Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
thatbastardken
Apr 23, 2010

A contract signed by a minor is not binding!

Those On My Left posted:

people who are not voting: Gwynplaine, Uber Kosh

people who are voting for completely unviable candidates (i.e. candidates who are highly unlikely to get lynched because they only have one vote): busb, Gough Suppressant

people who didn't vote D1: Uber Kosh, Gough Suppressant, busb

yeah this whole thing is pretty annoying. people who don't want to help down but want to look like they are trying to attract attention to a lost cause - why, if only we'd listened to them.

well, I'm going to simplify their choices a little. Display some leadership. Because I'm Optimus loving Prime.

white mans burping, ONE SHALL STAND, ONE SHALL FALL.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mDTqmgT3o30

everyone else: poo poo or get off the pot.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

busb
Mar 19, 2009

Thorgie
I would make the same post as scum or town as that's how i mod the role interaction.

black_tangled
Aug 2, 2004

Those On My Left posted:

yeah birdstrike not only is that below the belt but it's also just not very persuasive

Yeah the most recent one was 7pm?

thatbastardken
Apr 23, 2010

A contract signed by a minor is not binding!
poo poo yeah prime snype

white mans burping
Feb 24, 2015

black_tangled posted:

On this, I can't find a reference on mafia wiki to say the doc revives a kill, and that a kill would be successful. It references protection. What is normal?

eery game i've ever been involved in has had unsuccessful nightkills be unsuccessful for what it's worth


think of the alternative - if i got a SUCCESSFUL mod PM in repsonse to a NK attempt, but the person didnt die, people would start asking about busdrivers and lightning rods much more regularly



having said that, BUSB went pretty balls to the wall in defence of me and i know im not scum so inclined to trust them for now - the easy scum play would have been to hop on the bandwagon

X13Fen
Oct 18, 2006

"Is that an accurate quote? It should be.
I think about it often enough."
busb
Targets b_t for pushing for milky
Potential against Kat for the same
Agrees with Birdstrike about Mith
Comments on Bif's reluctance to put anything on Mith
Thinks Bif is scum
Believes in soag
First mention in game about lightning rod (scare campaign?)
Fruity already mentioned this
Kat also brought up

Argues that he has been pushing that soag wanted to lynch both milky
and splode on D1
Drops this argument because "the logic makes perfect sense to me and
if it still doesn't to you then i'll move on"

Soft Roleclaim + Brings up the message sent to Bif
Another lightning rod mention
Asks Kat to claim alliegance
Drive-by Sky Coq mention
Continues that lightning rod is only option
Thinks Fruity is Town
"Role fishing is bad play but i have literally never seen it work as a
'scum tell'"
Guess what you've done previously?
Kat and Fruity

Drops lightning theory
Cop investigation of Mith outta nowhere???
Suuuuper suss


TBK
Light flavourtext
Votes splode
Unvotes, votes milky
Shade on TOML
Calls avs suss
For pushing for Multi-lynch, splitting away from splode

Avs
Tie lynching fan
Starts by vote for milky
Bomb claim?
Shade on TOML
Lynching her would be bad?
Basically shitposting all day (not exactly out of character (except vanya stories)...)

Bif
First real post is big effortpost
Lots of shade on soag as scum
The lynchpin for either side
and Bif's arguments
Very equivocating
lots of conditional statements
Later says that TBK is scum so soag town

Tirade
Anidav vote, could go either way
Big poo poo-fling at TOML re: watching for vote swingers, then TOML does
No message
Still suss on TOML
First debunk of lightning rod
Bulletproof people
Shade on busb's "investigation" claim
Still outta nowhere that it was an investigation
People voting for milky at last minute
TOML voting for splode suuper late
Avs fakeclaiming

soag
Shade on TOML
Comment how Auspol tends to vote whoever posts the most
Subsequently been posting a lot
Not a lot of content either
Shade on tbk too

Kat
shade on avs and soag
also mith and tbk
Soft defence of TOML
big on soag
countering busb's arguments
shade on tbk
Admits possible overlook on TOML
claims town after busb's query
Big shade on soag
Bigger shade on busb

Mith
D1 flinging poo poo (own words)
Votes milky
Doesn't change
Says staying on splode would be good scum hiding ploy
Suss on tbk for projecting, scumminess, bad arguments

Fruity
shade on soag
shade on busb
Basically shitposting all day (not exactly out of character...)

