Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
twoday
May 4, 2005



C-SPAM Times best-selling author
Here is a hint:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tMeu7BKE-nQ

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

KiteAuraan
Aug 5, 2014

JER GEDDA FERDA RADDA ARA!


MonsieurChoc posted:

Some weirdo Jewish libertarian went on a rant about how the Palestinians are actually descended from the Samaritans and as such completely unrelated to the Jews who lived there in the first century.

Because I guess there was no mixing ever.

Which is ridiculous because there are still a few Samaritans. Who are basically Jewish in most ways but differ on aspects of worship, including the need for a temple and where the place of worship should be.

Palestinians are mostly the descendants of converts to Christianity and Islam, who returned after the several Roman explusions and also some mixing with various other Semitic peoples like Nabateans who lived in the area, from my understanding. Ashkenazi and Sephardi appear to be the descendants of the people who never came back and Mizrahi are the descendants of the people who never converted.

Inspector Hound
Jul 14, 2003


It's Mayans, no I won't think about the physics of it

Fuzzy McDoom
Oct 9, 2007

-MORE MONEY FOR US

-FUCK...YOU KNOW, THE THING

I used to keep a document where I listed all my favorite deaths of Roman emperors and I have no idea what happened to it but off the top of my head some good ones were:

Carus: Literally struck by lightning
Caracalla: Stabbed in the back by his bodyguard while taking a piss in the desert
Jovian: Accidentally poisoned himself by inhaling fumes from a mysterious hole in the ground
Constans II: Killed with a bucket

Captain_Maclaine
Sep 30, 2001

Every moment I'm alive, I pray for death!

mycomancy posted:

God drat Diogenes was such a shitbird.

He's a lot easier to appreciate from a distance of a couple millennia, for sure.

animist
Aug 28, 2018
precolombian america was super cool and 1491 is a good book

TheDon01
Mar 8, 2009


twoday posted:


To answer all this we will need to go back to some ancient sources, which I will do tomorrow. But feel free to wildly speculate in the meantime.

Odysseus?? :rolleye:

uber_stoat
Jan 21, 2001



Pillbug

Uranium posted:

Diogenes also once said, after leaving the privacy of his tub, that he wished he could also satiate his hunger by rubbing his belly.

burying the lede there buddy.

quote:

When scolded for masturbating in public, he said "I wish it were as easy to banish hunger by rubbing my belly."
:fap:

Bob Socko
Feb 20, 2001

twoday

Thanks for this thread.

Realistically, do you think we’ll ever have a good understanding of Etruscan, beyond what we know now?

Doktor Avalanche
Dec 30, 2008

Fuzzy McDoom posted:

Jovian: Accidentally poisoned himself by inhaling fumes from a mysterious hole in the ground

the TCC emperor

John Charity Spring
Nov 4, 2009

SCREEEEE
This is a cool thread and I'm glad it's here.

It's not really ancient history (more early medieval) but the talk about the Khazars did remind me of the Khazar Correspondence which I really love. Basically a Sephardic Jew in Muslim Spain (who was employed by the Caliph) heard of the Jewish khanate out on the steppes and sent a letter which eventually found its way to the Khazar Khanate and the Khan actually wrote back to him. It's a pretty fascinating look at 10th century society and the whole idea of it always strikes me as really cool.

You can read the letter and its reply here: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khazar_Correspondence

treasured8elief
Jul 25, 2011

Salad Prong

Inspector Hound
Jul 14, 2003


Aw, I can't remember the name of that place anymore but I remember climbing on those a long time ago. Or some just like it...

twoday
May 4, 2005



C-SPAM Times best-selling author

Inspector Hound posted:

Aw, I can't remember the name of that place anymore but I remember climbing on those a long time ago. Or some just like it...

are you the ghost of a monkey

Inspector Hound
Jul 14, 2003

twoday posted:

are you the ghost of a monkey

In many ways, but no I'm guessing it's in Cambodia? I remember a site that was a bunch of small, discrete buildings like that on a grassy/sandy clearing. I'm probably wrong buy it was fun to remember :clint: (pretend there's no cigar it's supposed to be Indiana Jones)

Communist Thoughts
Jan 7, 2008

Our war against free speech cannot end until we silence this bronze beast!


