|
Five, call it Spare Parts
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 16:29 |
|
|
# ? Apr 28, 2024 09:39 |
|
Detective No. 27 posted:Hey, I have a decent idea for a cyberman story. Tell me if it has any legs. So the Doctor lands in a star system made up of dying planets. Cybermen have been converting the people on each planet one by one. Most planets resist at first, but it's becoming apparent that they'll be converted. By the time it comes to whatever planet The Doctor ends up on, the residents are considering on non-resistance and embracing conversion. They're doomed either way, so they decide that survival might be better than extinction. I can't decide which Doctor would be best suited for it, but I'm leaning on Eight. That'd be an interesting reversal. The Doctor comes upon a people who don't want to be saved by the Cybermen. "Resist them, Doctor? You think we should just lay down and let our people die? Our history die?" "But you won't be you anymore. It won't be your history. You'll be emotionless drones." "But they will remember us." Creepy. I think only Big Finish could pull it off, though. It's not bombastic enough for modern TVWho.
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 16:31 |
|
If you replace the people with Mondasians, you guys really are basically describing Spare Parts.
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 16:44 |
|
Bicyclops posted:If you replace the people with Mondasians, you guys really are basically describing Spare Parts. Really???
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 16:47 |
|
MrL_JaKiri posted:Really??? Hey that sorta sounds like an audio I've heard before, but the name is on the tip of my tongue...
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 17:11 |
|
Mondassians are people too
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 17:41 |
|
Detective No. 27 posted:Hey, I have a decent idea for a cyberman story. Tell me if it has any legs. So the Doctor lands in a star system made up of dying planets. Cybermen have been converting the people on each planet one by one. Most planets resist at first, but it's becoming apparent that they'll be converted. By the time it comes to whatever planet The Doctor ends up on, the residents are considering on non-resistance and embracing conversion. They're doomed either way, so they decide that survival might be better than extinction. I can't decide which Doctor would be best suited for it, but I'm leaning on Eight. I've had a similar idea as well: I've always wanted the Cybermen to get a chance to make themselves sound almost reasonable in a story that's slightly ambivalent over whether cyberconversion is always a bad idea. I don't think it'd have to be similar to Spare Parts at all; in that story everyone's horrified by the Cybermen despite mechanical augmentation being commonplace, in the same way as how we're all horrified by them here despite having glasses and pacemakers. I think the key would be to discard the idea of survival completely, and have characters that just straight up think being emotionless and immortal is a preferable state of affairs.
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 17:47 |
|
Jerusalem posted:
I listened to Terror Firma after listening to Davros, and that really soured it for me, more than it already did by itself. I went from hearing Davros at his highest Davros, unrelenting and unending hatred, declaring he will survive anything thrown at him... to him begging the Doctor to kill him. I mean, I understand the circumstances but it seemed so uncharacteristic of the Davros I just listened to (I've only seen Genesis and the RTD 2-parter of Davros so I could be slightly off base here). The Davros in Davros would never allow the Dalek Emperor side to win, he'd invent some kind of mind-numbing app for his chair to suppress it until he can expel it. He'd definitely still do the rest of the plot of the episode, but just to do it. He wouldn't snivel or beg, he'd demand as hard as the Emperor Dalek was demanding him. Davros giving in and succumbing just doesn't seem right. Also I thought the same thing about C'Rizz... and boy do the squander that goodwill. Completely.
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 18:05 |
|
Spare Parts is excellent, but after the events of that story, the cybermen indiscriminetly convert any people. I was thinking that a group of cybermen would find it illogical to convert thriving races and target dying ones instead. It would have right to die undertones. (I don't know if that's an issue in the UK or not.)
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 18:08 |
|
Detective No. 27 posted:It would have right to die undertones. (I don't know if that's an issue in the UK or not.) Well, it is, but euthanasia isn't really that similar to turning into a robot that clanks around electrifying things. What are the specific parallels the story would draw on?
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 18:13 |
|
vegetables posted:Well, it is, but euthanasia isn't really that similar to turning into a robot that clanks around electrifying things. What are the specific parallels the story would draw on? Well, I guess maybe euthanasia isn't right direction. Hm. Yeah, my idea is basically Spare Parts now that I think of it.
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 18:20 |
|
Well, after binging as much of Black Books as I could get my hands on and telling my wife to get me the complete series for Christmas… 1. I want Dylan Moran as the Doctor at some point. I never wanted this until this series. 2. I never knew what a shipping report was until this series. 3. I will never be able to listen to a shipping report without thinking of this series.
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 18:38 |
|
Detective No. 27 posted:Well, I guess maybe euthanasia isn't right direction. Hm. Yeah, my idea is basically Spare Parts now that I think of it. Maybe not focused specifically on the dying but rather on the suffering. "You never have to feel grief or pain again" would seem like one hell of a deal to some people. Not unlike what Missy was selling to the people in her afterlife, come to think of it. Make it an informed choice, maybe even make it someone seeking out the Cybermen rather than it being their plan, and you've got something that is at least distinct from Spare Parts, even if it's not necessary all that original a premise either. (There aren't really original premises anyway.)
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 19:42 |
|
Lipset and Rock On posted:Yes, I am sperging over the realistic portrayal of public transport in a TV show where an alien travels in time in a blue box.
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 20:05 |
|
Payndz posted:I was distracted to an annoying degree from the otherwise very good Flatline by the presence of a long-out-of-mainline-service Diesel Multiple Unit, in 1960s British Railways livery at that. :sperg: That was Missy's TARDIS, as you'll discover in an audio play 20 years from now.
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 20:24 |
|
Payndz posted:I was distracted to an annoying degree from the otherwise very good Flatline by the presence of a long-out-of-mainline-service Diesel Multiple Unit, in 1960s British Railways livery at that. :sperg:
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 20:33 |
|
vegetables posted:That was Missy's TARDIS, as you'll discover in an audio play 20 years from now. Speaking of, they lingered so long on this shot at the end of Death in Heaven: I kept expecting that rubbish bin thing featured prominently on the left (or better yet, the carousel behind it) to VWORP VWORP away after Clara had gone.
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 20:34 |
|
Payndz posted:I was distracted to an annoying degree from the otherwise very good Flatline by the presence of a long-out-of-mainline-service Diesel Multiple Unit, in 1960s British Railways livery at that. :sperg:
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 21:55 |
|
CobiWann posted:Well, after binging as much of Black Books as I could get my hands on and telling my wife to get me the complete series for Christmas… Do you mean the shipping forecast? Edit: Also, the episode of Black Books that Simon Pegg is in is the best thing Simon Pegg has ever done.
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 22:38 |
|
Detective No. 27 posted:Spare Parts is excellent, but after the events of that story, the cybermen indiscriminetly convert any people. I was thinking that a group of cybermen would find it illogical to convert thriving races and target dying ones instead. It would have right to die undertones. (I don't know if that's an issue in the UK or not.) I'm sure I've said it before, but I've always said that the Cybermen should never be the aggressors in any war unless they're already in a state of peril with regards to their own survival. This is part of what would make them so terrifying, in my mind, that one day they'd show up out of nowhere and start unemotionally converting people to get their numbers back up, and the moment their territory/population reached some point where they felt their survival was guaranteed they would just.... stop. There might be a planet or a solar system or hell even a galaxy that is being mercilessly attacked and converted and then suddenly everything just slams to a halt and the Cybermen do NOTHING. They just stand motionless where they were or go into hibernation leaving small patrolling units to maintain equipment etc and then do nothing until some circumstance triggers the,"Our survival is in danger" alert in their minds and they slam back into action and begin fighting/converting again. CobiWann posted:Well, after binging as much of Black Books as I could get my hands on and telling my wife to get me the complete series for Christmas… Fraaaaaaaaan?
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 23:09 |
|
Jerusalem posted:Fraaaaaaaaan? Oh man, I think that was the first time I saw Serafinowitz. Those were the days.
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 23:11 |
|
BSam posted:Oh man, I think that was the first time I saw Serafinowitz. Those were the days. That was HIM?!? Stop blowing my drat mind, people!
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 23:54 |
|
CobiWann posted:That was HIM?!? Stop blowing my drat mind, people! I know we've only just gotten you into Black Books but have you watched Spaced yet? Watch that, then rewatch Shaun of the Dead (or watch it if you haven't yet). Might as well watch Hot Fuzz and The World's End after that too if you haven't already, given that they're also amazing. This will also further prep you for the glory that is going to be Nick Frost in the Christmas Special.
|
# ? Nov 14, 2014 23:56 |
|
Jerusalem posted:The World's End The climactic scene in The World's End is so great. It's like something out of Who if the Doctor was drunk off his rear end at the time.
|
# ? Nov 15, 2014 00:15 |
|
I still haven't seen World's End and really need to get around to it. I didn't honestly care too much for Shaun of the Dead, but Hot Fuzz was incredible.
|
# ? Nov 15, 2014 00:19 |
|
And anybody who is still craving more Peter Serafinowicz should watch Running Wilde, if they haven't. He's a great side character in it. Also, both seasons of Look Around You. Also, the one glorious episode of Radio Spirit World. Also, Markets of Britain.
|
# ? Nov 15, 2014 00:20 |
Little_wh0re posted:I am genuinely excited at the idea of someone getting to watch smiths run for the first time. Me too. Can't wait for the new year.
|
|
# ? Nov 15, 2014 00:28 |
|
Bicyclops posted:I didn't honestly care too much for Shaun of the Dead, but Hot Fuzz was incredible. I'm mostly of the same opinion. The World's End is good, and so is Shaun, but Hot Fuzz is leagues ahead of either.
