Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Farg
Nov 19, 2013
no way this all doesn't end with a zodiark v hydaelyn mech battle. the only question is who our opponent is and who is piloting what

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
fandaniel, back at it again in the white robes

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
i never realized how badly alphinaud needs to become MCH until now

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
the ironworks figured out time travel using technology reverse engineered from a space alien, and the immortal interdimensional wizards were blindsided by that plus the giant tower built by a society that reverse engineered space alien tech.

huh.

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
also after the people who reverse engineered time travel from space aliens sent back a catboy in a giant crystal tower to save the past, a gigantic space alien refugee woke up to protect them

Farg
Nov 19, 2013

cheetah7071 posted:

I haven't read the new story so maybe it clarifies but my recollection from the Twinning notes is that time travel was reverse engineered from Alexander, and they reverse engineered Omega to figure out how to aim the crystal tower's existing rift-traveling technology at a new place without getting lost

yeah this

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
imo the mostly likely scenario is that we pilot hydaelyn like a fuckin' mech suit or w/e against zodiark!zenos and both are completely destroyed in the process. no more benevolent god protecting the world, just us.

(20% chance this is flipped and for some reason we are piloting zodiark against zenos!hydaelyn. this would require venat to come into play)

even odds if zodiark and/or hydy show up in a form other than 'big crystal'. if they do, humanoid forms reminiscent of e8 shiva, obv.



solid 80% chance by the end of this we are neither the warrior of light or the warrior of darkness, but instead ''the warrior of dawn''

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
we gonna either eat zodiark or hydy to power up and face down powered up zenos who ate the other one

also at some point there will be a larger/newer danger force and we will power up off the prayers and hope and bonds and poo poo of everyone we've met along the way

also at one point we will be referred to as the "Warrior of Dawn"

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
we aren't azem, azem is us. we aren't special because of who we used to be, we've just Always Been This Way

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
i just dont really get the 'azem stuff cheapens your character' argument. sundered souls and past lives have been on the table for a while. all the azem stuff does is confirm that you've been the way you are even across other lifetimes

Farg
Nov 19, 2013

thetoughestbean posted:

Funny, I don’t get how the Azem stuff improves the story in any way! I don’t know how any story has been improved by having the main character be important because of them being a reincarnation of someone important from the past.

And I would have rather the question of why the WoL is naturally powerful and heroic be left up to player interpretation rather than them being the 9/14s reincarnation of the Ur-Hero

they aren't important because they are a reincarnation. they are important because of the type of person they are and the type of things they do, and they are the type of person who is the warrior of light/darkness so hard that they've always been that type of person

Farg
Nov 19, 2013

Cleretic posted:

You don't understand the angle that them coming out and directly saying 'your character, who was previously a nobody that got everywhere we've seen solely through personal effort and achievement, is actually one of the fourteen most Super Special people in the world in a past life and has established history with the big bad villains (that you may or may not actually like) and may in fact be the literal reincarnation of an in-universe god' might cheapen things for people who enjoyed that personal journey?

I liked that the WoL's journey was essentially 'started from the bottom now we're here', so I'm not a fan of the reveal that it's actually 'started here, now we're back here, not sure if we ever left actually'

i think we just gonna fundamentally disagree, i don't see a meaningful difference between "started from the bottom now we're here" and "im the kind of person who can 'start from the bottom now we're here' across lifetimes because my adventurer hustle game is that legit'"

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
i dunno dudes its like 3 am, its a matter of perspective and mine is better because i like it more and it doesn't bother me

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
also when the crystal said 'yours is the seat of azem' in the cutscene pre-WOL fight it was rad as hellllll

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
my real guess for azem-stuff is that when the zodiark/hydaelyn stuff was happening in the Final Days, they went off with whatever allies they might have had to try to kill whatever was causing the Sound

so whenever the Sound becomes a central concern, either in 6.0 or afterwards, what they knew/found out will be important to discover

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
yeah for the sound to not be A Thing the game would have to ignore a large amount of stuff its already explicitly said about it

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
what tha gently caress is a woobie

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
i'd bet that we'll have another sundered ascian show up and go 'uhhh hey so our master plan is over and fandaniel is a problem' and team up with us

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
fandaniel restarts the final days, we need to go to zodiark to find a way to use him to fix it

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
i guess in the sense that he got ate by thordan using nidhoggs eye and then the eye got popped sure

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
zenos is gonna eat zodiark so hydaelyn is gonna let herself get eaten by wol

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
the twins gonna get fuckin obliterated baby

Farg
Nov 19, 2013

Nebrilos posted:

Forgive me if these questions are naive. I seem to be bad at picking up subtext. And text.

