Moatillata posted:

Wow this is actually a great point because toal never explained why he voted hum as I did and I wanted to know his reasoning be he never gave it up. Great catch I think toal is a good choice

##vote toal

dmboogie posted:

please refer to the OP for people's pronouns

Moatillata posted:

You're not my dad

dmboogie posted:

##vote moat

gently caress off with that please

Moatillata posted:

Yeah never

Somberbrero posted:

The rules of Mafia, so far as I remember them, are as follows.

I. Don't be a dick. If someone asks you to chill out, please chill out. This is Fun. We're having Fun.

dmboogie posted:

Somberbrero posted:

I. Don't be a dick. If someone asks you to chill out, please chill out. This is Fun. We're having Fun.

Somberbrero posted:

Independent of anything else I would like to remind everyone to please be respectful of the people you are playing with. I do not make these kind of statements lightly.

Yami Fenrir posted:

Initial thoughts:

Hot drat, a second non-town dead already

Post-Initial thoughts:

Goddamnit, multiple scum/nontown teams. I'm going to have to revise all my day 1 reads ugh.

Post-post-initial thoughts:

Going to go do exactly that before I do much of anything else. I had a few reads that bothered me but didn't make sense on a scumteam with hum, but now that we've got 2 flips with 2 different non-town alignments...

Also, you can double mark somebody, huh.

Kind of tempted to mark RF as well just to see if he explodes from having too many marks on him or something but jokes aside, I will hold off for now.

Yami Fenrir posted:

Initial thoughts:

Hot drat, a second non-town dead already

Post-Initial thoughts:

Goddamnit, multiple scum/nontown teams. I'm going to have to revise all my day 1 reads ugh.

Post-post-initial thoughts:

Going to go do exactly that before I do much of anything else. I had a few reads that bothered me but didn't make sense on a scumteam with hum, but now that we've got 2 flips with 2 different non-town alignments...

Also, you can double mark somebody, huh.

Kind of tempted to mark RF again just to see if he explodes from having too many marks on him or something but jokes aside, I will hold off for now.

CirclMastr posted:

I'm here and I'm trying to process.

Still don't like Sandwolf's claim. Don't like Hum's defensiveness. Don't like Kash's reasoning on mark roles. I'd be fine lunching any of the three but it looks like it'll come down to either Sandwolf or Hum.

CirclMastr posted:

I'm inclined to switch to voting Hum but I also don't know etiquette about vote swings close to deadline and their appropriateness. So for now

##unvote

Toalpaz posted:

Moat do you have any thoughts on the grandicap flip?

Toalpaz posted:

really feel like this case was rehearsed in scumchat multiple times.

Toalpaz posted:

I also think RF hasn't checked in yet because he's shooketh

Moatillata posted:

Inf, when you have the time can you tell me your thoughts on Kash

Moatillata posted:

I'm back and now fat and sassy

I would like to see hum or sandwolf die

Prefer sandwolf at this point but will switch to hum to avoid a NL

Moatillata posted:

Since you're here what's your flavor?

Infinitum posted:

I am currently of 2 minds on Kash, but if asked on a position I would be leaning town slightly.
He has a brusque playstyle, but on a reread doesn't come across as particularly scummy to me at a gutread level.

I am also happy with my vote on yourself, but would also be OK with a Circlmastr vote.

The reason I am voting you is I did not like how you read tonally at the end of D1, and you were extremely apathetic about lynching a claimed protective role.


It comes across as "Just lynch someone, I don't care who", which to me reads as scum not caring who we lynch.
Town would be more interested in lynching correctly, regardless of the fact it was D1.


Also not sure why flavour was important to you on Sandwolf's claim, and gives me the impression that you're searching for a specific name to nightkill.

Retro Futurist posted:

And nobody should feel very good about the hum kill. Just because the last minute change worked this time doesn't mean it's not stupid as hell. I have years of documented rants about this

ilmucche posted:

I still want to lean moat or toalpaz but they both voted for humalong.

Yami Fenrir posted:

Got around to rereading circlmastr.

One thing I noticed is that they never actually voted Hum (they voiced suspicion twice):



But never actually voted them. These posts are roughly half an hour apart, so the second one seems strangely self conscious to me. "Oh no, voting close to deadline? That'd be suspicious!"

It may just be a gut feeling but I found it a bit strange that they never interacted with grandicap at all and then had this slight bit of weirdness around Hum.

Doesn't quite feel voteworthy to me yet but I did want to throw that out there to hear what people think.

Infinitum posted:

I don't need an extended rant, but out of curiosity why do you feel the hum kill wasn't 'good'?

Moatillata posted:

You lean town after a reread just now? How did you feel about him at the end of d1 is more my question

Moatillata posted:

Also I may be a bit biased but I think your case and vote on me are p lame

Moatillata posted:

I would like inf to check in too

Retro Futurist posted:

There's a big habit in this community of doing nothing all day, slowly building momentum on legitimate cases, and then all of a sudden a few hours to deadline there's a flurry of activity and everyone pivots to someone new, and it rarely works out.

Secondly, it tends to not be good to kill scum D1. I know that seems counterintuitive, but look at what we learned yesterday; not much. We have no history or solid interactions with hum to look at, whereas if Sandwolf died and flipped town at least we could look at the people voting him and catch a few there. That's also why I don't like the last minute switch, regardless of who it kills it throws out a solid day of work from everyone and at best puts us back at square one the next day.

Retro Futurist posted:

I also find it pretty hard to believe that we have three markers and none of them know how their power works, I'm ok with circl today to see a flip

Moatillata posted:

Kash how you feeling?

Bifauxnen posted:

I probably won't bother voting anyone besides RF today, but here's what else I've noticed looking back in light of the flips:

Moat and Toal had some early interactions with Hum that could be scum banter or bussing. Toal is especially interesting since they did cast the first serious vote of the game on Hum, which would be great for cred, but it was notably made on gut alone and thus extremely easy to drop and forget once anything else at all came along.

Grandi didn't have anything that similarly pinged me as much in jokephase though.

Moving on to more serious-looking posts, Hum threw some shade on dmboogie that felt more real to me, since it came right after boogie was marked due to other suspicions on him:


That seems like a dangerous time to be throwing around a bus vote, so I'm reading boogie as unlikely to be one of Hum's scumbros. Humbros?

Grandi was clearly pushing on Toal and Sandwolf so they seem legit not on the same team. But this list from Grandi was less forceful:


This is so vague and such an afterthought after more meaty talk about others, it could be a quick bit of distancing on Inf.

tl;dr:
* Toal and Moat potential Humbros
* dmboogie probably not a Humbro
* Sandwolf and Toal unlikely to be on Team Grandi
* Infinitum potential member of Team Grandi
* Team Grandi needs a better pun name

Infinitum posted:

Same answer. Nothing in his 3 posts D2 has persuaded me otherwise.


You seem intently focused on Kashuno and I for some reasaon D2.


Why were you interested in what I had to say D2?

If you're accusing me of something or are wanting me to answer one of your questions, I'd like you to be direct about it.

Kashuno posted:

I'm confused by this. I'm completely fine afaik!

Moatillata posted:

Let the

night action mafia^tm

Begin