|
# ? Nov 15, 2014 00:42 |
|
All three are great in their own way, Shaun is probably still my favorite but picking one feels silly since they're all so good. Also the fight scenes in The World's End are incredibly well choreographed.
|
# ? Nov 15, 2014 00:45 |
|
Jerusalem posted:All three are great in their own way, Shaun is probably still my favorite but picking one feels silly since they're all so good. Yeah the fight scenes are good but only Hot Fuzz has such incredible antagonists and World's End and Shaun are weakened by their more "ensemble" nature compared to Fuzz's focus on the Frost-and-Pegg Dream Team. For context, I saw Fuzz first.
|
# ? Nov 15, 2014 00:49 |
|
DoctorWhat posted:I'm mostly of the same opinion. The World's End is good, and so is Shaun, but Hot Fuzz is leagues ahead of either. Disagree, Hot Fuzz is not that funny and the directorial flourishes that work so well in the mundane Spaced are just cliche when used in an action film setting. howe_sam posted:The climactic scene in The World's End is so great. It's like something out of Who if the Doctor was drunk off his rear end at the time. ...so, Rick and Morty? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s5A5Mb__fiA
|
# ? Nov 15, 2014 01:13 |
|
Shaun of the Dead isn't that funny either, they definitely peaked early.
|
# ? Nov 15, 2014 01:14 |
|
MrL_JaKiri posted:Shaun of the Dead isn't that funny either, they definitely peaked early. The main thing is, all three movies are trying to be more than JUST be funny. For as much as they make fun of their subjects, they are also loving tributes to them. Shaun IS a Zombie movie first and foremost. It just happens to be funny. Hot Fuzz IS an action buddy cop movie first and foremost. It just happens to be funny. World's End IS a sci fi end of the world Pod People movie first and foremost. It just happens to be funny. Spaced was just a straight up comedy, nothing else. The others tried to be more, and I honestly think they succeeded.
|
# ? Nov 15, 2014 01:18 |
|
Oh, I've seen the "Blood and Ice Cream" trilogy more times than I can remember. I just have to many drat shows in the queue to watch...and that includes my current watch, Castrovalva. And Hot Fuzz is easily my favorite out of the three, but the other two are still incredibly funny, all three the more you re-watch then.
|
# ? Nov 15, 2014 01:23 |
|
Burkion posted:The main thing is, all three movies are trying to be more than JUST be funny. For as much as they make fun of their subjects, they are also loving tributes to them. So is Spaced, just not for the entire episode. Of the three films, I think World's End hits its mark the best - I find Hot Fuzz's plot a bit tedious. "Here's some more generic village peoples that you didn't care about to have a shoot out with"
|
# ? Nov 15, 2014 01:28 |
|
howe_sam posted:The climactic scene in The World's End is so great. It's like something out of Who if the Doctor was drunk off his rear end at the time. So if he was Tom Baker all the time?
|
# ? Nov 15, 2014 01:39 |
|
CobiWann posted:That was HIM?!? Stop blowing my drat mind, people! At last we will reveal ourselves to the Jedi. At last we will have revenge.
|
# ? Nov 15, 2014 02:30 |
|
When I rewatched Hot Fuzz recently I was actually struck by how much stronger it was than I remembered. Shaun of the Dead conversely hasn't stood up as well. World's End for me was fairly incoherent beyond the excellent action sequences. Payndz posted:I was distracted to an annoying degree from the otherwise very good Flatline by the presence of a long-out-of-mainline-service Diesel Multiple Unit, in 1960s British Railways livery at that. :sperg: Was Flatline set in the North because if so that's not a continuity error, they alternate two of those an hour with guys on one of those handpump-operated things from the Wild West. Psybro fucked around with this message at 02:56 on Nov 15, 2014 |
# ? Nov 15, 2014 02:41 |
|
Bicyclops posted:I still haven't seen World's End and really need to get around to it. I didn't honestly care too much for Shaun of the Dead, but Hot Fuzz was incredible. I had completely the opposite reaction - I really enjoyed Shaun of the Dead, and Hot Fuzz/World's End just seemed to be trying too hard. Funny how that goes.
|
# ? Nov 15, 2014 03:38 |
|
|
# ? Apr 28, 2024 09:39 |
|
howe_sam posted:The climactic scene in The World's End is so great. It's like something out of Who if the Doctor was drunk off his rear end at the time. One thing I really liked is quite often in stories with that kind of conclusion, like a lot of old Star Trek when Kirk destroyed a civilisation or two, the show never shows any of the negative consequences of rejecting technology or whatever, I liked that World's End was pretty apologetic in showing that while the baddies where doing bad stuff, just telling them to gently caress off kind of hosed everything up in a major way.
|
# ? Nov 15, 2014 06:03 |