At the conference between the Garlean Emperor and the leaders of Eorzia, the Emperor reveals that his goal is to cause the Rejoining "because that is the only way the mankind will be strong enough to fight the Ascians". But the Ascians' whole objective is to cause the rejoining. So his secret plan to defeat the Ascians is to accomplish their entire object for them? How does that make any sense? I had hoped that this question would be revisited, but since he died I guess it will never be explained.

The Emperor criticizes Gridania for trying to summon the Twelve in order to deal with Meteor, but why does no one point out that the Empire is responsible for Meteor?

The flood of darkness that destroyed the Thirteenth rendered it useless to the Ascians, but they were behind the flood of light on the First, which would have also rendered it useless. What was their actual plan on the First supposed to be?

It is shown on multiple occasions that Ran-jit is capable of seeing hidden things. Why is Thancred able to defeat him by turning invisible?

It is brought up that Elidibus has forgotten some things. What exactly did he forget? A promise to Azem? Did he forget about the whole Rejoining plan? Why did Emet-Selch help the WoL kill a person who was trying to achieve Emet's goals? Why does Elidibus constantly blame the WoL for killing Lahabrea, when it was the Archbishop of Ishgard who betrayed and killed Lahabrea?

How does everyone know that the WoL is a fragment of Azem? There were some hints on the first visit to Amourot that the WoL was a fragment of someone important to Emet-Selch and that Adbert was a fragment of the same person as the WoL, but how do we know that they are fragments of Azem, specifically? If the WoL was a fragment of Azem, shouldn't they be an Ascian, or were they spared that, since Azem didn't participate in the summoning of Zodiark?

"The Shadowhunter" carries the masks of all the Ascians he's killed, but how is he killing them? Does he carry white auracite? Can Garleans even use white auracite, given they can't use magic?

I feel like Tsukuyomi's summoning was completely avoidable. "Tsuyu"'s reaction to her parents showed she was starting to regain her memories, and she's shown she is capable of escaping the Doman Enclave, so they should have had someone accompanying her at all times. Her brother's outbursts to the WoL should have shown that he was not on the up-and-up, so they should have had someone escorting him any time he was in the Doman Enclave. Either of these measures would have prevented the tragedy.

Where was Gaia for the hundred years between when she was born and when she attacked in Eden's Gate: Descent? Also, what was that monster carrying her? Just something she created with her dark powers?

When Ryne and Gaia aren't sure what to do about their work being undone at the beginning of Eden's Promise, why don't they consider asking Uranger for advice? The WoL can still ferry messages between the First and the Source for them.

Mitron was one of the convocation of 14. Shouldn't that make him an unsundered? I thought all of the unsundered were supposed to be dead after Elidibus died.

How was the copied factory not noticed by Eulmore, since most of it is exposed to the sky and Eulmorians have airships?

In the lore of Nier: Automata, androids are programmed to love humans to an extent almost bordering on obsession, yet 2P and 2B don't really react to suddenly seeing humans again.

In ARR, the WoL slowly amasses 6 crystals of different colors, mostly from dealing with beast tribes. The WoL gets them, and then they are taken away, and then the WoL gets them back again. It's never really explained why they matter and they haven't been mentioned since HW.

Midgar-zolmir, Omega, and the technology behind Ultima are said to come from another planet. How does that fit in with the cosmology we know about, where there are 13 alternate dimensions. Are there other inhabited planets on the First as well?

One of the early Astrologian quests involves trying to find a woman who got separated from you in Limsa at night. One of the people you ask for information mentions "She's probably been taken to a pleasure-barge by now." Is sex slavery legal in Limsa? Does Merlwyb know? Why are we doing anything else besides immediately shutting it down?

One of the early Samurai quests involves a woman who owes money to an usurious moneylender and will probably be sold into sex slavery since she can't pay. When the moneylender is confronted, he says "You can't do anything to me, because this is all legal." It's legal in Ul'dah too? Why are we doing anything to help these two city states when they are so awful?