AnEdgelord posted:

The steppe nomads fascinate me.

They would seem to be inelegant barbarians that could never stand up to an imperial civilization like Rome, Persia or China but due to a quirk of their culture, their expert horsemanship and continuous development of the bow and arrow they were able to annihilate the armies of large settle nations on a regular basis.

Plus when they did rule over the settled peoples they were incredibly tolerant of different religious faiths and minority ethnic groups provided they did not attempt to resist their rule.

Also they were definitely they greatest warriors of premodern society despite what nazis and weaboos say.

AFAIK Barbarian is just a word that pretty much means foreigner. The big nomads had real complex logistics and societies and it seems like the word was basically just PR that survives to this day.

It seems to be the same with a lot of barbarian kingdoms Rome bangs on about, they weren't usually much more primitive than Rome just poorer and smaller.

John Charity Spring
Nov 4, 2009

SCREEEEE
Roman history is filled with them borrowing customs and inventions from the 'barbarians' who they disdained as primitives.

Her Dryer
Oct 15, 2012

Fuzzy McDoom posted:

I used to keep a document where I listed all my favorite deaths of Roman emperors and I have no idea what happened to it but off the top of my head some good ones were:

Carus: Literally struck by lightning
Caracalla: Stabbed in the back by his bodyguard while taking a piss in the desert
Jovian: Accidentally poisoned himself by inhaling fumes from a mysterious hole in the ground
Constans II: Killed with a bucket

Valentinian I: So enraged by Quadi envoys that he burst a blood vessel shouting at them and fell over dead.

twoday
May 4, 2005



C-SPAM Times best-selling author
Tiberius: He "died" of old age at 77. As people were standing around mourning him, he woke up, asked for something to eat, and then one of his servants freaked out and choked the emperor to death with his own clothes because he thought he was a zombie

Communist Thoughts
Jan 7, 2008

Our war against free speech cannot end until we silence this bronze beast!


ancient history owns, its all the same maniac human poo poo we've got today but its so far in the past I don't feel bad about it

Captain_Maclaine
Sep 30, 2001

Every moment I'm alive, I pray for death!

Hentai Jihadist posted:

ancient history owns, its all the same maniac human poo poo we've got today but its so far in the past I don't feel bad about it

The graffiti of Pompeii is one of my favorite examples of this, and one of the reasons that I'm convinced that if in some distant future a successor race of humans returns to the blasted planet to sort through our ruins after the long lost past, their first reaction is likely to be, "heh, dickbutt."

Hentai Jihadist posted:

AFAIK Barbarian is just a word that pretty much means foreigner. The big nomads had real complex logistics and societies and it seems like the word was basically just PR that survives to this day.

It seems to be the same with a lot of barbarian kingdoms Rome bangs on about, they weren't usually much more primitive than Rome just poorer and smaller.

While yes "barbarian" translated directly as "foreigner" for both the Greeks and Romans, it necessarily came larded down with a ton of baggage due to the cultural chauvinism baked in to both those languages. Hell, the Greeks considered the Macedonians, who were part of the same cultural heritage, to be barely one step above living in mud holes and whaling on each other with clubs.

Communist Thoughts
Jan 7, 2008

Our war against free speech cannot end until we silence this bronze beast!


i started watching that chinese show, Three Kingdoms a while back about the RotTK period

two things were immedaitely noticeable:
- very homoerotic but there is no sex anywhere, the only people who are confirmed to have sex are villains
- constant references to devouring people and cooking them as punishment

so i went on a brief googling tour of some chinese history and it turns out ancient chinese people were all gay cannibals

there's the famous cut-sleeve emperor (who cut his sleeve off rather than move his sleeping boyfriend) who made his teen boyfriend into the military commander of all china and built him an imperial palace before people got pissed off about it
his dad, the previous emperor, may have died of a viagra overdose

the friendly sleepovers they show in the tv show almost certainly involved a lot of loving, apparently emperor's boyfriends were so common they are written about but without much interest in the ancient records.
theres a cool emperor with a real interesting life story i was researching to maybe write about and looking around found out that the main "villain" of the peice, essentially the evil vizier type, was having an open affair with his slavemaster who was also loving his wife. (and this guy was considered pretty much the greatest man in china at this point)

Communist Thoughts has issued a correction as of 14:34 on Aug 18, 2019

Communist Thoughts
Jan 7, 2008

Our war against free speech cannot end until we silence this bronze beast!