Anidav
Low content posts
No scumhunting
No reasoning
Votes tbk

Seagull
Previously argued with me over voting milky
Agrees with thread consensus on tbk
Voted for splode before switching for milky
Roleclaim
Basically shitposting all day (not exactly out of character...)

TOML
Worried about tied lynches
"So I guess the main thing to avoid is atie (or, worse, a
three or four-way tie) at the end of the day."
Shade on soag
Votes splode
Despite previous shade on soag, comes to his defense?
"wmb is a really good scumhunting townie"
"wmb is a town hero and we should all be very proud of him"
Then votes for him??
Sarcasm aside, kinda weird?
Shade on busb, Avs
"Put forward theories"
Yeah, brief ones
Wants to vote for people other than tbk, but wants to avoid a tie?
No conviction to vote for who they think really is scum?

Sky Coq
Low content, low count
Shade on Gough, tbk

Gwyn
Super vague
Throws shade on Kat
Really hard to read

b_t
Eh? Kinda hard to get a read on
Mostly low-content posting
A few theories here and there
And a bit of reasoning
Not a lot to go off

zets
white noise and low count at that
No arguemnts proffered
Nothing really to go on

Gough
Small shade at TOML
Low content, low count posting
Small shade at soag
Kinda get a bad feeling
Reasonings for suspicions seem either tacked on (TOML, Soag)
Or not based on anything concrete

Birdstrike
First mafia game
Shade on TBK, Mith
Not a lot to go on
Agrees with suspicions about those who switched to milky
with <10mins to go on D1


There we go, my thoughts on D1 and D2 so far.

With all that in mind, my suspicious targets are #1 busb, #2 WMB, and #3 TOML.

white mans burping
Feb 24, 2015
im not loving optimus prime thats for sure

Asphyxious
Jun 25, 2012

I'm trying to explain that I'm a person who wishes to live a very quiet life.
ULTIMATE SHOWDOWN

Only votes for THATBASTARDKEN or WHITE MANS BURPING will count towards the end of day tally.

Tirade
Jul 17, 2001

Cybertron must act decisively to prevent and oppose acts of genocide and violations of international robot rights law and to bring perpetrators before the Decepticon Justice Division
Pillbug

Those On My Left posted:

god drat it tirade i switched off tbk because you told me to.

##vote thatbastardken

Haha sorry man.

busb
Mar 19, 2009

Thorgie

thatbastardken posted:

yeah this whole thing is pretty annoying. people who don't want to help down but want to look like they are trying to attract attention to a lost cause - why, if only we'd listened to them.

well, I'm going to simplify their choices a little. Display some leadership. Because I'm Optimus loving Prime.

white mans burping, ONE SHALL STAND, ONE SHALL FALL.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mDTqmgT3o30

everyone else: poo poo or get off the pot.

I'm sorry i'm annoying you and TOML, but there's no chance of a nolynch with the voting system in place and i actually think you could both end up flipping town. so i'll stick with my votes for people i think are most likely scum.

birdstrike
Oct 30, 2008

i;m gay
I apologise for thread-detectiving. It first struck me last evening when Avs was mysteriously absent here but still online.

I'll stop.

white mans burping
Feb 24, 2015
hahahaha awesome

X13Fen
Oct 18, 2006

"Is that an accurate quote? It should be.
I think about it often enough."
Busb only seems to have one vote - Coq, whereas MWB already has a few people in agreement against him.

And gently caress, with that showdown I'm hedging my bets.

##vote white mans burping

Can't disobey Prime.

X13Fen
Oct 18, 2006

"Is that an accurate quote? It should be.
I think about it often enough."
and jesus gently caress! sorting through all those posts was hell. I'll try and be on top of following posts from here on out.

Those On My Left
Jun 25, 2010

Uber Kosh posted:

TOML
Despite previous shade on soag, comes to his defense?
"wmb is a really good scumhunting townie"
"wmb is a town hero and we should all be very proud of him"
Then votes for him??
Sarcasm aside, kinda weird?
what are you even talking about

that was possibly the most blatant sarcasm ever posted anywhere on the internet, and you seem to vaguely have gotten that, but you still describe it as me coming to soag's defense

are you drunk

Uber Kosh posted:

Shade on busb, Avs
"Put forward theories"
Yeah, brief ones
Wants to vote for people other than tbk, but wants to avoid a tie?
No conviction to vote for who they think really is scum?
what bullshit, I've outright voted for both Avs and WMB

Zetsubou-san
Jan 28, 2015

Cruel Bifaunidas demanded that you [stand]🧍 I require only that you [kneel]🧎

thatbastardken posted:

white mans burping, ONE SHALL STAND, ONE SHALL FALL.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mDTqmgT3o30

everyone else: poo poo or get off the pot.

oh you've got to be loving kidding me. mr loving martyr to the loving rescue

Gough Suppressant
Nov 14, 2008
I still think gwynplaine is my number 1 pick but they're obviously not going to get up. I haven't really followed how tbk is polling so high compared to soag.

I think I'm going back to soag, who I really do think is scum, at the risk of another double lynch tonight since work will get busy between now and 12 so I won't be around to flip anything later on.

##vote white mans burping

Those On My Left
Jun 25, 2010

Asphyxious posted:

ULTIMATE SHOWDOWN

Only votes for THATBASTARDKEN or WHITE MANS BURPING will count towards the end of day tally.

hahaha okay

##vote white mans burping

there's literally no reason for this to be a tie, there are 19 players, you can't have 8.5 votes each way

anyone who doesn't vote on this is a shitlord

place your bets goons

X13Fen
Oct 18, 2006

"Is that an accurate quote? It should be.
I think about it often enough."
Forgive me. Periodically checking on the thread while going over old posts must've screwed me up somewhere and I've lost track of things.

Indeed you have voted for them both. Repeatedly in MWB's case.

My apologies.

black_tangled
Aug 2, 2004

drat, it's so exciting. I'm going to need a temaze to calm down before bed.

The Before Times
Mar 8, 2014

Once upon a time, I would have thrown you halfway to the moon for a crack like that.

Those On My Left posted:

hahaha okay

##vote white mans burping

there's literally no reason for this to be a tie, there are 19 players, you can't have 8.5 votes each way

anyone who doesn't vote on this is a shitlord

place your bets goons

Unless someone doesn't vote

*stares at Gwynplaine*

X13Fen
Oct 18, 2006

"Is that an accurate quote? It should be.
I think about it often enough."
gently caress, forgot to quote.

TOML, that was clearly directed at you.

Sorry!

Bifauxnen
Aug 12, 2010

Curses! Foiled again!


Whichever way this goes, remember my scumlists, dudes. I think it's more likely that TBK is scum and WMB is town, but if I'm wrong about WMB I had some reads that depended more on that contingency.

I just think there are others who were scummy no matter what, and hey, a bunch of em happen to be gunning for WMB instead of TBK, isn't that just a happy coincidence!

Those On My Left
Jun 25, 2010

Mithranderp posted:

Unless someone doesn't vote

*stares at Gwynplaine*

gently caress

gwynplaine don't you gently caress this up

Those On My Left
Jun 25, 2010

Uber Kosh posted:

gently caress, forgot to quote.

TOML, that was clearly directed at you.

Sorry!

np just had to set the record straight

votefinder
Jul 6, 2010

scoop scoop
Votecount for Day 2

thatbastardken (9): Bifauxnen, Seagull, white mans burping, white mans burping, white mans burping, Mithranderp, Zetsubou-san, Avshalom, Anidav, SKY COQ, Those On My Left, black_tangled, black_tangled, Those On My Left, Tirade, Those On My Left, Those On My Left
white mans burping (8): Fruity Gordo, Kat Delacour, Those On My Left, Those On My Left, Those On My Left, Birdstrike, Gough Suppressant, Gough Suppressant, Kat Delacour, Kat Delacour, thatbastardken, Gough Suppressant, Those On My Left, Gough Suppressant, Tirade, black_tangled, Those On My Left, Tirade, Those On My Left, Uber Kosh, Gough Suppressant, Those On My Left
SKY COQ (1): busb
Those On My Left (0): Tirade, Anidav, Tirade, white mans burping, white mans burping, Anidav
Avshalom (0): Those On My Left, Those On My Left
Gwynplaine (0): Gough Suppressant, Gough Suppressant
black_tangled (0): busb, busb
Mithranderp (0): Tirade, Tirade

Not Voting (1): Gwynplaine

With 19 alive, it's 10 votes to lynch. The current deadline is March 27th, 2015 at midnight EST -- that's in about 1 hour, 33 minutes.

white mans burping
Feb 24, 2015
remember soag's scum pics when 'm dead!

Gough, TOML, black tangled


Maybe kenny but this makes me think he might actually be prime

He's either Prime or Megatron

G-Spot Run
Jun 28, 2005

Those On My Left posted:

gently caress

gwynplaine don't you gently caress this up

Gwyn and busb

Only votes on the two count.

Tirade
Jul 17, 2001

Cybertron must act decisively to prevent and oppose acts of genocide and violations of international robot rights law and to bring perpetrators before the Decepticon Justice Division
Pillbug

Those On My Left posted:

hahaha okay

##vote white mans burping

there's literally no reason for this to be a tie, there are 19 players, you can't have 8.5 votes each way

anyone who doesn't vote on this is a shitlord

place your bets goons

Agreed. I'm gonna leave my vote on tbk but I don't much care about the result - I'm still convinced that the push off Splode on d1 had strong scum support so I'll look at others who voted milky if this doesn't work.

white mans burping
Feb 24, 2015
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kuS0lmBaBQg

black_tangled
Aug 2, 2004

In case of night death, busb for misdirection, birdstrike for the bs post on mith, mith for her votes yesterday, gwyn for being hella suss.

Coq au Nandos
Nov 7, 2006

I think I would say to my daughters if they were to ask me this question... A shitpost is the greatest gift that you can give someone, the ultimate gift of giving and don't give it to someone lightly, that's what I would say.
Oh god drat it.

Zetsubou-san
Jan 28, 2015

Cruel Bifaunidas demanded that you [stand]🧍 I require only that you [kneel]🧎

SKY COQ posted:

Oh god drat it.

i know, right? nice little cover for all the scum to jump on a bandwagon

Bifauxnen
Aug 12, 2010

Curses! Foiled again!


Bifauxnen posted:

In summary:
:siren: SCUMMY RIGHT NOW (from most suss to least suss imo) :siren:
Thatbastardken
Uber Kosh
Gough
TOML
Seagull


Possibly scummy depending on future data:

Mithranderp (if WMB is also scum, AND more valuable than Splode, she could be scum trying to keep Splode in a singular lead.)

Zetsubou-san (only joined Splode vote on bandwagon, but before Milky option. Becomes more suss if WMB is valuable scum, trying to save him)

Tirade (identical reasons to Zetsubou)

Black_tangled was the first to point out Splode as a no-show, where TOML omitted him. This could earn her some townie points. However, if WMB is town, the “saving WMB by bussing Splode” theory is kaput, and she could be seen as pushing WMB as the first alternative lynch.

Avshalom - (if TOML is town AND WMB is valuable scum, she could have been trying to push TOML as an alternative lynch when Splode and WMB were both in lead, then bailed thinking that she had no time and had to stick to Splode. She later pushed for the tie)

give b_t some extra scumpoints if WMB flips town, since she also seems to be reaching heavily for alternative cases.

black_tangled
Aug 2, 2004

Zetsubou-san posted:

i know, right? nice little cover for all the scum to jump on a bandwagon

Well since all except two had already voted for one of the two at the time of the announcement I have to say, wtf are you on about.

white mans burping
Feb 24, 2015
get off the bongs mate

Seagull
Oct 9, 2012

give me a chip
Uber I never switched votes I was always on Milky.

Seagull
Oct 9, 2012

give me a chip
please do not slander my good name

Zetsubou-san
Jan 28, 2015

Cruel Bifaunidas demanded that you [stand]🧍 I require only that you [kneel]🧎

black_tangled posted:

Well since all except two had already voted for one of the two at the time of the announcement I have to say, wtf are you on about.

Those On My Left posted:

##vote white mans burping

Gough Suppressant posted:

##vote white mans burping

Uber Kosh posted:

##vote white mans burping

yeah, you're right. sorry. me no math good

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

busb
Mar 19, 2009

Thorgie
##vote thatbastardken

This is dumb, they're both town.

  • Locked thread