:37 |
I feel like this entire saga would've made a lot more sense to me if I'd been posting in CD longer.
|
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 05:38 |
|
Baron Bifford posted:Yeah, semantics are a problem. When I say Superman is "politically neutral" or "apolitical", I mean that he almost never takes a position that could be offensive to a large number of Americans. He thinks democracy is cool and racism is bad and that Nazis suck - political indeed, but very non-controversial as far as Western audiences go. I also mean that most of Superman's villains and their schemes are too ridiculous and out-of-this-world. In the Golden Age, Superman used to fight strike-breakers and slumlords and negligent employers, and that was definitely a Superman who stood for something. How times have changed. Nowadays, Superman stands for nothing in particular. right now superman is fighting corrupt cops and politicians (who have been taken over by shadow monsters) who are making GBS threads on his mostly minority neighborhood i know this is a day late and he's eaten a 100k hour one but i need to point this out
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 05:39 |
|
Jenny Angel posted:My man Baron posts like an anime villain just mind controlled him into bashing his skull against a wall till he dies Baron's cycle of violence ends here.
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 05:45 |
|
With Baron gone, who's going to rush to post all the superhero movie OPs now!?!?
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 05:59 |
|
Congrats to the other two posters, who IMO wrote better essays than me but I'm not going to look the opportunity to feel powerful in the mouth: I'd previously said I didn't want to see Bifford banned, but his general attitude in the thread after that point has been to show that nothing can change his mind but his own - when someone simply enjoys being contrarian. they probably need to go away and think for awhile about what they think and why. I know I think clearer about things after I put some time between it. I see Bifford's currently probated for a crazy amount of time - over 4,000 days in fact - but personally I'd settle for however many days it takes for it to be december 25 next year (I can't do maths). It'll be like opening a christmas present. And for the rest of us it'll hopefully be the same - a wonderful new Baron Bifford, whose smiling dogface has learned what subtext is. Also in lieu of a new title can I get one of those tags like Jenny Angel's 'lipstick apathy' thing (I wish I knew what that was even from!), but one that reads 'Lacan's Lapdog' ?
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 07:14 |
People got those from donating to the new database server thing and I think the words were chosen randomly by Lowtax.
|
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 07:16 |
|
Hbomberguy posted:I see Bifford's currently probated for a crazy amount of time - over 4,000 days in fact - but personally I'd settle for however many days it takes for it to be december 25 next year (I can't do maths). As of this moment, he'd need to be probated 9407 hours for him to be released on Christmas next year (EST).
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 07:18 |
|
Hbomberguy posted:Congrats to the other two posters, who IMO wrote better essays than me but I'm not going to look the opportunity to feel powerful in the mouth: I didn't put in the ban, he asked for it himself. And yeah, those are from donating for DB3, I have no control over those.
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 07:33 |
|
Ah. In that case, is it possible to get a gang tag instead? If you PM me the dimensions/size requirements I can whip something up for that. I want to be in my very own gang. Of one.
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 07:45 |
|
You basically just insert it using the [img] tag into your usertext so if you ask for av cert you can add a gang tag if you want. e: also you like Kill la Kill right you should join N A N I S O R E the best anime gang Harime Nui fucked around with this message at 07:52 on Nov 28, 2015 |
# ? Nov 28, 2015 07:47 |
|
Batman v Superman sounds like a court case. That's all I've got. E: And Baron Bifford is probably gonna die in a ghetto.
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 08:59 |
|
Seriously when I was reading bifford's alien posts I wanted to scream at my phone. You done good, guys.
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 13:14 |
|
Tasteful Dickpic posted:Batman v Superman sounds like a court case.
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 13:32 |
|
Mod challenges are fun, bans are unfun. #FreedomToBaronBifford
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 14:09 |
|
|
# ? May 17, 2024 18:30 |
|
What a beautiful thread this has turned out too be
|
# ? Nov 28, 2015 14:32 |