Captain_Maclaine posted:

The graffiti of Pompeii is one of my favorite examples of this, and one of the reasons that I'm convinced that if in some distant future a successor race of humans returns to the blasted planet to sort through our ruins after the long lost past, their first reaction is likely to be, "heh, dickbutt."


While yes "barbarian" translated directly as "foreigner" for both the Greeks and Romans, it necessarily came larded down with a ton of baggage due to the cultural chauvinism baked in to both those languages. Hell, the Greeks considered the Macedonians, who were part of the same cultural heritage, to be barely one step above living in mud holes and whaling on each other with clubs.

yeah i agree

its sorta like today where the states are all fairly similar but some would be considered more "barbaric" than others

like the united $tate$ of amerikkka

mycomancy
Oct 16, 2016

twoday posted:



Welcome to the C-SPAM Ancient History thread!

This thread was born out of a massive derail in the Epstein thread that lead to pages of discussion about the ancient Roman pantheon, the Bronze Age Collapse, the Minoans, and a bunch of other stuff. C-SPAM seems to have a lot to say about this, so now you can do that here. Feel free to argue about the identity of the Sea Peoples or whatever other niche you have wondered into and want to talk about.

The western definition of "ancient history" is not universally applicable to the cultures of the world, and this is certainly not going to be a thread limited to the "classical world" of Eurasia-Africa, so the definition of 'ancient' will vary accordingly per culture and place. I won't define that, I just want to note that discussions about Pre-Columbian American history, for instance, or other societies from the distant past are also welcome and encouraged here.

Feel free to post documentaries and podcasts and links to articles, or just engage in pleasant friendly debate about minutia that nobody else knows or cares about anymore. The Mayans were right and the world is ending, but we still don't know how they built the pyramids, so here's your last chance to figure it out!



Hey dude, from where is that graphic? I'd like to fix two typos in it and then put it on a T-shirt.

Peanut President
Nov 5, 2008

by Athanatos

(and can't post for 8 days!)

twoday posted:

So, what kind of wax was this? What kind of letters? Where did the ship come from? How did the birds get there?

To answer all this we will need to go back to some ancient sources, which I will do tomorrow. But feel free to wildly speculate in the meantime.

Clearly it's Atlantis, duh

Agean90
Jun 28, 2008


small brain: the Mayans are similar to the Greek city states
Large brain: the inca were the Roman empire of the americas
Galaxy brain: Tarascans are the Etruscans on the new world

etalian
Mar 20, 2006

I always like the story how ancient football hooliganism almost destroyed the Byzantine empire

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dm9mscL2qHU

frankenfreak
Feb 16, 2007

I SCORED 85% ON A QUIZ ABOUT MONDAY NIGHT RAW AND ALL I GOT WAS THIS LOUSY TEXT

#bastionboogerbrigade

Captain_Maclaine posted:

The graffiti of Pompeii is one of my favorite examples of this, and one of the reasons that I'm convinced that if in some distant future a successor race of humans returns to the blasted planet to sort through our ruins after the long lost past, their first reaction is likely to be, "heh, dickbutt."
Yeah, one thing I've come to appreciate about history is that despite all the changes humanity has gone through, at the end of the day, we're still the same deep down and just want to eat, sleep and gently caress.

Uranium
Sep 11, 2001

Through constant decay
Uranium creates
the radioactive ray.



Ancient history is pretty neat. An actress and sex worker eventually married a Byzantine emperor, saved his reign by subduing riots, rebuilt Constantinople, and was venerated as a saint: Theodora.

Dreddout
Oct 1, 2015

You must stay drunk on writing so reality cannot destroy you.

Captain_Maclaine posted:

The graffiti of Pompeii is one of my favorite examples of this, and one of the reasons that I'm convinced that if in some distant future a successor race of humans returns to the blasted planet to sort through our ruins after the long lost past, their first reaction is likely to be, "heh, dickbutt."

"The ancient pre-interstellar american civilization appeared to worship this double sided anthropomorphic phallus as a god. They would even include him in unrelated media. The implication being that all things ultimately lead back to dickbutt"


Hentai Jihadist posted:

so i went on a brief googling tour of some chinese history and it turns out ancient chinese people were all gay cannibals

sry to burst your bubble but the cannibal thing was likely the invention of later dynasties in order to demonize Dong Zhou

Captain_Maclaine
Sep 30, 2001

Every moment I'm alive, I pray for death!

Dreddout posted:

"The ancient pre-interstellar american civilization appeared to worship this double sided anthropomorphic phallus as a god. They would even include him in unrelated media. The implication being that all things ultimately lead back to dickbutt"

brb got a new book proposal to submit to my publisher.

Real hurthling!
Sep 11, 2001




the word barbarians, from greek barbaroi, is literally exactly the same kind of insult as if we called chinese people "ching chong" today.
the greeks felt that bar bar bar was what west asians sounded like

C-Euro
Mar 20, 2010

:science:
Soiled Meat
I played a ton of Age of Empires 1 as a kid and I attribute that to my long-running interest in antiquity.

Shibby0709
Oct 30, 2011

one fat looking fat guy

Inspector Hound posted:

Aw, I can't remember the name of that place anymore but I remember climbing on those a long time ago. Or some just like it...

This is Mỹ Sơn in Central Vietnam not far from Da Nang. It is one of the best preserved sites of the old Champa civilization that predated the Vietnamese in the area. I visited it a few years back. It's a beautiful place. The Americans bombed it during the Vietnam War.

mycomancy
Oct 16, 2016

Real hurthling! posted:

the word barbarians, from greek barbaroi, is literally exactly the same kind of insult as if we called chinese people "ching chong" today.
the greeks felt that bar bar bar was what west asians sounded like

I don't know why but this struck me as very funny.

twoday
May 4, 2005



C-SPAM Times best-selling author

Real hurthling! posted:

the word barbarians, from greek barbaroi, is literally exactly the same kind of insult as if we called chinese people "ching chong" today.
the greeks felt that bar bar bar was what west asians sounded like

From this the Barbary Coast of North Africa got its name, and this is why the people there are called Berbers. They would call themselves Amazigh or some other local group name.

Real hurthling!
Sep 11, 2001




Shibby0709 posted:

This is Mỹ Sơn in Central Vietnam not far from Da Nang. It is one of the best preserved sites of the old Champa civilization that predated the Vietnamese in the area. I visited it a few years back. It's a beautiful place. The Americans bombed it during the Vietnam War.

my large world heritage son

sullat
Jan 9, 2012

Uranium posted:

Ancient history is pretty neat. An actress and sex worker eventually married a Byzantine emperor, saved his reign by subduing riots, rebuilt Constantinople, and was venerated as a saint: Theodora.

Well. She didn't subdue the riots, Belisarius did by killing thousands of people. She just gave Justinian some backbone by scolding him when he was thinking of grabbing the Imperial treasury and legging it.

twoday
May 4, 2005



C-SPAM Times best-selling author
Anyone have some cool ancient deities to share?

I think Bes is kind of neat. He was the ancient Egyptian dwarf god of music and warfare. People used to pray to him for protection from snake bites.



Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Communist Thoughts
Jan 7, 2008

Our war against free speech cannot end until we silence this bronze beast!


Dreddout posted:

"The ancient pre-interstellar american civilization appeared to worship this double sided anthropomorphic phallus as a god. They would even include him in unrelated media. The implication being that all things ultimately lead back to dickbutt"


sry to burst your bubble but the cannibal thing was likely the invention of later dynasties in order to demonize Dong Zhou

dong zhou is the least of it. i dont know a whole lot about china but from what i've looked into it medicinal cannibalism and cannibalism as a "gently caress you" seem fairly common in chinese history even into the modern period

according to wikipedia people were also just straight up cooked as food in "ancient times" but its very badly sourced

every culture has some weird poo poo to do with cannibalism though, look at the catholics, but im still holding onto my ancient gay cannibals hypothesis

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply