TMMadman posted:

##vote Moat

TMMadman posted:

While everyone else played mafia, I studied the blade.

TMMadman posted:

Now that the game is officially open, we should ##vote Moat

Just remember: it rhymes!

Tobbs Gnawed posted:

I see your moat vote and raise you a

##vote Totes it rhymes.

Murmur Twin posted:

I'll explain myself in our masonry

Tobbs Gnawed posted:

r u tree yet?

Know who's not tree?

Max.

Asphyxious posted:

Hello friends I’m here to have a good time! How great is feudalism?

CCKeane posted:

I am vig. Why shouldn't I kill Moat tomorrow morning? I'm just playing, I'm actually the watcher, but please, entertain my question.

Pinterest Mom posted:

confirming that I'm vanilla town

Xad posted:

I was playing Okami HD, it's good, someone please recap everything that happened while I was gone

got some chores tonight posted:

is moat good at loupgarou yet ?

CCKeane posted:

The correct answer for why I shouldn't murder moat is because he is my friend, smh smh.

LupusAter posted:

Moat and Keane confirmed for scumbuddies.

Dick Bastardly posted:

Celebrating? At a time when our brotherhood is under attack? Have you no heart?

LupusAter posted:

##vote moat

Is this a good start?

Tolly Totes posted:

This is kind of a gut thing but I have a bad feeling about moatillata

Murmur Twin posted:

Same!

I don't really have any opinions about him in-game yet though.

EccoRaven posted:

the next player who references a mafia game that ran during my retirement will get the vote.

got some chores tonight posted:

dickb, i believe

Tolly Totes posted:

Why

CCKeane posted:

I refuse to say hello to Ecco!

Greetings, Ecco.

Asphyxious posted:

Actually TT has pinged me a couple of times now.

##vote Tolly Totes

Pinterest Mom posted:

Tolly Totes posted:

It certainly didn't sound like that! You said it was a fake point, not a fake agreement. I know this is a nitpick, but your insistence that Ecco comes off worse than I do is puzzling, especially since the original objection really seems to be about the point itself as opposed to the agreement.


The game is the same. You have more control over what you say, sure, but doesn't that make your choices more important? Disguising motive or figuring out if people are disguising motive is the whole game.

I went back and checked, Merk responded within 10 minutes of the post they responded to, presumably as soon as they saw it. It was an immediate reaction and I think it looks defensive, especially because Merk was just accused of being overly self conscious.

I suppose I don't know the players in question, it's true.

Murmur Twin posted:

I've literally never been more serious about anything in my life.

Tobbs Gnawed posted:

You know those posts update when votefinder updates.

Murmur Twin posted:

(a) It's day one.
(b) It's Valentine's Day and I've been doing stuff.
(c) How can you actually possibly think I was being serious when I said that? Of course I don't really think the scumteam are the first four people to vote for me.

##vote Moat - I don't think this is a real case, I think it's him trying to sound town.

Also am I really at -4? That's super rude.

Murmur Twin posted:

It's not like there's a huge case history to search through and analyze? Yeah I know I like to tunnel, but that impulse doesn't usually kick in until the game has properly started.

Like did you actually think I thought the scumteam was comprised of the people voting for me? I figured it was you trying to carry us out of jokephase.

Murmur Twin posted:

You asked me a question and I answered it - how would you expect it to look different if I wasn't being defensive?

Murmur Twin posted:

(a) It's day one.
(b) It's Valentine's Day and I've been doing stuff.
(c) How can you actually possibly think I was being serious when I said that? Of course I don't really think the scumteam are the first four people to vote for me.

##vote Moat - I don't think this is a real case, I think it's him trying to sound town.

Also am I really at -4? That's super rude.

Murmur Twin posted:

I thought that your overreaction to innocuous nonsense (the original "scum detected" post) and trying to spin it like it's me being caught in a trap was worth my first vote on D1, yes.