Retro Futurist posted:

Toalpaz posted:

Please quote this post if you're scum.

Toalpaz posted:

##vote AA

This is a scum post trying to seem cool and with joke phase, but secretly wishing a turbo actually takes off. Note that AA doesn't put a vote down or even jokenly try and start a turbo on a person. The ultimate early scum hedge.

I'm not saying everyone who calls for a day 1 turbo is scum but it's probably at least more than half.

Quidthulhu posted:

I dunno about this. The case on me from Chili is essentially a shot in the dark that most people have just been like “yeah could be” about, if it’s even been mentioned, so to jump on Toal not discussing what isn’t really being discussed is weird to me.

Mr. Steak posted:

i would like to play, but first somebody tell me what the gently caress a mason does

Quidthulhu posted:

Mmmmm, not sure I like that explanation from Fenrir, feels a bit like backtrack explaining from his original stance

Anomalous Amalgam posted:

I will say, I don't think Yami is making good stances here... not quite full cases.

Toalpaz posted:

I've written plenty of good manuscripts as town. I would point to them but I don't care enough to.

I would say that LupusAter is probably scum too. Thank you.

Paul ReiserFS posted:

This is a scumpost IMO

Toal reads overzealous/stupid town to me at this point especially given the tunneling on Lupus after a non-case accusation

But Yami is just +1'ing nonsense and acting like "what are your thoughts" is content

Yami Fenrir posted:

chili I like your style.

relatedly, toal is pinging me here.


I don't like how Toal responded to this post but not to chili's read on quid at all.

Feels like Toal's going for the low hanging fruit there to me. I've seen toal play a few times and I do feel town toal wouldn't have ignored chili the way he did here.

##vote Toalpaz

Yami Fenrir posted:

lol It's been about toal from the beginning, scumbo.

Your reaction does make me think that toal was being dodgy about commenting about a 'case' on a scumbo even more now.

Would vote either toal or quid today.

Chili posted:

I don't know you. But I feel like I know you. You are good police. I hope you're town.

Think I'll put together a case on AA now, and by now I mean at some point.

Also, if you have a town reading on me, and would like to participate in an experiment, please volunteer. I will not provide any further details as to the contents of said experiment. Enlist, and enlist blindly!

Paul ReiserFS posted:

This is a scumpost IMO

Toal reads overzealous/stupid town to me at this point especially given the tunneling on Lupus after a non-case accusation

But Yami is just +1'ing nonsense and acting like "what are your thoughts" is content

Paul ReiserFS posted:

You're misunderstanding my point. I am calling your "yeah I agree" on Toal's nonsense Lupus 'case' as +1'ing (his) nonsense.

Paul ReiserFS posted:

What are you even on? You didn't post any case against Lupus. Your post agreeing with Toal's nonsense case on Lupus is scummy. That's what I said the first time, in less words.

Bernstrike posted:

weird that people claim to be voting for the idiot but Nep-Nep has no votes??

Yami Fenrir posted:

Kind of agree on Lupus, as their posts so far are only commentary... but given that there's only two of them, I mostly just want more.

Actual thoughts on quid, toal?

Mr. Steak posted:

elaborating because i have a tendency to shitpost:

paul's accusation of +1ing is certainly valid because toal's case in question is objectively bad. however, yami is also valid by countering with their real cases this game.

it doesnt reflect super well on yami that their low-effort +1 post was agreeing with the person they have been casing the most today, but it also doesnt reflect well on paul for not taking yami's entire posting history into account when casing

Anomalous Amalgam posted:

I will say, I don't think Yami is making good stances here... not quite full cases.

Anomalous Amalgam posted:

It was a weaker point where he it was conveyed doesn't explain what I mean.

It was that the conviction you were displaying didn't sync up with the flimsy ideas you put forth. Seemed too certain, but on my part, it was less of a condemnation and more of a hot take.

Tommunist posted:

Im phone posting as well but that doesnt mean i make incredibly scummy posts about what i think scum would do.

This post and last are just there to give illusion you're trying to scum hunt when you have provided nothing.

##vote fool

Mr. Steak posted:

binus because he is binus.

for day 1, i think that's the most compelling argument so far.

idk if you can say this vote isn't an "independent opinion" or whatever since i made it before anybody was talking about him and havent moved since

Paul ReiserFS posted:

“can be” and “has been” are different words with different meanings

Between you and Yami latching hard onto specific phrasing and making implications that I’m lying based on misunderstanding me I’m starting to wonder if I don’t speak English as fluently as I thought

b-minus1 posted:

Paul’s “explanation” and vote was loving awful, just like your post is. Notice how I have never backtracked and said I was joking around. If you can’t separate my joke posts from my actual reads, that’s on you.


I mean look at this poo poo. I haven’t rebuffed a drat thing. Both of these posts are scummy af. I would vote dead beat dad but I’m already voting Paul.

fool_of_sound posted:

I'm one shot and I'm blowing away quidthulhu here in a sec of the votes stay on me

Yami Fenrir posted:

Nice how people are jumping out of the woodworks now to defend a guy that has been consistently cased for having a very weak content game.

Bernstrike posted:

not if we vote you first! ##vote fool_of_sound

Mr. Steak posted:

just caught up on like 4 pages. oooohhhh boy.

first, i literally don't believe in "first letter of sentences" breadcrumbs because that's the obvious thing to do when you are scum with a fakeclaim.

i like quid and don't want him to die. i would very much rather lynch fool for the convincing cases against him PLUS he is asking to be replaced which is even better.

i'd believe him more if he wasn't aiming the gun directly at someone i feel very town about at the moment. idk enough about maf meta to conclude anything about the likelihood of a scum dayvig but im not discounting it.

##vote fool

i will unvote if you change targets

b-minus1 posted:

This however is a scumpost

##vote Paul ReiserFS

Paul ReiserFS posted:

You're right and got me thinking that lynching him is the right move.

##vote b-minus1

1) Shitposting is anti-town
2) I've expressed my opinion on his scumclaim
2.5) I still think his 'other scumteam' comments are a tell that he knows more than us, plus:
3)

4) Anything said against him can be superfically rebuffed with "i was joking around " so he's eseentially making himself unreadable, and Jen's post captures my feelings on that

b-minus1 posted:

Paul’s “explanation” and vote was loving awful, just like your post is. Notice how I have never backtracked and said I was joking around. If you can’t separate my joke posts from my actual reads, that’s on you.


I mean look at this poo poo. I haven’t rebuffed a drat thing. Both of these posts are scummy af. I would vote dead beat dad but I’m already voting Paul.

Bernstrike posted:

Earlier in the day Yami voted Steakumms for having a vote, paraphrasing, “because binus”:


then later in the day voted b-minus for reasons of, in my opinion, “because binus”


if you didn’t like b- play before then, Yami prob should have voted b- originally instead of steakumms

##vote Yami Yugi

chaoslord posted:

Yami and Paul posting around Bernstrike is so “look at me I’m so town! Harumph, good sir!”

chaoslord posted:

##vote xiw i believe in binus

chaoslord posted:

I agree with this. Going back, fool asked for a replacement only to show back up and shoot a random townie once pressure started mounting. If you’re town and asked for a replacement why do you care if your dayvig role gets voted out D1? It’s not like you’re the doc or cop, which I could kinda understand. It’s a vig. It’s not one of the more “mission critical” roles. This will come down to playstyle differences right? But I can’t imagine being a vig, asking for a replacement, and deciding “the vig is too important to let this happen to.” My thought would be “great now the mod doesn’t have to bother with a replacement”.

Seems more like scummates prodding someone to return to thread rather than a town imo