1. he's a dipshit

2. he's a hypocrite

3. they weren't trying to flood of light it, just get it to the tilting point so it would merge with the source at the next calamity

4. stopping his heartbeat and being 'dead' outsmarted ranjits vision

5. he's been around for countless years and has magical alzheimers and is losing his sense of self and his finer memories, the names and faces of his comrades, the specific moments, etc

6. in the cutscene pre-trial you literally have the soul stone of azem and emet selchs ascian-voice says 'yours is the 14th seat, the seat of azem'. azem left the convocation and didn't participate in summoning zodiark OR hydaelyn. their ultimate fate is unknown

7. there are lesser ascians that the Actual Ascians use as minions who can just be killed. they pop up in a few job quests and the like.

8. deeplomatic eemunitee

9. gaia-as-ascian got loving killed, her soul was recycled, she was born again and grew up and then the events of eden happen. also yeah something like that, made with her power as she was being controlled

10. ladies be doing it for themselves

11. no, the unsundered were members of the convocation of 14 who didn't get split in the sundering. the sundered ascians are members of the convocation who the unsundered ascians sought out and then uplifted by giving them their memories back via soul crystal


12. gently caress man, i dunno

13. gently caress man, i dunno, we'll find out maybe. (alternatively: there are no humans in ffxiv)

14. big ol aethery crystals of light that hydaelyn uses to help you out. honestly i was always fuzzy on this one. they aren't super special artifacts though its just a poo poo ton of aether iirc

15. they are literally space aliens, and not from one of hydaelyns shards. we don't totally know how the cosmology works. i like to think its a weird fuzzy area of space with a bunch of overlapping dimensions, but we dont actually know

16. shits illegal and shut down but also there are lots of evil pirates about so, yknow. we kill a bunch of em in satasha

17. uldah sucks yeah. i think actual slavery got outlawed in the recent history so that dude probably wasn't on the up and up.

Farg
Nov 19, 2013

Gearhead posted:

The only things we know about the WoL is that they appear to not be native to Eorzea, they came from somewhere else, and they had a friend who drowned when they were young. And this may be the original thing which set them on their current path.

The most recent, likely previous incarnation of the played character that we're aware of was Tenzen.

We aren't sure how long people sit in the lifestream before their souls are recycled.

Where's the drowned friend thing come from?

Farg
Nov 19, 2013

Gearhead posted:

DRK quest, just as you start to realize that Fray is actually your dark side, Fray starts ranting about how they always hated the sea because it reminded them of someone they lost when they were younger.

If your referring to the 45 quest, the friend he's referring to is yourself, and the incident is when you fought Leviathan

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
i dont get why people get like mad or offended when you lose a fight in the narrative. like, for me its just 'ah ok the games doing a thing, gotcha', but some people take it as a personal attack or some poo poo

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
that won't happen because it's not the part of the story where that happens anymore

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
yeah coming back via corpse possession echo/ascian style is said to have been a surprise to him

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
i mean, ardbert and wol are literally soulmates

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
it seems like a fairly obvious thing to me that the guy who shows up and tells everyone that he doesn't want anything besides death and don't try to reason with him because thats all there is to him, and then spends a lot of time when other characters can't see him smiling knowingly, maybe be masking large aspects of his intentions/plans/motives

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
we could just take out zenos' knees and then like, lend her a gun

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
I mean I definitely wanna zenos die in some sort of way that is personally tormenting, I also want a sick fight accompanied by sokens best take on the MGR ost

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
The WoL kills Zenos by poisoning his food

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
people were extremely "ughh this villain is gonna suck" about emet in 4.4/4.5

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
neither did fandaniel?

Farg
Nov 19, 2013

Sherry Bahm posted:

Characters like Cylva don't draw as much ire because, as far as we're aware, she's already spent over a hundred years feeling bad about it and basically tried to get us to put her out of her misery. Not much we can do there that she isn't already doing to herself.

But then you look at Gaius, who's newfound hate-boner for the Ascians conveniently puts them on our side now, and will still casually comment about how he still believes in the Empire, and intends to "do it right" this time when he finally gets all the "bad apples" out of there, and it's hard to have any real sympathy for the man, even when that same Empire literally eats up his children alive in mad scientist mecha experiments.


Turning into a God in the presence of a renowned God-Slayer is never a good move, no.

gaius isn't actually saying that poo poo by the time werlyt concludes

Farg
Nov 19, 2013
The clouds part and its 90% water

Farg
Nov 19, 2013

Cythereal posted:

Personally, what I'm hoping for is that there was no mysterious threat that brought down the Amaurotines. The Sound was an invention of Emet's recollections to explain the fear that brought down their society. They never 'mysteriously lost control,' it wasn't inflicted on them by an outside source, Amaurot died because people were afraid and misused their gifts. Zodiark saved the world from the actual threat facing it: Amaurot. A reality that Emet could never face, that Amaurot was the cause of its own destruction and needed to die.

I don't think this will occur, it doesn't make a lot of sense

Farg
Nov 19, 2013

Moofia Boss Val posted:

A king is invested in the fate of his country. It is in his selfinterest to ensure the wellbeing and prosperity of his people and his land. The king cannot easily walk away from his kingdom when things go south; his fate is anchored to it. If his people revolt or his kingdom is invaded, he and his family will most likely die. The king is extremely motivated to act in the best interests of his kingdom.

Elected officials in a democracy, however, are not invested in the fate of their country. They do not own the land or the people, nor are they at personal risk if things go south. The worst thing that can happen to an elected official is that they don't win reelection. As such, elected officials tend to not act in the best interests of their country, but for personal gain. They will take bribes/lobbying money or pay back favors by voting to do things that are counter to the wellbeing of the people and the country.

Furthermore, kings are highly visible public figures. They cannot act as a tyrant, or else they won't be king for very long. Pop culture likes to depict evil kings a lot, but in history most evil kings who fell in line were quickly punished and regined in by the aristocracy, and if not... they were overthrown and killed, and replaced by someone else who doesn't antagonize the populace. Whereas democracy as an institution exists to hide who the real decision makers are (usually wealthy unelected officials who are bribing the elected officials to work for them). People in feudal kingdoms were often more free than people in modern democratic societies, but I digress.
Ala Mhigo had a bad king, and as what usually happens in history, he was overthrown rather quickly. The only notable damage he managed to accomplish was sneak attacking an order of monks and wiping them out, before the rest of the country promptly took up arms and shut down the king. I find it most incredulous, however, that there were apparently no survivors of the royal family whatsoever. Ala Mhigo must've had some pretty awful bookkeeping of the royal family's heritage for no one to be able to figure out who was the next one in the line of succession, be they a cousin five times removed or whatever. Even that couldn't be found, there surely had to be some popular aristocrats who would have been nominated to start the next dynasty. Even if all of the aristocratic families had somehow died out, they could have just grabbed some popular local community leader and made him one too.



Then again, the Ala Mhigo storyline in Stormblood is quite poorly written. We're talking about Conrad's resistance group - said to be the largest of the many different resistance groups - apparently didn't even have a successor they planned to restore the throne, let alone an idea for what kind of government they would establish. Conrad also brought up that there were multiple factions in the Resistance with different ideas for what Ala Mhigo's government should be, but we never see them and that conflict is never brought up again (would have been great patch story material, but alas).
Could have been made by a good willed Amaurotine like Azem or Venat, but once the founders died out the society could have easily derailed as the following generations had slightly different ideas from their predecessors, until by today modern Sharalayn ideology is unrecognizable from whatever it was originally like.
Going by how it seems that Sharlayan is somehow involved in the creation and working of the towers, I suspect that the Forum is in collusion with Fandaniel and Zenos.

https://twitter.com/chocoboof/status/1396233293708763136


I think that (5.55) dad saw which way the wind was blowing in the Forum, but disagrees with the rest of the Forum (who voted unanimously to reject Eorzea's call for aid). So to maintain appearances, he voted to agree with the plan. That means he won't have to resign or be imprisoned... or possibly killed. He still has some power. I'm guessing he's going to try to work from behind the scenes to stop whatever is happening. He may have cut ties with his kids in order to keep them from being targetted by the Forum if they ever discover he is actually working against them. We know from the Astrologian storyline that the Forum is quite ruthless when comes to dealing with perceived traitors.
He was there as the Eastern Alliance's representative so the two continental alliances can coordinate with each other.

G'raha Tia was the useless guy in the room. He didn't have a single line at the meeting. Then again, G'raha Tia and Alphinaud are constantly fighting for screentime whenever they are in the same scene together. Whenever Alphinaud is the lead speaker, G'raha Tia has nothing to say, and vice versa.

this rules. keep it up. november is a long ways away

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Farg
Nov 19, 2013

Moofia Boss Val posted:


As for the 6.X patches, I'm hoping that they do the GW2 thing of having each patch introduce a brand new zone, so that way we can have the new saga kick off with an entirely brand new cast and continent/setting and we won't have to ever see Eorzea or the Scions or the city state leaders again.


weird

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply